Dear Havelock:
First, let me thank you for responding in a cogent and thoughtful manner, this is exactly the kind of counter argument I have been looking for here for months.
I will clarify, at all costs, I wish to "prevent" the abuse of innocent children and people, that being said the means can be multi facted in their design, so I am an advocate of those who have deviant urges to seek help without the risk of retribution.
We cannot always understand the motivation and drive of those who have deviant overtones to their pyschological makeup, but first we must establish that the sexual congress between a child and an adult is in itself, deviant, we, in our small little world here in this convoluted Western culture, must have a baseline or a pre-condition for our motivations.
I do not wish to debate the veracity of other social mores or religious cultures that might allow for such congress; we know that the culture of a Western society in itself, creates a "childhood" for young people far beyond the allowable limits of a childhood for other cultures. I refer to the middle east as a thirteen year old girl in the middle east, may already have taken on the behavioural patterns of a young women, therefore, in those cultures that permit, the marriage of a 13 year old to a forty year old man isn't consider a heinous act, rather a normal state.
I speak to our culture, in an Occidental, not Oriental mindset, we do not consider thirteen year olds, adults, we do not consider our young as being part of a mature subset of our culture.
Therefore when we see them abused, it is our cultural armor that causes us to react, and it's a good thing in my view, as I was not born in Afganistan, in conclusion, there are differences.
Now, on the subject of those who have not abused, however, have the makings of a deviant nature, just as a person who is suffering from a bi-polar disease, these people should seek help, I am not advocating the summarial execution of such individuals; I am speaking here of a very specific case, where no attempt, no actions, no REACTIONS were taken to stop the abuse.
I am more enraged at those who were not part and parcel of the direct act, rather the support structure that allowed this to continue, and I am also very, very, disgusted with those who placed a sport so high on a pedestal, that not even the tearing of lower abdomenal tissue by force, with no cooperation of the receipent whatsoever, in fact, no previous admonishment nor education of that young receipent given, that could have caused a "fight or flee" reaction. We cannot talk about the pyschological rending of a normal behavioural fabric, as you and I both cannot begin to bucket what that might be.
I am also disgusted with the individuals who are not associated in anyway shape or form with this evil episode, who are defending the other actors in this tragedy thru legalese, process, procedure etc.
To Hell with that!, where's the moral compass! If I were Mike McQueary, and I happened upon Sandusky in that shower, and heard the "slapping of skin in a rhythmic fashion", I would have served some jail time, I would have stopped him and most likely thru bodily harm, there's no question of that, the consequences are minor and secondary in nature, the primary reaction should have been extreme physical harm to Sandusky.
This isn't just a gut reaction Havelock, this is a measured, logical, and sane approach to the situation, why, because "fight or flee" is an ingrained human trigger, and one that the very young do not possess, even animals in the wild, show this kind of reaction, baby deer, baby cheetahs, hide in the grass, the adults, will fight, this a clear indicator of how natural this reaction is.
I take extreme umbrage with the vision of football as being a mythical state, Joseph Campbell who wrote in the "power of myth" that we seek myths to sustain ourselves, he cites the Star wars series as a modern day mythological state, where good battles evil, We tend to side in a sport, and honor those we consider "good" and root for them to win, it satisfy some state of being in ourselves. But when that satisfaction is coupled with revenue, with gain, then sidebars like a defense coach physically abusing young children becomes the collateral damage in the protection of such a state. Campbell also refers to our worship of sports figures, whereas we attribute them with super human qualities, skills, etc. Therefore we worship, we seek to better ourselves thru our likes and associations with those we perceive as worthy of our praise. In this sense we associate and impart a sense of honor thru the minor act of worshiping those individuals. I am neither a romantic nor a seeker of such panaceas; I am a skeptic and a stoic, in my view? this is not necessary, in fact, it's wasteful, and time consuming.
This is where I have the MOST ire, and if you wish, ill intent; I wish to see those who are groomed and polished before a lectern and podium, speaking to their own reaction these events, when in fact, they were well aware of these events prior, shackled and disheveled in a court room, well publicized, defending their positions. I wish to see them brought down to the level of the shackled and disheveled 10 year old who was the receipent of a life altering act;
I do not advocate the wall papering over of the secret deviant urges of humans, I am not a big fan of the fifties, with all it's false equilavency, and subterfuge; I do support those who are experiencing any kind of mental illness. I like reality Havelock, I embrace it, and when it comes to truth and death, both get my widest smiles.
But let me be very clear, the goal for me is to prevent the abuse of children, and there are many means and methods to achieve that goal. In a Western society, we are not, any of us, advocates or rationalizers of this kind of state of being; we never will be.
I will rest my position on my birthright as Western child; and I will state again, above all else, the prevention of this kind of abuse, thru multifaceted approaches, is fine by me. I care nothing about the rationalization of the methods, I wish to see results when it comes to the goal.
Regards
Pace