New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Public or Private School?

Arkady

President
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.
 
You guys are fortunate to have good options available either way. I'd say you're just going to have to settle it between yourselves. I don't want any part of a husband/wife argument. I've got my own to deal with. ;)
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.



It's your choice. My daughter is twelve years old and is in her second year of Chinese and third year of Spanish. Her grade point average is 4.00 and tested in the top 1% for our state in math, science and reading. She attends private school, and is light-years ahead of her friends who attend public school. Now I'm bragging a bit I realize, and I'm confident she would excel in any academic environment. The public schools in this area simply would not challenge her though, and my wife and I are extremely pleased with where she goes to school now. It may be different in your area.

And, yes, she gets her smarts from her mother, obviously.
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.

It looks like you have good choices for your daughter either way you go. Maybe to help make the decision you might want to look at the curricula taught by each and see which one you like best.

Keep in mind that while it's good to expose your child to a lot of different people, she might gravitate (hypothetically speaking here) toward those who don't consider education to be very important. Kids go through periods of their life (junior high age is a definite one) where anyone's opinion is regarded more highly than their parents' opinions. So while exposing her to kids who don't have high regard for education might seem noble and good............ if she identifies with them at some point it might go into a difficult era in your family life.

Raising a child is fraught with stuff like that and even in a private school you won't be able to avoid the cliff they fall off in the 6th grade (or thereabouts) but maybe you can manage it better if she is in a bit of a guarded atmosphere. My oldest son went to public school all the way through, was in AP classes and he graduated from college with honors. My younger children started in public schools, (same excellent district as my older son) but it was a mess. So I put them into a private school. Eventually I took them out and finished their schooling at home. They too all graduated from college with honors.

I am guessing that whatever way you go with your daughter she will be fine. The home life counts for more than people realize. But do check out the curriculum and maybe one will jump out at you as the one you want for your child. When I was teaching at home, I compared and the choice was obvious. That might help in making your decision.
 
It's your choice. My daughter is twelve years old and is in her second year of Chinese and third year of Spanish. Her grade point average is 4.00 and tested in the top 1% for our state in math, science and reading. She attends private school, and is light-years ahead of her friends who attend public school. Now I'm bragging a bit I realize, and I'm confident she would excel in any academic environment. The public schools in this area simply would not challenge her though, and my wife and I are extremely pleased with where she goes to school now. It may be different in your area.

And, yes, she gets her smarts from her mother, obviously.

Private schools are usually well ahead of public schools. My twins switched from public to private schooling in the 4th grade and barely made the cut. The private school wanted to hold them back a year (but I refused because they were tall boys and I knew they were smart enough to do the work)........... and 4th grade was VERY difficult for them, but they came up to speed. That's why I advised Arkady to take a look and compare curriculum. There might be a marked difference there that's easy to see.
 
Private schools are usually well ahead of public schools. My twins switched from public to private schooling in the 4th grade and barely made the cut. The private school wanted to hold them back a year........... and 4th grade was VERY difficult for them, but they came up to speed. That's why I advised Arkady to take a look and compare curriculum. There might be a marked difference there that's easy to see.


That's good advice. It is also worth noting that not all private schools are created equally. Compare and contrast, and choose wisely.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
It looks like you have good choices for your daughter either way you go. Maybe to help make the decision you might want to look at the curricula taught by each and see which one you like best.

Keep in mind that while it's good to expose your child to a lot of different people, she might gravitate (hypothetically speaking here) toward those who don't consider education to be very important. Kids go through periods of their life (junior high age is a definite one) where anyone's opinion is regarded more highly than their parents' opinions. So while exposing her to kids who don't have high regard for education might seem noble and good............ if she identifies with them at some point it might go into a difficult era in your family life.

Raising a child is fraught with stuff like that and even in a private school you won't be able to avoid the cliff they fall off in the 6th grade (or thereabouts) but maybe you can manage it better if she is in a bit of a guarded atmosphere. My oldest son went to public school all the way through, was in AP classes and he graduated from college with honors. My younger children started in public schools, (same excellent district as my older son) but it was a mess. So I put them into a private school. Eventually I took them out and finished their schooling at home. They too all graduated from college with honors.

I am guessing that whatever way you go with your daughter she will be fine. The home life counts for more than people realize. But do check out the curriculum and maybe one will jump out at you as the one you want for your child. When I was teaching at home, I compared and the choice was obvious. That might help in making your decision.
Thanks, that helps.

In my own case, I have to admit I didn't learn all that much in school. I had a couple good teachers who really helped, but I mean literally a couple: two. Other than that, I was mostly an auto-didact when it came to academic stuff -- tuning out lessons and skipping classes a lot. But I still found the public school experience extremely important for the social education it provided. I guess I'm coming from a weird place, mentally, and my daughter may not have that same kind of mentality, which is going to make it harder for me to decide on her behalf.
 
That's good advice. It is also worth noting that not all private schools are created equally. Compare and contrast, and choose wisely.
Oh... absolutely. I didn't mention that because they seemed to have checked out the private schools they are considering. But the second one my kids went to was downright scary. Luckily that was short-lived and I was teaching there (so I could keep an eye on them). That was in Alaska and even with that scary private school, it was hugely better than public schools there. We really had no good choices, sad to say, until I home schooled them and I believe I did a good job.
 
Thanks, that helps.

In my own case, I have to admit I didn't learn all that much in school. I had a couple good teachers who really helped, but I mean literally a couple: two. Other than that, I was mostly an auto-didact when it came to academic stuff -- tuning out lessons and skipping classes a lot. But I still found the public school experience extremely important for the social education it provided. I guess I'm coming from a weird place, mentally, and my daughter may not have that same kind of mentality, which is going to make it harder for me to decide on her behalf.

I think there might be safer ways to give her that social experience. But that's just my viewpoint. I have to side with your wife (private school), but I am certain that the two of you will decide on what's best.

Consider this: would you want her to go on "auto-didact" and "tune out lessons and skipping class" a lot? Not saying she would do that, but..............
 
You guys are fortunate to have good options available either way. I'd say you're just going to have to settle it between yourselves. I don't want any part of a husband/wife argument. I've got my own to deal with. ;)
Hehe. I think I'm going to win this one, but I may be kicking myself later if my daughter struggles and I'm left wondering whether private school would have set her up better.
 
It's your choice. My daughter is twelve years old and is in her second year of Chinese and third year of Spanish. Her grade point average is 4.00 and tested in the top 1% for our state in math, science and reading. She attends private school, and is light-years ahead of her friends who attend public school. Now I'm bragging a bit I realize, and I'm confident she would excel in any academic environment. The public schools in this area simply would not challenge her though, and my wife and I are extremely pleased with where she goes to school now. It may be different in your area.

And, yes, she gets her smarts from her mother, obviously.
Interesting that you mentioned languages, since that's one of the few things pushing me towards private school. As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, I was an autodidact, and I believe strongly in the ability of people to learn most things without a lot of hand-holding by a teacher. But other than with a few absurdly gifted people, there are a few topics where instruction is almost indispensable, including music and languages. Even a genius is unlikely to pick up Mandarin through self study. You need someone to correct your pronunciation and speak to you in an interactive way, to learn a language. And that kind of elite language instruction just isn't something a person is likely to get at even the best public school

That was one of the few areas where I graduated high school with a pathetic education. I'd taken three years of German, but could hardly hold the most simple conversation. I didn't get remotely good at it until college. And my brother was worse. He'd had seven years of public-school French and yet tested into first-year French in college. So I'm very skeptical about public school education on that front.
 
Hehe. I think I'm going to win this one, but I may be kicking myself later if my daughter struggles and I'm left wondering whether private school would have set her up better.

Good chance she will struggle less in a public school. Curriculum is inherently easier in public schools.
 
Oh... absolutely. I didn't mention that because they seemed to have checked out the private schools they are considering. But the second one my kids went to was downright scary. Luckily that was short-lived and I was teaching there (so I could keep an eye on them). That was in Alaska and even with that scary private school, it was hugely better than public schools there. We really had no good choices, sad to say, until I home schooled them and I believe I did a good job.
Yeah. A couple of my cousins went to private school and were practically illiterate when they graduated. It was a religious school that really emphasized sports, but not much else.

The ones I'm considering for my daughter are highly competitive, academically and have great numbers, though.
 
Interesting that you mentioned languages, since that's one of the few things pushing me towards private school. As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, I was an autodidact, and I believe strongly in the ability of people to learn most things without a lot of hand-holding by a teacher. But other than with a few absurdly gifted people, there are a few topics where instruction is almost indispensable, including music and languages. Even a genius is unlikely to pick up Mandarin through self study. You need someone to correct your pronunciation and speak to you in an interactive way, to learn a language. And that kind of elite language instruction just isn't something a person is likely to get at even the best public school

That was one of the few areas where I graduated high school with a pathetic education. I'd taken three years of German, but could hardly hold the most simple conversation. I didn't get remotely good at it until college. And my brother was worse. He'd had seven years of public-school French and yet tested into first-year French in college. So I'm very skeptical about public school education on that front.


My daughter started piano lessons when she was four, and I believe that has helped her with languages. She also took ASL in second grade as part of the curriculum, which she picked up rather quickly, although she seldom has a chance to use it.
 
Second languages should be taught at the pre-school level. We start losing our natural ability to learn language by the age of three. After that, the older one becomes, the harder it is to assimilate a new language.
 
Good chance she will struggle less in a public school. Curriculum is inherently easier in public schools.
Yeah. I meant struggling more in terms of struggling to get into a good college, if she didn't have private school reputation and connections helping her out. In my own case, I got into a good college despite having gone to an unremarkable public school, but that was entirely based on SATs. I had plenty of friends who had better grades and extra-curriculars who couldn't get into a very good college.
 
Yeah. A couple of my cousins went to private school and were practically illiterate when they graduated. It was a religious school that really emphasized sports, but not much else.

The ones I'm considering for my daughter are highly competitive, academically and have great numbers, though.

That's why you have to really check out the private school. Is it a haven for good kids from good families? Or is it a school that takes in the public school rejects? Both kinds of private schools are necessary but you need to know beforehand which your daughter will be attending. The private school where I taught in Alaska was created as a haven, but when I was there it had become the other.........we had kids expelled from public school for selling drugs, one girl I taught was expelled because she threw a knife at someone on the school ground and another was kicked out from just always being on drugs. My kids were unscathed by that (they were younger than these kids) but you need to really check it out.
 
Second languages should be taught at the pre-school level. We start losing our natural ability to learn language by the age of three. After that, the older one becomes, the harder it is to assimilate a new language.
Yep. At one point I'd gotten good enough at German to take classes in an elite German university without too much trouble, but my accent was always atrocious, and speaking was never easy, because I learned it much too late.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Yep. At one point I'd gotten good enough at German to take classes in an elite German university without too much trouble, but my accent was always atrocious, and speaking was never easy, because I learned it much too late.

It is difficult in the US to learn and maintain a second language. Due to the prevalence of English, you aren't likely to be exposed to your second language on a regular basis.
 
Back
Top