New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Over-long copyrights

Arkady

President
As I've mentioned before, during most of the history of copyrights, that limited exclusive monopoly has, indeed, been quite limited. When the Founders first set up the copyright, it was a single 14-year period, with the ability to pay a fee to renew for an additional 14 years if the author was still alive. That was consistent with the Founders' strong support of free speech. For 14, or at most 28 years, the artist had exclusive control over a product, and then it was open to the rest of the world to copy and modify freely.

This allowed for free flow of information, and creative cross-pollination of arts and culture. Think of the Disney movies, for example -- the majority of which are a creative riff on some earlier public-domain property (Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, The Little Mermaid, The Jungle Book, Cinderella, Treasure Island, etc.) Unfortunately, although Walt Disney the man was an eager and highly creative borrower of other people's creations, the Walt Disney Corporation, which he left as his legacy, has worked tirelessly to cut off the ability of others to do the same thing. Every time Mickey Mouse is ready to fall into the public domain, they buy up a gang of Congressmen to push through a change in copyright law, to extend the corporation's exclusive monopoly, with the side effect being that no new things have fallen into the public domain for as long as most of us have been alive. Mickey is now 85 years old, meaning the Founders would have had him in the public domain for 57 years by now.

Think of what would today be in the public domain, if the Founders' vision of the copyright were still in force. Stanley Kubrick died 14 years ago, so everything he ever did would be available for others to rework and reimagine. Even for artists still alive, everything done before 1985 would now be open to reimagining. The entire ouvre of the Beatles, the film Back to the Future, the novel Pet Sematary, the original Star Wars trilogy, etc. Any high school could mount a production of nearly any Broadway musical you'd ever heard of, up through the time of Les Miserables, without a ridiculous cost. Any Jazz ensemble could play any of the classics without financing the corporations that own those works. One could reboot the TV shows "The A Team" or "MASH" based entirely on the strength of one's vision, rather than some licensing deal. And in video games, the Mario Brothers would now be open for reimagining:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_t...ing_and_should_be_taken_down_immediately.html

This would open the door to investments being made into the quality of a product, rather than paying high-price licensing rights. It would also open the door to competition among various competing visions, where what matters is the quality of the work, not the bid paid to some corporation for the right to use the material. It would be like the world of fan fiction, writ large.

To flip this around, picture the situation if today's de facto perpetual copyrights had existed in earlier eras. Picture if, for example, you couldn't mount a production of Shakespeare (see Joss Whedon's excellent recent Much Ado About Nothing), or borrow its characters and themes (see West Side Story), without the permission and the enrichment of whatever corporation happened to hold that copyright. Picture if Mozart, Beethoven, and Bach were all locked up, unless you could pay a sufficient fee to their distant descendents. Picture if Michelangelo, Inc. sent out cease and desist letters every time someone showed a picture of the Statue of David without a licensing fee, and Leonardo's estate bogged Dan Brown down in lawsuits to prevent his novel from seeing the light of day. Picture if the Harry Potter books were a non-starter, because wizards, trolls, magic wands, and hippogriffs are all things that JK Rowling borrowed, rather than inventing from scratch. Picture if half the banks and government buildings in this country were wrapped up in litigation for having borrowed copyrighted architectural cues from the Acropolis and Pantheon.

I'm all for the existence of a copyright. It creates a financial incentive for the creation of intellectual property, without which, arguably, such property would be created less frequently. But if something is EVER going to be profitable enough to have made its creation financially worthwhile, it will have already passed that mark within 28 years, if not 14. As I've pointed out before, it's not like John Lennon, in 1963, would have said "Well, Paul, I'm just not sure it's worth making the effort to write this song, because we won't get any more royalties on it after 1991." For most art, nearly the entirety of the profit comes in the first few years, and for the few pieces of art with a "long tail" (profits stretching out for decades), the profit within those first few years will already have been enough to incentivize the work. Everything after that is just a transfer of wealth from the masses to the few -- in the best case, a few wealthy highly successful artists, or in the worst case, a few giant "content" aggragation corporations.
 
you've done this one before.. IP and such... some months ago..

..

Yep. I thought I'd post on it again, after having read the article I linked to, regarding an unlicensed online version of Super Mario Brothers that someone came up with. I figured some people might not have seen my previous post, and besides, if we only got one crack at posting about a particular political topic, I think we'd all be silent here, at this point, about gun control, abortion, Obamacare, tax policy, the war on Iraq, the federal debt, climate change, and so on. I just happen to have interests that run outside of the usual policy issues we regularly go around and around in circles on, for years on end.
 
As I've mentioned before, during most of the history of copyrights, that limited exclusive monopoly has, indeed, been quite limited. When the Founders first set up the copyright, it was a single 14-year period, with the ability to pay a fee to renew for an additional 14 years if the author was still alive. That was consistent with the Founders' strong support of free speech. For 14, or at most 28 years, the artist had exclusive control over a product, and then it was open to the rest of the world to copy and modify freely.

This allowed for free flow of information, and creative cross-pollination of arts and culture. Think of the Disney movies, for example -- the majority of which are a creative riff on some earlier public-domain property (Beauty and the Beast, Aladdin, The Little Mermaid, The Jungle Book, Cinderella, Treasure Island, etc.) Unfortunately, although Walt Disney the man was an eager and highly creative borrower of other people's creations, the Walt Disney Corporation, which he left as his legacy, has worked tirelessly to cut off the ability of others to do the same thing. Every time Mickey Mouse is ready to fall into the public domain, they buy up a gang of Congressmen to push through a change in copyright law, to extend the corporation's exclusive monopoly, with the side effect being that no new things have fallen into the public domain for as long as most of us have been alive. Mickey is now 85 years old, meaning the Founders would have had him in the public domain for 57 years by now.

Think of what would today be in the public domain, if the Founders' vision of the copyright were still in force. Stanley Kubrick died 14 years ago, so everything he ever did would be available for others to rework and reimagine. Even for artists still alive, everything done before 1985 would now be open to reimagining. The entire ouvre of the Beatles, the film Back to the Future, the novel Pet Sematary, the original Star Wars trilogy, etc. Any high school could mount a production of nearly any Broadway musical you'd ever heard of, up through the time of Les Miserables, without a ridiculous cost. Any Jazz ensemble could play any of the classics without financing the corporations that own those works. One could reboot the TV shows "The A Team" or "MASH" based entirely on the strength of one's vision, rather than some licensing deal. And in video games, the Mario Brothers would now be open for reimagining:

http://www.slate.com/blogs/future_t...ing_and_should_be_taken_down_immediately.html

This would open the door to investments being made into the quality of a product, rather than paying high-price licensing rights. It would also open the door to competition among various competing visions, where what matters is the quality of the work, not the bid paid to some corporation for the right to use the material. It would be like the world of fan fiction, writ large.

To flip this around, picture the situation if today's de facto perpetual copyrights had existed in earlier eras. Picture if, for example, you couldn't mount a production of Shakespeare (see Joss Whedon's excellent recent Much Ado About Nothing), or borrow its characters and themes (see West Side Story), without the permission and the enrichment of whatever corporation happened to hold that copyright. Picture if Mozart, Beethoven, and Bach were all locked up, unless you could pay a sufficient fee to their distant descendents. Picture if Michelangelo, Inc. sent out cease and desist letters every time someone showed a picture of the Statue of David without a licensing fee, and Leonardo's estate bogged Dan Brown down in lawsuits to prevent his novel from seeing the light of day. Picture if the Harry Potter books were a non-starter, because wizards, trolls, magic wands, and hippogriffs are all things that JK Rowling borrowed, rather than inventing from scratch. Picture if half the banks and government buildings in this country were wrapped up in litigation for having borrowed copyrighted architectural cues from the Acropolis and Pantheon.

I'm all for the existence of a copyright. It creates a financial incentive for the creation of intellectual property, without which, arguably, such property would be created less frequently. But if something is EVER going to be profitable enough to have made its creation financially worthwhile, it will have already passed that mark within 28 years, if not 14. As I've pointed out before, it's not like John Lennon, in 1963, would have said "Well, Paul, I'm just not sure it's worth making the effort to write this song, because we won't get any more royalties on it after 1991." For most art, nearly the entirety of the profit comes in the first few years, and for the few pieces of art with a "long tail" (profits stretching out for decades), the profit within those first few years will already have been enough to incentivize the work. Everything after that is just a transfer of wealth from the masses to the few -- in the best case, a few wealthy highly successful artists, or in the worst case, a few giant "content" aggragation corporations.

While I'm ranting about copyrights, here's another pet peeve:

Basically, digital copyright laws combine with the power of big business to allow companies to snuff out unfavorable press on the disingenuous grounds of protecting their copyrights (from what is clearly "fair use"). Other times, fair use gets improperly flagged as part of an automated sweep.

This wouldn't be an issue if there were a "public square" outlet for online discussion -- a public Facebook of YouTube to compete with private companies, the way a public real-world forum competes with private ones. But since the vast majority of the Internet consists of, effectively, private property, owned ultimately by a handful of big companies, your free speech rights don't matter much here. If you reach a big enough audience to matter to a big company, and you provide content they don't like, they can usually convince the big company that hosts your materialize provides you access to the internet to take it down, simply by making dishonest copyright claims or otherwise convincing the other company it isn't worth the fight to protect your speech.
 
Back
Top