New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Public versus Private Job Creation

Arkady

President
One of the sensible knocks against the Obama era has been the unofficial policy of austerity, during a time when orthodox economic theory would call for expansion of government spending to offset the private-sector pull-back. Though you'd never know it if you've walled yourself up in the Fox News echo chamber, government spending has been declining at a rate unprecedented in the modern era, and government payrolls have shrunk considerably. As a public service, I'd like to educate the forum by providing the annualized rate of private sector and government payroll growth under each recent president.

Obama Private Sector +0.43% Government -0.81%
GW Bush Private Sector -0.07$ Government +1.01%
Clinton Private Sector +2.62% Government +1.22%
GHW Bush Private Sector +0.41% Government +1.55%
Reagan Private Sector +2.27% Government +1.04%
Carter Private Sector +3.28% Government +2.10%

So, on the private sector side, the Obama era has been mediocre --worse than Carter, Clinton, and Reagan, but better than either of the Bushes. The reason things seem so bleak is that government has been shrinking, which is something that didn't happen in any of those other eras (and probably last happened in the years of demobilization following WWII).

Plus, standard economic theory tells us that at a time like this (with low interest rates and high unemployment), more government hiring would actually result in more private sector hiring, too. That isn't always the case -- if interest rates were high, more government hiring could pull needed capital away from the private sector, hurting their ability to hire, and if unemployment rates were low more government hiring could dry up an already-under-supplied labor pool. But, right now, more government hiring would boost demand, stimulating private sector hiring. So, there's every reason to think that if the austerity mania hadn't struck, our jobs situation would be looking much better on the private side, as well.

Paul Krugman has a great description of our current crisis in his most recent book. He points out that this is a self-inflicted wound. On paper, there's no reason we should be poorer than we were. Locusts didn't come and eat up all our crops. We didn't somehow forget the technologies that were making us so productive before. Instead, we let ourselves get caught in an economic rut of low demand. And the tragedy is that, unlike the poor fools who suffered through the Great Depression when similar dynamics were at work, we know how to get out of this rut. We have developed both the academic knowledge and the real-world experience for boosting an economy out of a rut just like this one. But, instead, we remain mired here, as a matter of national choice, with millions suffering, while the "Very Serious People" obsess over long-term debt (and thereby actually make that debt worse as a share of GDP).

Here's an analogy of my own. Doctors are properly worried about the over-use of antibiotics. When they're prescribed in the wrong situations, and taken haphazardly, they create all sorts of problems, including developing super bugs and wiping out beneficial flora in a person's body and thereby making it more vulnerable to future infections. But, antibiotics are also a life saver -- next to sanitation, the biggest medical life saver of the modern age. Deficits are similar -- running deficits in a chronic way, during good economic times in particular, causes all sorts of problems, not least of which is growing debt that can become unmaintainable. But deficits are also the right medicine for certain ailments -- an economic life-saver. Our current situation is like one where someone is suffering from a serious and debilitating bacterial infection, with a soaring fever, and he's not taking antibiotics because of a preoccupation with the long-term negative impact of people abusing antibiotics in situations where they aren't really called for.

If a physician withheld antibiotics in a situation like that, he'd be endangering the life of his patient pointlessly and would be guilty of medical malpractice. Well, in the same way, the politicians who withhold the government-sector growth we so desperately need, right now, are guilty of malpractice, which is causing pointless suffering for a whole nation. Yes, by all means, we need to consider long-term strategies for preventing abuse of deficits. For example, we need to find a way to make sure that some future Bush-style politician doesn't piss away a record surplus, during an economic growth cycle, in order to finance an economically inert tax cut primarily for the wealthy. But that's a fight for another day. Our patient has an immediate problem that need immediate attention first.
 
yep, we need to cut spending is what a republican will get out of this, and it's Obama's fault of course.
 
Arkady, sadly, we've been through this a million times.

Facts and figures hold no meaning for the guys locked in the Rightwing Media Echo Chamber. Rush or Hannity or O'Reilly or some "economic expert" like Stuart Varney tell them "Obama is only creating Gub'mint jobs....no private sector jobs are being created"......they believe it.

Despite all the evidence you can present to them.

Look at the recent "scandals"....they blow up in their faces. Are SHOWN to be false....even some of their own guys in RW Media ADMIT they are false.....and the True Believers shake their heads and say "No, no,no....it's all lies. Fox ALWAYS tells the truth to me. I know it. I KNOW IT!!!!!"

Re-read your Orwell...Winston Smith in the last chapter after the Room 101 treatment...

"He gazed up at the enormous face. Forty years it had taken him to learn what kind of smile was hidden beneath the dark moustache. O cruel, needless misunderstanding! O stubborn, self-willed exile from the loving breast! Two gin-scented tears trickled down the sides of his nose. But it was all right, everything was all right, the struggle was finished. He had won the victory over himself. He loved Big Brother."

(Now watch the inevitable responses....from the Usual Suspects...as predictable as a sunrise.)
 
Arkady, sadly, we've been through this a million times.

Facts and figures hold no meaning for the guys locked in the Rightwing Media Echo Chamber. Rush or Hannity or O'Reilly or some "economic expert" like Stuart Varney tell them "Obama is only creating Gub'mint jobs....no private sector jobs are being created"......they believe it.

Despite all the evidence you can present to them.

Look at the recent "scandals"....they blow up in their faces. Are SHOWN to be false....even some of their own guys in RW Media ADMIT they are false.....and the True Believers shake their heads and say "No, no,no....it's all lies. Fox ALWAYS tells the truth to me. I know it. I KNOW IT!!!!!"

Re-read your Orwell...Winston Smith in the last chapter after the Room 101 treatment...

"He gazed up at the enormous face. Forty years it had taken him to learn what kind of smile was hidden beneath the dark moustache. O cruel, needless misunderstanding! O stubborn, self-willed exile from the loving breast! Two gin-scented tears trickled down the sides of his nose. But it was all right, everything was all right, the struggle was finished. He had won the victory over himself. He loved Big Brother."

(Now watch the inevitable responses....from the Usual Suspects...as predictable as a sunrise.)



So Chubs, I won't try to challenge your expertise on the right wing media. Since you said you watch 9+ hours of Fox/Rush/Hannity, et al daily, I can't even try to match your knowledge. But, do you still believe Harry Reid's assertion that Mitt Romney didn't pay any income tax for 10 years?
 
"(Now watch the inevitable responses....from the Usual Suspects...as predictable as a sunrise.)"


Told ya. marv will make a resposne about ME...not the topic. Drumm will blame Democrats. Dino will defend Fox News and RW Media. worldly will predict the Apocalypse. The "pure conservatives" will blame "both sides...but mostly Obama." And Barbella will find some way to blame blacks and Hispanics and then complain "libs are making it about race!!!"

And NONE of them will be able to refute the numbers you cited, Arkady.
 
So Chubs, I won't try to challenge your expertise on the right wing media. Since you said you watch 9+ hours of Fox/Rush/Hannity, et al daily, I can't even try to match your knowledge. But, do you still believe Harry Reid's assertion that Mitt Romney didn't pay any income tax for 10 years?

Well. We don't KNOW. Do we? Or has Mitt shown you his tax returns for those years? Why would he show them to a schlemiel like you?
 
Well. We don't KNOW. Do we? Or has Mitt shown you his tax returns for those years? Why would he show them to a schlemiel like you?

What's funny....but typical and hypocritical, for marv? Just a few hours ago, marv was complaining about people "still bringing up the election and not talking about today"......so, naturally, he "forgets" his outrage at that and brings up Romney's tax forms.

Just as it's typical with him....that I'm living rent-free between his ears.

:)
 
Which job actually produces wealth? Afterall, dept of energy has a $40B budget, yet does not produce 1 barrel oil or 1 kilowatt electricity
 
Which job actually produces wealth? Afterall, dept of energy has a $40B budget, yet does not produce 1 barrel oil or 1 kilowatt electricity

While its true govt spending is down, it is only because states don't have a central bank that can kite their bonds like Washingstan
 
"(Now watch the inevitable responses....from the Usual Suspects...as predictable as a sunrise.)"


Told ya. marv will make a resposne about ME...not the topic. Drumm will blame Democrats. Dino will defend Fox News and RW Media. worldly will predict the Apocalypse. The "pure conservatives" will blame "both sides...but mostly Obama." And Barbella will find some way to blame blacks and Hispanics and then complain "libs are making it about race!!!"

And NONE of them will be able to refute the numbers you cited, Arkady.

Chubs, your response had nothing to do with Arkady's numbers, either. I was responding to your post, not his. Try to keep up, ok?
 
The OP presents a false choice between public sector and private sector jobs. The government can tax you, spend the money on a tank and give the order to GM. Or they can borrow the money and do likewise. The key point to remember though is that money allocates meaning that money spent by the government should, at least in theory, be capable of directing our nation’s labor and capital into desired projects. For instance, if the government spends a certain sum of money on a GM car and that same amount of money is also spent on a GM car by a private business, we intuitively understand that GM doesn’t really care who is buying the car. This is where the concept of the opportunity cost of the stimulus funds becomes pertinent. The important point to remember is that the government wasn’t actually creating anything; the government expenditure, by its nature, represents transferred demand. Every dollar the government spends is a dollar somebody else didn’t spend. It’s very simple to see how that’s the case because either that dollar spent by the government was taxed and taken by the government, or the government borrowed it by selling a bond. There’s no free lunch. At the end of the day, public expenditures are what they are, they cannot be anything else, they move resources from the private sector to the public sector and are then allocated by the public sector. The result is that the private sector doesn’t get to allocate those funds, doesn’t employ people with those funds, and doesn’t invest those funds. The public sector does and time and again we find out that the public sector isn’t very good at this.
 
and time and time again we find that the private sector isn't very good at allocating investment to areas the citizens of the country deem necessary
 
The OP presents a false choice between public sector and private sector jobs. The government can tax you, spend the money on a tank and give the order to GM. Or they can borrow the money and do likewise. The key point to remember though is that money allocates meaning that money spent by the government should, at least in theory, be capable of directing our nation’s labor and capital into desired projects. For instance, if the government spends a certain sum of money on a GM car and that same amount of money is also spent on a GM car by a private business, we intuitively understand that GM doesn’t really care who is buying the car. This is where the concept of the opportunity cost of the stimulus funds becomes pertinent. The important point to remember is that the government wasn’t actually creating anything; the government expenditure, by its nature, represents transferred demand. Every dollar the government spends is a dollar somebody else didn’t spend. It’s very simple to see how that’s the case because either that dollar spent by the government was taxed and taken by the government, or the government borrowed it by selling a bond. There’s no free lunch. At the end of the day, public expenditures are what they are, they cannot be anything else, they move resources from the private sector to the public sector and are then allocated by the public sector. The result is that the private sector doesn’t get to allocate those funds, doesn’t employ people with those funds, and doesn’t invest those funds. The public sector does and time and again we find out that the public sector isn’t very good at this.

The general phenomenon you are talking about here is called 'the crowding out of private investment by public borrowing'. And in ordinary times, this would be a valid argument. But these are not ordinary times. For the better part of the past four years (and some months), we have been caught in a classic Keynesian liquidity trap, with interest rates very close to zero, but with monetary policy rendered largely ineffective. Enormous amounts of money are simply sitting in the banks, as excess reserves, with very little loan demand. Meanwhile, corporate profits are at all-time record high levels, so corporations have plenty of retained earnings, with no need to borrow, if they truly see a good investment opportunity. The upshot is that right now, there is no crowding out of private investment going on. Historically, the only way to escape from a Keynesian liquidity trap is to have a massive government expenditure program---and hopefully on some project(s) that have intrinsic value, and will pay a nice return to society over time.

Well-designed government spending programs can also lead to a 'crowding in' phenomenon, leading to a burst of complementary private investment spending. The classic example of this was Eisenhower's Interstate Highway program. Think of all the restaurants, gas stations, and motels, that sprung up---as if by magic---at all the Interstate exits and entrances. Wouldn't have happened without the government program that made those investments worthwhile.

Or are you saying we should have never built the Interstate Highway system?
 
The OP presents a false choice between public sector and private sector jobs. The government can tax you, spend the money on a tank and give the order to GM. Or they can borrow the money and do likewise. The key point to remember though is that money allocates meaning that money spent by the government should, at least in theory, be capable of directing our nation’s labor and capital into desired projects. For instance, if the government spends a certain sum of money on a GM car and that same amount of money is also spent on a GM car by a private business, we intuitively understand that GM doesn’t really care who is buying the car. This is where the concept of the opportunity cost of the stimulus funds becomes pertinent. The important point to remember is that the government wasn’t actually creating anything; the government expenditure, by its nature, represents transferred demand. Every dollar the government spends is a dollar somebody else didn’t spend. It’s very simple to see how that’s the case because either that dollar spent by the government was taxed and taken by the government, or the government borrowed it by selling a bond. There’s no free lunch. At the end of the day, public expenditures are what they are, they cannot be anything else, they move resources from the private sector to the public sector and are then allocated by the public sector. The result is that the private sector doesn’t get to allocate those funds, doesn’t employ people with those funds, and doesn’t invest those funds. The public sector does and time and again we find out that the public sector isn’t very good at this.

It's true that government spending should be able to create jobs whether through direct government payroll increase or through projects that result in private sector hiring. But, as a practical matter, the two aren't the same. When the government does the hiring, you tend to get a lot of jobs per dollar, because even the highest-paid senior managers in the government are dirt-cheap by private sector standards. When you funnel money through the private sector, you need to pay off the eight-figure CEOs, the seven-figure senior VPs, and a bunch of six-figure managers, along with shareholder from all over the world who demand a cut of profit from any work the business takes on. That's a big part of why ARRA produced a lot fewer jobs per inflation-adjusted dollar than New Deal era programs that involved more direct government hiring.

As for your contention that every dollar the government spends is a dollar somebody else didn't spend, the concept of government spending crowding out private spending is a very serious one in other settings. If we had high interest rates, indicating a voracious private sector hunger for capital, then government spending would tend to be displacing private-sector spending. But, right now, that's simply not the case. The private sector is so reluctant to spend that the government can borrow at effectively zero interest rates. If the government isn't spending that money, a lot of it will be sitting around doing nothing productive.
 
and time and time again we find that the private sector isn't very good at allocating investment to areas the citizens of the country deem necessary

The only reasonable inference I can draw from this statement is that you would support nationalization to permit the government to make all investment decisions.

@leroy, it does displace private spending, the savings rates are very low. The fact of the matter is that the government has raised the money, the opportunity cost will be paid. The reverse is true too. If we have a bridge and toll the drivers a dollar to maintain the bridge, the drivers won't have that dollar to spend on coffee. Likewise if we don't have the toll, we'll have drivers with coffee but no road maintenance for the bridge. These are fundamentally different allocations. So be it, but much of the bonds are bought by foreigners who, no longer armed with dollars after buying our bonds, can't physically buy the exports. The governments financing of its activities isn't just displacing activity, it actually physically prevents, precludes it from happening.

The recent recession saw unemployment reach slightly over 10%. Full employment sees unemployment at 4%, that 6% difference is a shortcut to the 'output gap' as it were. 9-10 million people unemployed. For sure, we would naturally prefer a state of employment, for all of them, but to get back to full employment we'd want those 9-10 million working again.

And there's your rub because you could've handed them $50K apiece and that would've amounted to $500 billion, instead we were running deficits of 10% of GDP. And this is why the results of the stimulus and subsequent trillion dollar plus deficit spending were less than spectacular. The figure most often bantered about when discussing the stimulus is that the stimulus created 3 million jobs, specifically the Congressional Budget Office cites a figure of 3.3 million when calculating the effect on employment the stimulus had. Of course this begets the question- Dollar for dollar, is spending nearly $800 billion and employing 3.3 million additional people a ‘good’ result? The inherent problem is that most people have no real measure or concept of what $800 billion dollars actually represents or what it should buy, or how many people it should keep working.

In the grand scheme of things, we actually have an excellent point of comparison which will demonstrate the government’s futility in enacting the stimulus program. That comparison is the State of Florida. As it turns out the gross state product of the State of Florida is approximately $754 billion. This represents the cumulative expenditures of the people of the State of Florida and we can also see what this expenditure sustains in employment. As it turns out, even in a situation where unemployment is aggravated due to the recession, the State of Florida’s active employed labor force is 8.4 million.

So the natural question that follows this analysis is why did the stimulus, a $787 billion expenditure only create 3.3 million jobs whereas a smaller expenditure in Florida sustains employment of 5.4 million additional jobs.

As for the point that spending directly on employment is more efficient at creating employment, this remains a tangent. The government should simply be focusing on things that are, at its core, a government function. The government maintains police, but they're not going to run an auto factory to make police cars. They're going to run a paper mill to make the tons of paper they go through. They outsource on a rational basis, just like any private company would do.
 
Now watch the inevitable responses....from the Usual Suspects...as predictable as a sunrise.)


yep we heard yours...now go balance a budget then get back to us....but there in lies the problem....your fat ass cant stop stuffing donuts in your mouth long enough to do anything and your President....too busy playing golf.

Btw next time you want to play the usual suspect card for the 490th time... but there again forced by byour party to only spout Demkkrat rhetoric you have no choice in what you say.
 
Chubs, your response had nothing to do with Arkady's numbers, either. I was responding to your post, not his. Try to keep up, ok?

Gecko has to say that crap...what was he going to say? Democrats balanced a budget....stopped racism, created jobs, developed foreign policy that benefitted Americans, reduced the debt, ...lol his ass has nothing but hate rants because his party cant do jacksh!t...Go ahead gecko tell how going from 10 trillion to 16 trillion is reducing the debt...go ahead genius...come one...you are so smart tell us...come on we are waiting...and still waiting.
 
Back
Top