New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Pragmatism unchained

justoffal

Senator
Certain things in life define themselves even when we don''t want them to. Pragmatism is the ability to recognize those particular manifestations. Take people for instance and the forms of government they choose. Though there are general categories none of them are 100 percent pure. No culture can survive on 100 percent democracy or 100 percent socialism or 100 percent communism. All of them need to be in the mix to a greater or lesser degree together with perhaps a dozen other categories or subcategories that are needed to make a practical system work...practically speaking.

As we move toward exponential population increase there is no denial that humanity will become and is in point of fact right now a macro system. Though it pains me to say this...systems like communism or socialism are more well suited to this type of proliferate population growth than are ...democracy or republic type systems for instance. Marx was more than just a philosopher he was a social engineer of sorts though I suspect he was altogether too trusting of the human nature he was trying to deal with. He no doubt recognized that eventually the world of men would need some kind of unified management system or else we would have utter chaos....and I give you the present day state of the Globe as proof thereof. In fact we have had warnings from many such social engineers who have unwittingly described this system with terms that are the social engineer's analysis tools like " Aggregate Demand " ( Keynes ), " Proletariat ' ( Marx ) and " Middle class" ( Stevenson ). Their observations seem to indicate that eventually mankind would either become one unified system or we would likely spiral out of control to extinction. It is a relentless pressure that results from high numerical count. The high numerical count is a by product of our reproductive habits and therefore it becomes a natural process like an earthquake or hurricane. As time goes by it will take more and more energy to fight off the encroachment of sameness and forced uniformity and some say that maybe we shouldn't do that but I digress.

For now we hold both our individuality and our freedom of personal choice to be both dear and sacred. This does not work well with a macro system. Macro systems thrive on uniformity, compliance and to put it in terms of brutal honesty ....bland acquiescence.

Conclusion:

The natural pressures of our existence will push us harder and at times even violently toward macro system management. Where we will end up is anyone's guess. If we are to keep out individuality we are going to have to think ahead because as sure as that next baby is born the exploding population of this planet will assume a predictable form of social mechanism that will have a mind of its own....( no pun intended )
 
If this is what you think than why do you bother? Just submit. Or do you want liberty for yourself and submission for your children?
 
I think you're reading me wrong.

It's not a prediction just an observation. I think it's a pressure that we will face/are facing...... not something that we MUST submit to. In fact I think this is what we are seeing right now from the left and they probably don't even realize what this pressure is or where it comes from. The pressure to conform, the pressure to surrender our individuality...it's not something I want but I tell you most assuredly that we had better be ready for this massive onslaught of sameness because it will come from every direction all at once and it will have no tolerance for things that are different.

Obama is one such Harbinger of what we can expect.

JO
 
Certain things in life define themselves even when we don''t want them to. Pragmatism is the ability to recognize those particular manifestations. Take people for instance and the forms of government they choose. Though there are general categories none of them are 100 percent pure. No culture can survive on 100 percent democracy or 100 percent socialism or 100 percent communism. All of them need to be in the mix to a greater or lesser degree together with perhaps a dozen other categories or subcategories that are needed to make a practical system work...practically speaking.

As we move toward exponential population increase there is no denial that humanity will become and is in point of fact right now a macro system. Though it pains me to say this...systems like communism or socialism are more well suited to this type of proliferate population growth then are say...democracy or republic type systems. Marx was more than just a philosopher he was a social engineer of sorts though I suspect he was altogether too trusting of the human nature he was trying to deal with. He no doubt recognized that eventually the world of men would need some kind of unified management system or else we would have utter chaos....and I give you the present day state of the Globe as proof thereof. In fact we have had warnings from many such social engineers who have unwittingly described this system with terms that are the social engineer's analysis tools like " Aggregate Demand " ( Keynes ), " Proletariat ' ( Marx ) and " Middle class" ( Stevenson ). Their observations seem to indicate that eventually mankind would either become one unified system or we would likely spiral out of control to extinction. It is a relentless pressure that results from high numerical count. The high numerical count is a by product of our reproductive habits and therefore it becomes a natural process like an earthquake or Hurricane. As time goes by it will take more and more energy to fight it off and maybe we shouldn't do that but I digress.

For now we hold both our individuality and our freedom of personal choice to be both dear and sacred. This does not work well with a macro system. Macro systems thrive on uniformity, compliance and to put it in terms of brutal honesty ....bland acquiescence.

Conclusion:

The natural pressures of our existence will push us harder and at times even violently toward macro system management. Where we will end up is anyone's guess. If we are to keep out individuality we are going to have to think ahead because as sure as that next baby is born the exploding population of this planet will assume a predictable form of social mechanism that will have a mind of its own....( no pun intended )

I like Maslow. The hierarchy of needs seems a good guide to understanding the various levels of humanity we pass through as societies and civilizations. If we struggle to meet the first level of needs, it's going to be an unsettled society. All energy dedicated to the most basic considerations of life. There can be no wealth accrual under such circumstances, no exploration of the individual can occur. Once those needs are met, well...life gets quite a bit easier, doesn't it? And if a surplus can be gained...a little food in the larder, a little extra coin from trade...well...now we're talkin'. Now romance and gifts and special things can occur...and we are free to create. Aesthetic become important...as a civilization attempts to make its mark...

Pragmatism tells us everybody has to eat. And drink. If those needs are not met...expect chaos. Unfortunately, droughts cause food shortages and worldwide food and water distribution is not equal.

Therefore...some system of "general welfare" is required if a society is to grow and succeed with the vast numbers of humanity we experience in the world today.
 
By moving the population underground and going strictly vegetarian, while stunting growth to 4 feet or so, we could optimally suppport 40 billion on the planet, if all land was converted to food only, and the oceans became vast algae plantations. Brave New World.
 
Once upon a time in America... in my grandparents' days... 30-40 acre lots were considered homesteads; not farms, just enough land to live on and grow your own vegetables, keep some chickens, do some fishing, do some hunting, and plant some fruit trees. It was reasonable reward for having labored and contributed.

Today, those lots are all but totally vanished, they have been sliced and diced and the land is now roads and postage stamp lots and nobody - not even the upper crest - has 40 acres for a back yard. Life, Liberty, and Land... that was real freedom.

My grandfather had 30 acres and there's nothing else like it for family reunions on the 4th of July or Thanksgiving... my son will never know that feeling, playing bocce beneath the willow trees, owning a winchester pump shot gun, learning to shoot from the hip, I did all those things, my son doesn't have the first notion that such a lifestyle exists. Of course we don't want those things taken from us; but it is inevitable, the more people pour into the land, the less land there is to go around. Fencing out the unfortunate is not the answer (God calls that evil for a reason) ... the simple result from over population is a loss of freedoms for everybody. Possessions and privacy get thinned down, there's no way around it. Pretty soon, food and water will be scarce also... we were born into this moment, designed to make us pray to escape the terrors of the day; we can't stop what is coming, so we better learn to acclimate.
 
JO,

Just out of curiosity, why do you call Marx a philosopher? Why do you call him a social engineer? Finally, have you ever read anything that he wrote?


Certain things in life define themselves even when we don''t want them to. Pragmatism is the ability to recognize those particular manifestations. Take people for instance and the forms of government they choose. Though there are general categories none of them are 100 percent pure. No culture can survive on 100 percent democracy or 100 percent socialism or 100 percent communism. All of them need to be in the mix to a greater or lesser degree together with perhaps a dozen other categories or subcategories that are needed to make a practical system work...practically speaking.

As we move toward exponential population increase there is no denial that humanity will become and is in point of fact right now a macro system. Though it pains me to say this...systems like communism or socialism are more well suited to this type of proliferate population growth then are say...democracy or republic type systems. Marx was more than just a philosopher he was a social engineer of sorts though I suspect he was altogether too trusting of the human nature he was trying to deal with. He no doubt recognized that eventually the world of men would need some kind of unified management system or else we would have utter chaos....and I give you the present day state of the Globe as proof thereof. In fact we have had warnings from many such social engineers who have unwittingly described this system with terms that are the social engineer's analysis tools like " Aggregate Demand " ( Keynes ), " Proletariat ' ( Marx ) and " Middle class" ( Stevenson ). Their observations seem to indicate that eventually mankind would either become one unified system or we would likely spiral out of control to extinction. It is a relentless pressure that results from high numerical count. The high numerical count is a by product of our reproductive habits and therefore it becomes a natural process like an earthquake or Hurricane. As time goes by it will take more and more energy to fight it off and maybe we shouldn't do that but I digress.

For now we hold both our individuality and our freedom of personal choice to be both dear and sacred. This does not work well with a macro system. Macro systems thrive on uniformity, compliance and to put it in terms of brutal honesty ....bland acquiescence.

Conclusion:

The natural pressures of our existence will push us harder and at times even violently toward macro system management. Where we will end up is anyone's guess. If we are to keep out individuality we are going to have to think ahead because as sure as that next baby is born the exploding population of this planet will assume a predictable form of social mechanism that will have a mind of its own....( no pun intended )
 
World population growth is slowing down, dramatically. The world population growth rate peaked at about 2.2% per year, in about 1963. At that rate, the world population was doubling about every 32 years. This is why there was so much alarmism about population growth in the late 1960s, and why the environmental movement began to gather strength at that time. Today, the world population growth rate is about 1.1% per year, i.e, it has fallen by about HALF from its peak. At a growth rate of 1.1% per year, world population would still double about every 64 years....BUT....virtually every expert expects that the growth rate will continue to fall in the decades ahead. We have been in an era of sub-exponential population growth since ~1963. Before then, population growth was super-exponential, with the growth rate itself increasing.

Most demographers expect the world population will peak sometime around mid-century, and then begin a slow decline. At that point, we will be in an era of negative population growth. Some countries in Europe are already there, and Japan is close to zero population growth. [That can create its own problems in terms of financing old-age pension systems, but must nevertheless be considered a net positive, for the world as a whole.] Will the population peak, though, at 9 billion (the low estimate), at 10 billion (the medium estimate), or at 11 or 12 billion (the high estimates)? It makes a difference, I think.
 
All true Leroy. One reason that I asked JO if he had read Marx (and understood the context in which Marx was writing) was simply that Marx was writing in the early phases of the industrial and scientific/technological revolutions when the gloomy predictions of Malthus (which were very much grounded in the realities of population and economic resources of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries) were being "overturned." These revolutions vastly increased - at least for a time - the carrying capacity of the Earth.

That said, JO raised some interesting problems. Not sure that I would agree with his analysis. But recognizing a potential problem is a good first step.


World population growth is slowing down, dramatically. The world population growth rate peaked at about 2.2% per year, in about 1963. At that rate, the world population was doubling about every 32 years. This is why there was so much alarmism about population growth in the late 1960s, and why the environmental movement began to gather strength at that time. Today, the world population growth rate is about 1.1% per year, i.e, it has fallen by about HALF from its peak. At a growth rate of 1.1% per year, world population would still double about every 64 years....BUT....virtually every expert expects that the growth rate will continue to fall in the decades ahead. We have been in an era of sub-exponential population growth since ~1963. Before then, population growth was super-exponential, with the growth rate itself increasing.

Most demographers expect the world population will peak sometime around mid-century, and then begin a slow decline. At that point, we will be in an era of negative population growth. Some countries in Europe are already there, and Japan is close to zero population growth. [That can create its own problems in terms of financing old-age pension systems, but must nevertheless be considered a net positive, for the world as a whole.] Will the population peak, though, at 9 billion (the low estimate), at 10 billion (the medium estimate), or at 11 or 12 billion (the high estimates)? It makes a difference, I think.
 
Interestingly, Marx had a very low opinion of Malthus, and thought that he was completely "ahistorical". [That was the word Marx used.]

But Malthus was wrong about some things, and right about others. The Malthusian population doctrine WAS a pretty good description of how the PRE-industrial world worked.
 
I think that Malthus was "asociological" rather than "ahistorical." Marx (like Weber and Durkheim) were really concerned with historical macrosociology. (Marx was a social scientist as well as a social philosopher and social engineer. But if you leave out the social scientist, you miss a lot.) I honestly think that this is the direction in which JO was trying to head. Complicated stuff.

Interestingly, Marx had a very low opinion of Malthus, and thought that he was completely "ahistorical". [That was the word Marx used.]

But Malthus was wrong about some things, and right about others. The Malthusian population doctrine WAS a pretty good description of how the PRE-industrial world worked.
 
I thought that Marx was a somewhat more astute analyst of the means of production, that Durkheim was a somewhat more astute analyst of the culture of "modernism," and that Weber provided the most sophisticated analysis of the social relations involved. Malthus wasn't in the league of the other three. But he did popularize an important topic.

It's just my opinion, of course, but I think Max Weber was the most interesting of all those guys (Malthus, Marx, Durkheim).
 
I have not studied Marx in depth...

I have read many of his writings and read many others opinions of his writings. The term social engineer is what I come away with as a personal opinion of his positions and why he formed them the way he did. I certainly am not the last word on who he was or what he stood for, I just haven't spent enough time on the subject to make that claim. Instead I am more interested in how Marx forms a chain pattern with other Macro effects analysts who dealt with those same effects.

I have found that patient observation of a system will eventually render certain predictable patterns or likelihoods that can be plotted with a fair amount of accuracy.

JO
 
Yes....I am aware of that slow down.

Also...I believe that china is currently experiencing the very crisis you mentioned.....What do do with the seniors who have no children to care for them? Last I heard it was damn near a national emergency.
 
What strikes me about Marx is dispassionate logic.... Just as surely as the weight of a locomotive wheel will sever the hapless animal that strays beneath it Marx seems to be pointing to the inevitable direction of the Macro system we call humanity almost as if we have no choices to make.

JO
 
I'm a bit of a pain in the ass when it comes to that. My job is to see problems before they become problems. I don't have to tell you that it doesn't always happen that way... :).
I'm not very much fun to take anywhere because I can't stop examining the systems that confront me all the time. That restaurant is poorly designed! The waitresses have to make too many turns from the kitchen to the dining room! Hey you! Did you check the modulus of elasticity on that frame board before deciding to use it in your porch rebuild? Did you realize that after a pitch of 60% on that upright that the load can go infinite? ..... sigh.....my wife is often horrified by it.....I really need to let down a bit and just let life happen.

:)

JO
 
I am not sure that you would consider yourself a social engineer but there definitely seems to be an engineer in you.

I'm a bit of a pain in the ass when it comes to that. My job is to see problems before they become problems. I don't have to tell you that it doesn't always happen that way... :).
I'm not very much fun to take anywhere because I can't stop examining the systems that confront me all the time. That restaurant is poorly designed! The waitresses have to make too many turns from the kitchen to the dining room! Hey you! Did you check the modulus of elasticity on that frame board before deciding to use it in your porch rebuild? Did you realize that after a pitch of 60% on that upright that the load can go infinite? ..... sigh.....my wife is often horrified by it.....I really need to let down a bit and just let life happen.

:)

JO
 
Back
Top