Lukey
Senator
Looking for something to bridge the gap here between liberals and libertarians. I'm thinking prison reform is one such area. This is what brought it on:
"A guy on the inside who blamed me for his conviction did everything possible to jack my time, from putting a bounty on me to bragging to the other inmates that he had hired someone on the outside to rape my 8-year-old daughter, and then promised he would rape her again personally when he got out," Kimelman said. "From a societal point of view, I learned what an abject disgrace our prison system is (really the entire criminal-justice system). While I get that it's supposed to be punitive, I find it hard to believe that the American public would allow it to exist in its present state if they knew what it was like."
http://www.cnbc.com/id/102623576
Shouldn't we be able to keep non-violent offenders from being subjected to prison violence (or the threat of violence) such that it sends them back into society in an angry state where they are likely to become a violent re-offender? This is certainly retribution and incapacitation, but how is it deterrence or rehabilitation if we are creating a mental state that is agitated and looking for a little retribution of its own from the society that put him/her into such a dysfunctional environment?
Most non-violent offenders should never spend time behind bars! Keep them confined to home and make them do community service. For really egregious non-violent offenders (i.e. Bernie Madoff) we should have a "work camp" type setting with dorms where they stay at night and then have them do organized community service as part of a work crew made up of non-violent offenders only each day (seven days a week). And if they become violent in there then send them to the real prison for violent offenders. And in the prisons for violent offenders, every inmate should be in solitary confinement with limited recreation, except reading and one hour a day exercise. They should have the opportunity to go to classes or learn a trade (if they have a release date), as should those in the "work camp" setting. But beyond that (class setting) no contact with other inmates. We'll leave the court system out of it for now but I'd be interested in hearing other people's opinions on this obvious failed part of our society.
"A guy on the inside who blamed me for his conviction did everything possible to jack my time, from putting a bounty on me to bragging to the other inmates that he had hired someone on the outside to rape my 8-year-old daughter, and then promised he would rape her again personally when he got out," Kimelman said. "From a societal point of view, I learned what an abject disgrace our prison system is (really the entire criminal-justice system). While I get that it's supposed to be punitive, I find it hard to believe that the American public would allow it to exist in its present state if they knew what it was like."
http://www.cnbc.com/id/102623576
Shouldn't we be able to keep non-violent offenders from being subjected to prison violence (or the threat of violence) such that it sends them back into society in an angry state where they are likely to become a violent re-offender? This is certainly retribution and incapacitation, but how is it deterrence or rehabilitation if we are creating a mental state that is agitated and looking for a little retribution of its own from the society that put him/her into such a dysfunctional environment?
Most non-violent offenders should never spend time behind bars! Keep them confined to home and make them do community service. For really egregious non-violent offenders (i.e. Bernie Madoff) we should have a "work camp" type setting with dorms where they stay at night and then have them do organized community service as part of a work crew made up of non-violent offenders only each day (seven days a week). And if they become violent in there then send them to the real prison for violent offenders. And in the prisons for violent offenders, every inmate should be in solitary confinement with limited recreation, except reading and one hour a day exercise. They should have the opportunity to go to classes or learn a trade (if they have a release date), as should those in the "work camp" setting. But beyond that (class setting) no contact with other inmates. We'll leave the court system out of it for now but I'd be interested in hearing other people's opinions on this obvious failed part of our society.