New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Pragmatism unchained

I am guessing that I have read a little more deeply in Marx's original work than you have. That said, I am certainly not the last word on the topic of Marx. (I don't think that there will ever be a last word.)

That said, I would agree that there is a dispassionate logic in Marx. Marx called his theories "scientific socialism." He thought that he had discovered the "laws of historical development" and was predicting how history would unfold as the world moved from the nineteenth century (when Marx lived) into the twentieth century. All of this was centered around the concepts of the development of the means of production (basically technological advance) and the relations of production (how production was organized) and the class struggle with regard to who "controlled" the means of production. In the nineteenth century, he was concerned with the struggle between the bourgoisie who owned the means of production and the proletariet who sold their labor and manned the means of production. He basically predicted that as the means of production became more advanced that the proletariet would become more powerful in relation to the bourgoisie and eventually be in a position to "expropriate the expropriaters." But Marx was not so much "engineering" socialism as predicting that history would unfold in a specific way. (In a sense, he was similar to Adam Smith in that respect. Smith thought that the "invisible hand" was built on the natural laws of human nature). That said, there were followers of Marx who were more interested in "social engineering." For example, there were the founders of European "democratic socialism" (e.g. Eduard Bernstein) and the bolsheviks (e.g. Lenin).

In any case, Marx saw himself as being on the "right side of history." Personally, I think that history is more complicated and I am skeptical of anyone who thinks that he or she has discovered the "laws of historical development." That said, I do think that the means of production, the relations of production, and "class struggle" (which I think is a better term than class warfare) are interesting ideas.

What strikes me about Marx is dispassionate logic.... Just as surely as the weight of a locomotive wheel will sever the hapless animal that strays beneath it Marx seems to be pointing to the inevitable direction of the Macro system we call humanity almost as if we have no choices to make.

JO
 
Heh heh heh ...

Yes....well I am involved in several fields..Power is the major category... power plant sub systems is my specialty....
I really need to learn how to leave work....IN WORK......

JO
 
Yeah...he just strikes me as a systems person....the way he examines, prognosticates and then forecasts....of course the world has change much since Marx...perhaps if he was alive today he would make many retractions.

JO
 
Yes....I am aware of that slow down.

Also...I believe that china is currently experiencing the very crisis you mentioned.....What do do with the seniors who have no children to care for them? Last I heard it was damn near a national emergency.

LeRoy: China's problem is that it may grow old before it grows rich. And, with life expectancy almost as long in China as it is in the U.S., that does indeed present a serious conundrum as to how to support a rapidly growing cadre of the elderly. The one-child-per-family policy was probably a not unreasonable approach to the rapid population growth that China was experiencing beforehand, but in conjunction with the Chinese cultural preference for boys, has resulted in a severely skewed sex ratio that is already causing some pretty predictable social tensions; namely, a relative lack of marriageable women in their 20s. Equals lots of unhappy young men.

It's different with a country like Japan, which is growing old at an even more rapid rate. Much richer than China, Japan will simply roboticize. Twenty years from now, I would expect there will be large numbers of advanced robots in Japan, helping to take care of the elderly.
 
Back
Top