Arkady
President
How would you rate your memory, overall? I'm curious if there are political tendencies when it comes to the way different people's memories work. My own sense, based on nothing but personal experience, is that liberals cluster less in the middle of the curve than conservatives. It seems you find more liberals both among those who are profoundly muddle-headed (having strong feelings about what's right and wrong, but without the ability to marshal even a handful of facts in support of the argument), and also among those who have the ability to call up vast armies of very specific examples and data to make their case. Conservatives, by comparison, seem more likely to fall into the middle: consistently able to command a small platoon of facts in support of an argument.
There's nothing inherently superior about any of these modes, which makes sense if you stop and think about how memory really works. Photographic memories are great as a cocktail party trick, but they have a real downside:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/2013/07/18/what_is_it_like_to_have_a_photographic_memory.html
There's a reason the human brain doesn't usually work that way. Being inundated with a tidal wave of details isn't a great thing for efficient or even accurate thought. So, typically, the brain generalizes -- gradually integrating new facts into "gut level" reactions, letting the details pass from memory in favor of simplified mental models of the world that can be deployed very quickly and, quite possibly, more reliably than undigested specifics.
So, I'm not attempting to argue there's something morally or intellectually better about liberals spreading to the high and low ends of the memory spectrum, or about conservatives clustering in the middle (if that guess is even right). I'm just curious if it's correct and, if so, what implications that might have for the best ways to find common ground.
For my own part, I have a really strong memory in a lot of ways. I can, many years later, recite exact sentences and phrases from books I read just once -- sometimes I can even picture right where the sentences sat on the pages. My brain records numbers quite accurately, too, especially if I ever deployed them in an argument (e.g., knowing exactly what the unemployment rate was in December of 2000, or the GDP growth rate in 1937). I've got what an ex-girlfriend called a "garbage mind," since my brain just doesn't tend to "take out the trash" very often -- things, especially academic things, that others tend to forget are lodged with me long term. It makes me deadly at Jeopardy or Trivial Pursuit, and makes me very quick at my job (since I basically carry a database of legal language around in my head that lets me do on the fly what others require constant research to do).
For me, the downside isn't so much brain clutter, of the sort those with true eidetic or photographic memories talk about, but rather than my brain seems to have pulled off the trick by way of freeing up space with an almost sociopathic neglect for personal memory. I can literally be shaking someone's hand, having been introduced ten seconds earlier, and I will have already forgotten their name. It's bizarre. I am constantly having to fake recognition of names and faces that I know I should know, but I just don't, which is potentially quite embarrassing, since most people remember me very well. I often offend people without meaning to, by forgetting basic facts about them. This can also make me socially awkward, because I'm cautious during interactions, for fear of screwing something up by way of poor memory (e.g., asking about how someone's sick parent is doing, having forgotten that the parent died a few months ago).
My brain also seems to have freed up space by not establishing the kinds of sub-routines most people have that remind them to do stuff. If my wife asks me to start the dish washer before going to bed, I will forget, unless I tell my phone to remind me. It's not "convenient amnesia," since it's actually quite inconvenient: it generally results in me having to set up electronic reminders or do things immediately to avoid forgetting. It's just the way my brain works. There's no "background process" running, waiting to tell me to do something when the time is right. Something's either on my mind at that very moment, or it's in cold storage. If it's in cold storage, I can recall it at will, but there's no subconscious mechanism that pushes it up to the front of my mind without a conscious trigger. I'm always amazed by other people's ability to just spontaneously remember that they wanted to buy a certain thing at the store the next time they were there, which would never happen for me: if I didn't write it down and am not thinking about it actively at the moment, it's never going to bubble up into my consciousness at the right moment.
So, in a sense, my memory is at both ends of the spectrum -- shocking to people who get to know me first for my extraordinary recall of some facts, and then later equally shocking to them when they get to know just how absent minded and foggy I can be in other ways.
There's nothing inherently superior about any of these modes, which makes sense if you stop and think about how memory really works. Photographic memories are great as a cocktail party trick, but they have a real downside:
http://www.slate.com/blogs/quora/2013/07/18/what_is_it_like_to_have_a_photographic_memory.html
There's a reason the human brain doesn't usually work that way. Being inundated with a tidal wave of details isn't a great thing for efficient or even accurate thought. So, typically, the brain generalizes -- gradually integrating new facts into "gut level" reactions, letting the details pass from memory in favor of simplified mental models of the world that can be deployed very quickly and, quite possibly, more reliably than undigested specifics.
So, I'm not attempting to argue there's something morally or intellectually better about liberals spreading to the high and low ends of the memory spectrum, or about conservatives clustering in the middle (if that guess is even right). I'm just curious if it's correct and, if so, what implications that might have for the best ways to find common ground.
For my own part, I have a really strong memory in a lot of ways. I can, many years later, recite exact sentences and phrases from books I read just once -- sometimes I can even picture right where the sentences sat on the pages. My brain records numbers quite accurately, too, especially if I ever deployed them in an argument (e.g., knowing exactly what the unemployment rate was in December of 2000, or the GDP growth rate in 1937). I've got what an ex-girlfriend called a "garbage mind," since my brain just doesn't tend to "take out the trash" very often -- things, especially academic things, that others tend to forget are lodged with me long term. It makes me deadly at Jeopardy or Trivial Pursuit, and makes me very quick at my job (since I basically carry a database of legal language around in my head that lets me do on the fly what others require constant research to do).
For me, the downside isn't so much brain clutter, of the sort those with true eidetic or photographic memories talk about, but rather than my brain seems to have pulled off the trick by way of freeing up space with an almost sociopathic neglect for personal memory. I can literally be shaking someone's hand, having been introduced ten seconds earlier, and I will have already forgotten their name. It's bizarre. I am constantly having to fake recognition of names and faces that I know I should know, but I just don't, which is potentially quite embarrassing, since most people remember me very well. I often offend people without meaning to, by forgetting basic facts about them. This can also make me socially awkward, because I'm cautious during interactions, for fear of screwing something up by way of poor memory (e.g., asking about how someone's sick parent is doing, having forgotten that the parent died a few months ago).
My brain also seems to have freed up space by not establishing the kinds of sub-routines most people have that remind them to do stuff. If my wife asks me to start the dish washer before going to bed, I will forget, unless I tell my phone to remind me. It's not "convenient amnesia," since it's actually quite inconvenient: it generally results in me having to set up electronic reminders or do things immediately to avoid forgetting. It's just the way my brain works. There's no "background process" running, waiting to tell me to do something when the time is right. Something's either on my mind at that very moment, or it's in cold storage. If it's in cold storage, I can recall it at will, but there's no subconscious mechanism that pushes it up to the front of my mind without a conscious trigger. I'm always amazed by other people's ability to just spontaneously remember that they wanted to buy a certain thing at the store the next time they were there, which would never happen for me: if I didn't write it down and am not thinking about it actively at the moment, it's never going to bubble up into my consciousness at the right moment.
So, in a sense, my memory is at both ends of the spectrum -- shocking to people who get to know me first for my extraordinary recall of some facts, and then later equally shocking to them when they get to know just how absent minded and foggy I can be in other ways.