New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Paging all "computer experts..."

Raoul_Luke

"Wait, it's all Marxism?" "Always has been."
Specifically @middleview

I'd seriously like to hear your take on this, as I believe you had a valid criticism of the VIPS' earlier theory on the DNC file transfers. This, however, seems even more specific:

...and we were looking at the files posted by Wikileaks, because the allegation from the beginning is that Russia hacked the DNC and gave the emails to Wikileaks to publish. So, we looked at those emails, to see if there was something there that might give us some idea of how Wikileaks got that data. Well, in all the 35,813 emails that they posted in three batches, one [batch was] downloaded according to last modified times on the 23rd of May, and another on the 25th of May, and one [other] on the 26th of August, of 2016. Now, all those files, all 35,813, had a last modified time that was rounded off [rounded up] to an even [the next-higher] second, so they all ended up in even [meaning complete or full, not fractional] seconds. Now, if you know anything about data processing and data storage and things of that nature, there is a program that was quite common in the past [including 2016] using what’s called fat file formatting file allocation, table formatting, which is a process that when doing a batch process of data and transferring it to a storage device like a thumb drive or a CD-ROM, it rounds off the last modified time to the nearest even [next-higher] second, so that’s exactly the property we found in all that data posted by Wikileaks. Now, that said very simply this data was downloaded to a storage device a CD-ROM or a thumb drive and physically transported before Wikileaks could post it, so that meant it was not a hack [since there’s no rounding off to the next-higher second, as it would be if it’s a file that’s been carried over the internet], no matter how you look at it. We’re looking at the forensic evidence that says the DNC emails were not hacked, they were downloaded and physically transported to Wikileaks.


Would it be possible, for instance, to transfer the files to another server (which of course Crowdstrike claims they have no proof of) and then to a thumb drive, thereby creating this timestamp issue?

Additionally, if the files were downloaded directly from, say, the mail server itself to a thumb drive - would that be something that Crowdstrike's monitoring software would be able to pick up? Or is it likely they were focusing solely on outgoing ip traffic?
 
Specifically @middleview

I'd seriously like to hear your take on this, as I believe you had a valid criticism of the VIPS' earlier theory on the DNC file transfers. This, however, seems even more specific:

...and we were looking at the files posted by Wikileaks, because the allegation from the beginning is that Russia hacked the DNC and gave the emails to Wikileaks to publish. So, we looked at those emails, to see if there was something there that might give us some idea of how Wikileaks got that data. Well, in all the 35,813 emails that they posted in three batches, one [batch was] downloaded according to last modified times on the 23rd of May, and another on the 25th of May, and one [other] on the 26th of August, of 2016. Now, all those files, all 35,813, had a last modified time that was rounded off [rounded up] to an even [the next-higher] second, so they all ended up in even [meaning complete or full, not fractional] seconds. Now, if you know anything about data processing and data storage and things of that nature, there is a program that was quite common in the past [including 2016] using what’s called fat file formatting file allocation, table formatting, which is a process that when doing a batch process of data and transferring it to a storage device like a thumb drive or a CD-ROM, it rounds off the last modified time to the nearest even [next-higher] second, so that’s exactly the property we found in all that data posted by Wikileaks. Now, that said very simply this data was downloaded to a storage device a CD-ROM or a thumb drive and physically transported before Wikileaks could post it, so that meant it was not a hack [since there’s no rounding off to the next-higher second, as it would be if it’s a file that’s been carried over the internet], no matter how you look at it. We’re looking at the forensic evidence that says the DNC emails were not hacked, they were downloaded and physically transported to Wikileaks.


Would it be possible, for instance, to transfer the files to another server (which of course Crowdstrike claims they have no proof of) and then to a thumb drive, thereby creating this timestamp issue?

Additionally, if the files were downloaded directly from, say, the mail server itself to a thumb drive - would that be something that Crowdstrike's monitoring software would be able to pick up? Or is it likely they were focusing solely on outgoing ip traffic?

You seem to have gotten someone's very limited idea of how data might be captured from an email server. I assume they are using outlook. Not that I know that for sure.

Here is a file I extracted from OUTLOOK and saved as a file

1596392213894.png

Notice the seconds on the modified time stamp was rounded to the next even number. I tried it several times...it always ended up an even number.
The email time isn't the same as the time that would be recorded on a PKZIP file.
So if I ZIP a file on the DNC server, copy the ZIP file to another system and unZIP it the timestamp would be of the file would be the original timestamp of the file extracted.

You ask about things I cannot know. It would be highly unusual to have their email server systems in an unsecured area...(I think there were actually 9 systems). You'd have to have direct access to copy to a thumb drive and certainly access to a computer room would be logged. I don't know what crowdstrike's software actually does and neither does Zerohedge.

If security was lax someone could have copied from the email server directly to a thumb drive on a remote PC (as in someone's local DNC office). That would also require ADMIN access to extract email in bulk to a file. Accessing your own email and saving it as a file would be easier.
 
You seem to have gotten someone's very limited idea of how data might be captured from an email server. I assume they are using outlook. Not that I know that for sure.

Here is a file I extracted from OUTLOOK and saved as a file

View attachment 55226

Notice the seconds on the modified time stamp was rounded to the next even number. I tried it several times...it always ended up an even number.
The email time isn't the same as the time that would be recorded on a PKZIP file.
So if I ZIP a file on the DNC server, copy the ZIP file to another system and unZIP it the timestamp would be of the file would be the original timestamp of the file extracted.

You ask about things I cannot know. It would be highly unusual to have their email server systems in an unsecured area...(I think there were actually 9 systems). You'd have to have direct access to copy to a thumb drive and certainly access to a computer room would be logged. I don't know what crowdstrike's software actually does and neither does Zerohedge.

If security was lax someone could have copied from the email server directly to a thumb drive on a remote PC (as in someone's local DNC office). That would also require ADMIN access to extract email in bulk to a file. Accessing your own email and saving it as a file would be easier.

So you did it remotely and it did the same thing (round up to the next even second)?
 
So you did it remotely and it did the same thing (round up to the next even second)?

Er,what? The software the Russian ran would have looked like it was logged on locally.
You think if I used something like TeamViewer or a simple TTY logon it would look any different? Crowdstrike found the data extracted from outlook (or whatever email software) on the local email systems.

I did use PKZIP to compress it, move it to a different system and had the same creation and mod times.
 
Er,what? The software the Russian ran would have looked like it was logged on locally.
You think if I used something like TeamViewer or a simple TTY logon it would look any different? Crowdstrike found the data extracted from outlook (or whatever email software) on the local email systems.

I did use PKZIP to compress it, move it to a different system and had the same creation and mod times.

"Looked like" isn't "is." Are you suggesting that there is a way to log in remotely without the intrusion detection regime employed by Crowdstrike being able to see it? Why on earth would anyone waste their money on an "intrusion" consultant who can't see, well, intrusions?
 
"Looked like" isn't "is." Are you suggesting that there is a way to log in remotely without the intrusion detection regime employed by Crowdstrike being able to see it? Why on earth would anyone waste their money on an "intrusion" consultant who can't see, well, intrusions?

Do you think the Russians had to have logged in while Crowdstrike software was installed on all 9 of the DNC email servers? If you are thinking Crowdstrike should have caught the remote logon how in hell did some DNC employee walk into the data center, logon and download email to a thumbdrive and nobody saw him?

So the hack at Target stores took place over a period of time. Software was installed to capture the data they wanted and then the software sent the captured data to a site off network.
 
Do you think the Russians had to have logged in while Crowdstrike software was installed on all 9 of the DNC email servers? If you are thinking Crowdstrike should have caught the remote logon how in hell did some DNC employee walk into the data center, logon and download email to a thumbdrive and nobody saw him?

So the hack at Target stores took place over a period of time. Software was installed to capture the data they wanted and then the software sent the captured data to a site off network.

Probably at least one of the three times the emails were taken (between May 23rd and August 26th), don't you?

If Crowdstrike was looking at what the Russians were doing remotely because that is what they were hired to do, it's very possible that they would have missed the internal actor.
 
Do you think the Russians had to have logged in while Crowdstrike software was installed on all 9 of the DNC email servers? If you are thinking Crowdstrike should have caught the remote logon how in hell did some DNC employee walk into the data center, logon and download email to a thumbdrive and nobody saw him?

So the hack at Target stores took place over a period of time. Software was installed to capture the data they wanted and then the software sent the captured data to a site off network.
I’ve been a network engineer for over 25 years. You would not believe the lack of physical security that I have seen in some data centers. Especially when it comes to internal threats.
 
Back
Top