Arkady
President
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.
Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.
My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.
My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.
My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.
Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.
My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.
My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.
My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.