New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Obama's Bipartisanship

Arkady

President
Lately, I've posted several times about instances of Obama bending over backwards to try to get Republican support, throughout his presidency. For healthcare reform, he pushed a program devised by a conservative think tank and previously supported by a Republican governor and eventual party standard-bearer. On stimulus, he built his plan not around New Deal-style direct government employment programs, but instead around tax cuts (bringing revenues as a share of GDP to their lowest point in sixty years), and what spending there was mostly shuttled through big corporations, with the idea they'd spend it better than Uncle Sam, which is a Republican notion. Also regarding taxes, he first extended all the Bush tax cuts, when he had the unilateral power to end them, and then signed off on making 97% of them permanent (something even Bush hadn't dared to try). There's another item I neglected to mention: he put a former Republican Senator into one of the most crucial positions in his cabinet.

Try to think this through and see how likely you'd find any of those events if you reversed the parties. Picture GW Bush pushing through a healthcare reform that had been devised by a liberal think tank and previously supported by a Democratic governor and future presidential nominee. Picture Bush building a stimulus plan not around tax cuts, but around the kind of direct jobs programs FDR once pushed. Picture GW Bush cooperating in the raising of tax rates until revenues were at their highest level, as a share of GDP, in 60 years. Picture Bush, with the power to lower taxes through nothing but a veto, agreeing to cooperate with the Democrats in pushing through permanent tax increases, instead. Picture him pulling someone like George Mitchell (a former ranking Democratic Senator) into a key cabinet position.

Those events are simply politically unthinkable in the opposite direction. They may happen repeatedly when it comes to Democratic presidents (Clinton, too, handed over the Department of Defense to a former Republican Senator), but that striving for bipartisanship just isn't something we see with Republicans.

I don't really blame Republicans. Their strategy of not giving an inch and always presenting a united front has proven quite successful. But it does make it hilarious when you hear them whimpering like frightened little girls any time Obama shows even the slightest hint of a spine. It's like they really believe their braindead rhetoric about him pursuing divisive politics. Could they honestly be stupid enough to swallow that tripe, or are they just faking?
 
Still stuck on Bush, eh? I will compliment you on your prodigious water-carrying skills, however. Well done! Your work for the Barack Obama Martyrs' Brigade will not go unrecognized...
 
so to sum up, after all the testimony by gruber about how the "experts" deliberately designed a bill to fool congress and the voters; make it difficult for the congressional budget office to determine actual costs/impacts; reneging on "keep your doctor"; the concealment of huge premium increases -

after all this deliberate effort to mislead us by the bill's sponsors, you still think republicans had an obligation to put their judgement aside, and support the federal bill, simply because Massachussetts had an HONEST bill with none of those built in problems?

why do you believe this?
 
Still stuck on Bush, eh? I will compliment you on your prodigious water-carrying skills, however. Well done! Your work for the Barack Obama Martyrs' Brigade will not go unrecognized...
Let me know if you ever have something interesting to offer.
 
so to sum up, after all the testimony by gruber about how the "experts" deliberately designed a bill to fool congress and the voters; make it difficult for the congressional budget office to determine actual costs/impacts; reneging on "keep your doctor"; the concealment of huge premium increases -

after all this deliberate effort to mislead us by the bill's sponsors, you still think republicans had an obligation to put their judgement aside, and support the federal bill, simply because Massachussetts had an HONEST bill with none of those built in problems?

why do you believe this?
This isn't about Republicans having an obligation to put their judgment aside. It's about the huge contrast between the almost desperate attempts at bipartisanship by Obama (and before him, Clinton), and the lock-step partisanship of recent Republican presidents. They're two very different strategies. Democrats maneuver to try to capture the "center" by coopting Republican ideas and cooperating with Republican politicians, while Republicans maneuver to appeal to their base, generally by moving ever farther to the right to keep daylight between themselves and the "triangulating" Democrats. As I said, I'm not even faulting the Republicans for that. It's a strategy that seems to work for conservatives, in that it sets up a dynamic where Democrats basically chase Republicans further and further rightward. I just find it funny to see such an obvious dynamic apparently overlooked by the dim bulbs who characterize Obama as intentionally dictatorial and divisive.
 
I'd say Obama pretty much poisoned the well by bypassing Congress to give amnesty to some illegals.

Very bipartisan.
 
Back
Top