Arkady
President
I may have missed it, but I haven't seen anyone here draw the parallel between the Rick Perry indictment and the supposedly planned lawsuit against Obama. Obviously, there are some differences, starting with the fact we're talking about a civil suit versus a criminal prosecution, and that the one only had to convince partisan Republican politicians to get rolling, whereas the other had to convince a grand jury. But, there are some similarities. In each case, there is an issue about how far an executive can push discretion in exercising his powers. If Obama uses his discretion to effectively negate laws he doesn't like, or Perry uses his to force elected officials he doesn't like out of office, does that cross a line?
I'm curious whether people here have taken consistent positions between the two, or whether they distinguish between the two. If the latter, presumably they do so along partisan lines (e.g., a Republican supporting the action against Obama but not against Perry, and vice versa for a Democrat). But presumably those who distinguish between them aren't going to characterize that as a partisan distinction, but rather will say it's based on substantive differences between the cases, and that their positions would be the same if the parties were reversed. As skeptical as we'll naturally be about such claims, I'm curious to hear how people on each side draw that distinction.
For my part, I have taken consistent positions. Although I think the House Republicans are hypocritical scumbags, and that Obama has been far less abusive of his authority than Bush was, I actually favor a lawsuit along the general lines of what the Republicans have been talking about. I think it will be valuable to get precedent-setting court rulings delineating the proper parameters of presidential discretion, since I think Executive power and autonomy have been horribly over-extended in recent decades. So, I think I'm on sturdy ground, now, to also take a strong stance against a governor using veto power to try to force an elected official to resign.
I'm curious whether people here have taken consistent positions between the two, or whether they distinguish between the two. If the latter, presumably they do so along partisan lines (e.g., a Republican supporting the action against Obama but not against Perry, and vice versa for a Democrat). But presumably those who distinguish between them aren't going to characterize that as a partisan distinction, but rather will say it's based on substantive differences between the cases, and that their positions would be the same if the parties were reversed. As skeptical as we'll naturally be about such claims, I'm curious to hear how people on each side draw that distinction.
For my part, I have taken consistent positions. Although I think the House Republicans are hypocritical scumbags, and that Obama has been far less abusive of his authority than Bush was, I actually favor a lawsuit along the general lines of what the Republicans have been talking about. I think it will be valuable to get precedent-setting court rulings delineating the proper parameters of presidential discretion, since I think Executive power and autonomy have been horribly over-extended in recent decades. So, I think I'm on sturdy ground, now, to also take a strong stance against a governor using veto power to try to force an elected official to resign.