New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Original Classification Authority

As Original Classification Authority IT WAS HER RESPONSIBILITY TO KNOW WHAT SHE WAS SENDING.
Do you have any evidence she sent email that contained information that, at the time, she should have known should have been classified? If so, please share the evidence.

As someone who thinks the government abuses classification, reflexively slapping secrecy on matters that should be public knowledge (and even matters that have been public knowledge for a while), I'm not going to be terribly sympathetic to a claim that a member of government should have been even less transparent than they already are. But if you have an example of some information she emailed that she should have realized should never be emailed, I'm happy to consider it. Just cite it specifically. But the mere fact someone in our overly secretive government later slapped a classified label on something isn't going to be enough to convince me it was genuinely patently sensitive enough that Clinton should have realize it should be classified. I'm too aware of the many things that have been classified that no reasonable person would have regarded as secret (including information that was already public).
 
Which provision of the Act, specifically? Please cite the provision of the Act that says a government official can't use a private server that way.



Judicial Watch is a right wing operation designed to use the inherited wealth of conservative donors to fuel endless litigation against Democrats. It's been running that grift since the Clinton administration. There are ALWAYS Judicial Watch cases, and always will be, as long as there are Democrats to sue. It doesn't matter how often they lose, as long as the donations keep coming.

Anyway, Powell used a personal email account. Rice didn't use email at all, relying on the personal email account of her assistant.
http://mediamatters.org/blog/2016/03/07/state-dept-concludes-past-secretaries-of-state/209044
http://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news...o-got-classified-info-personal-emails-n511181
In a general way, the Freedom of Information Act does not allow the govt to hide documents that are not state secrets. Clinton hid those by running a private server, in so doing, she violated the spirit of the Freedom of Information Act, and it seems obvious that was her whole intent in setting up the server... to keep those docs from the GOP in her planned run for the presidency. Judicial Watch, as you pointed out, has an endless stream of court cases, only two of the current 34 on docket concern Clinton's e-mails. These two appear to be pretty strong cases, they accuse the State Department of a conspiracy to conceal public documents... looks to be exactly the case. If the lawsuits were brought by political enemies, that's all the more reason to fear they will go for the jugular.

No prior Sec of State or any similar high ranking official built their own private network like Clinton did. This is a unique case of evading the laws that intend to make public documents available to the public and it especially violated the intent of the Espionage Act to keep secret documents in secure storage and handling. It is ironic, that while Clinton's intent in setting up the server was probably to keep her operation secret from the GOP, she exposed it to hackers and foreign espionage. The latter sin is the bigger sin, but the former is already in court and when you Lie before a grand jury, like Hillary just did... that's what Petraeus went to jail for, perjury. BTW, the same team at the FBI that prosecuted Petraeus is investigating Hillary... aka, the best the FBI has, and already battle tested.
 
In a general way, the Freedom of Information Act does not allow the govt to hide documents that are not state secrets. Clinton hid those by running a private server
What makes you think she hid the documents by running a private server? My understanding is that private servers were specifically allowed, so long as document retention policies were observed.

in so doing, she violated the spirit of the Freedom of Information Act

How so? The spirit of FOIA is to give the public access to information. So long as she retained the emails and turned them over when asked, why does it matter which server they were sitting on? I can see why one might want to ban the use of private email servers, so that the government has more direct control over the data, but at the time, private servers were allowed and had been widely used. And, it's not like Clinton failed to hand over the emails when asked. She disclosed 55,000 emails, at least. She was SoS for about four years. Just for some back-of-the-napkin math, based on the average American worker's 1789 hours of yearly work, that's around eight emails per hour for her time in office. It sure sounds like she was retaining her emails.

and it seems obvious that was her whole intent in setting up the server... to keep those docs from the GOP in her planned run for the presidency.

I would assume her reason for the private server was to keep out of the hands of the GOP documents they had no legal right to have. As you'll recall from the ugliness of the Ken Starr days, there's a tendency for corrupt right-wingers to try to use legal disclosure as a way to probe into personally embarrassing information of their political enemies, having nothing to do with the matter being legitimately investigated. Even if the matter under investigation is supposed to be an old land deal in Arkansas, they'll start digging for dirt about the person's recent sex life, and absolutely anything else they can get their grubby paws on, and they'll happily leak it to the press, in breach of all ethical standards.
Having experienced that, wouldn't it have been really stupid for Hillary Clinton NOT to have taken steps to make sure that whatever materials the corrupt Republicans got their hands on were only those materials subject to FOIA, or that they otherwise had a legal right to view? With a private server, which she could scrub for personal communications before handing over information, she had the ability to do that. With a state-controlled server, the corrupt Republicans would have more ability to demand the material be handed over unscrubbed, increasing their ability to personally embarrass her with private matters that are none of their business nor ours. Since the law allowed for such private servers, at the time, and for scrubbing personal emails from disclosures, wouldn't she have been foolish NOT to take advantage of that, knowing how evil her political opponents are?

No prior Sec of State or any similar high ranking official built their own private network like Clinton did

I'll grant that Clinton seems to have taken security and document retention much more seriously than Powell and Rice, who apparently relied on insecure off-the-shelf non-governmental private email to do business, instead of a custom-built private server. But that's a point in her favor, relative to them.

she exposed it to hackers and foreign espionage.

All email servers connected to the internet are exposed to hackers and foreign espionage. Was Clinton's server more exposed than a dotgov account? Very likely it was much less exposed, since it's easier, as a hacker, to figure out how to get into a big system like the state department's email server, where there are a whole lot of people with access, and plenty of current and former employees who know the setup, than something private, where you're operating more in the dark when trying to figure out how the security works in order to bypass it. There's no question in my mind, for example, that I'd much rather have my most personal information sitting on my own server at home, which I control, than on my employer's big server, where hacking the material could be as simple as slipping an agent into the organization by way of some temp tech employment outfit, or bribing some disgruntled employee, etc.

when you Lie before a grand jury, like Hillary just did

What, specifically, makes you think she lied?

... that's what Petraeus went to jail for, perjury.

What makes you think Petraeus went to jail for perjury? Possibly you should read up on this before posting.
 
What makes you think she hid the documents by running a private server? My understanding is that private servers were specifically allowed, so long as document retention policies were observed.



How so? The spirit of FOIA is to give the public access to information. So long as she retained the emails and turned them over when asked, why does it matter which server they were sitting on? I can see why one might want to ban the use of private email servers, so that the government has more direct control over the data, but at the time, private servers were allowed and had been widely used. And, it's not like Clinton failed to hand over the emails when asked. She disclosed 55,000 emails, at least. She was SoS for about four years. Just for some back-of-the-napkin math, based on the average American worker's 1789 hours of yearly work, that's around eight emails per hour for her time in office. It sure sounds like she was retaining her emails.



I would assume her reason for the private server was to keep out of the hands of the GOP documents they had no legal right to have. As you'll recall from the ugliness of the Ken Starr days, there's a tendency for corrupt right-wingers to try to use legal disclosure as a way to probe into personally embarrassing information of their political enemies, having nothing to do with the matter being legitimately investigated. Even if the matter under investigation is supposed to be an old land deal in Arkansas, they'll start digging for dirt about the person's recent sex life, and absolutely anything else they can get their grubby paws on, and they'll happily leak it to the press, in breach of all ethical standards.
Having experienced that, wouldn't it have been really stupid for Hillary Clinton NOT to have taken steps to make sure that whatever materials the corrupt Republicans got their hands on were only those materials subject to FOIA, or that they otherwise had a legal right to view? With a private server, which she could scrub for personal communications before handing over information, she had the ability to do that. With a state-controlled server, the corrupt Republicans would have more ability to demand the material be handed over unscrubbed, increasing their ability to personally embarrass her with private matters that are none of their business nor ours. Since the law allowed for such private servers, at the time, and for scrubbing personal emails from disclosures, wouldn't she have been foolish NOT to take advantage of that, knowing how evil her political opponents are?



I'll grant that Clinton seems to have taken security and document retention much more seriously than Powell and Rice, who apparently relied on insecure off-the-shelf non-governmental private email to do business, instead of a custom-built private server. But that's a point in her favor, relative to them.



All email servers connected to the internet are exposed to hackers and foreign espionage. Was Clinton's server more exposed than a dotgov account? Very likely it was much less exposed, since it's easier, as a hacker, to figure out how to get into a big system like the state department's email server, where there are a whole lot of people with access, and plenty of current and former employees who know the setup, than something private, where you're operating more in the dark when trying to figure out how the security works in order to bypass it. There's no question in my mind, for example, that I'd much rather have my most personal information sitting on my own server at home, which I control, than on my employer's big server, where hacking the material could be as simple as slipping an agent into the organization by way of some temp tech employment outfit, or bribing some disgruntled employee, etc.



What, specifically, makes you think she lied?



What makes you think Petraeus went to jail for perjury? Possibly you should read up on this before posting.
When the State Department was contacted for public documents concerning affairs handled by the office of the SEC of State, the response was they had zero documents. Clinton hid everything from public view. Judicial Watch had to bring lawsuit against Hillary to find out there was a private server. Clinton did not voluntarily testify in that court case, she was subpoenad - nor did she voluntarily turn over e-mails, those were subpoena'd also. Nor did she turn over the server to the FBI, it was seized in a raid on her home. And when Clinton deleted private e-mails from the server, before turning over a data dump to the court... she certified to the court - in front of the grand jury - that she had turned over every last public e-mail on the server, that she was not holding back anything. Since then, the FBI has seized the entire network of servers... and it is reported that there was public documents amongst those 30,000 e-mails Clinton deleted. Something like 1200 public documents. There only has to be one, for Clinton to be guilty of perjury.

At the same time, Hillary and aides will have to testify again in the 2nd Judicial Watch lawsuit... this month.

 
Last edited:
When the State Department was contacted for public documents concerning affairs handled by the office of the SEC of State, the response was they had zero documents. Clinton hid everything from public view. Judicial Watch had to bring lawsuit against Hillary to find out there was a private server. Clinton did not voluntarily testify in that court case, she was subpoenad - nor did she voluntarily turn over e-mails, those were subpoena'd also. Nor did she turn over the server to the FBI, it was seized in a raid on her home. And when Clinton deleted private e-mails from the server, before turning over a data dump to the court... she certified to the court - in front of the grand jury - that she had turned over every last public e-mail on the server, that she was not holding back anything. Since then, the FBI has seized the entire network of servers... and it is reported that there was public documents amongst those 30,000 e-mails Clinton deleted. Something like 1200 public documents.
Could you link to the information about 1200 public documents being among the 30,000 she deleted?

There only has to be one, for Clinton to be guilty of perjury.
Incorrect. Perjury requires a knowing misstatement of fact. If she reasonably believed she'd turned over all the public documents, but one or two were deleted in a manner that suggests she could plausibly not have been aware that happened, that's not perjury. Hell, even if a lot got deleted, but she plausibly wouldn't have realized that at the time of her statement, that wouldn't be perjury. For example, if she thought all the old public emails were being archived, but it turns out whoever set up her server had implemented a junk mail filter that deleted old junk mail, and it was badly programmed to delete some documents that weren't junk mail, as well, but she had no reason to know that, such that her testimony was an attempt to state the truth as she understood it at the time, that wouldn't be perjury.
 
Do you have any evidence she sent email that contained information that, at the time, she should have known should have been classified? If so, please share the evidence.

As someone who thinks the government abuses classification, reflexively slapping secrecy on matters that should be public knowledge (and even matters that have been public knowledge for a while), I'm not going to be terribly sympathetic to a claim that a member of government should have been even less transparent than they already are. But if you have an example of some information she emailed that she should have realized should never be emailed, I'm happy to consider it. Just cite it specifically. But the mere fact someone in our overly secretive government later slapped a classified label on something isn't going to be enough to convince me it was genuinely patently sensitive enough that Clinton should have realize it should be classified. I'm too aware of the many things that have been classified that no reasonable person would have regarded as secret (including information that was already public).
According to the FBI yes when she sent her emails they were classified and some higher than top secret.
 
Could you link to the information about 1200 public documents being among the 30,000 she deleted?


Incorrect. Perjury requires a knowing misstatement of fact. If she reasonably believed she'd turned over all the public documents, but one or two were deleted in a manner that suggests she could plausibly not have been aware that happened, that's not perjury. Hell, even if a lot got deleted, but she plausibly wouldn't have realized that at the time of her statement, that wouldn't be perjury. For example, if she thought all the old public emails were being archived, but it turns out whoever set up her server had implemented a junk mail filter that deleted old junk mail, and it was badly programmed to delete some documents that weren't junk mail, as well, but she had no reason to know that, such that her testimony was an attempt to state the truth as she understood it at the time, that wouldn't be perjury.
STOP IT dude you're on the wrong side of history on this.
 
My post this thread is nothing but fact Mr. non-sequitur.
Reason being those emails she sent the FBI has said they were secret or Top secret before she sent them.

I have lurked for a wee bit but this post made me decide to register.

Facts as I know them:
1. It has been reported that classified e-mails without classification markings were found on her server
2. Clinton has claimed she did not forward any information that had classification markings and the FBI hasn't said that she did.
3. Clinton has classification authority
I don't see how the above proves anything about Clinton. Being a classification authority means she has the ability to label information as being classified and, therefore, requiring protection. This authority does not make her responsible for all unmarked information that may or may not be classified that somehow crosses her path.

Did the e-mails have classification markings before she sent them? Did she strip off the markings that others have determined to be classified? I have no idea what you think being a CA means relative to the e-mails determined to be classified that were found on the server and how that proves Clinton guilty with the above facts.

I was first granted a security clearance in 1980. I have always been told that there are 3 levels of classified information: Confidential, Secret, and Top Secret. There is no "above top secret" and the Wikipedia article (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._security_clearance_terms) backs this up. "Information "above Top Secret" is either Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) or special access program (SAP) which are phrases used by media. It is not truly "above" Top Secret, since there is no civilian clearance higher than Top Secret". I believe you used that term somewhere in this thread and, if so, the fact that you did use the term makes me suspicious of what you do know. If you didn't, ignore this paragraph.

There are millions of pages of classified information from many sources. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of CAs in the U.S. government. Generals and high-ranking civil servants that I have worked with don't seem to know what specific details are classified and at what level. They deal with too many programs that span huge amounts of material. I can't always keep it straight at my level. So, I wouldn't expect a U.S. Secretary of State to always be able to determine which pieces of information that pass in front of him or her are classified. High-ranking people have staffs and subordinates to deal with that and it appears that they may have screwed up.
 
I have lurked for a wee bit but this post made me decide to register.

Facts as I know them:
1. It has been reported that classified e-mails without classification markings were found on her server
2. Clinton has claimed she did not forward any information that had classification markings and the FBI hasn't said that she did.
3. Clinton has classification authority
I don't see how the above proves anything about Clinton. Being a classification authority means she has the ability to label information as being classified and, therefore, requiring protection. This authority does not make her responsible for all unmarked information that may or may not be classified that somehow crosses her path.

Did the e-mails have classification markings before she sent them? Did she strip off the markings that others have determined to be classified? I have no idea what you think being a CA means relative to the e-mails determined to be classified that were found on the server and how that proves Clinton guilty with the above facts.

I was first granted a security clearance in 1980. I have always been told that there are 3 levels of classified information: Confidential, Secret, and Top Secret. There is no "above top secret" and the Wikipedia article (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._security_clearance_terms) backs this up. "Information "above Top Secret" is either Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) or special access program (SAP) which are phrases used by media. It is not truly "above" Top Secret, since there is no civilian clearance higher than Top Secret". I believe you used that term somewhere in this thread and, if so, the fact that you did use the term makes me suspicious of what you do know. If you didn't, ignore this paragraph.

There are millions of pages of classified information from many sources. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of CAs in the U.S. government. Generals and high-ranking civil servants that I have worked with don't seem to know what specific details are classified and at what level. They deal with too many programs that span huge amounts of material. I can't always keep it straight at my level. So, I wouldn't expect a U.S. Secretary of State to always be able to determine which pieces of information that pass in front of him or her are classified. High-ranking people have staffs and subordinates to deal with that and it appears that they may have screwed up.
The problem is this SHE IS OR WAS THE ORIGINAL CLASSIFICATION ARTHOURITY. She knew what emails sent were classified when they were sent, so she lied
She had a private server when she wasn't supposed to have one her deleting those emails shows she was trying to hide from the public view. So don't give me that shit you wrote and expect me to accept it.
 
The problem is this SHE IS OR WAS THE ORIGINAL CLASSIFICATION ARTHOURITY. She knew what emails sent were classified when they were sent, so she lied
She had a private server when she wasn't supposed to have one her deleting those emails shows she was trying to hide from the public view. So don't give me that shit you wrote and expect me to accept it.
What evidence do you have that she knew?
 
I have lurked for a wee bit but this post made me decide to register.

Facts as I know them:
1. It has been reported that classified e-mails without classification markings were found on her server
2. Clinton has claimed she did not forward any information that had classification markings and the FBI hasn't said that she did.
3. Clinton has classification authority
I don't see how the above proves anything about Clinton. Being a classification authority means she has the ability to label information as being classified and, therefore, requiring protection. This authority does not make her responsible for all unmarked information that may or may not be classified that somehow crosses her path.

Did the e-mails have classification markings before she sent them? Did she strip off the markings that others have determined to be classified? I have no idea what you think being a CA means relative to the e-mails determined to be classified that were found on the server and how that proves Clinton guilty with the above facts.

I was first granted a security clearance in 1980. I have always been told that there are 3 levels of classified information: Confidential, Secret, and Top Secret. There is no "above top secret" and the Wikipedia article (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._security_clearance_terms) backs this up. "Information "above Top Secret" is either Sensitive Compartmented Information (SCI) or special access program (SAP) which are phrases used by media. It is not truly "above" Top Secret, since there is no civilian clearance higher than Top Secret". I believe you used that term somewhere in this thread and, if so, the fact that you did use the term makes me suspicious of what you do know. If you didn't, ignore this paragraph.

There are millions of pages of classified information from many sources. There are hundreds, if not thousands, of CAs in the U.S. government. Generals and high-ranking civil servants that I have worked with don't seem to know what specific details are classified and at what level. They deal with too many programs that span huge amounts of material. I can't always keep it straight at my level. So, I wouldn't expect a U.S. Secretary of State to always be able to determine which pieces of information that pass in front of him or her are classified. High-ranking people have staffs and subordinates to deal with that and it appears that they may have screwed up.
Welcome to Political Jack.
 
The problem is this SHE IS OR WAS THE ORIGINAL CLASSIFICATION ARTHOURITY. She knew what emails sent were classified when they were sent, so she lied

How do you know she was the original classification authority for the classified information in the unmarked e-mails? I have never heard that.
 
How do you know she was the original classification authority for the classified information in the unmarked e-mails? I have never heard that.
I re-quoted your first post
Well jack ass if you have been lurking and this thread caused you to join you would know why she was the original classification authority it's in the TOP POST.
I have lurked for a wee bit but this post made me decide to register..
fU CKING TROLLS
 
Back
Top