New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Outlaws

The government could put a lien on his property and collect, just not at the present moment. Correct? It would be a far better option than confronting someone, who you know will not comply, with massive force creating a side show.

Proper steps are one thing and OK in my book, but when a situation is deliberately escalated from a government agency, it becomes a major issue. The situation could have gotten VERY nasty, and it would have been at the governments hands as they should anticipate the response they got from certain people in our country.

Putin invades Ukraine, Obama invades Nevada. Didn't you ever know a pissant little kid who had to prove something to everyone?
 
Overwhelming displays of potential force are a time-honored and respected means of DISSUADING violence.

LOL!!!

Watch how brave these heavily armed fed officials (formerly public servants), try to dissuade violence on unarmed little old lady by body slamming her onto the pavement and siccing attack dogs on her..


Definitely a medal should be awarded for this kind of bravery and public service.
 
Last edited:
You don't know what I mean, huh? Bullshit....
So where do you draw the line between where government is allowed to use force against an armed criminal element and where they should just stick to passive means of trying to compel compliance? We're talking about a guy who has spent years in defiance of the law, and who is armed and implicitly threatening violence against authorities. He's been stealing our grass and trespassing on our land for years and years. At what point is force an appropriate response?

What's amusing to me, here, is to see the turnaround from the conservatives here relative to their response to a story I told a while back. The story involved me hiking in the mountains and cutting across a field, which wasn't fenced off or marked with "no trespassing," or anything of the sort. And, part-way across that field, I was confronted by a shotgun-toting yokel demanding that I get off his land or he'd kill me. I thought that was excessive, since I wasn't harming anything and would actually have cleared his property faster if he hadn't stopped me to threaten me. Most of the conservatives here, on the other hand, saw nothing wrong with his behavior. Yet, when it comes to a guy who isn't just passing harmlessly across some unmarked land on which he didn't realize he was unwelcome, but instead moving a destructive herd of cattle onto the land, knowing full well that he'd failed to pay the required grazing fees, and carrying arms to defend that willful criminal misconduct, somehow it's then irresponsible for the landowner to confront him. Very weird.
 
LOL!!!

Watch how brave these heavily armed fed officials (formerly public servants), try to dissuade violence on unarmed little old lady by body slamming her onto the pavement and siccing attack dogs on her..


Definitely a medal should be awarded for this kind of bravery and public service.

In a more self-respecting world, a poster would realize that this little snippet is probably only good once.
 
So where do you draw the line between where government is allowed to use force against an armed criminal element and where they should just stick to passive means of trying to compel compliance? We're talking about a guy who has spent years in defiance of the law, and who is armed and implicitly threatening violence against authorities. He's been stealing our grass and trespassing on our land for years and years. At what point is force an appropriate response?

What's amusing to me, here, is to see the turnaround from the conservatives here relative to their response to a story I told a while back. The story involved me hiking in the mountains and cutting across a field, which wasn't fenced off or marked with "no trespassing," or anything of the sort. And, part-way across that field, I was confronted by a shotgun-toting yokel demanding that I get off his land or he'd kill me. I thought that was excessive, since I wasn't harming anything and would actually have cleared his property faster if he hadn't stopped me to threaten me. Most of the conservatives here, on the other hand, saw nothing wrong with his behavior. Yet, when it comes to a guy who isn't just passing harmlessly across some unmarked land on which he didn't realize he was unwelcome, but instead moving a destructive herd of cattle onto the land, knowing full well that he'd failed to pay the required grazing fees, and carrying arms to defend that willful criminal misconduct, somehow it's then irresponsible for the landowner to confront him. Very weird.
IIRC, I did say that guy's response was extreme, but that you were also at fault for trespassing in the first place. Should he have shot you for it?
 
Oh, I see.

So then, your argument is that law enforcement officers shouldn't attempt to use force in the event that they are outnumbered by gun wielding outlaws.
Is it a matter of life, limb, or eyesight if they don't? Is someone going to be assaulted or murdered if they don't get their man right then and there? Is it likely that he will flee and escape? Or can they just back off a bit till everyone's adrenaline runs it's course and pick him up when he goes to get groceries in a week? Without anyone getting shot because a dick-measuring contest escalated? What kind of LEOs would you prefer to have on the job?
 
IIRC, I did say that guy's response was extreme, but that you were also at fault for trespassing in the first place. Should he have shot you for it?
Not in that scenario. But imagine if, instead, I'd stampeded a whole herd of cattle onto his land, which was chewing up his grass, trampling his land, and endangering the wildlife living there, and imagine that he knew I'd done it willfully and repeatedly for many years, despite a court order telling me to stop, and imagine that when he summoned the police to help, I pulled a gun on them. Now we've got a rough parallel.
 
Not in that scenario. But imagine if, instead, I'd stampeded a whole herd of cattle onto his land, which was chewing up his grass, trampling his land, and endangering the wildlife living there, and imagine that he knew I'd done it willfully and repeatedly for many years, despite a court order telling me to stop, and imagine that when he summoned the police to help, I pulled a gun on them. Now we've got a rough parallel.
Not really, no....
 
Not in that scenario. But imagine if, instead, I'd stampeded a whole herd of cattle onto his land, which was chewing up his grass, trampling his land, and endangering the wildlife living there, and imagine that he knew I'd done it willfully and repeatedly for many years, despite a court order telling me to stop, and imagine that when he summoned the police to help, I pulled a gun on them. Now we've got a rough parallel.
Umm... BTW, ranchers tend to know better how to mange land than people who have never seen said land.
 
Umm... BTW, ranchers tend to know better how to mange land than people who have never seen said land.
If he wants to manage his land, by all means he should. But apparently he didn't "manage" it well enough to be able to graze his cattle without the assistance of a government handout, since he's demanding sub-market access to public land.
 
If he wants to manage his land, by all means he should. But apparently he didn't "manage" it well enough to be able to graze his cattle without the assistance of a government handout, since he's demanding sub-market access to public land.
Not sure that is exactly what happened. I thought he was paying the fees and grazing around a 1000 head of livestock, and then he was told he could only graze 150 head there. Without grazeland for all of his stock, he would go out of business. I thought that was what prompted him to stop paying and to tell the feds to go pound sand....
 
Not sure that is exactly what happened. I thought he was paying the fees and grazing around a 1000 head of livestock, and then he was told he could only graze 150 head there. Without grazeland for all of his stock, he would go out of business. I thought that was what prompted him to stop paying and to tell the feds to go pound sand....

The idea that the decision of how to exploit the public lands should be left to the ranchers, is silly. And, that's not suggesting anything untoward about the ranchers. It's a simple free market thing. It's in the rancher's interest to push the limits in terms of lands he doesn't even own. It's the same with the discharge of heavy metals from manufacturing, into our rivers. Should we leave it up to the manufacturers to decide how much is too much?
 
The idea that the decision of how to exploit the public lands should be left to the ranchers, is silly. And, that's not suggesting anything untoward about the ranchers. It's a simple free market thing. It's in the rancher's interest to push the limits in terms of lands he doesn't even own. It's the same with the discharge of heavy metals from manufacturing, into our rivers. Should we leave it up to the manufacturers to decide how much is too much?
The rancher needs to maintain that land in order to maintain his stock. He is heavily invested, (and his family has been for quite some time) in keeping that land in good condition. Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't it the Federal gov't who turned half of NV into a radioactive wasteland?
 
The rancher needs to maintain that land in order to maintain his stock. He is heavily invested, (and his family has been for quite some time) in keeping that land in good condition. Correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't it the Federal gov't who turned half of NV into a radioactive wasteland?

Half of NV isn't a radioactive wasteland, and your suggestion that our exploiters of our natural resources should be free to make their one rules, because it's "in their interest", is silly. And don't forget, the rancher's only "interest" is grazing. The rest of we 300 million+ owners of that land are okay with grazing, but we have other interests in that land as well.
 
Had so many fisheries not been overfished, I might believe such nonsense.

When I was in high school/college, we had a big kerfuffle hereabouts, around Indian fishing rights - or lack thereof. The Indians didn't think they were getting their fair share per the treaties. The white descendants of the Slavs were bitchin' that the guvmint was messing with their "god-given" right to fish as they had for the last 75 years.

The Boldt Decision finally settled it, Half went to the Indians and half went to the non-Indians. The whole thing was most contentious. And for what it's worth, I knew a lot of the white fisherman and none of the Indians!

That was a different time and the Indians didn't get much support from the non-Indians. BUT.....whitey got less support than he thought he might, because everyone knew that if whitey was left to his own devices, he was on a track to destroy the whole godamned resource in short order.
 
Half of NV isn't a radioactive wasteland, and your suggestion that our exploiters of our natural resources should be free to make their one rules, because it's "in their interest", is silly. And don't forget, the rancher's only "interest" is grazing. The rest of we 300 million+ owners of that land are okay with grazing, but we have other interests in that land as well.
Ok then, like what? What else is it being used for that he can't graze his cattle there?
 
Ok then, like what? What else is it being used for that he can't graze his cattle there?

He CAN graze his cattle there...

Is...and has...and has failed to pay his fees for 21 years. Why is this so difficult to understand?
 
Back
Top