New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Public or Private School?

Yep. At one point I'd gotten good enough at German to take classes in an elite German university without too much trouble, but my accent was always atrocious, and speaking was never easy, because I learned it much too late.

"accent".......I was in service with some Mass guys.......lol.....made my Southern accent not sound so strange......
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.

...the answer is, it depends. It really just depends on your public schools which sound very good. If they are strong, populated with a high percentage of upwardly mobile parents, the public school option should be sound.

...while we live in CA, our school district is in the top 1% in the State. The high school my son now attends is academically rated in the top 2% of the country. The high school has >90% of the teachers with advanced degrees. We live near several very good private schools that can cost between $14K-$42K per year but we figured why pay college tuition for high school when we have an excellent public high school.

...perhaps the biggest thing is parental involvement -be an active participant in her education, early on and everything will be fine.

Good luck!
 
Yeah. I meant struggling more in terms of struggling to get into a good college, if she didn't have private school reputation and connections helping her out. In my own case, I got into a good college despite having gone to an unremarkable public school, but that was entirely based on SATs. I had plenty of friends who had better grades and extra-curriculars who couldn't get into a very good college.

Again it goes back to a challenging curriculum all the way through. Compare what your public school uses to what the private school uses. You can probably see examples of each online if you find out what they use. The curriculum I used was noticeably more challenging than that of a public school.
 
Yep. At one point I'd gotten good enough at German to take classes in an elite German university without too much trouble, but my accent was always atrocious, and speaking was never easy, because I learned it much too late.

I learned Spanish from birth on. So my accent in Spanish is excellent. Oddly enough, I can adopt an English-speaker's accent for Spanish which is equally as "good" (my parents had that one). I can sort of get a Puerto Rican accent for Spanish, but I have some difficulty with it and I can't do Spanish or Mexico or South American Spanish accents at all. I have a pretty good accent in Italian because it's not too much of a slide from Spanish. But................French! OMG.............nobody wants to hear me speak French unless they want to laugh loud and long. My German accent is just about that bad too.

My son is making certain his son hears Tagalog and Spanish from birth so that he will have a good ear for languages. My son is multi-lingual because I exposed him to as many languages as possible before he even started school. I think that is important. I have known young children who spoke numerous languages at early ages........exposure is a fantastic teacher.
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.
There are far too many variables that you will have to weigh out that most of us could not give a well informed opinion on what to do. First and foremost what is the quality of the school and how do the students measure up compared to private and other schools that may be available . If you are in a decent school district you could probably be ok in the public system. If I had the means and considering the number of under achievers and transient students in the schools my kids have been zoned to I would go the private route. I don't have the means but do have the ability to keep my kids active in club sports and get extra tutoring when required and have so far had good results. The most important thing is to be sure your kids know you are going to be in their "business" from day one and be serious about it. At public schools band is good program to direct your kids into as it reduces their exposure to kids that just don't value education the same as you do, Good Luck on whatever you decide
 
There are far too many variables that you will have to weigh out that most of us could not give a well informed opinion on what to do. First and foremost what is the quality of the school and how do the students measure up compared to private and other schools that may be available . If you are in a decent school district you could probably be ok in the public system. If I had the means and considering the number of under achievers and transient students in the schools my kids have been zoned to I would go the private route. I don't have the means but do have the ability to keep my kids active in club sports and get extra tutoring when required and have so far had good results. The most important thing is to be sure your kids know you are going to be in their "business" from day one and be serious about it. At public schools band is good program to direct your kids into as it reduces their exposure to kids that just don't value education the same as you do, Good Luck on whatever you decide

I hope that all of the input helps Arkady make a good choice. His daughter will no doubt be fine because she has firm support from her home. Same for your kids and mine........... with both private and public schools (as well as home school) behind them. The family is crucial to a child's education.
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.

Sounds like you are in a decent public school district. They are definitely out here. From what you have posted, it appears to me it comes down to whether the potential networking opportunities at the private school are worth it to you.
 
I'm leaning towards public school for my daughter (who just turned three, so pre-K starts next year), but would be interested to hear advice.

Some background. The private school we're considering is a local one, which covers Pre-k up through middle school. There's also a local private high school that picks up from there. They're both elite schools that have a list of distinguished alumni, including foreign royalty, celebrities, professors, politicians, etc. They're pricey, but that isn't a big concern for us. The bigger concern is what will be best for our daughter. Our alternative is a good local public school. The public school system has over 98% graduation rate, strong SAT scores (1700 average), low student-teacher ratio (under 14, compared to a national average of 15.4) and no significant crime problem.

My wife went to private school for most of her life. I went to a Catholic elementary school for first and second grade, but otherwise was publicly schooled. We both turned out well -- she got into a top-10 university, while I got into a top-20 university, and we're both pretty well-adjusted and happy.

My wife favors private school for our daughter, while I favor public school. Although I know private school provides connections and cachet that make later academic admittance easier, and provides a shortcut up many career ladders, I worry about the social implications. I thank my own public school education for having given me much better exposure to a wide range of my fellow Americans than my wife got. Not only did I have friends who were poor or blue collar, I had friends who weren't terribly academically focused, whereas everyone my wife was friends with was from a wealthy, white-collar family focused on academics, and I think it gave her a bit of a skewed view. I think it also made her less appreciative of the nice things in life than if she'd had a more immediate understanding of the fact that most people can't take such things for granted. I count myself as rich, because I'm rich compared to nearly all the families of the kids I grew up with, whereas my wife counts herself as middle class, because at least half the kids she grew up with had serious money. I'd like my daughter's senses to be calibrated such that she doesn't have to be wealthy just to feel middle class.

My thought is that our local public school is good enough -- that it won't hold my daughter back from anything she might otherwise be able to achieve, so there isn't a pressing need to put her in a private school, the way there might be if our school district was dangerous or an academic wreck. But my wife's right about private school opening doors that you otherwise have to kick down the hard way, and I don't want to deny my daughter opportunities simply based on my own political beliefs. So, although I'm leaning towards public school, I'm torn.

If your public schools have those kinds of numbers, there would be little advanatge to a private school. Public schools are rated also and your district has weight. Another thing to consider is to see how she enjoys it and how you perceive her intellectual growth
Not all private schools carry the same weight...especially religious schools. There are great teachers in public schools ....when I speak at private schools, their biggest complaint is the best teachers leave because the pay is better in public schools.
 
I hope that all of the input helps Arkady make a good choice. His daughter will no doubt be fine because she has firm support from her home. Same for your kids and mine........... with both private and public schools (as well as home school) behind them. The family is crucial to a child's education.


Until middle school......then peers become the crucial element. I have seen the best parents struggle with their kids, and the worst parents have superstars. But I agree, good values are important and most parents believe their values are the right ones.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Until middle school......then peers become the crucial element. I have seen the best parents struggle with their kids, and the worst parents have superstars. But I agree, good values are important and most parents believe their values are the right ones.

Middle school is difficult no matter who the parents are. Girls fall of that cliff by the middle of 6th grade (sometimes during 5th) and boys aren't far beyond that. Parents need to have their values (whatever they are) in mind firmly before that time and then be ready to bend just a tiny bit when they have to. That said.............. I enjoyed three-plus years teaching that age group. I love their intensity at that age.

I had mentioned that about peers becoming crucial during that age in an earlier post. Suddenly parents know nothing and friends know everything.;)
 
...the answer is, it depends. It really just depends on your public schools which sound very good. If they are strong, populated with a high percentage of upwardly mobile parents, the public school option should be sound.

...while we live in CA, our school district is in the top 1% in the State. The high school my son now attends is academically rated in the top 2% of the country. The high school has >90% of the teachers with advanced degrees. We live near several very good private schools that can cost between $14K-$42K per year but we figured why pay college tuition for high school when we have an excellent public high school.

...perhaps the biggest thing is parental involvement -be an active participant in her education, early on and everything will be fine.

Good luck!

As the resident teacher....parent involvement is great....but overly involved parents are often a detriment. The biggest change I had seen in my loooooong career is parents. Parents blame teachers too often, and don't challenge their kids. I used to tell "helicopter parents"(hovering) "we are on the same team....we both love your child " ( most cases I did love the kids....but if I didn't I would say "we both care about your child" . I reiterate...I agree about being involved.
I once had a parent whose kid I failed and she said, "my cousin is a teacher and she said You were racist because you failed my daughter. " I said, " if you notice the entire class is minority students and I hardly failed any. Ask your cousin if not doing 75 home works is a factor".
 
Middle school is difficult no matter who the parents are. Girls fall of that cliff by the middle of 6th grade (sometimes during 5th) and boys aren't far beyond that. Parents need to have their values (whatever they are) in mind firmly before that time and then be ready to bend just a tiny bit when they have to. That said.............. I enjoyed three-plus years teaching that age group. I love their intensity at that age.

I had mentioned that about peers becoming crucial during that age in an earlier post. Suddenly parents know nothing and friends know everything.;)

That's why teaching sex Ed to middle schoolers was a trip. I also loved that age....in my book I call it the "age of agony." You're too fat , too skinny, you're not good enough in sports, you're too short, too tall...and zits! My kids wrote journals to me and some of them were so funny, but most were filled with angst. Girls are into their looks, and boys are tripping over their feet. ...and of course puberty! I had a blast teaching that subject ...humor was necessary! I was a therapist to so many. Kids would confide in me because it was in writing, not in person. I always wrote back and kept in mind that parents might be reading them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
As the resident teacher....parent involvement is great....but overly involved parents are often a detriment. The biggest change I had seen in my loooooong career is parents. Parents blame teachers too often, and don't challenge their kids. I used to tell "helicopter parents"(hovering) "we are on the same team....we both love your child " ( most cases I did love the kids....but if I didn't I would say "we both care about your child" . I reiterate...I agree about being involved.
I once had a parent whose kid I failed and she said, "my cousin is a teacher and she said You were racist because you failed my daughter. " I said, " if you notice the entire class is minority students and I hardly failed any. Ask your cousin if not doing 75 home works is a factor".

Ummm.........I was the resident teacher here before you were, but I'm thinking we can both be that unless your liberality (sic) won't allow for me to be a teacher anymore since you are here.:p

I agree about the helicopter (hovering) parents. It is definitely possible to hover too close and with my kids going to the school where I taught I had to be especially carefully of that. I had a lot of respect for their teachers and stayed out of the way.

By parent involvement, I was thinking more along the lines of providing a conducive atmosphere for learning at home and modeling behavior like parents themselves reading books and watching television programs (Discovery Channel, etc) as a family event. NOT meddling in the part that the teacher does, but supporting the teacher in words, tone and mood.
 
That's why teaching sex Ed to middle schoolers was a trip. I also loved that age....in my book I call it the "age of agony." You're too fat , too skinny, you're not good enough in sports, you're too short, too tall...and zits! My kids wrote journals to me and some of them were so funny, but most were filled with angst. Girls are into their looks, and boys are tripping over their feet. ...and of course puberty! I had a blast teaching that subject ...humor was necessary! I was a therapist to so many. Kids would confide in me because it was in writing, not in person. I always wrote back and kept in mind that parents might be reading them.

I spent my entire off period with a 6th grade girl who was in agony because she had called an RV a "motor home" and her friends were mocking her relentlessly for saying motor home when everyone knows it is an RV!! And the thing with girls having to go to the restroom in a group to commiserate with the one girl who is crying about something is just something that nobody but them understands. I taught 7th and 8th grade health. Not sex ed specifically, but health. I loved it.
 
Ummm.........I was the resident teacher here before you were, but I'm thinking we can both be that unless your liberality (sic) won't allow for me to be a teacher anymore since you are here.:p

I agree about the helicopter (hovering) parents. It is definitely possible to hover too close and with my kids going to the school where I taught I had to be especially carefully of that. I had a lot of respect for their teachers and stayed out of the way.

By parent involvement, I was thinking more along the lines of providing a conducive atmosphere for learning at home and modeling behavior like parents themselves reading books and watching television programs (Discovery Channel, etc) as a family event. NOT meddling in the part that the teacher does, but supporting the teacher in words, tone and mood.
Sorry... I thought you were a homeschooler.........how many years did you teach ? ,ay be you're right my "liberality" won't allow you to be the teacher here....rightwingers just don't count . ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
I spent my entire off period with a 6th grade girl who was in agony because she had called an RV a "motor home" and her friends were mocking her relentlessly for saying motor home when everyone knows it is an RV!! And the thing with girls having to go to the restroom in a group to commiserate with the one girl who is crying about something is just something that nobody but them understands. I taught 7th and 8th grade health. Not sex ed specifically, but health. I loved it.


Oh I understand....I recall how important my own girlfriends were and the support they gave me, sadly too many boys aren't "allowed" to cry. Something else I realized in sex Ed is that boys actually have more pressure to be sexual. Girls can say no, but boys are mocked if they say no, many lie. I can't tell you how many boys would write ." Please don't tell anyone but I am not having sex...and i swear I'm not gay" I would write back that he's in good company because most if the boys are telling me the same thing, it was an eye opener for me,
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
Sorry... I thought you were a homeschooler.........how many years did you teach ? ,ay be you're right my "liberality" won't allow you to be the teacher here....rightwingers just don't count . ;)

I taught 7 years inner city in San Antonio, Texas. I have bilingual certification along with certification in elementary education and music ed. My kids did Christmas television programs each year that I wrote and directed on San Antonio television (in Spanish). And we did several programs on the River with Latino (Trini Lopez et al) celebrities from time to time.

I started my master's in Bilingual Education but quit to start my family.... left Texas and have never moved back (my life took twists and turns after that).

I taught 2 years for DoD in Italy. That was great.

I headed a Community Outreach Educational program in Groton, Connecticut and had 3 teachers under me doing projects for inner city children that needed extra tutoring, etc after school.

I taught in private schools in Washington State [music k - 8; band; choir; English 6th grade and Health 7th and 8th grade] and in an Alaskan community [high school English, World History, Government, and Spanish].

I think that's about it. I didn't home school until the Alaskan school closed.
 
That's why teaching sex Ed to middle schoolers was a trip. I also loved that age....in my book I call it the "age of agony." You're too fat , too skinny, you're not good enough in sports, you're too short, too tall...and zits! My kids wrote journals to me and some of them were so funny, but most were filled with angst. Girls are into their looks, and boys are tripping over their feet. ...and of course puberty! I had a blast teaching that subject ...humor was necessary! I was a therapist to so many. Kids would confide in me because it was in writing, not in person. I always wrote back and kept in mind that parents might be reading them.

What is the name of your book, Renee? I would be interested in reading it. You've probably posted it and I missed it........... :oops:
 
What is the name of your book, Renee? I would be interested in reading it. You've probably posted it and I missed it........... :oops:

I did not post it....I can give it to you privately...but I am sure how
 
I did not post it....I can give it to you privately...but I am sure how

If you make a "conversation" it will come to just me. To start a conversation with someone click on the "inbox" button, top right of your screen between your name and Alerts and just follow the prompts( it's just like posting here except that it goes only to the people you name).

I just realized that your book would have your name and possibly information about you there..... it you prefer not to give that information I absolutely understand. I thought maybe you had posted it here and I missed it.
 
Back
Top