New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Petition.....

How come no support, Leroy?

Needed to sign up for an account. The first several times I tried it---yesterday---it was rejecting me, saying I did not correctly answer the computer security question (the caption question). I got annoyed and gave up. It just accepted me, and I am waiting for the email from them to finalize my account. I'll sign it, even though I have some mild misgivings about switching ENTIRELY to a popular vote. I don't like the way the electoral college is currently set up, but think that if every state apportioned electoral votes by Congressional district, the way Maine and Nebraska do, it would be better.
 
middleview, I can't sign your petition. Please consider my hypothetical:

I'm a righteous do-gooder, who's made the underage sex trade, my cause celebre. I've formed a foundation dedicated to researching the issue to the nth degree, and maximizing practical advocacy for victims of this crime. I've solicited $5 Million in donations from people-of-goodwill, from around the nation.

I've convinced MY Congressman to take up this cause. Since he chairs a committee that encompasses this cause, I'm hopeful that he'll be a big help.

My Congressman is in a very tight race this year and is being outspent by his opponent. He desperately needs $1 Million to even the ad score. Per your suggested regimes, I'm forbidden from giving him $1 Million from my fund.
 
If only that were the common case...but it isn't.

1. If you want someone to win then encourage your supporters to make direct contributions to that congressman....if they are in his district.
2. The fact is probably that he'd be outspent by a candidate getting money from out of his district....right? If all things were fair then if your pal the congressman couldn't raise money from his own constituency then he probably doesn't deserve election.
3. The majority of those 501c3s and their dark money are devoted to eliminating the EPA or the tax breaks for oil companies....Sheldon Adelson put $10 million into Gingrich and then Romney's races.

Regardless of how well meaning your fundraising is, most contributions are not so clean....
 
1. If you want someone to win then encourage your supporters to make direct contributions to that congressman....if they are in his district.
2. The fact is probably that he'd be outspent by a candidate getting money from out of his district....right? If all things were fair then if your pal the congressman couldn't raise money from his own constituency then he probably doesn't deserve election.
3. The majority of those 501c3s and their dark money are devoted to eliminating the EPA or the tax breaks for oil companies....Sheldon Adelson put $10 million into Gingrich and then Romney's races.

Regardless of how well meaning your fundraising is, most contributions are not so clean....

Even if I stipulate to your suggestion that most contributions aren't clean, the fact remains that my cause, (my hypothetical one) is. My cause is spred disparately and randomly across our entire country, as are those who're sufficiently motivated and resourced to address it effectively. Yet, you're telling me that my cause MUST be circumscribed by my 1/435th little part of our politic.
 
If you are correct in interpreting your rights, then you should be able to vote in congressional elections regardless of where you live. You are not. Therefore your participation in the elecxtion of my congressmen or women is actually an infringment on my rights. The senators and representatives in my state should win or lose based on the support of the voters in my state. There are many ways for your hypothetical group to get your message out without attempting to gain influence over the elected officials in my district.....unless you are in my district. Even a group with a good cause should have no more financial influence than an individual does. The number of congressmen who are scared to death to cross the NRA is a prime example....Someone may have a tiny number of gun owners in his district but fear the potential attack ads from the NRA....
 
I agree and will sign that petition as soon as I can log on. One interesting point here is that the voter will again have some say over the direction of their patch, their state, and their country. The other thing of note is that such a scheme forces the politicians to get out their personally and talk to voters, find out what they want and need from him/her. No more mass mailings as that wouldn't be affordable, no more mass TV campaigns with unknown money and unknown interests, no more hiding away how you would govern.

I especially liked #2; it keeps out people without a direct interest in the result.
 
The founders also restricted voting to land owners, but such a step would violate the spirit if not the letter of the constitution. By the way, item #2 does what you want; restricts contributions to only those who will be represented by someone, IE, no outside money.
 
I think it means that a congressman would have to rely on volunteers, not paid campaign workers. More of their own constituents and neighbors have to be involved. That would make them more aware of what their elected officials are up to. I want the federal government to do less. I don't understand an interstate highway on Oahu. I don't understand a federally financed parking lot in Talkeetna Alaska (where there are no federal employees). I don't want the federal government to pay for a railroad museum in Pennsylvania....

Corruption begins with the money needed to get elected and to stay there. We can clean it up and I think this is the start.

Thanks for your signature...
 
If you are correct in interpreting your rights, then you should be able to vote in congressional elections regardless of where you live. You are not. Therefore your participation in the elecxtion of my congressmen or women is actually an infringment on my rights. The senators and representatives in my state should win or lose based on the support of the voters in my state. There are many ways for your hypothetical group to get your message out without attempting to gain influence over the elected officials in my district.....unless you are in my district. Even a group with a good cause should have no more financial influence than an individual does. The number of congressmen who are scared to death to cross the NRA is a prime example....Someone may have a tiny number of gun owners in his district but fear the potential attack ads from the NRA....

When you say "gain influence", you hint at a commonly held view that although it's not entirely invalid by any stretch, is not necessarily dispositive. Per my hypothetical, I'm not proposing to "bribe" my Congressman into taking up my cause. My Congressman is a fine man who would take up my cause in any case. His "problem" is that in order to to so, he needs to get re-elected and in order to get re-elected, he needs $1 Million.

The better approach imho, than telling him he can't have that $1 Million, is to design a system whereby he doesn't NEED that $1 Million.
 
Sorry, I just don't see that your hypothetical, in any way, justifies the $140 million Karl Rove spent slandering democrats. If you candidate is a fine man, but has a million bucks less than the opposition and they are operating with the same limitiations that your guys has....that does not persuade me that outside money makes sense. Limiting the source of money would be necessity limit the amount being spent. If only voters can contribute and voters can only contribute $2,000, but the opposition has a lot more money....what does that tell you? Your guy is probably going to lose.

The alternative is our candidates spending time out of state and meeting with all sorts of special interests to get money.

So let's say, for the sake of argument, that you have $5 million raised from around the country in support of some cause. Spend the money educating voters about the cause....not about the politics. Let your candidate then speak out in support of that cause.....as it is the 501c3 ads make the voters more polarized and less informed.
 
I have no intentions of defending Karl Rove and his modus. But, your proposed regime is a non-starter due to its rather radical "free speech" issues. I just can't get behind ideas that're non-starters.

In the case of "Citizens United", Rove, et al, I think our better and more realistic approach is to push for expanded transparency. Take my hypothetical: Let's say my favored Congressman's opponent took in $1 Million from "The American Strip Club Association". We can dream of a law (that would never happen) that would prevent him from accessing that dough. OR, we could realistically pass a law that requires him to publish the source of his dough.

I would argue that my cause would actually be BETTER served by his taking that money and my making its source public, than it would've been had he never gotten it in the first place.
 
So in you hypothetical, a group with the name "Americans for Prosperity" if disclosed as the source of money for a given campaign would be enough? It isn't. The Koch brothers tried to fund Cain's campaign and you and I knew nothing about it. It wasn't a group, it was two guys. They'd have had enormous influence over the Cain administration....

What is wrong with your group suggesting to it's members or supporters that they support their own elected representative to work for the cause you are in favor of? Instead you have a situation where a group, even one with a good cause, may support a campaign because that rep supports your cause...that doesn't mean that your cause supercedes the interests of the constituents of the person running for office in my district....if your opinion about free speech were to apply then you should be able to vote for my congressman or senator.....in other words....we are talking about my congressmen and not yours.
 
Back
Top