New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Poll on Moderating

Are we all happy about the new PJ rules?

  • Moderating should be harsher,

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    12
Yes, it is good if you are able to cause some basic introspection and rethinking of poorly conceived concessions (and, believe me, I specifically use the term "concessions" for a reason - frankly, it's been one ankle-grab after another - from symbols, buttons, and emoticons to rules enforcement). The whining, moaning squeaky wheel gets the lube.

Good luck with that. Principle and...ahem...testicular fortitude are in short supply in 21st Century America.

We're all Oprah now.

Ohhhh no not Oprah!!!! You'll give us all nightmares!

xxx Night sweety xxx Dunno if I can sleep but I have reading to catch up with ---- The effects of The Treaty of Rome on Local Government in England and Wales ---- nice and light --- I'll be asleep in no time ;)
 
Ohhhh no not Oprah!!!! You'll give us all nightmares!

xxx Night sweety xxx Dunno if I can sleep but I have reading to catch up with ---- The effects of The Treaty of Rome on Local Government in England and Wales ---- nice and light --- I'll be asleep in no time ;)
God bless, good nite, and kick it in the tail (in that order). :)
 
Who knows? It's his call - as it should be as owner.
I'm not actually arguing for insults in any case. I am arguing that there exist more formidable obstacles to good faith discussion than simple name-calling...and that stifling expression is a cure worse than the disease. Many is the time I've been called all manner of things...from "Theocrat" to "fake Christian" (virtually EVERY TIME I AM HERE) by the same two posters. I never report it. I will never report other posters. Never have, never will.
Free expression is too important. Even when folks are wrong.
I abide by the rules. If one person isn't allowed that free expression, then nobody should be allowed it. So if I see the rules broken, I turn it in. I would like to see some rules deleted in the name of free speech.

I would like to see rules that don't amount to censorship. I prefer it when a topic is discussed without insults, but I know that insults are going to happen at some point. Let 'em happen and moderators should just stay out of the way.

It would be nice if we had a threaded view so that when someone tries to derail a thread, their little derailment tangent could be ignored by those of us who want an actual discussion. But to see a threaded view is the only way to really make that happen. And we don't have that.
 
Ohhhh no not Oprah!!!! You'll give us all nightmares!

xxx Night sweety xxx Dunno if I can sleep but I have reading to catch up with ---- The effects of The Treaty of Rome on Local Government in England and Wales ---- nice and light --- I'll be asleep in no time ;)
God bless, good nite, and kick it in the tail (in that order). :)
I abide by the rules. If one person isn't allowed that free expression, then nobody should be allowed it. So if I see the rules broken, I turn it in. I would like to see some rules deleted in the name of free speech.

I would like to see rules that don't amount to censorship. I prefer it when a topic is discussed without insults, but I know that insults are going to happen at some point. Let 'em happen and moderators should just stay out of the way.

It would be nice if we had a threaded view so that when someone tries to derail a thread, their little derailment tangent could be ignored by those of us who want an actual discussion. But to see a threaded view is the only way to really make that happen. And we don't have that.
Totally agree on the "threaded view" utility. That is very helpful. I miss it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Dang.
I had no idea.
There is no point in posting when there are so many words in the list of things we can't say that nobody can remember what they are.

Moderators should be pleased if they are asked to just moderate actual threats and illegal statements. That's how I would like to see it go.

But then, of course................. the thread killers would be out there killing any decent thread that shows up. Clearly, we have people here who would never be allowed to stay on any other board.

It is those thread killers, and we all know who they are, and the thread killing is no accident .............who will kill the board if they can. I am here less too.
Yep. I find it very hard to abide by the rules since I can't even remember what they are from one day to the next... LOL

Too much gray in that there 'rule book' for my taste. :rolleyes:
 
SW is an intelligent man. He can see thru the ugly motives of some here. I don't think he is going to allow name calling anymore. And he shouldn't. It isn't censorship; it's just common courtesy.
Anyone who doesn't like his rules is free to seek greener pastures.

Sticks and stones... don't be such a sensitive flower. In the heat of discussion, there will always be a 'slip of the tongue'. So what?
 
i guess let's start this again. It's like talking to the alzheimerish grandparent who forgets what was said moments ago...and offers you the cookie for the umpteenth time...

a. moderation is pretty light.
b. same people, over and over again.
c. a is b, b is a. (one time people want strict moderation, the next no moderation.)
d. no one knows about no rules. theyve been in the same place since they were placed there years ago. no one really cares other than to use some piecie of it as a bludgeon against another.
e. see b.
f. i could ask those complaining to come moderate, again, and again but, never any takers. (if you saw the dialoge on the back end, you would understand how even it is.
g. g, well mostly even. see.b.
 
i guess let's start this again. It's like talking to the alzheimerish grandparent who forgets what was said moments ago...and offers you the cookie for the umpteenth time...

a. moderation is pretty light.
b. same people, over and over again.
c. a is b, b is a. (one time people want strict moderation, the next no moderation.)
d. no one knows about no rules. theyve been in the same place since they were placed there years ago. no one really cares other than to use some piecie of it as a bludgeon against another.
e. see b.
f. i could ask those complaining to come moderate, again, and again but, never any takers. (if you saw the dialoge on the back end, you would understand how even it is.
g. g, well mostly even. see.b.

I am not a, nor am I b.
 
i guess let's start this again. It's like talking to the alzheimerish grandparent who forgets what was said moments ago...and offers you the cookie for the umpteenth time...

a. moderation is pretty light.
b. same people, over and over again.
c. a is b, b is a. (one time people want strict moderation, the next no moderation.)
d. no one knows about no rules. theyve been in the same place since they were placed there years ago. no one really cares other than to use some piecie of it as a bludgeon against another.
e. see b.
f. i could ask those complaining to come moderate, again, and again but, never any takers. (if you saw the dialoge on the back end, you would understand how even it is.
g. g, well mostly even. see.b.

I understand what you are saying, @PhilFish . And @SW48 , if you care for my opinion for the umpteenth time. :oops:
But don't say there are never any takers when you ask people to come moderate. I know of several who have volunteered.

Moderation will never make everyone happy, but it is a good idea to try for consistency.

For example, sometimes calling someone "bonehead" gets a person banned for a couple of days, other times it doesn't. Why? Because if it doesn't get turned in, it won't be moderated. "Moderators can't be here 24/7 to police the board" , you say. And of course that's true.

So what is the logical answer?

To me the answer is this: "Suck it up, Buttercup". If you get called a name, deal with it. Name-calling won't be moderated. Period. Don't send it in...... Mods don't care.

There can be a few (really, less than 5) words so terrible that if they are posted they are Xed out. But even they shouldn't bring on a suspension unless the poster causes undue work by the mods by overusing those words and THAT would be moderator discretion as to how much is too much.

Simple?
Yep.
Outright threats and illegal postings should be moderated as always...........always bad.

Suspensions/ temp bannings.......... mostly a thing of the past.
That's what I think.
 
Last edited:
I understand what you are saying, @PhilFish . And @SW48 , if you care for my opinion for the umpteenth time. :oops:
But don't say there are never any takers when you ask people to come moderate. I know of several who have volunteered.

Moderation will never make everyone happy, but it is a good idea to try for consistency.

For example, sometimes calling someone "bonehead" gets a person banned for a couple of days, other times it doesn't. Why? Because if it doesn't get turned in, it won't be moderated. "Moderators can't be here 24/7 to police the board" , you say. And of course that's true.

So what is the logical answer?

To me the answer is this: "Suck it up, Buttercup". If you get called a name, deal with it. Name-calling won't be moderated. Period. Don't send it in...... Mods don't care.

There can be a few (really, less than 5) words so terrible that if they are posted they are Xed out. But even they shouldn't bring on a suspension unless the poster causes undue work by the mods by overusing those words and THAT would be moderator discretion as to how much is too much.

Simple?
Yep.
Outright threats and illegal postings should be moderated as always...........always bad.

Suspensions/ temp bannings.......... mostly a thing of the past.
That's what I think.


there are no takers. i thin maybe one or two came and went that took the offer...that i remember... one did it to read up on back end pms, the other..it was a joke to them..

or something like that.

point being...and you know, cause you were mod one... its a pain in the ass

people will come back in droves with less moderating. fine.
people dont want 'excessive' moderation/ ok.
let's fight. bb style? is say yup. (but then, not my site)...
onle mod the really serious stuff/okie. not really any really serious stuff... okie.

but then, lets all stfu when the serial a holes are let back in. when you know who and the gang fight for 82 pages over the same old shit....again and aggain and again.
let's all just agree..they love it. and let them be.

or lets not and throw them out and be a site of what....11-15 posters...with the erran visitors.. (aka the 7 person solution. remember?)
 
there are no takers. i thin maybe one or two came and went that took the offer...that i remember... one did it to read up on back end pms, the other..it was a joke to them..

or something like that.

point being...and you know, cause you were mod one... its a pain in the ass

people will come back in droves with less moderating. fine.
people dont want 'excessive' moderation/ ok.
let's fight. bb style? is say yup. (but then, not my site)...
onle mod the really serious stuff/okie. not really any really serious stuff... okie.

but then, lets all stfu when the serial a holes are let back in. when you know who and the gang fight for 82 pages over the same old shit....again and aggain and again.
let's all just agree..they love it. and let them be.

or lets not and throw them out and be a site of what....11-15 posters...with the erran visitors.. (aka the 7 person solution. remember?)
I know......... it's a tough job.........thankless. I haven't forgotten.
And although I love my solution, I also know what it would bring.

But still, maybe that is a direction to go. The inconsistency will be there unless everyone reports on rule breaks - name calling.

Maybe it doesn't need to be the sort of announcement that will alert people who have left the site. Maybe there is some way to work with that though.

And maybe something can be written in regarding "moderator discretion for board preservation" where those who go on name-calling rants can be deleted if necessary to preserve the board.

Nothing will make everyone happy but the "no name calling" might be eased off of without too much consequence.
 
I know......... it's a tough job.........thankless. I haven't forgotten.
And although I love my solution, I also know what it would bring.

But still, maybe that is a direction to go. The inconsistency will be there unless everyone reports on rule breaks - name calling.

Maybe it doesn't need to be the sort of announcement that will alert people who have left the site. Maybe there is some way to work with that though.

And maybe something can be written in regarding "moderator discretion for board preservation" where those who go on name-calling rants can be deleted if necessary to preserve the board.

Nothing will make everyone happy but the "no name calling" might be eased off of without too much consequence.

Not better to delete excessive name callers on a whim? I think so. :)
 
Not better to delete excessive name callers on a whim? I think so. :)
Perhaps.
But that solid poster who gets banned because he called someone a bonehead on a whim is lost to us.

And now .........or soon.........we may be bereft of solid posters if the "whim" catches them too often.:(

And I know................ all the name-calling will also drive away solid posters.

Definitely a lose/ lose situation.
 
there are no takers. i thin maybe one or two came and went that took the offer...that i remember... one did it to read up on back end pms, the other..it was a joke to them..

or something like that.

point being...and you know, cause you were mod one... its a pain in the ass

people will come back in droves with less moderating. fine.
people dont want 'excessive' moderation/ ok.
let's fight. bb style? is say yup. (but then, not my site)...
onle mod the really serious stuff/okie. not really any really serious stuff... okie.

but then, lets all stfu when the serial a holes are let back in. when you know who and the gang fight for 82 pages over the same old shit....again and aggain and again.
let's all just agree..they love it. and let them be.

or lets not and throw them out and be a site of what....11-15 posters...with the erran visitors.. (aka the 7 person solution. remember?)


A and B play the report game ---- more stringent rules are put in place because of and only because of this game. Along comes a non Aer or Ber who has never been involved in 'the game' --- they post as they always have done and suddenly are shut out of the site --- mid sentence, as it were --- for calling another poster 'a fool' in judgment of a view they put forth. Other poster is an Aer or a Ber and reports - Non player doesn't report the insult Aer or Ber hurled their way.

Outside the argument of curbing free expression - thus stultifying discussion which otherwise flowed - outside that, is PJ only now gonna be home to A and B because non game players are at a disadvantage in play?
 
Last edited:
Not better to delete excessive name callers on a whim? I think so. :)

Who does it bother? It never bothered me -

For years one side called the other side 'racist' --- for years and years. So now the other side are throwing it back at them. So what? It will balance out in the end............ having your insult thrown back in your face - could possibly bring some sensible conversations with it.
 
Who does it bother? It never bothered me -

For years one side called the other side 'racist' --- for years and years. So now the other side are throwing it back at them. So what? It will balance out in the end............ having your insult thrown back in your face - could possibly bring some sensible conversations with it.
And how bad would it be if those who are all butthurt about being called a "bonehead" left?
 
How can a happy balance be found?

I pay so little attention and not a lot of time here so I don’t have a feel.

Back in the Fray days I had the distinguished honor of being the most banned poster.....

Here I don’t know if I have been banned or not.
Since they do one or two day bans... but admittedly I don’t post like I did then either....

So that being said I’m good with how it goes.

SB













joke
 
And how bad would it be if those who are all butthurt about being called a "bonehead" left?

But they are not Jen, we know they are not. They have skins like a Rinosurus ;)

We are all thick skinned now --- none of us are snowflakes -even the snowflakes are not.

I get the reasons why, the cat fights of old where only fun on occasion - not as a constant. I just think that if we put our heads together we would find a way for Mods to do their thing with less effort and we could all, including A&B, talk without having to watch our every word.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen

If ever you are given time out for stating the fact that a knucklehead is a knucklehead or a blockhead is a blockhead --- please let us know, it is all going down in the little black book ;)
 
Back
Top