New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question about the rules

To distinguish between races is not automatically negative - racialism is not necessarily negative. Racism isn't a proper word but a diminutive of racialism used as a slur. Sure it is in the dictionary now but it came out of racialism = to distinguish between races.
Pretty much every word in the dictionary comes from some earlier word. That doesn't mean they're not proper words. For example, you used "distinguish," which didn't exist in English until the 16th century, when it was derived from earlier words.

Anyway, am I right to understand that the distinction you see is that "racialism" focuses in a value-neutral way on differences between the races, while "racism" focuses on alleged racial inferiority?
 
Pretty much every word in the dictionary comes from some earlier word. That doesn't mean they're not proper words. For example, you used "distinguish," which didn't exist in English until the 16th century, when it was derived from earlier words.

Anyway, am I right to understand that the distinction you see is that "racialism" focuses in a value-neutral way on differences between the races, while "racism" focuses on alleged racial inferiority?

Yes, we know ---- I gave you the place from which racism came - that place being not necessarily a negative one.

We are all racist/racialist by simply distinguishing by colour for eg - if you say he is black and he white you are making a racialist statement - if you say he is black and therefore inferior to he who is white - that is a separate idea. If you say he is black and he white, they are equal but different, that again is a separate idea - BUT with this crudifying of the word we are unable to explore/philosophize over or even vive la difference.

And yes it does matter because we are where we are now - in a state of division through race.
 
As you know, there was no substantial movement in the polls following her "deplorables" comment, and within a month her polls were significantly higher than they'd been before the comment. So, there doesn't appear to be any evidence the comment hurt her in any meaningful way. By comparison, look at the hit she took with Comey's October Surprise Letter -- a sudden dip in her polling numbers, from which she never really recovered. If we saw a pattern like that following the deplorables comment, one could make a good case that it killed her elections chances. But that's an alternate-reality analysis.

Negative

https://stream.org/deplorable-election-over-instant-hillary-said-this-word/

What good are Polls........remember poll of double digit leads.................

(why so much red in your post)
 
Yes, we know ---- I gave you the place from which racism came - that place being not necessarily a negative one.

We are all racist/racialist by simply distinguishing by colour for eg - if you say he is black and he white you are making a racialist statement - if you say he is black and therefore inferior to he who is white - that is a separate idea. If you say he is black and he white, they are equal but different, that again is a separate idea - BUT with this crudifying of the word we are unable to explore/philosophize over or even vive la difference.

And yes it does matter because we are where we are now - in a state of division through race.
I have no problem with pointing out racial tendencies where there's good reason for believing in them. For example, blacks are more likely to have sickle cell anemia than most people, and whites are more likely to have blue eyes than most people. I suppose I could call those "racialist" observations, as opposed to racist ones. I believe in speaking accurately and openly about such things. But, the problems come when racial thinking runs into tribalist instincts, such that people are drawn to smearing members of other races, and implementing or supporting systems that keep members of other races down.
 
I have no problem with pointing out racial tendencies where there's good reason for believing in them. For example, blacks are more likely to have sickle cell anemia than most people, and whites are more likely to have blue eyes than most people. I suppose I could call those "racialist" observations, as opposed to racist ones. I believe in speaking accurately and openly about such things. But, the problems come when racial thinking runs into tribalist instincts, such that people are drawn to smearing members of other races, and implementing or supporting systems that keep members of other races down.

But .............. if a persons says anything against the 'child gang rapists from Pakistan' 'the acid attacks brought from Bangladesh' ' the growing aggression from some Muslim groups, toward Britain' and such like, they are a racist - if someone says all mass immigration to this country is a good thing, we should be grateful for them and or all Muslims are peace loving people then they are applauded. The questions are actually ones of culture, not of colour, but still criticisms and concerns are shouted down, silenced and labelled racist. If anyone says 'we have a problem' what can we do about it' they are racists.

I am more and more of the mind that Britain will be Islamic within the next couple of generations ---- and if that is inevitable, which I suspect it is --- the conversations should rather be over which form of Islam is to be embraced and which not --- rather than at the mere mention of Mohammed shouts of racist ring in the air.

That is the same problem in every question where racist is the insult. Who fu'cking cares if a person discerns that they don't like Poles because they are dour - don't like Nigerians because they are too black -ect and so on, who fu'cking cares? We should all be allowed to discern as our own experience or instinct or intuition informs us - otherwise there can be no honest dialogue and thus we shall endure a never ending division via suppression.
 
But .............. if a persons says anything against the 'child gang rapists from Pakistan' 'the acid attacks brought from Bangladesh' ' the growing aggression from some Muslim groups, toward Britain' and such like, they are a racist - if someone says all mass immigration to this country is a good thing, we should be grateful for them and or all Muslims are peace loving people then they are applauded. The questions are actually ones of culture, not of colour, but still criticisms and concerns are shouted down, silenced and labelled racist. If anyone says 'we have a problem' what can we do about it' they are racists.

I am more and more of the mind that Britain will be Islamic within the next couple of generations ---- and if that is inevitable, which I suspect it is --- the conversations should rather be over which form of Islam is to be embraced and which not --- rather than at the mere mention of Mohammed shouts of racist ring in the air.

That is the same problem in every question where racist is the insult. Who fu'cking cares if a person discerns that they don't like Poles because they are dour - don't like Nigerians because they are too black -ect and so on, who fu'cking cares? We should all be allowed to discern as our own experience or instinct or intuition informs us - otherwise there can be no honest dialogue and thus we shall endure a never ending division via suppression.
The thing that people do that identifies themselves as rapists is when they obsess over crimes when committed by people of whatever races they have a problem with, while blithely ignoring similar crimes by other races. Thus, for example, if you're a social campaigner who makes a mission out of stamping out child prostitution, you're not likely to be called a racist. But if the only kind of child prostitution you get worked up about is when it's done by Muslims, people are going to be suspicious about why.

Similarly, if you're the kinds of person who has a problem with anyone who is too dour, you're unlikely to be accused of racism. If, on the other hand, you have a problem with Poles because of your perception that too many of them are dour, that's going to be seen as bigotry.
 
JackDallas said: ↑
To a Liberal, everything sounds like bigotry. You have to resort to that because most of you are so simple minded, you are incapable of making an intelligible argument.


My guess is because you are too simple-minded to understand basic English. It's clear that meant you and your ilk. Only the extremely simple-minded would not understand what I meant.
JackDallas, I am so sorry to hear that you are extremely simple minded. But, there may be hope for you. 1) Pay more attention to the wise Democrats on the PJ board. 2) Try to absorb some of their intelligence. 3)Distance yourself from the know nothing PJ cons here.
I hope this advice helps.
 
The thing that people do that identifies themselves as rapists is when they obsess over crimes when committed by people of whatever races they have a problem with, while blithely ignoring similar crimes by other races. Thus, for example, if you're a social campaigner who makes a mission out of stamping out child prostitution, you're not likely to be called a racist. But if the only kind of child prostitution you get worked up about is when it's done by Muslims, people are going to be suspicious about why.

Similarly, if you're the kinds of person who has a problem with anyone who is too dour, you're unlikely to be accused of racism. If, on the other hand, you have a problem with Poles because of your perception that too many of them are dour, that's going to be seen as bigotry.

Bigotry being the operative word – which, for the sake of clarity, should perhaps replace racism. Why is a person not racist if they hate Poles? You are judging another African of lighter coloured skin in a continent you do not know or understand.



The Pakistani child gang rapes are specific - speaking of them does not ignore nor diminish any other rape. Edward Heath, the PM who took us into Europe, was ( police admit it now) a known sadistic molester of little boys - an MP ( deceased) spent years and years collecting evidence against other MPs - he gave the list to May, who lost it ------- she even advocated for paedophiles, but that is another story -Part of an earlier list was seen by the public, in 1984 , we know who many of them are., still and over 20 years later.



Should we forget the Pakistani gangs because of the Parliamentary one? No - If there is a paedophile found to have abused 60 children, should we forget Parliament's open secrets? No - but the Parliamentary paedos and the Pakistani rape gangs both enjoy police protection - and what of their victims? What of their future victims? A lone predator is a lone criminal – organized gangs of predators are criminal gangs. No?
 
Bigotry being the operative word – which, for the sake of clarity, should perhaps replace racism. Why is a person not racist if they hate Poles?

He may be, but in general discussion in the contemporary world, people don’t generally regard poles as a race.

Pakistani rape gangs both enjoy police protection

What makes you think that? -
 
He may be, but in general discussion in the contemporary world, people don’t generally regard poles as a race.



What makes you think that? -

So hating Germans is not racist - hating a Scot the French or Poles too not but hating a Nigerian, Pakistani, West Indian is?

Research it yourself - in the trials of those few who were eventually prosecuted, because of the courage of two women - who both lost their jobs over it - we saw that they were just the tip of the iceberg. Many horrific attacks and abuses have never been prosecuted, even though the forensic evidence was collected and there were witnesses.

The authorities do not know what to do about it, fear reactions, so they keep a lid on it --- and or they protect the top rung - also out of fear.

Authority has lost its nerve. May is dismantling the Police now anyway -
 
I'm sure I'm not. But the question is whether the rule against name-calling is narrowly about the term "racist" or whether similar insults are also off limits. For example, when discussing your Jew-baiting attacks on Jon Stewart, would it be OK for me to call you an anti-Semite? Would it be OK to call Barbella a "black-hater," and Dawg a "Hispanic hater," so long as I avoid the word "racist"? Or is it a more widespread rule requiring that we not highlight those personal defects in any terms, and instead just stick to discussing the issues at hand?

Anything from calling someone a kook to a blockhead to a nazi is now suppressed speech.

The 'wild bunch' is officially incarcerated - free speech straight jacketed -

woman-with-red-tape-strtched-across-her-mouth-HN5MMH.jpg
 
The thing that people do that identifies themselves as rapists is when they obsess over crimes when committed by people of whatever races they have a problem with, while blithely ignoring similar crimes by other races. Thus, for example, if you're a social campaigner who makes a mission out of stamping out child prostitution, you're not likely to be called a racist. But if the only kind of child prostitution you get worked up about is when it's done by Muslims, people are going to be suspicious about why.

Similarly, if you're the kinds of person who has a problem with anyone who is too dour, you're unlikely to be accused of racism. If, on the other hand, you have a problem with Poles because of your perception that too many of them are dour, that's going to be seen as bigotry.

Like what Oprah did at her awards speech?
 
Anything from calling someone a kook to a blockhead to a nazi is now suppressed speech.

The 'wild bunch' is officially incarcerated - free speech straight jacketed -

Posters here at PJ don't get banned for using the word blockhead. They get temp banned for calling another poster a blockhead. Do you see the difference?

When you resort to name calling you are posting about the other poster and not the topic. And when we name call (and yes I have done it and been banned for it) we are resorting to name calling because we have lost the debate on the topic.
 
Posters here at PJ don't get banned for using the word blockhead. They get temp banned for calling another poster a blockhead. Do you see the difference?

When you resort to name calling you are posting about the other poster and not the topic. And when we name call (and yes I have done it and been banned for it) we are resorting to name calling because we have lost the debate on the topic.

SW, said poster has called me every nasty name that he could come up with over the years , on a regular basis - so what? Did I ever report him or any other for their personal attacks on me? It is all in the game and insults have been a part of the political game since the day of the birth of politics.

I call it as I see it, if I see an elephant in front of me I call it an elephant - If I see a blockhead in front of me I call it a blockhead. But yesterday I was just testing the waters - after hearing of a banning over the word kook --- I mean really!

Really I do think that this is now going to to far - I didn't care about yesterday - I should be studying anyway and perhaps from now on when I find myself here too long instead of studying I'll call everyone a blockhead 100 times over.

So what if we insult each other? So what? This is the home of the 'wild bunch' and you want to put them in chains.

It ain't right I say - it just ain't right. I protest.

I am composing a poem to blockheads btw I may share it with one oneday -
 
SW, said poster has called me every nasty name that he could come up with over the years , on a regular basis - so what? Did I ever report him or any other for their personal attacks on me? It is all in the game and insults have been a part of the political game since the day of the birth of politics.

I call it as I see it, if I see an elephant in front of me I call it an elephant - If I see a blockhead in front of me I call it a blockhead. But yesterday I was just testing the waters - after hearing of a banning over the word kook --- I mean really!

Really I do think that this is now going to to far - I didn't care about yesterday - I should be studying anyway and perhaps from now on when I find myself here too long instead of studying I'll call everyone a blockhead 100 times over.

So what if we insult each other? So what? This is the home of the 'wild bunch' and you want to put them in chains.

It ain't right I say - it just ain't right. I protest.

I am composing a poem to blockheads btw I may share it with one oneday -

I guess if you all get together and all agree that you can name call all you want then I guess thats what you want and we won't have that rule anymore. But it doesn't seem that your PJ friends agree with you. I don't think any of them like being called names and the number of reports seem to be higher than ever from both sides.

I feel the name calling is out of control and takes away from the debates and has no place on a message board especially if we ever want to get a new poster.

Name calling is childish.

I hope everyone realizes moderators don't have time to read anything but the reported posts.
 
I guess if you all get together and all agree that you can name call all you want then I guess thats what you want and we won't have that rule anymore. But it doesn't seem that your PJ friends agree with you. I don't think any of them like being called names and the number of reports seem to be higher than ever from both sides.

I feel the name calling is out of control and takes away from the debates and has no place on a message board especially if we ever want to get a new poster.

Name calling is childish.

I hope everyone realizes moderators don't have time to read anything but the reported posts.

It has become a tit for tat game - of course Mods only read the reported ---- we do not all report though ---- but surely, since you see what is reported, there must be an 'Oh fs grow up' in there somewhere. Mods are not robots either, here only to the bidding of the few.

Insults are just a part of the game - through them and in between them there is discussion -- sometime out of them discussion comes eg - racism.
 
So hating Germans is not racist - hating a Scot the French or Poles too not but hating a Nigerian, Pakistani, West Indian is?

No. It depends on one's conception of "race." If you consider Germans to be a race and you hate people for belonging to that race, then that would be racist. Similarly, if you consider Nigerians to be a race and hate people for belonging to it, then that would be racist. If, on the other hand, you consider Germans to be an ethnicity within the white race, and you hate Germans for their ethnicity but like others you consider to be members of the same race, then that's bigoted, but not racist. Similarly, if you consider Nigerians to be an ethnicity within the black race, and you hate Nigerians for their ethnicity but like others you consider to be members of the same race, then that's bigoted but not racist.

I think most people in the Western World tend to think of race in terms of those bigger blocks, like "white," "black," "Arab," etc., and that group-based hatreds tend to clump together on those bases (for example, the typical person here who has a dislike of black people doesn't care if their ancestors came from West Africa, like most African Americans, or East Africa, like Obama.) Their prejudice against Obama wasn't based on a preconception about people with Kenyan ancestry, specifically, but rather based on a preconception about people with African ancestry, generally.

Research it yourself

I did, the last time we discussed it. As you know, they were prosecuted with the assistance of the police, which is the opposite of police protection.
 
Back
Top