New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Professional Hazing

Arkady

President
Here's a story of a banking intern who died after putting in three all-nighters in pursuit of a highly paid career in the industry:

http://www.salon.com/2013/08/20/banking_intern_dies_after_working_three_all_nighters/

This isn't such an uncommon thing for those pursuing the brass ring of elite professional employment. When I was a young lawyer, I went through something similar. There was a three-month period when I averaged eighty hours or more of work per week. Add in an hour and a half commute per day, and it worked out to 14 hours dedicated to work for six days, with a half day on Sunday. Outside of Sunday, I had no personal life at all -- every waking hour was getting ready for work, traveling to or from work, working, eating, or getting ready for bed. On Sunday, I had a few hours to run the chores I couldn't get to during the week.

The thing is, this didn't really benefit my employer. People's brains stop working well when you work them that way, so they were getting crappy work product. And it was doing nothing to develop me as a lawyer, since people's memories get fried by that variety of chronic stress, so that nothing I was doing was sticking in my long-term memory. It was wrecking my health, straining my relationships, and poorly serving the clients. It served no real purpose for anyone, other than as a kind of hazing.

I know I'm not alone in this. It's very common for lawyers in their first and second years out of law school. For me, at least the hours dropped back to a saner 60 per week before long -- I've known some people at the white-shoe firms who were putting in 70 hours per week for a couple years before they were able to cut back to something a little less ridiculous. I have doctor friends who say it's common in medicine, too, during one's time as a resident, compounded by the difficulties of shift work -- and there it can lead to deadly mistakes. It's not surprising that it's also common in the investment banking world. It comes across as more of a test of toughness --or maybe just an orgy of sadomasochism-- than as anything that serves a professional purpose.

Does anyone know if this is peculiar to the US? We work much longer hours than most other wealthy nations, so it wouldn't surprise me if it were.
 
If one takes on the responsibility of handling an important project, then they will become indispensable. That's the price that one pays for accepting a challenge. It's a shame that an unpaid intern was trusted with so much responsibility as to have to resort to this sort of overexertion. Seems to me that any position that demands such sacrifice should at least be a paid position.
 
Here's a story of a banking intern who died after putting in three all-nighters in pursuit of a highly paid career in the industry:

http://www.salon.com/2013/08/20/banking_intern_dies_after_working_three_all_nighters/

This isn't such an uncommon thing for those pursuing the brass ring of elite professional employment. When I was a young lawyer, I went through something similar. There was a three-month period when I averaged eighty hours or more of work per week. Add in an hour and a half commute per day, and it worked out to 14 hours dedicated to work for six days, with a half day on Sunday. Outside of Sunday, I had no personal life at all -- every waking hour was getting ready for work, traveling to or from work, working, eating, or getting ready for bed. On Sunday, I had a few hours to run the chores I couldn't get to during the week.

The thing is, this didn't really benefit my employer. People's brains stop working well when you work them that way, so they were getting crappy work product. And it was doing nothing to develop me as a lawyer, since people's memories get fried by that variety of chronic stress, so that nothing I was doing was sticking in my long-term memory. It was wrecking my health, straining my relationships, and poorly serving the clients. It served no real purpose for anyone, other than as a kind of hazing.

I know I'm not alone in this. It's very common for lawyers in their first and second years out of law school. For me, at least the hours dropped back to a saner 60 per week before long -- I've known some people at the white-shoe firms who were putting in 70 hours per week for a couple years before they were able to cut back to something a little less ridiculous. I have doctor friends who say it's common in medicine, too, during one's time as a resident, compounded by the difficulties of shift work -- and there it can lead to deadly mistakes. It's not surprising that it's also common in the investment banking world. It comes across as more of a test of toughness --or maybe just an orgy of sadomasochism-- than as anything that serves a professional purpose.

Does anyone know if this is peculiar to the US? We work much longer hours than most other wealthy nations, so it wouldn't surprise me if it were.

I dunno. Here's one link: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/201...nch-germans-and-chinese-are-very-interesting/ that shows we work more than some, less than others, and less now than earlier. WRT the guy unfortunately dying, I'm not convinced it was due to overwork. I have worked for periods of time, particularly when working proposals, that I had a cot installed in the office because I was there until 2-3 every morning and back up at 6 when people started banging through the office door. True, it was short-term, but did last for about 2 weeks straight each time. Sure it's exhausting, but doable. I normally work 40-hour weeks, punctuated by 70-80 hour weeks when I'm running a test. Not the easiest thing to do when trying to maintain family and relationships, but it likely won't kill me. It certainly wouldn't have killed me when I was 21.
 
I dunno. Here's one link: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/201...nch-germans-and-chinese-are-very-interesting/ that shows we work more than some, less than others, and less now than earlier. WRT the guy unfortunately dying, I'm not convinced it was due to overwork. I have worked for periods of time, particularly when working proposals, that I had a cot installed in the office because I was there until 2-3 every morning and back up at 6 when people started banging through the office door. True, it was short-term, but did last for about 2 weeks straight each time. Sure it's exhausting, but doable. I normally work 40-hour weeks, punctuated by 70-80 hour weeks when I'm running a test. Not the easiest thing to do when trying to maintain family and relationships, but it likely won't kill me. It certainly wouldn't have killed me when I was 21.
In my late teens and early 20s, I could handle that stuff easily -- my work quality would decline and I'd get sick a lot, but it's not like I was going to die or something. These days, though, I feel it a whole lot more, physically, when I put in hours like that. A single 70-hour week leaves me feeling incredibly ragged -- and if I power through it with too much coffee, I get heart arrhythmia. I could definitely picture giving myself a heart attack if I tried to do a couple months of 80-hour weeks, or even just a few days straight of 18-hour days. So, if the kid wasn't in great health to begin with, it's not hard to imagine it putting him over the edge.
 
In my late teens and early 20s, I could handle that stuff easily -- my work quality would decline and I'd get sick a lot, but it's not like I was going to die or something. These days, though, I feel it a whole lot more, physically, when I put in hours like that. A single 70-hour week leaves me feeling incredibly ragged -- and if I power through it with too much coffee, I get heart arrhythmia. I could definitely picture giving myself a heart attack if I tried to do a couple months of 80-hour weeks, or even just a few days straight of 18-hour days. So, if the kid wasn't in great health to begin with, it's not hard to imagine it putting him over the edge.

I'm with you there - it takes more out of me to work long hours than it used to. But as for the poor guy who died, if he wasn't in great health and died from overwork as a result, he's not a great example to use when discussing the potential deleterious health impacts of overwork (not that you're necessarily using him as said example).
 
Here's a story of a banking intern who died after putting in three all-nighters in pursuit of a highly paid career in the industry:

http://www.salon.com/2013/08/20/banking_intern_dies_after_working_three_all_nighters/

This isn't such an uncommon thing for those pursuing the brass ring of elite professional employment. When I was a young lawyer, I went through something similar. There was a three-month period when I averaged eighty hours or more of work per week. Add in an hour and a half commute per day, and it worked out to 14 hours dedicated to work for six days, with a half day on Sunday. Outside of Sunday, I had no personal life at all -- every waking hour was getting ready for work, traveling to or from work, working, eating, or getting ready for bed. On Sunday, I had a few hours to run the chores I couldn't get to during the week.

The thing is, this didn't really benefit my employer. People's brains stop working well when you work them that way, so they were getting crappy work product. And it was doing nothing to develop me as a lawyer, since people's memories get fried by that variety of chronic stress, so that nothing I was doing was sticking in my long-term memory. It was wrecking my health, straining my relationships, and poorly serving the clients. It served no real purpose for anyone, other than as a kind of hazing.

I know I'm not alone in this. It's very common for lawyers in their first and second years out of law school. For me, at least the hours dropped back to a saner 60 per week before long -- I've known some people at the white-shoe firms who were putting in 70 hours per week for a couple years before they were able to cut back to something a little less ridiculous. I have doctor friends who say it's common in medicine, too, during one's time as a resident, compounded by the difficulties of shift work -- and there it can lead to deadly mistakes. It's not surprising that it's also common in the investment banking world. It comes across as more of a test of toughness --or maybe just an orgy of sadomasochism-- than as anything that serves a professional purpose.

Does anyone know if this is peculiar to the US? We work much longer hours than most other wealthy nations, so it wouldn't surprise me if it were.

Hah!!! At least there's a brass ring.... check out Airborne School, or Ranger School, or (most useless of all) Air Assault School. If you're going to ruin your health and run yourself ragged, at least get paid for it. Ya'll are smarter than I was....
 
I dunno. Here's one link: http://www.theblaze.com/stories/201...nch-germans-and-chinese-are-very-interesting/ that shows we work more than some, less than others, and less now than earlier. WRT the guy unfortunately dying, I'm not convinced it was due to overwork. I have worked for periods of time, particularly when working proposals, that I had a cot installed in the office because I was there until 2-3 every morning and back up at 6 when people started banging through the office door. True, it was short-term, but did last for about 2 weeks straight each time. Sure it's exhausting, but doable. I normally work 40-hour weeks, punctuated by 70-80 hour weeks when I'm running a test. Not the easiest thing to do when trying to maintain family and relationships, but it likely won't kill me. It certainly wouldn't have killed me when I was 21.
Those graphs are interesting. I was already aware of where the US stood relative to other nations presently, but hadn't seen the historical data. It's interesting that the general trend, relative to our peers, is that they used to work much longer hours than us, but now typically work considerably less. I think that makes some sense when you think of how the US and many other wealthy nations diverged when it came to social policy. Europe, for example, pursued labor-friendly policies that allowed for a greater share of national wealth to flow to the workers as benefits (paid vacation, government healthcare, etc.), allowing people to live comfortable lives with fewer and fewer hours of work. The US didn't really do that, such that more and more of the value our workers were creating was going to the economic elite, and so people needed to continue to slave away to keep up a decent standard of living (although our stats show falling hours per worker, this was at a time when women were entering the workforce, meaning more hours of work per household). Wages are now at the lowest point, as a share of national income, that they've ever been since data started being tracked right after WWII.
 
Hah!!! At least there's a brass ring.... check out Airborne School, or Ranger School, or (most useless of all) Air Assault School. If you're going to ruin your health and run yourself ragged, at least get paid for it. Ya'll are smarter than I was....

True frey. Most of the military guys I work with are special forces (mostly Army) and "running yourself ragged" is an understatement - not to mention the recounting of what they went thru in Afghanistan.
 
Hah!!! At least there's a brass ring.... check out Airborne School, or Ranger School, or (most useless of all) Air Assault School. If you're going to ruin your health and run yourself ragged, at least get paid for it. Ya'll are smarter than I was....
I saw a good documentary on Ranger School. It looks horrible. But, at least, there, you can argue the hazing serves several legitimate purposes. First, it creates a sense among those who pass that they're something special -- a kind of confidence that could prove useful if you have to order them to do something a little insane. Second, it weeds out those who can't function under that kind of intense stress -- better to find out at that point than when lives are really on the line. Third, it trains people to know their own minds and bodies so they can better cope with intense stress when it counts. But with most professional employment, is seems the hazing is more sadistic than calculated. It's not like older lawyers need to be able to work 80-hour work-weeks, such that you need to weed out the weaklings early. Once you make it through the initial months or years of "hazing," things normalize (as they would need to in order to have people doing highly-mentally-demanding work without a lot of errors).
 
True frey. Most of the military guys I work with are special forces (mostly Army) and "running yourself ragged" is an understatement - not to mention the recounting of what they went thru in Afghanistan.
In 2006 I was running patrols in the Korengal Valley at the age of 35/36 yrs old. I was one of the 4 or 5 oldest guys there, and the other old guys never left the wire. We had half of an ODA show up and look at setting up shop but after a few days of looking around, (and meeting our sorry-ass CO), they said "[Unwelcome language removed] this place" and bounced. I got back from a patrol and they were gone.... Running up and down those mountains got me down to 169lbs; I normally walk around at between 210 and 220. Ranger school ain't shit compared to that place....
 
In 2006 I was running patrols in the Korengal Valley at the age of 35/36 yrs old. I was one of the 4 or 5 oldest guys there, and the other old guys never left the wire. We had half of an ODA show up and look at setting up shop but after a few days of looking around, (and meeting our sorry-ass CO), they said "**** this place" and bounced. I got back from a patrol and they were gone.... Running up and down those mountains got me down to 169lbs; I normally walk around at between 210 and 220. Ranger school ain't shit compared to that place....

Yes. Another contributing factor (and props for doing that in your mid-30's) is the amount of weight that has to be carried; including armor and kit, it can be significant. One of the guys told me he gained about 70 pounds while there because he bulked up so much from having to carry so much weight wherever he went. That guy, in addition, is in the wounded warrier program because he was, as he said, "blown up" five times. The hardest part for him? Being removed from group.
 
Yes. Another contributing factor (and props for doing that in your mid-30's) is the amount of weight that has to be carried; including armor and kit, it can be significant. One of the guys told me he gained about 70 pounds while there because he bulked up so much from having to carry so much weight wherever he went. That guy, in addition, is in the wounded warrier program because he was, as he said, "blown up" five times. The hardest part for him? Being removed from group.
Little secret; the guys in SpecOps don't get tested for steroids ;). I have seen some absolute monsters.....
 
Little secret; the guys in SpecOps don't get tested for steroids ;). I have seen some absolute monsters.....

Ok I've never asked that specific question! OTOH, I can't imagine wanting to bulk up over and above carrying all that weight around but who knows? I'd rather be nimble in a firefight ...
 
Yes. Another contributing factor (and props for doing that in your mid-30's) is the amount of weight that has to be carried; including armor and kit, it can be significant. One of the guys told me he gained about 70 pounds while there because he bulked up so much from having to carry so much weight wherever he went. That guy, in addition, is in the wounded warrier program because he was, as he said, "blown up" five times. The hardest part for him? Being removed from group.

The load each individual soldier was expected to carry was a constant issue between myself and the chain of command. I had been to Afghanistan before but almost nobody in that company had; they were all Iraq vets and assumed it would be the same. They were used to having vehicles to haul their gear, and as far as "Lightfighting" in the mountains, they were clueless. I would object to the Company leadership dictating the packing list for each patrol, it was blatant micro-managing by people who knew very little to begin with. I had several soldiers sustain serious injuries, (knees, ankles, etc.) as a result, as well as having a few just straight punk out, and claim to be injured to get out of patrolling, due to being overloaded. This constant friction between myself and the CoC was a big reason my platoon bore the brunt of the mission load, IMO, and it also led to my platoon being used as bait to draw out insurgents. I'll bet that sawed off little maggot of a CO is still pissed that I didn't die out there....
 
Little secret; the guys in SpecOps don't get tested for steroids ;). I have seen some absolute monsters.....
That sounds like a bad idea, given the 'roid rage problem. I used to be a shot-putter and football player and knew a lot of steroid users, and to a man they had unpredictable flashes of serious rage. I'd be worried about giving people with that hormonal imbalance weapons and putting them in a high-stress position where the lives of innocents depend on their self control
 
Here's a story of a banking intern who died after putting in three all-nighters in pursuit of a highly paid career in the industry:

http://www.salon.com/2013/08/20/banking_intern_dies_after_working_three_all_nighters/

This isn't such an uncommon thing for those pursuing the brass ring of elite professional employment. When I was a young lawyer, I went through something similar. There was a three-month period when I averaged eighty hours or more of work per week. Add in an hour and a half commute per day, and it worked out to 14 hours dedicated to work for six days, with a half day on Sunday. Outside of Sunday, I had no personal life at all -- every waking hour was getting ready for work, traveling to or from work, working, eating, or getting ready for bed. On Sunday, I had a few hours to run the chores I couldn't get to during the week.

The thing is, this didn't really benefit my employer. People's brains stop working well when you work them that way, so they were getting crappy work product. And it was doing nothing to develop me as a lawyer, since people's memories get fried by that variety of chronic stress, so that nothing I was doing was sticking in my long-term memory. It was wrecking my health, straining my relationships, and poorly serving the clients. It served no real purpose for anyone, other than as a kind of hazing.

I know I'm not alone in this. It's very common for lawyers in their first and second years out of law school. For me, at least the hours dropped back to a saner 60 per week before long -- I've known some people at the white-shoe firms who were putting in 70 hours per week for a couple years before they were able to cut back to something a little less ridiculous. I have doctor friends who say it's common in medicine, too, during one's time as a resident, compounded by the difficulties of shift work -- and there it can lead to deadly mistakes. It's not surprising that it's also common in the investment banking world. It comes across as more of a test of toughness --or maybe just an orgy of sadomasochism-- than as anything that serves a professional purpose.

Does anyone know if this is peculiar to the US? We work much longer hours than most other wealthy nations, so it wouldn't surprise me if it were.


It is a test of toughness. While his three days of all nighters is well... extreme... there may be times in his career where he would have been pushed up against the wall of a major deadline - and where he would need to forsake home, sleep, family to get the job done.

In some circles - if you can't prove that you are that guy - you may still have a job - but you will never get the chance to advance. Advancement does by far go to those who are willing to put work ahead of family and ahead of personal comfort.

It is unique, to here, I think. Maybe only superseded by Japan as far as a test of "work ethic". I think they have a highly competitve work environment there.

Personally, I don't have a problem with it. While I have no idea what drove this kid to work three days straight for an unpaid internship - I think its good to force someone to test their metal and just see what exactly you are getting. I declined job offers at what was the big 8 back in the day.. because I knew that is the kind of environment I was going to go into. Even in a local firm, the hours in tax season are brutal. But, its also the nature of the beast and I think its good to see who will crack under pressure and who won't.

And, despite the dearth of lazy people we have in this country - I do think in a comparision of upper level employees - we have some that do work the hardest and have probably culled the heard of the weak links better. I have a friend whose husband is in upperlevel management in the Pharmaceutical industry. He works in Switzerland and all of the top management at his company are ex-pats. Why - because the Swiss, while good, steady, hardworking people - like their family time. No one there works past 5, like many European countries - they have weeks upon weeks of vacation, etc... and in the worldwide highly competitive pharma industry - that just doesn't cut it. So they use mostly American's to run their business. People who are used to sacrificing homelife and family life for the corporate bottom line.

I don't really care if someone doesn't want to enter that rat race, but then don't look at those people who practically kill themselves for thier jobs or positions and say - well... but I still want what he has or somehow I am entitled to a little bit of what he has.

connie
 
It is a test of toughness. While his three days of all nighters is well... extreme... there may be times in his career where he would have been pushed up against the wall of a major deadline - and where he would need to forsake home, sleep, family to get the job done.

In some circles - if you can't prove that you are that guy - you may still have a job - but you will never get the chance to advance. Advancement does by far go to those who are willing to put work ahead of family and ahead of personal comfort.

It is unique, to here, I think. Maybe only superseded by Japan as far as a test of "work ethic". I think they have a highly competitve work environment there.

Personally, I don't have a problem with it. While I have no idea what drove this kid to work three days straight for an unpaid internship - I think its good to force someone to test their metal and just see what exactly you are getting. I declined job offers at what was the big 8 back in the day.. because I knew that is the kind of environment I was going to go into. Even in a local firm, the hours in tax season are brutal. But, its also the nature of the beast and I think its good to see who will crack under pressure and who won't.

And, despite the dearth of lazy people we have in this country - I do think in a comparision of upper level employees - we have some that do work the hardest and have probably culled the heard of the weak links better. I have a friend whose husband is in upperlevel management in the Pharmaceutical industry. He works in Switzerland and all of the top management at his company are ex-pats. Why - because the Swiss, while good, steady, hardworking people - like their family time. No one there works past 5, like many European countries - they have weeks upon weeks of vacation, etc... and in the worldwide highly competitive pharma industry - that just doesn't cut it. So they use mostly American's to run their business. People who are used to sacrificing homelife and family life for the corporate bottom line.

I don't really care if someone doesn't want to enter that rat race, but then don't look at those people who practically kill themselves for thier jobs or positions and say - well... but I still want what he has or somehow I am entitled to a little bit of what he has.

connie

Just a personal pet peeve: it's "test their mettle" not "test their metal."
 
That sounds like a bad idea, given the 'roid rage problem. I used to be a shot-putter and football player and knew a lot of steroid users, and to a man they had unpredictable flashes of serious rage. I'd be worried about giving people with that hormonal imbalance weapons and putting them in a high-stress position where the lives of innocents depend on their self control
Brother, most of the stuff that goes on in the military is a bad idea.....
 
Back
Top