Arkady
President
Years ago (maybe in the late 80s), US News and World Report put together a "budget game." The idea was to see if you could balance the budget. You were allowed to make certain changes, each of which moves the budget one way or another, based on some simple rules. Even though the "rules" were horribly over-simplified, they were still very useful for educating people about where the money actually goes, and what kinds of changes would be needed to create a balanced budget.
I've toyed with the idea of recreating this game as a web site (assuming someone hasn't already done so). It could be done much more accurately that way, since the numbers could be crunched instantly and in a way that allowed for much more complexity and dynamic interactions between different budget factors. For example, if you want to lower the corporate tax rate to X%, but also eliminate Y loophole, how much does that change the revenue stream from corporate taxes? The US News game couldn't accommodate those kinds of interactive changes very well, but a web page could.
What I'd love about the page is that it would force willfully ignorant people to educate themselves about the actual budget. I'm sick of having discussions with people who pretend to think a balanced budget is critically important, but refuse to consider cuts to the military, Social Security, and Medicare, and actually want taxes to be lower. If you play around with the real numbers even a little, you realize that there's little hope of reaching balance without addressing one or more of those items. We've got a $1.3 trillion budget shortfall. Perhaps half of that is attributable to the business cycle, and will possibly fix itself when the economy improves, but that still leaves many hundreds of billions to be found, either in raised revenues or lowered savings.
Unfortunately, I haven't actually put that web page together, and I may not have the programming skills to do it justice. But, in the meantime, I'm curious what people here would do to balance the budget, long term. Here's a quick overview of my ideas:
(1) Raise taxes on the rich. Start by treating various forms of income the same (it makes no sense for Romney to pay 15% while someone with much lower income pays 30%, simply because Romney gets to treat his income as capital gains). Dividends, interest, capital gains (after indexing), gifts and inheritance (after low annual exemptions) should all be treated as regular income and subjected to progressive taxation. Also, eliminate the Social Security tax cap, the same way we did with Medicare, so that the rich have to pay into the system all year, like everyone else, rather than being permitted to stop when they hit the cap. This would be such an effective change that you could actually permanently lower the payroll tax rate (employer plus employee) from 12.40% to 12.12% and still have Social Security solvent for at least 75 more years (the farthest forward you can do any meaningful projection). I'd also create several more brackets, to differentiate between wealthier workers, with rates escalating upwards towards something more similar to what we had in our golden economic era of the postwar period. Those changes would eliminate the long-term Social Security deficit. Meanwhile, they'd boost individual income tax receipts by at least several hundred billion dollars (depending on the details of the new brackets). Just as an estimate, picture we could get income tax receipts back up to 10.2% (where they were in 2000) -- that would bring in about $400 billion per year.
(2) Lower the effective corporate rate but close loopholes, to keep the same average effective rate. The US has a high nominal tax rate on corporations, but relatively normal effective tax rates on them (the percent a corporation pays after considering exemptions, etc.) Our effective rate is lower than Germany, Japan, and Italy, but higher than the UK, France, and Australia. My hope would be that lowering the nominal rate while preserving the effective rate would reduce the distortions caused by a high nominal rate, resulting in higher revenues. But since that is largely speculative, I'll just treat this as revenue neutral.
(3) Cut defense spending by approximately $400 billion. I've provided details about the cuts I've made in other posts. Keep in mind, this would leave us with far and away the highest-spending military in the world.
(4) A few nickel-and-dime savings. Eliminate all non-humanitarian foreign aid (e.g., aid to rich countries like Israel). At best, this would save $5 billion, so it's not a major budget factor, but it's worth doing, anyway. Eliminate agricultural subsidies (keep the farm programs based around preventing erosion and other public-good programs, but get rid of those based around trying to preserve agrarian lifestyles). This might be worth $10 billion per year.
So, I've accounted for approximately $815 billion in deficit reduction, without having to hit those who are already hard hit by taking away programs that the poor rely on. If you grant me relatively modest assumptions about how much revenues will grow naturally, just from GDP growth as we accelerate out of this recession, I think it's not hard to picture that as being sufficient to fix the deficit.
In fact, what I've just laid out is a practical suggestion, in the sense that it's fairly close to what we already did, the last time we eliminated record deficits. In the Clinton years, we held military spending down to about the level I'm calling for, we hiked taxes, primarily on the rich, in the ballpark of what I'm calling for, and we benefited from keeping the economy growing, which brought about natural revenue increases. It's not unrealistic to think we could repeat that success with similar ingredients.
There's no such thing as a free lunch, so to balance the budget, someone's going to take a hit. Whether that someone is a mom trying to figure out how to keep her kids from going hungry, or a CEO trying to figure out how to upgrade to a longer yacht is a choice we, as society, can make, but one way or another SOMEONE'S going to take the hit. However, I just wanted to mention that there is one area that is as close to a free lunch as economics allows: economies of scale. One possibility for saving money, on a societal-wide scale, is to capitalize on the benefits of bulk-buying and the efficiencies of larger programs. Healthcare is one obvious example. As has been pointed out repeatedly, most other wealthy nations spend about half as much as we do on healthcare, and get a better product for it, because they get various efficiencies that we're not capitalizing on. We could replicate that with something like "Medicare for All." This would allow people to have more money in their pocket at the end of the day, despite higher taxes, while still getting better healthcare. Another example of these economies of scale would be to centralize some state-level functions (especially education) to the federal government. Rather than inefficiently have 50+ bureaucracies duplicating one another's functions, have a centralized function do it more cheaply. For every dollar in extra taxes you'd have to collect on the federal level to make that work, you could collect two fewer dollars on the state level, leaving people considerably better off.
So, what are your ideas?
I've toyed with the idea of recreating this game as a web site (assuming someone hasn't already done so). It could be done much more accurately that way, since the numbers could be crunched instantly and in a way that allowed for much more complexity and dynamic interactions between different budget factors. For example, if you want to lower the corporate tax rate to X%, but also eliminate Y loophole, how much does that change the revenue stream from corporate taxes? The US News game couldn't accommodate those kinds of interactive changes very well, but a web page could.
What I'd love about the page is that it would force willfully ignorant people to educate themselves about the actual budget. I'm sick of having discussions with people who pretend to think a balanced budget is critically important, but refuse to consider cuts to the military, Social Security, and Medicare, and actually want taxes to be lower. If you play around with the real numbers even a little, you realize that there's little hope of reaching balance without addressing one or more of those items. We've got a $1.3 trillion budget shortfall. Perhaps half of that is attributable to the business cycle, and will possibly fix itself when the economy improves, but that still leaves many hundreds of billions to be found, either in raised revenues or lowered savings.
Unfortunately, I haven't actually put that web page together, and I may not have the programming skills to do it justice. But, in the meantime, I'm curious what people here would do to balance the budget, long term. Here's a quick overview of my ideas:
(1) Raise taxes on the rich. Start by treating various forms of income the same (it makes no sense for Romney to pay 15% while someone with much lower income pays 30%, simply because Romney gets to treat his income as capital gains). Dividends, interest, capital gains (after indexing), gifts and inheritance (after low annual exemptions) should all be treated as regular income and subjected to progressive taxation. Also, eliminate the Social Security tax cap, the same way we did with Medicare, so that the rich have to pay into the system all year, like everyone else, rather than being permitted to stop when they hit the cap. This would be such an effective change that you could actually permanently lower the payroll tax rate (employer plus employee) from 12.40% to 12.12% and still have Social Security solvent for at least 75 more years (the farthest forward you can do any meaningful projection). I'd also create several more brackets, to differentiate between wealthier workers, with rates escalating upwards towards something more similar to what we had in our golden economic era of the postwar period. Those changes would eliminate the long-term Social Security deficit. Meanwhile, they'd boost individual income tax receipts by at least several hundred billion dollars (depending on the details of the new brackets). Just as an estimate, picture we could get income tax receipts back up to 10.2% (where they were in 2000) -- that would bring in about $400 billion per year.
(2) Lower the effective corporate rate but close loopholes, to keep the same average effective rate. The US has a high nominal tax rate on corporations, but relatively normal effective tax rates on them (the percent a corporation pays after considering exemptions, etc.) Our effective rate is lower than Germany, Japan, and Italy, but higher than the UK, France, and Australia. My hope would be that lowering the nominal rate while preserving the effective rate would reduce the distortions caused by a high nominal rate, resulting in higher revenues. But since that is largely speculative, I'll just treat this as revenue neutral.
(3) Cut defense spending by approximately $400 billion. I've provided details about the cuts I've made in other posts. Keep in mind, this would leave us with far and away the highest-spending military in the world.
(4) A few nickel-and-dime savings. Eliminate all non-humanitarian foreign aid (e.g., aid to rich countries like Israel). At best, this would save $5 billion, so it's not a major budget factor, but it's worth doing, anyway. Eliminate agricultural subsidies (keep the farm programs based around preventing erosion and other public-good programs, but get rid of those based around trying to preserve agrarian lifestyles). This might be worth $10 billion per year.
So, I've accounted for approximately $815 billion in deficit reduction, without having to hit those who are already hard hit by taking away programs that the poor rely on. If you grant me relatively modest assumptions about how much revenues will grow naturally, just from GDP growth as we accelerate out of this recession, I think it's not hard to picture that as being sufficient to fix the deficit.
In fact, what I've just laid out is a practical suggestion, in the sense that it's fairly close to what we already did, the last time we eliminated record deficits. In the Clinton years, we held military spending down to about the level I'm calling for, we hiked taxes, primarily on the rich, in the ballpark of what I'm calling for, and we benefited from keeping the economy growing, which brought about natural revenue increases. It's not unrealistic to think we could repeat that success with similar ingredients.
There's no such thing as a free lunch, so to balance the budget, someone's going to take a hit. Whether that someone is a mom trying to figure out how to keep her kids from going hungry, or a CEO trying to figure out how to upgrade to a longer yacht is a choice we, as society, can make, but one way or another SOMEONE'S going to take the hit. However, I just wanted to mention that there is one area that is as close to a free lunch as economics allows: economies of scale. One possibility for saving money, on a societal-wide scale, is to capitalize on the benefits of bulk-buying and the efficiencies of larger programs. Healthcare is one obvious example. As has been pointed out repeatedly, most other wealthy nations spend about half as much as we do on healthcare, and get a better product for it, because they get various efficiencies that we're not capitalizing on. We could replicate that with something like "Medicare for All." This would allow people to have more money in their pocket at the end of the day, despite higher taxes, while still getting better healthcare. Another example of these economies of scale would be to centralize some state-level functions (especially education) to the federal government. Rather than inefficiently have 50+ bureaucracies duplicating one another's functions, have a centralized function do it more cheaply. For every dollar in extra taxes you'd have to collect on the federal level to make that work, you could collect two fewer dollars on the state level, leaving people considerably better off.
So, what are your ideas?