New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Philosophical Differences

"History clearly shows that lower tax rates don't lead to greater economic growth".

LeRoy: That same conclusion also holds true in cross-national comparisons. And the richest countries in the world tend to have the highest tax rates, a fact which leaves Republicans simply flabbergasted.
 
I did not inquire as to the founders beliefs.

You used a specific phrase and you attributed that specific phrase to the "founders".

As we can see...it's nonsense. Some of the founders were devout Christians, others were not. Jefferson is well known for his version of the Bible. I could post plenty of quotes that showed their doubts as well.

None of that means a damn thing in the context of this conversation...and it is merely a distraction.

The phrase is what I am discussing....and it it what you are running from.

I've been told there is but one God...but you now name a "Christian" God. And one who seems very insecure.

Trying to revise Jefferson's stance on religion got Barton in trouble. Link
 
"History clearly shows that lower tax rates don't lead to greater economic growth".

LeRoy: That same conclusion also holds true in cross-national comparisons. And the richest countries in the world tend to have the highest tax rates, a fact which leaves Republicans simply flabbergasted.

Not just the richest nations, but the ones that still have the most stable economies. The founders of this nation wanted to combine rule of "the people" (society) self-governance, but through representative government. Strange that "republicans" are against government since elected non-hereditary representatives as a function of democratic self rule, essentially defines a need for a formal government. A pure democracy essentially says all the people are "reperesentatives" of themselves or all the people constitute "government" or a "Congress". In our system, logistically easier to deal with, "the people" elect people from their numbers to be their representatives, rather than have 200 million plus adults descend upon D.C. to hammer our each piece of legislation. By reference to "we the people" (as a collective society) the founders were essentially presenting a social government where through elected representatives, society creates the rules, not small groups or individuals. The system designed and chosen has its downsides as it can still be dominated by special interests, but the checks and balances to that are the collective vote of the masses.

Some wealthy, as a group, could use their wealth to pay off people to look the other way or vote for representatives that would vote in ways to advantage the wealthy, but the foil to that is that while the wealthy may have monetary resources, they don't have equal resources in numbers of population who are wealthy, thus some semblence of balance is offered. People are naturally to an extent, look out for their own interests and counterbalance one another. Our founders were coming from a history of monarchies and tyranical rule, their fear of government was not so much as characterized today as usurpation of their design through cracks in it, by people who would become more like monarchs, dictators and tyrants. I imagine they saw and foresaw waxing and waning in the size and scope of their government design as required by "the people". As Madison (who had changes of mind regarding waryiness of government), said, "if all men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither external nor internal controls on government would be necessary"

In other words, he was pointing out that human behavior has much to do with the need and the scope of government and control of the government. If we all, or a lot more of us would just act more angelic, there would be no or a lot less need for government, and a lot less need for government oversight. If there were much fewer or no starving people in the U.S., no unemployed and communities pitched in and together to do things like interstate highway systems and managed their books, lives and businesses perfectly, were honest and offered fair and square deals, there were no natural disasters that people need emergency relief and help from in their aftermath, if people would simply send checks to schools in excess of the amount needed to educate all children to a minimum modern standard.................etc...etc...all those down on their government would be happy.

Where there is "a government of the people, by the people and for the people" the size and scope of that government is up to "the people", not small numbers of the people, not individuals.

I think some people recognized and recognize that a corrupt and selfish society is going to see the same in "a governent of the people, by the people and for the people". So the solution to better government is better societal behavior, attitudes and action. That would seem to include doing more walking of the talk.
 
That isn't what he was talking about and Lefty knows it.

Says the guy who obviously hasn't read it in context because he likes being deceived.
 
Romney and Ryan

Anagram:

Rmoney/Ayn Rand

But I'm not superstitious.
 
IOW Government ventures.

But not FEDERAL government ventures -- a significant difference.


NONE were purely private. Because it was impossible for them to gain the land for their Right Of Ways' without use of the exact sort of "emminent domain" condemnation you have decried and derided in Kelo


"None" is one of those wonderful all-encompassing terms that you probably shouldn't use. Some of the early railroads simply purchased their easements.
 
If government is not there to define what is and is not a "good" or "service" and what constitutes "owerneship" - what precludes "might makes right" slavery?

As government doesn't do this, what's you're point? The government, just for example, has determined that marijuana is NOT a good or service -- and yet it is traded globally.
 
It never ceases to amaze me that when the far far left socialist progressives are confronted with facts, they either deny these facts or refute their sources saying the source was biased or far right, even when there are numerous sources provided from many different points of view.

All right... what got the panties wound up?
 
If government is not there to define what is and is not a "good" or "service" and what constitutes "owerneship" - what precludes "might makes right" slavery?

As government doesn't do this, what's you're point? The government, just for example, has determined that marijuana is NOT a good or service -- and yet it is traded globally.

How is it that government does NOT do this? As you point out, government does not protect the MJ trade, so the market is a Might Makes Right market... yes and?

After all if I take MJ from you that you believe is yours what recourse do you have except violence towards me?
If you sell me oregano as MJ what recourse do I have against you except violence?
If you have MJ in your pocket and I say it is mine - what mechanism other than violence - do you have with which to dispute that claim?

If you have MJ in your speedboat and I come alongside with more guys and a bigger boat and say that your MJ actually is mine - what recourse do you have other than violence?

If I hold a gun to your family's heads and force you to cultivate my MJ fields... how is that not slavery?


So again, how is it that The government does not define what is a good and what is ownership?
How does it not preclude Might Makes Right slavery?
 
Back
Top