New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Prison reform...

Lukey

Senator
Looking for something to bridge the gap here between liberals and libertarians. I'm thinking prison reform is one such area. This is what brought it on:

"A guy on the inside who blamed me for his conviction did everything possible to jack my time, from putting a bounty on me to bragging to the other inmates that he had hired someone on the outside to rape my 8-year-old daughter, and then promised he would rape her again personally when he got out," Kimelman said. "From a societal point of view, I learned what an abject disgrace our prison system is (really the entire criminal-justice system). While I get that it's supposed to be punitive, I find it hard to believe that the American public would allow it to exist in its present state if they knew what it was like."

http://www.cnbc.com/id/102623576

Shouldn't we be able to keep non-violent offenders from being subjected to prison violence (or the threat of violence) such that it sends them back into society in an angry state where they are likely to become a violent re-offender? This is certainly retribution and incapacitation, but how is it deterrence or rehabilitation if we are creating a mental state that is agitated and looking for a little retribution of its own from the society that put him/her into such a dysfunctional environment?

Most non-violent offenders should never spend time behind bars! Keep them confined to home and make them do community service. For really egregious non-violent offenders (i.e. Bernie Madoff) we should have a "work camp" type setting with dorms where they stay at night and then have them do organized community service as part of a work crew made up of non-violent offenders only each day (seven days a week). And if they become violent in there then send them to the real prison for violent offenders. And in the prisons for violent offenders, every inmate should be in solitary confinement with limited recreation, except reading and one hour a day exercise. They should have the opportunity to go to classes or learn a trade (if they have a release date), as should those in the "work camp" setting. But beyond that (class setting) no contact with other inmates. We'll leave the court system out of it for now but I'd be interested in hearing other people's opinions on this obvious failed part of our society.
 
Looking for something to bridge the gap here between liberals and libertarians. I'm thinking prison reform is one such area. This is what brought it on:

"A guy on the inside who blamed me for his conviction did everything possible to jack my time, from putting a bounty on me to bragging to the other inmates that he had hired someone on the outside to rape my 8-year-old daughter, and then promised he would rape her again personally when he got out," Kimelman said. "From a societal point of view, I learned what an abject disgrace our prison system is (really the entire criminal-justice system). While I get that it's supposed to be punitive, I find it hard to believe that the American public would allow it to exist in its present state if they knew what it was like."

http://www.cnbc.com/id/102623576

Shouldn't we be able to keep non-violent offenders from being subjected to prison violence (or the threat of violence) such that it sends them back into society in an angry state where they are likely to become a violent re-offender? This is certainly retribution and incapacitation, but how is it deterrence or rehabilitation if we are creating a mental state that is agitated and looking for a little retribution of its own from the society that put him/her into such a dysfunctional environment?

Most non-violent offenders should never spend time behind bars! Keep them confined to home and make them do community service. For really egregious non-violent offenders (i.e. Bernie Madoff) we should have a "work camp" type setting with dorms where they stay at night and then have them do organized community service as part of a work crew made up of non-violent offenders only each day (seven days a week). And if they become violent in there then send them to the real prison for violent offenders. And in the prisons for violent offenders, every inmate should be in solitary confinement with limited recreation, except reading and one hour a day exercise. They should have the opportunity to go to classes or learn a trade (if they have a release date), as should those in the "work camp" setting. But beyond that (class setting) no contact with other inmates. We'll leave the court system out of it for now but I'd be interested in hearing other people's opinions on this obvious failed part of our society.

I'm on the same page...but with a few differences.

No prisons for profit...and only violent offenders get any major jail time. And even within that system, a push to try and retrain, rehabilitate and educate...and improve the lives of prisoners, as some will be returned to society and we all benefit if recidivism is halted...or at least limited to a small fraction.

If a prisoner proves to be incapable of improving, then I'm fine with bread, water, a head of lettuce and a hole in the ground.

Fines and community service for the non violent...
 
I'm on the same page...but with a few differences.

No prisons for profit...and only violent offenders get any major jail time. And even within that system, a push to try and retrain, rehabilitate and educate...and improve the lives of prisoners, as some will be returned to society and we all benefit if recidivism is halted...or at least limited to a small fraction.

If a prisoner proves to be incapable of improving, then I'm fine with bread, water, a head of lettuce and a hole in the ground.

Fines and community service for the non violent...

The only real difference you cite is the no "for-profit" prisons and I'm totally fine with that as well. See - we agree again!
 
I'm on the same page...but with a few differences.

No prisons for profit...and only violent offenders get any major jail time. And even within that system, a push to try and retrain, rehabilitate and educate...and improve the lives of prisoners, as some will be returned to society and we all benefit if recidivism is halted...or at least limited to a small fraction.

If a prisoner proves to be incapable of improving, then I'm fine with bread, water, a head of lettuce and a hole in the ground.

Fines and community service for the non violent...

Hey Craig - you ever see Straight Time with Dustin Hoffman and Harry Dean Stanton? In addition to being one of the best movies I ever saw, it really does a good job of showing how hard it is for ex-cons re-acclimating to society.
 
Hey Craig - you ever see Straight Time with Dustin Hoffman and Harry Dean Stanton? In addition to being one of the best movies I ever saw, it really does a good job of showing how hard it is for ex-cons re-acclimating to society.

I've not seen that one. I'll keep an eye out; love Harry Dean...
 
Last edited:
Looks good...


On a decidedly different path...I thought this was pretty funny for those of us known to be a bit weird...

Why You Should Keep Things Weird at Work

http://www.inc.com/magazine/201504/...its-about-to-get-weird.html?cid=cp01002quartz

That's a good read thanks! It reminds me a bit of Richard Florida's work regarding city planning around catering to "artsy" creative types, as they are the ones who drive development.

Oh, and watch Straight Time - it's only $5.99 on Amazon - you won't be disappointed!

Here's another one that is pretty good - not as good as Straight Time, but worth the watch:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0085210/?ref_=nm_flmg_act_51
 
That's a good read thanks! It reminds me a bit of Richard Florida's work regarding city planning around catering to "artsy" creative types, as they are the ones who drive development.

Oh, and watch Straight Time - it's only $5.99 on Amazon - you won't be disappointed!

Here's another one that is pretty good - not as good as Straight Time, but worth the watch:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0085210/?ref_=nm_flmg_act_51

I know I'm butting in here, but John Grisham, my all-time favorite author, has been a huge influence in my thinking. I devoured all of his books... more than once. Here's one that has left a very lasting impression me, while we're on the subject:

John Grisham’s first work of nonfiction, an exploration of small town justice gone terribly awry, is his most extraordinary legal thriller yet.

"In the major league draft of 1971, the first player chosen from the State of Oklahoma was Ron Williamson. When he signed with the Oakland A’s, he said goodbye to his hometown of Ada and left to pursue his dreams of big league glory.

Six years later he was back, his dreams broken by a bad arm and bad habits—drinking, drugs, and women. He began to show signs of mental illness. Unable to keep a job, he moved in with his mother and slept twenty hours a day on her sofa.

In 1982, a 21-year-old cocktail waitress in Ada named Debra Sue Carter was raped and murdered, and for five years the police could not solve the crime. For reasons that were never clear, they suspected Ron Williamson and his friend Dennis Fritz. The two were finally arrested in 1987 and charged with capital murder.

With no physical evidence, the prosecution’s case was built on junk science and the testimony of jailhouse snitches and convicts. Dennis Fritz was found guilty and given a life sentence. Ron Williamson was sent to death row.

If you believe that in America you are innocent until proven guilty, this book will shock you. If you believe in the death penalty, this book will disturb you. If you believe the criminal justice system is fair, this book will infuriate you."


http://www.jgrisham.com/books/the-innocent-man/
 
The problem is that the juvenile system excuses and forgives violence endlessly. Then when they finally turn 18 theyre complete animals.

Are you suggesting that we liminate jail time for nonviolent or fist time offenders lik bernie madoff who masterminded a $50 billion fraud?

How about mayors and senators who use their office to collect massive bribes? Police officers who fake evidence in order to get a wrongful conviction? Drug kingpins? People who launder money for terrorists?

I can do this all day long . . .
 
I know I'm butting in here, but John Grisham, my all-time favorite author, has been a huge influence in my thinking. I devoured all of his books... more than once. Here's one that has left a very lasting impression me, while we're on the subject:

John Grisham’s first work of nonfiction, an exploration of small town justice gone terribly awry, is his most extraordinary legal thriller yet.

"In the major league draft of 1971, the first player chosen from the State of Oklahoma was Ron Williamson. When he signed with the Oakland A’s, he said goodbye to his hometown of Ada and left to pursue his dreams of big league glory.

Six years later he was back, his dreams broken by a bad arm and bad habits—drinking, drugs, and women. He began to show signs of mental illness. Unable to keep a job, he moved in with his mother and slept twenty hours a day on her sofa.

In 1982, a 21-year-old cocktail waitress in Ada named Debra Sue Carter was raped and murdered, and for five years the police could not solve the crime. For reasons that were never clear, they suspected Ron Williamson and his friend Dennis Fritz. The two were finally arrested in 1987 and charged with capital murder.

With no physical evidence, the prosecution’s case was built on junk science and the testimony of jailhouse snitches and convicts. Dennis Fritz was found guilty and given a life sentence. Ron Williamson was sent to death row.

If you believe that in America you are innocent until proven guilty, this book will shock you. If you believe in the death penalty, this book will disturb you. If you believe the criminal justice system is fair, this book will infuriate you."


http://www.jgrisham.com/books/the-innocent-man/

That's the first order of business - do away with capital punishment! You can't undo it if the conviction is over-turned post execution.
 
The problem is that the juvenile system excuses and forgives violence endlessly. Then when they finally turn 18 theyre complete animals.

Are you suggesting that we liminate jail time for nonviolent or fist time offenders lik bernie madoff who masterminded a $50 billion fraud?

How about mayors and senators who use their office to collect massive bribes? Police officers who fake evidence in order to get a wrongful conviction? Drug kingpins? People who launder money for terrorists?

I can do this all day long . . .

In my post I suggested that really egregious white collar criminals should be housed only with other non-violent criminals and forced to do community service all day every day.
 
The only real difference you cite is the no "for-profit" prisons and I'm totally fine with that as well. See - we agree again!
I'm in agreement, too. I think having for-profit prisons creates a perverse economic incentive to keep locking up a larger share of the population behind bars, since some of those profits get flowed back into the campaign coffers of the politicians who vote for harsh sentencing standards.
 
I'm in agreement, too. I think having for-profit prisons creates a perverse economic incentive to keep locking up a larger share of the population behind bars, since some of those profits get flowed back into the campaign coffers of the politicians who vote for harsh sentencing standards.

It's nice to be able to finally agree with people I always seem to be arguing with...

http://elementarygenocide.com/12-major-corporations-benefiting-from-the-prison-industrial-complex/
 
One of the things that bothers me about prisons is the conversion and radicalization of prisoners to Islam. I believe all religions should be blocked from talking with prisoners. The prison system is turning into a good recruiting ground for Radical Muslims.
 
One of the things that bothers me about prisons is the conversion and radicalization of prisoners to Islam. I believe all religions should be blocked from talking with prisoners. The prison system is turning into a good recruiting ground for Radical Muslims.

Maybe, but part of that (being successful) is the chip they get on their shoulders due to the deplorable conditions under which they live. I don't think you can deprive inmates of access to religious counseling, but I certainly think getting the gang mentality out (via the solitary confinement) would lessen the appeal of (radical) Islam.
 
Back
Top