Arkady
President
One of the sensible knocks against the Obama era has been the unofficial policy of austerity, during a time when orthodox economic theory would call for expansion of government spending to offset the private-sector pull-back. Though you'd never know it if you've walled yourself up in the Fox News echo chamber, government spending has been declining at a rate unprecedented in the modern era, and government payrolls have shrunk considerably. As a public service, I'd like to educate the forum by providing the annualized rate of private sector and government payroll growth under each recent president.
Obama Private Sector +0.43% Government -0.81%
GW Bush Private Sector -0.07$ Government +1.01%
Clinton Private Sector +2.62% Government +1.22%
GHW Bush Private Sector +0.41% Government +1.55%
Reagan Private Sector +2.27% Government +1.04%
Carter Private Sector +3.28% Government +2.10%
So, on the private sector side, the Obama era has been mediocre --worse than Carter, Clinton, and Reagan, but better than either of the Bushes. The reason things seem so bleak is that government has been shrinking, which is something that didn't happen in any of those other eras (and probably last happened in the years of demobilization following WWII).
Plus, standard economic theory tells us that at a time like this (with low interest rates and high unemployment), more government hiring would actually result in more private sector hiring, too. That isn't always the case -- if interest rates were high, more government hiring could pull needed capital away from the private sector, hurting their ability to hire, and if unemployment rates were low more government hiring could dry up an already-under-supplied labor pool. But, right now, more government hiring would boost demand, stimulating private sector hiring. So, there's every reason to think that if the austerity mania hadn't struck, our jobs situation would be looking much better on the private side, as well.
Paul Krugman has a great description of our current crisis in his most recent book. He points out that this is a self-inflicted wound. On paper, there's no reason we should be poorer than we were. Locusts didn't come and eat up all our crops. We didn't somehow forget the technologies that were making us so productive before. Instead, we let ourselves get caught in an economic rut of low demand. And the tragedy is that, unlike the poor fools who suffered through the Great Depression when similar dynamics were at work, we know how to get out of this rut. We have developed both the academic knowledge and the real-world experience for boosting an economy out of a rut just like this one. But, instead, we remain mired here, as a matter of national choice, with millions suffering, while the "Very Serious People" obsess over long-term debt (and thereby actually make that debt worse as a share of GDP).
Here's an analogy of my own. Doctors are properly worried about the over-use of antibiotics. When they're prescribed in the wrong situations, and taken haphazardly, they create all sorts of problems, including developing super bugs and wiping out beneficial flora in a person's body and thereby making it more vulnerable to future infections. But, antibiotics are also a life saver -- next to sanitation, the biggest medical life saver of the modern age. Deficits are similar -- running deficits in a chronic way, during good economic times in particular, causes all sorts of problems, not least of which is growing debt that can become unmaintainable. But deficits are also the right medicine for certain ailments -- an economic life-saver. Our current situation is like one where someone is suffering from a serious and debilitating bacterial infection, with a soaring fever, and he's not taking antibiotics because of a preoccupation with the long-term negative impact of people abusing antibiotics in situations where they aren't really called for.
If a physician withheld antibiotics in a situation like that, he'd be endangering the life of his patient pointlessly and would be guilty of medical malpractice. Well, in the same way, the politicians who withhold the government-sector growth we so desperately need, right now, are guilty of malpractice, which is causing pointless suffering for a whole nation. Yes, by all means, we need to consider long-term strategies for preventing abuse of deficits. For example, we need to find a way to make sure that some future Bush-style politician doesn't piss away a record surplus, during an economic growth cycle, in order to finance an economically inert tax cut primarily for the wealthy. But that's a fight for another day. Our patient has an immediate problem that need immediate attention first.
Obama Private Sector +0.43% Government -0.81%
GW Bush Private Sector -0.07$ Government +1.01%
Clinton Private Sector +2.62% Government +1.22%
GHW Bush Private Sector +0.41% Government +1.55%
Reagan Private Sector +2.27% Government +1.04%
Carter Private Sector +3.28% Government +2.10%
So, on the private sector side, the Obama era has been mediocre --worse than Carter, Clinton, and Reagan, but better than either of the Bushes. The reason things seem so bleak is that government has been shrinking, which is something that didn't happen in any of those other eras (and probably last happened in the years of demobilization following WWII).
Plus, standard economic theory tells us that at a time like this (with low interest rates and high unemployment), more government hiring would actually result in more private sector hiring, too. That isn't always the case -- if interest rates were high, more government hiring could pull needed capital away from the private sector, hurting their ability to hire, and if unemployment rates were low more government hiring could dry up an already-under-supplied labor pool. But, right now, more government hiring would boost demand, stimulating private sector hiring. So, there's every reason to think that if the austerity mania hadn't struck, our jobs situation would be looking much better on the private side, as well.
Paul Krugman has a great description of our current crisis in his most recent book. He points out that this is a self-inflicted wound. On paper, there's no reason we should be poorer than we were. Locusts didn't come and eat up all our crops. We didn't somehow forget the technologies that were making us so productive before. Instead, we let ourselves get caught in an economic rut of low demand. And the tragedy is that, unlike the poor fools who suffered through the Great Depression when similar dynamics were at work, we know how to get out of this rut. We have developed both the academic knowledge and the real-world experience for boosting an economy out of a rut just like this one. But, instead, we remain mired here, as a matter of national choice, with millions suffering, while the "Very Serious People" obsess over long-term debt (and thereby actually make that debt worse as a share of GDP).
Here's an analogy of my own. Doctors are properly worried about the over-use of antibiotics. When they're prescribed in the wrong situations, and taken haphazardly, they create all sorts of problems, including developing super bugs and wiping out beneficial flora in a person's body and thereby making it more vulnerable to future infections. But, antibiotics are also a life saver -- next to sanitation, the biggest medical life saver of the modern age. Deficits are similar -- running deficits in a chronic way, during good economic times in particular, causes all sorts of problems, not least of which is growing debt that can become unmaintainable. But deficits are also the right medicine for certain ailments -- an economic life-saver. Our current situation is like one where someone is suffering from a serious and debilitating bacterial infection, with a soaring fever, and he's not taking antibiotics because of a preoccupation with the long-term negative impact of people abusing antibiotics in situations where they aren't really called for.
If a physician withheld antibiotics in a situation like that, he'd be endangering the life of his patient pointlessly and would be guilty of medical malpractice. Well, in the same way, the politicians who withhold the government-sector growth we so desperately need, right now, are guilty of malpractice, which is causing pointless suffering for a whole nation. Yes, by all means, we need to consider long-term strategies for preventing abuse of deficits. For example, we need to find a way to make sure that some future Bush-style politician doesn't piss away a record surplus, during an economic growth cycle, in order to finance an economically inert tax cut primarily for the wealthy. But that's a fight for another day. Our patient has an immediate problem that need immediate attention first.