New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Original Classification Authority

Not for state secrets.

Powell did not expose any state secrets on his private network

What makes you think that? Keep in mind that to compare Powell's email to Clinto's, you'd need to subject Powell's emails to the same scrutiny as Clinton's -- you'd need to farm out tens of thousands of emails to dozens of agencies and order them to go line by line looking for any material that was classified. As you know, Powell's emails were never subjected to that scrutiny. Nobody at that level ever had email subjected to that scrutiny before or since, because there was never the same single-minded desire to find something --anything-- to use against the official. And even if they'd wanted to subject Powell's emails to that treatment, they couldn't have, since Powell didn't control the server his emails were on, and so couldn't arrange for document retention, which was done on AOL's deletion schedule.

The evidence remains available for future prosecutions.

Yes, in theory, Powell could still be prosecuted for what he did. So could Condaleeza Rice's team: they also used private email for work-related correspondence. And at least six Trump White House advisers could potentially be prosecuted, too, based on using private email for public work. I wouldn't hold your breath, though. The email story was just something to get the dummies worked up during the election. The Republicans knew it wouldn't survive the scrutiny it would get if there were ever an indictment, so it was never going to go anywhere. That's why, when so many dummies in this forum predicted an indictment was coming in the next few weeks --for months and months-- I scoffed. You remember that, right? I can't claim any special powers of prognostication. But I have a firm enough grounding in the real world that I never slid down into the sewer of paranoia so many conservatives here did.
 
Comey is playing with a "weasel's or" there. For his statement to be true, only one half or the other has to be true. Either Clinton or whoever she was communicating with should have known that an unclassified system was no place for the conversation. Which is it? Should Clinton have known, or should the others have known it? That's a key question if you want to determine who is responsible.

For example, picture a situation where Clinton asked the Pentagon for assurances that they were in a position to evacuate a diplomatic facility in Indonesia if needed. And picture that someone at the Pentagon assured her that, in fact, there was a base nearby with the equipment needed to mount a quick evacuation if needed. Only picture if the fact we had a base with that equipment in that areas was classified. In that case, it would be true to say "There is evidence to support a conclusion that any reasonable person in Secretary Clinton’s position, or in the position of those government employees with whom she was corresponding about these matters, should have known that an unclassified system was no place for that conversation." Even if Clinton was not in a position to know it, the Pentagon was, and only one half of an "or" statement needs to be true for the statement to be true ("I'm going to grab breakfast at the drive-through or just wait until I get to work" is true if I do either.)

So, in how many of these instances of classified material being in Clinton's email was she at fault, if any? For some reason, Comey didn't provide an answer to that. Why? Well, given the way he acted as a Republican political operative and eventually handed the presidency to Trump, I have my suspicions.
No Comey let a criminal go
 
What makes you think that? Keep in mind that to compare Powell's email to Clinto's, you'd need to subject Powell's emails to the same scrutiny as Clinton's -- you'd need to farm out tens of thousands of emails to dozens of agencies and order them to go line by line looking for any material that was classified. As you know, Powell's emails were never subjected to that scrutiny. Nobody at that level ever had email subjected to that scrutiny before or since, because there was never the same single-minded desire to find something --anything-- to use against the official. And even if they'd wanted to subject Powell's emails to that treatment, they couldn't have, since Powell didn't control the server his emails were on, and so couldn't arrange for document retention, which was done on AOL's deletion schedule.



Yes, in theory, Powell could still be prosecuted for what he did. So could Condaleeza Rice's team: they also used private email for work-related correspondence. And at least six Trump White House advisers could potentially be prosecuted, too, based on using private email for public work. I wouldn't hold your breath, though. The email story was just something to get the dummies worked up during the election. The Republicans knew it wouldn't survive the scrutiny it would get if there were ever an indictment, so it was never going to go anywhere. That's why, when so many dummies in this forum predicted an indictment was coming in the next few weeks --for months and months-- I scoffed. You remember that, right? I can't claim any special powers of prognostication. But I have a firm enough grounding in the real world that I never slid down into the sewer of paranoia so many conservatives here did.
What makes you think what you think? You have no training or exprince with the subject,
 
Is it your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails? If so, which law, in particular, are you relying on for that claim?
No it's not a belief it is by my knowledge on the subject.
Here we go again dancing. Laws? Look up what an OCA is and what their duties are.
 
Look up what an OCA is and what their duties are

I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
 
I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
If you know what an OCA is you should also know what their responsibilities are.
And you wouldn't be asking moronic questions.
 
If you know what an OCA is you should also know what their responsibilities are.
And you wouldn't be asking moronic questions.

Do you think that because Clinton had authority to classify material, that meant that she was the one who classified any classified material that found its way onto her server? Because that obviously would be necessarily the case only if no one else had that authority. Or is your argument that she should have known that any classified material should have been classified? That's just pure nonsense. Things get classified for all kinds of stupid reasons, and she's not privy to the most arcane workings of the bureaucracy in every department in Washington.
 
Do you think that because Clinton had authority to classify material, that meant that she was the one who classified any classified material that found its way onto her server? Because that obviously would be necessarily the case only if no one else had that authority. Or is your argument that she should have known that any classified material should have been classified? That's just pure nonsense. Things get classified for all kinds of stupid reasons, and she's not privy to the most arcane workings of the bureaucracy in every department in Washington.
She was the OCA for the state department only, and from your comment, I can see you also don't know much about OCA's.
 
If you know what an OCA is you should also know what their responsibilities are.
And you wouldn't be asking moronic questions.
I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
 
I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
If you have too ask that then you don't know what an OCA is
 
If you have too ask that then you don't know what an OCA is
I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
 
I know what an OCA is and what their duties are. I'm not asking about that. I'm asking for a link that substantiates your belief that an OCA is responsible for any classified information that makes it into one of his or her emails. If you can substantiate that with the law or regulation in question, do so.
Reading will educate you I have even posted FYI for an OCA on page one go fetch
 
Back
Top