Arkady
President
An octogenarian friend of ours is starting to fade, mentally, and her family has decided that it's no longer a good idea for her to live on her own. What tipped them off was a recent visit to help clean up the house when they found all sorts of weird stuff she'd ordered and never even opened, including magazine subscriptions she'd never have found an interest in. They also found she'd given money to various causes she'd never heard of and politicians who weren't even local (like Joe Arpaio, on the other side of the country), and that she had past-due bills for a number of things she had no recollection signing up for. It wasn't identity theft, though. Instead, she was actually doing all these transactions herself, without even realizing what she was doing, because of communications specifically designed to trick the elderly and the naive with small-print and deceptive presentation.
We've all seen that kind of material, although usually we see right through it. For example, surely you've received in the mail something that looks like a check but, in fact, if you endorse it you're signing up for some kind of service. Or you'll be told that you'd won one of three prizes of various values, where even the lowest value seems great (e.g., a $100 gift certificate to some store you frequent), but, in fact, the middle-valued prize is actually the one that 99.9% of all people have won, which is valued at $500 but that's actually just the nominal discount on something you could buy on your own for much less. Or you'll go to a website that has a pop-up that informs you that your computer is infected with some malware, but in reality the pop-up itself is a link that will download malware to your computer. Or you'll be mailed something that's designed to look like a bill for something you already ordered, but somewhere in it, it will say that it's not a bill (the "get out of jail free" card for the con artist), so that the only way you'll be taken in is if you don't read carefully.
I can't recall ever having been taken in by anything of that sort, but obviously lots and lots of people are, or the business model of doing mass mailings of that sort wouldn't endure for decades. People whose minds aren't as sharp as they once were, or who have lousy eyesight for small print are particularly vulnerable. What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses. If you have a website with a pop-up designed to look like Windows system alerts, to deceive someone into clicking on them, that should be against the law, even if the goal is merely to steer them to some legitimate advertising, rather than to infect them with a virus. If you design a mass-mailing to look like a bill when it isn't, or to look like someone won a contest when you're just extending to them an offer available to the general public, that should likewise be illegal. If the manifest intent of the way something is presented is to deceive people, however naive or careless, about what they're seeing, that should be punishable under the law. It serves no legitimate capitalist purpose to allow that kind of willfully deceptive trade practice, and so it should be stamped out.
We've all seen that kind of material, although usually we see right through it. For example, surely you've received in the mail something that looks like a check but, in fact, if you endorse it you're signing up for some kind of service. Or you'll be told that you'd won one of three prizes of various values, where even the lowest value seems great (e.g., a $100 gift certificate to some store you frequent), but, in fact, the middle-valued prize is actually the one that 99.9% of all people have won, which is valued at $500 but that's actually just the nominal discount on something you could buy on your own for much less. Or you'll go to a website that has a pop-up that informs you that your computer is infected with some malware, but in reality the pop-up itself is a link that will download malware to your computer. Or you'll be mailed something that's designed to look like a bill for something you already ordered, but somewhere in it, it will say that it's not a bill (the "get out of jail free" card for the con artist), so that the only way you'll be taken in is if you don't read carefully.
I can't recall ever having been taken in by anything of that sort, but obviously lots and lots of people are, or the business model of doing mass mailings of that sort wouldn't endure for decades. People whose minds aren't as sharp as they once were, or who have lousy eyesight for small print are particularly vulnerable. What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses. If you have a website with a pop-up designed to look like Windows system alerts, to deceive someone into clicking on them, that should be against the law, even if the goal is merely to steer them to some legitimate advertising, rather than to infect them with a virus. If you design a mass-mailing to look like a bill when it isn't, or to look like someone won a contest when you're just extending to them an offer available to the general public, that should likewise be illegal. If the manifest intent of the way something is presented is to deceive people, however naive or careless, about what they're seeing, that should be punishable under the law. It serves no legitimate capitalist purpose to allow that kind of willfully deceptive trade practice, and so it should be stamped out.