New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Personal responsibility...

Some people are saying there should be more personal responsibility, but isn't that where we have been and a big MESS was the result????

Did the government crash the economy or was it irresponsible people? How is it some seem to want to blame the crash on the government or those that hadn't even been elected to their current office for the problems we face? I think lots of Americans know why. Because some want to distract from where the root of the problem lies.

People were also "personally responsible" before the Great Depression, yet look how "responsible" they were. Did the governent cause the Great Depression or all the economic problems in a "free banking" economy?

Is it "responsible" as a human being or a corporate head to walk all over people you have already knocked over or are down and out?

Is it "responsible" to get a tax break for providing benefits to employees, takng too much off the top, find one's company or self in financial straights because they didin't plan their finances right and paid themselves, upper management, if not everyone else too much and didn't "conserve" enough to sustain the benefits and pay they offered in exchange for people's labor, then ask only the lower paid employees to be laid off, take lower pay, lower benefits or both (renege on their agreements) so they can keep their own level of pay or make even more for themselves?

How "responsible" is it to claim the current president ruined or has been terrible for the economy of this nation when the nation's economy had crashed BEFORE the current president was elected to that office?

How "responsible is it to watch your own nation and so many people in it suffer as you profit from investing in companies or head up companies that fire Americans to hire cheaper labor in other nations, then quibble about being asked to help your own nation out a little more??

The problem I see is that many of the people suggesting the government needs to spend less on helping people of the nation survive through tough times and spend more on weapons of war are some of the biggest contributors to why this nation has economic problems and why MORE people, not fewer people, end up falling off the edge.

Can someone show me where, in the books of the Bible or other scripture or even universally known sectarian values, capitalism in the form of excessive wealth, vanity, greed and gluttony is promoted???

Why is it so many "personal responsibility" promoters are all for other people being "personally responsible" as long as they are doing financially well and profitting at the expense of others, but call for others to help them or pass a law to favor or protect them when they are not doing so well or losing at the expense of others?

Does anyone think crooks wouldn't love to have "less government" so they can rip off more people without being held accountable or with no one saying no, you can't be unethical, unfair, unjust, just because you want to make a profit?

We've been through the "might makes right" animal like "survival of the fittest" eras in human history during the stone age and before. Some humans found they had emotions, one of those emotions being caring about their fellow human beings, along with a sense of fairness, justice and all the values that represent humanitarianism.

It would seem some want to return to the stone age and earlier to a "might makes right", "survival of the fittest" world under the guise of "personal responsibility". I'm not sure they really know what they want as the same seem to be the first to look for help from their fellow human beings when they or one of their loved ones run into trouble and need help.
 
It would seem some want to return to the stone age and earlier to a "might makes right", "survival of the fittest" world under the guise of "personal responsibility". I'm not sure they really know what they want as the same seem tp be the first to look for help from their fellow human beings when they or one of their loved ones run into trouble and need help.


For some folks, that's the only point at which realism finally trumps idealism.
 
For some folks, that's the only point at which realism finally trumps idealism.

Is it idealism or self-denial and denial of their group's idealism in relation to their group's claims about themselves, I don't know?

I've been trying to figure out how owning, 4, 5,6 or more homes when so many people struggle to afford and maintain one or to put food on the table for their family while working three jobs, demonstrates humility, conservativism or a belief in the teachings of Christ, but some seem to say or think it does. Others ask why how that is so and are called communists for asking.

36557_400286483326828_109200595768753_1266454_34568784_n.jpg

530078_394198780602265_109200595768753_1251597_459316866_n.jpg
 
I've been trying to figure out how owning, 4, 5,6 or more homes when so many people struggle to afford and maintain one or to put food on the table for their family while working three jobs, demonstrates humility, conservativism or a belief in the teachings of Christ, but some seem to say or think it does.


I understand. And yet, one could (and would) easily make the argument that Mitt can't improve the lot of the poor simply by not having several houses and cars. That's true. It's irrelevant to the point being discussed, but it's true. There's nothing inherently wrong with being born wealthy. But it's certainly hypocritical for someone to live such a lavish lifestyle while simultaneously claiming adherence to a religious tradition that teaches it's followers to do the very opposite. The problem with religion is that everyone seems to have their own, personal version.

The modern American Republican Party is not "Conservative". It has been radicalized and is closer in political philosophy to Objectivism than to Conservatism.
 
I understand. And yet, one could (and would) easily make the argument that Mitt can't improve the lot of the poor simply by not having several houses and cars. That's true. It's irrelevant to the point being discussed, but it's true. There's nothing inherently wrong with being born wealthy. But it's certainly hypocritical for someone to live such a lavish lifestyle while simultaneously claiming adherence to a religious tradition that teaches it's followers to do the very opposite. The problem with religion is that everyone seems to have their own, personal version.

The modern American Republican Party is not "Conservative". It has been radicalized and is closer in political philosophy to Objectivism than to Conservatism.

I agree that Mitt doing as Christ suggested with regard to giving his great fortune away would not individually, improve the lot of the poor, but taken as a "rule" for the very fortunate, the cumulative effect of ALL in Mitt Romney's position doing the same, or in the very least, contributing a lot more than they do, actually WOULD improve the lot of the poor and improve is the key word. Because there are a lot fewer wealthy people than poor, the act of the wealthy giving away much of their wealth to the poor will not be as some of the wealthy of today like to characterize it. It will not simply be taking from the wealthy and transferring their wealth to make others equally wealthy, but will in effect, improve the lot of the poor, not making them wealthy in the sense that the most wealthy are, but will help them rise from their poverty. The practical ideal behind doing so is that all are elevated and that the wealthy are doing as the god they claim to believe in would be doing.

Taxes just prior to the days of Christ were collected by the Tax Farmers (Publicani) and that turned out to be quite profitable for them along with their also being money lenders (bankers), - http://www.unrv.com/economy/roman-taxes.php - but too much corruption put an end to that and other means of taxation came into being.

But here's just one direct reference to those "Republicani" in scripture.

Matthew 5:46-47

46 For if ye love them which love you, what reward have ye? do not even the publicans the same?

47 And if ye salute your brethren only, what do ye more than others? do not even the publicans so?


Somewhat interesting that Matthew 5 seems to contain a lot of things that seem most overlooked or ignored by some of those most vocal about their own piety.

While the political philosophy of the current American "republican" Party might be Ayn Rand's version of "Objectivism", I see her philosophy of life more as subjectivism (through her's and those of her followers, own eyes). I have always viewed being objective as being focused on something outside of one's personal realm and subjectivism as being absorbed with one's personal realm and reality.

I see the objective of Congress as well as humanity as a combination of survival as the "self" as an individual and as a contributor to the survival of society or maybe a better way to put it, an objective of direct and indirect ways of working to ensure one's own survival. It would seem one's survival is best ensured, not subjectively, as that would appear to try to ignore reality at times in favor of what one believed, but by helping to ensure the society one was a part of was healthy as a means of ensuring one's own health since humans tend to live in societies.

While we might all belong to the same species, we are also unique from one another, thus we are bound to each other in certain ways, independent in other ways. Because we live in societies, there is a great deal of benefit to each individual in our societies because of the exchange and interaction between individuals. We're here typing messages to one another, NOT because we each invented our own computer and somehow plugged them into some central network that we all literally physically constructed jointly. We may have bought our computers individually and independently from one another and pay for our internet service providers and access individually, but as Mr. Obama pointed out in general, the vast majority of us didn't invent and make our own computers or the internet, other people did that and we take advantage of it in any number of ways to enrich our own lives, mentally or literally as a money making tool.

As you have pointed out, some seem to believe what defies reality with regard to what they have literally and physically done on their own versus what they take advantage of that was not built by them, but the collective efforts of the society they seem to believe is their enemy or simply does not exist outside of what they believe in some odd fantasy, they have done solely on their own.

I always say, if one thinks so highly of their individualism, then let them live in the wilderness for a while to realize what they truly have built solely on their own or are truly capable of "building" on their own without anyone else around to help them. Their "reality" seems to view hiring a hundred people to move a rock as their moving the rock on their own because they were the one's that hired the hundred people. The reality of others is that while one might be responsible for hring a hundred people, were there not a hundred people to hire or also involved in the act of moving the rock, the person that claims to have been responsible for moving the rock wouldn't have a chance in hell of moving the rock by themselves. The reality is that 101 people, maybe more, moved the rock, each playing a role in doing so. Mitt Romeny does not solely support the U.S. economy or his own income, nor do the wealthy as a group solely support the nation's economy or their own incomes. The nation's economy is supported by the combination or massive numbers of lower and middle incomes and wealthy incomes and as with the pyramids, the tiny tip at the top is supported and held up by all under it.

Oddly, some of those that benefit most from it have either forgotten or strangely can't seem to comprehend how a 6,7 or 8 figure income is made possible.

Mrs. Fields cookies ae awfully tasty, but Debbi Fields a long time ago stopped being the sole baker of all the cookies sold under her name and if she was the sole baker, her income from the sale of those cookies would be a minute fraction of what it is due to all those that do that labor for her, in exchange for what they are paid and they are paid less than what their labors produce for the company based on what the product is sold for. The difference between cost to produce and gross income is called profit. Thus it means employees of profitable companies generally donate some of their labors toward profit. That is why there appears to be a higher sense of stability in most employee owned businesses. http://chrs.rutgers.edu/pub_documents/PKS_530.pdf Economic and social stability also seems to be a common factor in nations with a higher balance of societal contribution.

The romanticized notion or vision of "individualism" seems to have been derived from pioneer days when this nation was being settled by people who set out to the fringes of western "civilization" to carve a living out of a "virgin" piece of land or place. Regardless of what they "built from nothing", the fact remains that they didn't in reality build small business empires soley and physically on their own. Any supplies and tools (harvested, mined or fabricated by others) they had shipped in contributed to whatever has been claimed as their sole doing. Same with any labor they hired as it demonstrates their need for others to achieve what they claim as their sole doing or others claim as their sole work.

In a subjective sense, one could claim business empires were "built" by those with their names on the letterhead, but in a literal sense, take away any other human contribution to the whole package and there is not likely to be a whole package one can claim as something they "built on their own.".

Have a great Friday NS!
Knot
 
Back
Top