New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Preying on the elderly

Arkady

President
An octogenarian friend of ours is starting to fade, mentally, and her family has decided that it's no longer a good idea for her to live on her own. What tipped them off was a recent visit to help clean up the house when they found all sorts of weird stuff she'd ordered and never even opened, including magazine subscriptions she'd never have found an interest in. They also found she'd given money to various causes she'd never heard of and politicians who weren't even local (like Joe Arpaio, on the other side of the country), and that she had past-due bills for a number of things she had no recollection signing up for. It wasn't identity theft, though. Instead, she was actually doing all these transactions herself, without even realizing what she was doing, because of communications specifically designed to trick the elderly and the naive with small-print and deceptive presentation.

We've all seen that kind of material, although usually we see right through it. For example, surely you've received in the mail something that looks like a check but, in fact, if you endorse it you're signing up for some kind of service. Or you'll be told that you'd won one of three prizes of various values, where even the lowest value seems great (e.g., a $100 gift certificate to some store you frequent), but, in fact, the middle-valued prize is actually the one that 99.9% of all people have won, which is valued at $500 but that's actually just the nominal discount on something you could buy on your own for much less. Or you'll go to a website that has a pop-up that informs you that your computer is infected with some malware, but in reality the pop-up itself is a link that will download malware to your computer. Or you'll be mailed something that's designed to look like a bill for something you already ordered, but somewhere in it, it will say that it's not a bill (the "get out of jail free" card for the con artist), so that the only way you'll be taken in is if you don't read carefully.

I can't recall ever having been taken in by anything of that sort, but obviously lots and lots of people are, or the business model of doing mass mailings of that sort wouldn't endure for decades. People whose minds aren't as sharp as they once were, or who have lousy eyesight for small print are particularly vulnerable. What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses. If you have a website with a pop-up designed to look like Windows system alerts, to deceive someone into clicking on them, that should be against the law, even if the goal is merely to steer them to some legitimate advertising, rather than to infect them with a virus. If you design a mass-mailing to look like a bill when it isn't, or to look like someone won a contest when you're just extending to them an offer available to the general public, that should likewise be illegal. If the manifest intent of the way something is presented is to deceive people, however naive or careless, about what they're seeing, that should be punishable under the law. It serves no legitimate capitalist purpose to allow that kind of willfully deceptive trade practice, and so it should be stamped out.
 
Who do you think those Nigerian spammers are targeting? Same way with those door to door "handymen" who con people into paying them to do work.

I agree whole heartedly with your suggestion about the deceptive mailings and trade practices.
 
What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses.

In that case, Jay Carney should be the first one arrested...
 
Who do you think those Nigerian spammers are targeting? Same way with those door to door "handymen" who con people into paying them to do work.

I agree whole heartedly with your suggestion about the deceptive mailings and trade practices.

...barely a day goes by that I do not find a misspelled laden email from someone telling me they want to give me millions of dollars. If they were true, over the years, I could have paid off the National debt myself!
 
An octogenarian friend of ours is starting to fade, mentally, and her family has decided that it's no longer a good idea for her to live on her own. What tipped them off was a recent visit to help clean up the house when they found all sorts of weird stuff she'd ordered and never even opened, including magazine subscriptions she'd never have found an interest in. They also found she'd given money to various causes she'd never heard of and politicians who weren't even local (like Joe Arpaio, on the other side of the country), and that she had past-due bills for a number of things she had no recollection signing up for. It wasn't identity theft, though. Instead, she was actually doing all these transactions herself, without even realizing what she was doing, because of communications specifically designed to trick the elderly and the naive with small-print and deceptive presentation.

We've all seen that kind of material, although usually we see right through it. For example, surely you've received in the mail something that looks like a check but, in fact, if you endorse it you're signing up for some kind of service. Or you'll be told that you'd won one of three prizes of various values, where even the lowest value seems great (e.g., a $100 gift certificate to some store you frequent), but, in fact, the middle-valued prize is actually the one that 99.9% of all people have won, which is valued at $500 but that's actually just the nominal discount on something you could buy on your own for much less. Or you'll go to a website that has a pop-up that informs you that your computer is infected with some malware, but in reality the pop-up itself is a link that will download malware to your computer. Or you'll be mailed something that's designed to look like a bill for something you already ordered, but somewhere in it, it will say that it's not a bill (the "get out of jail free" card for the con artist), so that the only way you'll be taken in is if you don't read carefully.

I can't recall ever having been taken in by anything of that sort, but obviously lots and lots of people are, or the business model of doing mass mailings of that sort wouldn't endure for decades. People whose minds aren't as sharp as they once were, or who have lousy eyesight for small print are particularly vulnerable. What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses. If you have a website with a pop-up designed to look like Windows system alerts, to deceive someone into clicking on them, that should be against the law, even if the goal is merely to steer them to some legitimate advertising, rather than to infect them with a virus. If you design a mass-mailing to look like a bill when it isn't, or to look like someone won a contest when you're just extending to them an offer available to the general public, that should likewise be illegal. If the manifest intent of the way something is presented is to deceive people, however naive or careless, about what they're seeing, that should be punishable under the law. It serves no legitimate capitalist purpose to allow that kind of willfully deceptive trade practice, and so it should be stamped out.


Arkady,

I have to disagree. Adversiting is all in some way intended to deceive or entice. It is in the eye of the beholder.

But, I believe in buyer beware. It is unfortunate that there are people who have lost their faculties enough to be deceived by those things. But, that is where friends and relatives need to step in and make sure that their loved ones are getting the care they need and oversee their finances better.

Yes, that kind of advertising gets suckers. But, I do not think it is unfair trade practices. People who follow through and read all the details and are appropriately skeptical do not get taken. It would behoove us then to have more education on how to not be taken, then to in effect limit free speech and business enterprise.

I would like to see the government crack down more on the outright scams though of callling an elderly person and trying to get them to wire money, etc. REcently someone called my Grandfather and told him that he had an oustanding ticket and so they had a warrant to arrest him and if he didn't show up at a certain place with the money he was going to go to jail. He was ACTUALLY scared, which is suprising because although he is in his mid 80's he still works about 3/4 time and is otherwise pretty savvy compared to others his age. But, I guess they know what buttons to push. He called my dad, who is a lawyer and my dad told him it was a scam. It does concern me what others who don't have someone they can just call though would do in that sort of situation... yet these people and the nigerian prince type scams seem to go unprosecuted. I would rather we take a good hard look at this stuff, rather than the stuff that is essentially selling crap you don't need. In the end - at least you get something - even if its not something you want or need.


connie
 
Yes, that kind of advertising gets suckers. But, I do not think it is unfair trade practices. People who follow through and read all the details and are appropriately skeptical do not get taken. It would behoove us then to have more education on how to not be taken, then to in effect limit free speech and business enterprise.

This is what happened with so many people who signed mortgage documents they didn't read after "qualifying" for a loan they couldn't repay by lying on their application, then claimed the lenders were "predatory" and wanted the goverment to make restitution using my tax money...
 
I understand with the disasters in Egypt, Libya and now Syria, the left are making a push to convince themselves that Bush is still running the country, but it just isn't so...

...never said he was - I thought you were making a list of people who make sh1t up - arie is on the list - no, thankfully the reign of error has been over now for 5-years - though Obama is not very high on my approval rating for 2012/2013...
 
This is what happened with so many people who signed mortgage documents they didn't read after "qualifying" for a loan they couldn't repay by lying on their application, then claimed the lenders were "predatory" and wanted the goverment to make restitution using my tax money...

Exactly. Most sales to some degree is predatory. They all use the same tactics. Some fall for it, some don't. DH and I went to look at cars over the weekend, and we really got the high pressure sales tactics? Is it their fault if I am a sucker? No, I don't think so. That is part of being a responsible adult. You figure out how to navigate situations like that.

connie
 
This is what happened with so many people who signed mortgage documents they didn't read after "qualifying" for a loan they couldn't repay by lying on their application, then claimed the lenders were "predatory" and wanted the goverment to make restitution using my tax money...

...they are in-part to blame - BUT - the system was set up to compensate lending agents on volume not viability. Some lending institutions intentionally mis-lead borrowers and misrepresented their income to close the deal - not right, not right at all...

...and let's not even start talking about the clusterfvck called "mortgage-backed securities" - financial institutions bear a LOT of blame - and yet we the people bailed them out - how messed-up was that?...
 
This is what happened with so many people who signed mortgage documents they didn't read after "qualifying" for a loan they couldn't repay by lying on their application, then claimed the lenders were "predatory" and wanted the goverment to make restitution using my tax money...

Mr martian, there may have been a number of people who lied on their mortgage applications, but the problem was largely because of the lenders.
Several years ago when I bought my present home, I went to the mortgage dept. of a very large bank to get qualified before I started to look at properties. I not only didn't lie about my finances, I produced a couple of years of tax returns to verify my income.

The people qualified me for nearly twice what I wound up buying a house for. I knew that if I had used that whole amount I could wind up getting into trouble so I opted for a smaller amount. Not everybody would understand the expenses that they could wind up incurring. It would be a natural tendency to trust and believe the bank.
 
This is what happened with so many people who signed mortgage documents they didn't read after "qualifying" for a loan they couldn't repay by lying on their application, then claimed the lenders were "predatory" and wanted the goverment to make restitution using my tax money...

I remember when state AGs identified the mortgage scam, but the Bush admin. stopped them from doing anything about it.
 
An octogenarian friend of ours is starting to fade, mentally, and her family has decided that it's no longer a good idea for her to live on her own. What tipped them off was a recent visit to help clean up the house when they found all sorts of weird stuff she'd ordered and never even opened, including magazine subscriptions she'd never have found an interest in. They also found she'd given money to various causes she'd never heard of and politicians who weren't even local (like Joe Arpaio, on the other side of the country), and that she had past-due bills for a number of things she had no recollection signing up for. It wasn't identity theft, though. Instead, she was actually doing all these transactions herself, without even realizing what she was doing, because of communications specifically designed to trick the elderly and the naive with small-print and deceptive presentation.

We've all seen that kind of material, although usually we see right through it. For example, surely you've received in the mail something that looks like a check but, in fact, if you endorse it you're signing up for some kind of service. Or you'll be told that you'd won one of three prizes of various values, where even the lowest value seems great (e.g., a $100 gift certificate to some store you frequent), but, in fact, the middle-valued prize is actually the one that 99.9% of all people have won, which is valued at $500 but that's actually just the nominal discount on something you could buy on your own for much less. Or you'll go to a website that has a pop-up that informs you that your computer is infected with some malware, but in reality the pop-up itself is a link that will download malware to your computer. Or you'll be mailed something that's designed to look like a bill for something you already ordered, but somewhere in it, it will say that it's not a bill (the "get out of jail free" card for the con artist), so that the only way you'll be taken in is if you don't read carefully.

I can't recall ever having been taken in by anything of that sort, but obviously lots and lots of people are, or the business model of doing mass mailings of that sort wouldn't endure for decades. People whose minds aren't as sharp as they once were, or who have lousy eyesight for small print are particularly vulnerable. What I'd like to see is a broader law that allows serious enforcement against anyone who designs a communication in a way that's clearly designed to deceive, no matter how many "get out of jail free" fine-print clarifications they use to try to cover their asses. If you have a website with a pop-up designed to look like Windows system alerts, to deceive someone into clicking on them, that should be against the law, even if the goal is merely to steer them to some legitimate advertising, rather than to infect them with a virus. If you design a mass-mailing to look like a bill when it isn't, or to look like someone won a contest when you're just extending to them an offer available to the general public, that should likewise be illegal. If the manifest intent of the way something is presented is to deceive people, however naive or careless, about what they're seeing, that should be punishable under the law. It serves no legitimate capitalist purpose to allow that kind of willfully deceptive trade practice, and so it should be stamped out.

my local Better Business Bureau keeps track of these scams targeting the elderly and alerts the public.
 
Who do you think those Nigerian spammers are targeting? Same way with those door to door "handymen" who con people into paying them to do work.

I agree whole heartedly with your suggestion about the deceptive mailings and trade practices.
The Nigerian ones are bad, but at least those are already illegal -- it's just hard to stamp them out since they're generally one-man operations somewhere abroad. Where we could have more success are the bigger operations associated with businesses that have serious assets. The mass-mailings are a good example. Sometimes these are even associated with large, legitimate companies. Unlike the Nigerian example, they're usually careful not to say anything that's an outright lie, and the fine print generally includes the truth. But the intent is still to deceive, and any time there's no honest argument about that fact, it should be treated as a deceptive trade practice and punished.
 
Mr martian, there may have been a number of people who lied on their mortgage applications, but the problem was largely because of the lenders.
Several years ago when I bought my present home, I went to the mortgage dept. of a very large bank to get qualified before I started to look at properties. I not only didn't lie about my finances, I produced a couple of years of tax returns to verify my income.

The people qualified me for nearly twice what I wound up buying a house for. I knew that if I had used that whole amount I could wind up getting into trouble so I opted for a smaller amount. Not everybody would understand the expenses that they could wind up incurring. It would be a natural tendency to trust and believe the bank.

You mean you exercised good judgement and sound financial decision-making? Good for you! It was the people who didn't do that who contributed to the whole mess. I'm not saying the lenders aren't partly to blame as well, but there's a reason why the saying caveat emptor is so old, it's in Latin!
 
The Nigerian ones are bad, but at least those are already illegal -- it's just hard to stamp them out since they're generally one-man operations somewhere abroad. Where we could have more success are the bigger operations associated with businesses that have serious assets. The mass-mailings are a good example. Sometimes these are even associated with large, legitimate companies. Unlike the Nigerian example, they're usually careful not to say anything that's an outright lie, and the fine print generally includes the truth. But the intent is still to deceive, and any time there's no honest argument about that fact, it should be treated as a deceptive trade practice and punished.

Just got one in the mail that has an official sounding name and includes a card for people to use that supposedly will save them money on prescriptions. One of our tv stations did an expose' recently that showed that people actually had to pay more for their prescriptions than if they didn't use the card. I got the thing after the tv expose'.
 
Arkady,

I have to disagree. Adversiting is all in some way intended to deceive or entice. It is in the eye of the beholder.

But, I believe in buyer beware. It is unfortunate that there are people who have lost their faculties enough to be deceived by those things. But, that is where friends and relatives need to step in and make sure that their loved ones are getting the care they need and oversee their finances better.

Yes, that kind of advertising gets suckers. But, I do not think it is unfair trade practices. People who follow through and read all the details and are appropriately skeptical do not get taken. It would behoove us then to have more education on how to not be taken, then to in effect limit free speech and business enterprise.

I would like to see the government crack down more on the outright scams though of callling an elderly person and trying to get them to wire money, etc. REcently someone called my Grandfather and told him that he had an oustanding ticket and so they had a warrant to arrest him and if he didn't show up at a certain place with the money he was going to go to jail. He was ACTUALLY scared, which is suprising because although he is in his mid 80's he still works about 3/4 time and is otherwise pretty savvy compared to others his age. But, I guess they know what buttons to push. He called my dad, who is a lawyer and my dad told him it was a scam. It does concern me what others who don't have someone they can just call though would do in that sort of situation... yet these people and the nigerian prince type scams seem to go unprosecuted. I would rather we take a good hard look at this stuff, rather than the stuff that is essentially selling crap you don't need. In the end - at least you get something - even if its not something you want or need.


connie
I'm not trying to crack down on mere "puffery." If an ad exaggerates the virtues of a product, fine. That kind of hype is something we're stuck with. But when the whole reason an ad is put together a particular way is the hope of making some credulous person believe something that's an outright falsehood, that's where I think it crosses the line. For example, a mailer that is carefully designed to look exactly like a bill, with a "please mail $X to so-and-so address, by this date" message, and all the important terms hidden in small print, is clearly designed to fool someone into thinking it is a bill, not an offer to sell something. It's designed to get someone who is old or dumb or in a hurry to just write the check for something he would never otherwise buy, because he thinks he's paying for something he already bought. What value is there, for society, in allowing that form of advertising?

There are only four effects I can see to that kind of advertising:

(1) The use of consumer money on different products than they would have bought without the deceptive practices;
(2) The impoverishment of the gullible (which often becomes an expense for their loved ones);
(3) The enrichment of unscrupulous people who put their energies not into coming up with useful goods and services, but rather into ways to prey on the vulnerable;
(4) The wasting of all of our time, since we all end up having to spend a lot more of our precious, productive time reading pointless fine print just to find out if a communication is what it is clearly trying to make us think it is on its surface.

As for the outright scams, I'm in favor of cracking on those, but when it comes to bang for the buck, that's not the place to put our national resources. It takes a huge amount of time and money to try to track down some solo con man sitting in an Internet cafe in some third-world nation, and even if you get him, its like cutting at the heads of a hydra. By comparison, if you go after a relatively small handful of big, profitable, mass-mailing companies and Internet operations, you can get them to police themselves... they've got a lot more to lose than some poor 20-year-old kid sitting in Lagos.
 
Exactly. Most sales to some degree is predatory. They all use the same tactics. Some fall for it, some don't. DH and I went to look at cars over the weekend, and we really got the high pressure sales tactics? Is it their fault if I am a sucker? No, I don't think so. That is part of being a responsible adult. You figure out how to navigate situations like that.

connie
It's partly a question of efficiency. Picture the choice between two options:

(1) A law requiring a handful of businesses to design their advertising in such a way that there's no manifest intent to deceive people about what they're agreeing to.

(2) Instead requiring 300 million people to read everything very closely to make sure that an ad that is manifestly trying to make them think it's one thing isn't, in fact, revealed in the fine print to be something completely different.

In terms of minimizing wasted man-hours, which is better? Is it better to have a few sophisticated business people take another once-over through their mass mailings to make sure they couldn't be seen as an attempt to deceive about key terms? Or is it better to multiply the same amount of work over three hundred million people to make sure something isn't deceiving them?

This is the very heart of consumer protection legislation. Yes, in theory, we could all hire labs to test all our own foods, prior to eating them, to make sure they aren't contaminated by noxious chemicals or bacteria and to determine their nutritional content. But it's vastly more efficient, from a societal perspective, to pass a law requiring companies to make sure their foods aren't contaminated and that they have clear, consistent nutrition labeling. In the same way, we could all be expected to go through the fine print of every commercial communication, to detect ways the material is trying to fool us, but as a practical matter that's not going to happen, and even if it did it would be a colossal waste of time that could be spent more productively. Better to have a regulation that causes the commercial communications we receive to at least be free from that kind of manifest effort to deceive.

A few years back, I reviewed a software license from a very famous software company. The language was exactly the same as they'd used in their "click-through" licenses that had nominally been read and agreed to by hundreds of millions of people worldwide, over the course of several years. But, I noticed that one sentence was actually misdrafted, so that rather than reading as the licensee saying he agreed to obey all relevant laws governing use of the software, it instead read as him saying he agreed NOT to obey all such laws. I demanded that be changed before my company signed the agreement, and they complied, but the software vendor's lawyer was astonished and amused by the fact that error had persisted without anyone else objecting to the CLEAR mistake for so many years. It showed just how unlikely anyone is to read through that material. So, even if it weren't for the efficiency objection to requiring people to read that stuff to avoid being deceived, there's just the practical objection that very few will. In all honesty, how often to you read through all the terms of every "click through" license and "terms of use" web page you're nominally agreeing to? How many times have you really read through the pages of fine print about how your credit card works?
 
It's partly a question of efficiency. Picture the choice between two options:

(1) A law requiring a handful of businesses to design their advertising in such a way that there's no manifest intent to deceive people about what they're agreeing to.

(2) Instead requiring 300 million people to read everything very closely to make sure that an ad that is manifestly trying to make them think it's one thing isn't, in fact, revealed in the fine print to be something completely different.

In terms of minimizing wasted man-hours, which is better? Is it better to have a few sophisticated business people take another once-over through their mass mailings to make sure they couldn't be seen as an attempt to deceive about key terms? Or is it better to multiply the same amount of work over three hundred million people to make sure something isn't deceiving them?

This is the very heart of consumer protection legislation. Yes, in theory, we could all hire labs to test all our own foods, prior to eating them, to make sure they aren't contaminated by noxious chemicals or bacteria and to determine their nutritional content. But it's vastly more efficient, from a societal perspective, to pass a law requiring companies to make sure their foods aren't contaminated and that they have clear, consistent nutrition labeling. In the same way, we could all be expected to go through the fine print of every commercial communication, to detect ways the material is trying to fool us, but as a practical matter that's not going to happen, and even if it did it would be a colossal waste of time that could be spent more productively. Better to have a regulation that causes the commercial communications we receive to at least be free from that kind of manifest effort to deceive.

A few years back, I reviewed a software license from a very famous software company. The language was exactly the same as they'd used in their "click-through" licenses that had nominally been read and agreed to by hundreds of millions of people worldwide, over the course of several years. But, I noticed that one sentence was actually misdrafted, so that rather than reading as the licensee saying he agreed to obey all relevant laws governing use of the software, it instead read as him saying he agreed NOT to obey all such laws. I demanded that be changed before my company signed the agreement, and they complied, but the software vendor's lawyer was astonished and amused by the fact that error had persisted without anyone else objecting to the CLEAR mistake for so many years. It showed just how unlikely anyone is to read through that material. So, even if it weren't for the efficiency objection to requiring people to read that stuff to avoid being deceived, there's just the practical objection that very few will. In all honesty, how often to you read through all the terms of every "click through" license and "terms of use" web page you're nominally agreeing to? How many times have you really read through the pages of fine print about how your credit card works?

Ah, lefty's bubble-wrapped Utopia, where lawyers control everything...
 
Back
Top