New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

The market rations healthcare as well. I think that you like the kind of rationing that the market delivers and you could care less if millions of people have no access to any kind of healthcare.

If you knew economics, you would know that the purpose of the market is to ALLOCATE SCARCE RESOURCES. That is rationing.

Want to know why? Because IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO PAY FOR WITHOUT RATIONING.

Because it gives the government CONTROL OVER WHAT KIND, HOW MUCH AND WHO GETS WHAT TREATMENTS and because it GIVES GOVERNMENT CONTROL OVER EVERYTHING THAT IMPACTS YOUR HEALTH. We don't do that in countries that respect individual liberty.

And lastly because it NEGATIVELY IMPACTS ADVANCES IN MEDICINE and raises the cost of medicine.
 
Not in the post that I responded to. In the post that I responded to you just did some of your typical Obama bashing.

Then you did not read my post. I spelled out exactly what I would have done and how it would have worked. When you're ready to have a substantive discussion about it, let me know.
 
You mean the one where I was responding to Sgt Staples? Well gosh IRP, how many times did you want me to simply repeat my initial post to Arkady?

Different posts get different responses.

Let me nursemaid you a little:
We should have had government get out of the way and let the economy heal. The problem wasn't a systemic problem with the economy, but the bursting of a housing bubble that was decades in the making. Obama took advantage of the situation to impose regulations that are making it hard for business to pull themselves back on track.

Obama has taken the "Catholic Nun with a large ruler" mentality to the economy, and it's hard to run an economy that way.
 
If Obabble had done absolutely nothing, our economy would have recovered long ago, our national debt would be a lot less than it is now, and our food and fuel would be a lot cheaper than it is now.[/quote
RIGHT Pixie Dust.

Pixie Dust would have turned around a $1Trillion SHRINKING of the US Economy by itself
Pixie Dust would have turned 820,000 jobs lost per month into 3 years of 150,000 jobs/mo job growth
Pixie Dust would have kept Accts Receivable Lending in July of 2009 from locking up as local commercial banks had all their assets stuck on car lots
Pixie Dust would have knocked 17% off unemployment (with the Accts Rcvbl lending lock up unemployment would have peaked at over 25% OFFICIALLY, 40% unofficially) in 3 years

RIGHHTT.

The rest of your stuff is just the usual bullsh!t.

But I have a question. Where do yuu get your ideas about the GM Bankruptcy from. Because it is quite easy to verify the actual facts of the matter.

  • FACT - GM tried to find buyers for itself in the year prior to the bankruptcy and FAILD
  • FACT this was not a Chapter 11 bankruptcy with restructuring, it was a Chapter 7 Bankruptcy with Liquidation
  • FACT the Obama administration tried to PREVENT the Bankruptcy but the bankruptcy was FORCED BY THE BOND HOLDERS
  • FACT the bankruptcy process was a normal one with one difference, The Government TARP program stepped in to buy out GM and Chrysler whole sale so that it COULD restructure
  • FACT there were no buyers able to buy GM or Chrysler because banks - both local and foreign COULD NOT LEND THAT MONEY due to the crash in the banking system
  • FACT the Bankrutpcy process otherwise was 100% normal.

So where do you get the notion that something else happened? What is the source of your provably incorrect belief?

FACTS MATTER
got any?

Oh yeah here's the link to the Documents on GM's Bankruptcy. https://ecf.nysb-mega.uscourts.gov/
http://www.motorsliquidationdocket.com/

Can you point to where the evidence exists that it was not a normal bankruptcy FORCED BY THE BOND HOLDERS?
 
The market rations healthcare as well.



False, you can get any type of (legal) treatment if you can pay for it. It's up to you to pay for it, not anyone else.

If you knew economics, you would know that the purpose of the market is to ALLOCATE SCARCE RESOURCES. That is rationing.

I'm quite familiar with economics. The best way to have the best goods and services at the lowest prices is through free market competition, not government monopolies.
 
When a thread gets long, I quite using the threaded view and just use a linear view. So I may have missed the fact that you were seconding Sarge's post. If so, I apologize. (You did engage in a lot of Obama bashing in the process however.)

Vis a vis Sarge's suggestion that you just let the market take care of things, I disagree. I suspect that you also thought that TARP was a bad idea. In that case, you also disagree with Bush, Romney, and Ryan who did support TARP. To be fair to Ryan, he has subsequently expressed disillusion with the way that the TARP funds were used (though I suspect that has more to do with the fact that Obama was President than anything else.)

Paul Ryan voted for the bailouts but has since soured on them

In any case, as you should know by now, I don't find that Austrian economics (which informs the novels of Ayn Rand) has a great deal of empirical support or very persuasive. I do not think that the market would just have "healed itself" quickly. I have substantive reasons for this grounded in my reading of economic history and in my own business experience. Rather, I think that your preferred solution would have led to an even more severe crisis and a much worse situation than we face today. Our economy is tepid now. I think that your preferred solution would have resulted in a full-blown depression.

As to "regulations," I assume that you are referring to Dodd-Frank on the new regulations on financial institutions. To be honest, I don't think Dodd-Frank went far enough. I would have been in favor of going back to Glass-Steagal and repealing Gramm-Leach-Bliley. I would also consider breaking up the "too big to fail" financial institutions. All I see Romney and Ryan proposing is to go back to the wild west days of unfettered Gramm-Leach-Bliley. Do you favor that?

Finally, I am a Keynesian and not a monetarist. Obama is a Keynesian. Despite the rhetoric, Keynes was not a Marxist. And I think that conservatives who call Keynesians Marxists are silly partisans who don't know what they are talking about.

In any case, I think that your prescriptions would have made the crisis of 2009 even worse and - if applied by Romney and Ryan - would make circumstances even worse. That is why I would never support Romney and Ryan. I think that their prescriptions are bad medicine. If I wanted to use the sort of rhetoric that you and Sarge seem to prefer, I would talk about what a thief Romney is and what an idiot Ryan is. But I don't use that rhetoric. I just say that I think that Romney and Ryan are wrong for me, for my family, and for America. You obviously disagree.


You mean the one where I was responding to Sgt Staples? Well gosh IRP, how many times did you want me to simply repeat my initial post to Arkady?

Different posts get different responses.

Let me nursemaid you a little:
 
False, you can get any type of (legal) treatment if you can pay for it. It's up to you to pay for it, not anyone else.

It is true, Sarge. If you can't pay for it (or for insurance), you can't get healthcare. If you need a liver transplant and don't have insurance (and sometimes even if you do have insurance), you won't get a liver transplant. That is rationing based on ability to pay. No two ways about it Sarge. (BTW, do you suppor the EMTALA bill that was supported by and passed under Reagan? Based on what you have written, apparently you think that EMTALA is a crock.

I'm quite familiar with economics. The best way to have the best goods and services at the lowest prices is through free market competition, not government monopolies.

That demonstrates that you know talking points. It shows no understanding of economics. You subcribe to a creed without understanding the substance of the creed (and you are led around by the nose by private monopolists.)
 
When a thread gets long, I quite using the threaded view and just use a linear view. So I may have missed the fact that you were seconding Sarge's post. If so, I apologize. (You did engage in a lot of Obama bashing in the process however.)

Well thank you, I do enjoy my Obama bashing.
Vis a vis Sarge's suggestion that you just let the market take care of things, I disagree. I suspect that you also thought that TARP was a bad idea. In that case, you also disagree with Bush, Romney, and Ryan who did support TARP. To be fair to Ryan, he has subsequently expressed disillusion with the way that the TARP funds were used (though I suspect that has more to do with the fact that Obama was President than anything else.).)

TARP was a temporary loan to the financial industry as a way of getting the banks our from under the sudden pressure they were under. It was meant to be, and was, paid back to the American people. I had no problem with it. The simple giving away of money, that I have a problem with.

Paul Ryan voted for the bailouts but has since soured on them

Interesting factoid, but not germaine to the discussion at hand.

In any case, as you should know by now, I don't find that Austrian economics (which informs the novels of Ayn Rand) has a great deal of empirical support or very persuasive. I do not think that the market would just have "healed itself" quickly. I have substantive reasons for this grounded in my reading of economic history and in my own business experience. Rather, I think that your preferred solution would have led to an even more severe crisis and a much worse situation than we face today. Our economy is tepid now. I think that your preferred solution would have resulted in a full-blown depression.

In a discussion, we don't simply make declarations and then move on. What "substantive reasons" can you cite that backs up your assertion, as yet unsubstanciated, that the economy would not have healed itself if left to its own devices?

As to "regulations," I assume that you are referring to Dodd-Frank on the new regulations on financial institutions. To be honest, I don't think Dodd-Frank went far enough. I would have been in favor of going back to Glass-Steagal and repealing Gramm-Leach-Bliley. I would also consider breaking up the "too big to fail" financial institutions. All I see Romney and Ryan proposing is to go back to the wild west days of unfettered Gramm-Leach-Bliley. Do you favor that?

Glass-Steagal should never have been repealed, however, the administration is currently piliing on with all new regulations, such as the one laughed off my your compatriots, costing businesses billions of dollars and making it difficult for them to get loans from the banks in order to meet payrolls.

Finally, I am a Keynesian and not a monetarist. Obama is a Keynesian. Despite the rhetoric, Keynes was not a Marxist. And I think that conservatives who call Keynesians Marxists are silly partisans who don't know what they are talking about.

Being a Keynesian doesn't make you a Marxist, being an anti-business, pro-union socialist makes you a Marxist.

In any case, I think that your prescriptions would have made the crisis of 2009 even worse and - if applied by Romney and Ryan - would make circumstances even worse. That is why I would never support Romney and Ryan. I think that their prescriptions are bad medicine. If I wanted to use the sort of rhetoric that you and Sarge seem to prefer, I would talk about what a thief Romney is and what an idiot Ryan is. But I don't use that rhetoric. I just say that I think that Romney and Ryan are wrong for me, for my family, and for America. You obviously disagree.

Again, unsubstantiated declarations does not a discussion make. Simply saying "Romney/Ryan bad, Obama Good" is not a basis for rational debate.
 
TARP was a temporary loan to the financial industry as a way of getting the banks our from under the sudden pressure they were under. It was meant to be, and was, paid back to the American people. I had no problem with it. The simple giving away of money, that I have a problem with.

I mentioned TARP because there were many folks at the time (2008) who were very opposed to TARP. I wasn't sure what camp that you fell into. (A lot of Tea Party folks hated TARP and were willing to see the banks collapse.)

Interesting factoid, but not germaine to the discussion at hand.

I mentioned it primarily because I did not know what opinion that you had of TARP. But evidently, you do not think that Obama was wrong about TARP.

In a discussion, we don't simply make declarations and then move on. What "substantive reasons" can you cite that backs up your assertion, as yet unsubstanciated, that the economy would not have healed itself if left to its own devices?

Well, in fact, Sarge made the opposite assertion without providing any substantive reasons other than a faith in the free market. Neither of us is going to be able to prove what would have happened if a "free-market" solution had been tried. You can't prove counterfactuals one way or the other. You can just speculate. The primary source of my skepticism is the failure of Hoover's response to the Stock Market Crash of 1929 and the cascading crises that continued to 1933 when FDR was elected. In my mind, Bush was about a return to the policies of Coolidge and Romney and Ryan are about a return to the policies of Hoover. I am not inclined to go in that direction. But you are certainly free to disagree.

Glass-Steagal should never have been repealed, however, the administration is currently piliing on with all new regulations, such as the one laughed off my your compatriots, costing businesses billions of dollars and making it difficult for them to get loans from the banks in order to meet payrolls.

Well, if we talked long enough, we might come up with a decent solution. The problem is that - in my view - the Republicans - with the exception of a few folks like Bob Corker - tried to undermine the efforts of reform of the financial institutions and seem to be intent on going back to the circumstances as they existed in 2006. It sounds to me that you are not in favor of going back to 2006 either. I am very willing to believe that small businesses are still having trouble establishing lines of credit so that they can have working capital. If that is indeed the case, that is a problem and one that I think to which a bi-partisan solution can be found without returning to the wild west of 2006. That said, this is not an area in which I have particular expertise and I recognize that there may be things that I do not know or am not aware of. That said, you have not supplied evidence that new Obama regulations are causing this credit crunch. You have asserted it but you have never backed it up as far as I know (other than possibly with the anecdote about your two friends who own small businesses and blame their problems on Obama.)

Being a Keynesian doesn't make you a Marxist, being an anti-business, pro-union socialist makes you a Marxist.

Obama is not anti-business in any way, shape, or form. (And again you seem to be making an assertion without backing it up.) Being pro-union does not make you either a socialist or a Marxist. It means that you support the right of workers to organize and bargain collectively.

Again, unsubstantiated declarations does not a discussion make. Simply saying "Romney/Ryan bad, Obama Good" is not a basis for rational debate.

First, I did not say "Romney and Ryan bad/Obama good." I was really mimicking what I took you to be saying. Second, I did say "Romney and Ryan (going forward) worse/Obama (going forward) better. I think that Romney and Ryan would just repeat the failures of Bush. You think that Obama has been a failure. We can both put forward substantive reasons to support our beliefs about the past. And we can draw on our view of the past to predict what we think will happen in the future. Given our perspectives, we are not likely to agree. But your calling Obama an idiot is not an invitation to a substantive discussion either. If you want to do some bashing, I don't know why you expect people to engage you in a discussion.
 
Want to know why? Because IT'S IMPOSSIBLE TO PAY FOR WITHOUT RATIONING.

Because it gives the government CONTROL OVER WHAT KIND, HOW MUCH AND WHO GETS WHAT TREATMENTS and because it GIVES GOVERNMENT CONTROL OVER EVERYTHING THAT IMPACTS YOUR HEALTH. We don't do that in countries that respect individual liberty.

And lastly because it NEGATIVELY IMPACTS ADVANCES IN MEDICINE and raises the cost of medicine.


And just how does it do that, and where is the rationing. I see some real control over what Insurance Companies can charge for administering programs, don't see many controls on the CARE the patient receives. Oh it does close the medicine doughnut hole which prevents insurance companies from demanding exhorbitant co-pays. MOF, my father needed a medication to correct the sodium levels in his blood. His Medicare managed health care plan would only approve 4 doses and the medicine could only be secured in 12 dose units. So he was left with the option of paying himself for 8 pills he did not need, at $1300 per pill or doing without. He did not do without, the reason, he had a son smarter than the insurance company. I got him the count and dosage he needed, by going though a hospital pharmacy that had surplus from another patient. You see had he been in the hospital at the time, the cost would have been fully covered.


As to the totally ill-informed idea that the government get to control patient care, well they don't. They don't have it now and its not part of the Affordable Health Care Act. This board is done a grave disservice when paid for opinions are substituted for fact. Sourcing information from bought and paid for shills like the CATO Institute and Rush Limbaugh, lowers the level of intelligent discourse outlets like this make available.

I'm an independent voter, I am also an professional analyst. Facts, not fantasies impress me. The lack of facts in the quoted post have failed to do so because they are so obvious by their absence and the intent of the author is so blatantly skewed by it. Rumor, innuendo, and latrinograms service the those unwilling to find out for themselves what the facts are. Truth serves the public interest, propaganda does not. Italy, Germany, France, Britain, and a host of other Capitalist countries all over the globe provide for universal healthcare, and in the final analysis in US dollars they pay less for it than we do. Give you any ideas that maybe what you have heard is wrong ?

Tai Pan
 
I'm quite familiar with economics. The best way to have the best goods and services at the lowest prices is through free market competition, not government monopolies.

No actually you don't seem to be. There are many examples where market competition does not yield best prices. That you don't seem to understand this, that you don't even seem to understand what an efficient market requires is the major part of the problem here.
 
No actually you don't seem to be. There are many examples where market competition does not yield best prices. That you don't seem to understand this, that you don't even seem to understand what an efficient market requires is the major part of the problem here.

Oh wow ! There is actually another person in here who recognizes that all governments protect their markets and their producers, through tariffs, direct price supports, subsidies, tax breaks, marketing programs, and a myriad other programs. All of which are ultimately designed to provide the best consumer prices achievable for that countries products, both at home and abroad. I mean there really is someone else here who understand what customs duties are designed to do ?


I have been reborn and entered Heaven. Intelligence, knowledge and experience is once again roaming the ether.


Tai Pan
 
Oh wow ! There is actually another person in here who recognizes that all governments protect their markets and their producers, through tariffs, direct price supports, subsidies, tax breaks, marketing programs, and a myriad other programs. All of which are ultimately designed to provide the best consumer prices achievable for that countries products, both at home and abroad. I mean there really is someone else here who understand what customs duties are designed to do ?


I have been reborn and entered Heaven. Intelligence, knowledge and experience is once again roaming the ether.


Tai Pan

Well I go further TP... The notion of a "free" market - as in one that is "unregulated" is an inherently unstable one... After all, protections against fraud, enforcement of contracts, and protections of property rights - even the very definition of what is and is not "property" are all parts of a regulatory system.

So if you are going to insist on an unregulated market (as Sgt seems to demand) you are removing ALL of these factors from the marketplace. Which means it very quickly devolves to Might Makes Right.. and we know that Might Makes Right is NOT an efficient market.

Now if you ARE going to introduce such regulations, you are inherently going to distort that "free" market. Because in enforcing contracts you are favoring those who write better contracts over others. And in defining what is property (deeded land) and what is not (the air) you are creating incentives for exploitation of the unownable resources with a sequestering of ownable resources.

So now you already have an inherently distorted market. And in reality there are a set of basic things you need for a market to work efficiently:

  • information symmetry
  • Risk symmetry
  • Low barriers to entry relative to profit margins
  • Low barriers to exit relative to investments in the market
  • A "profit feedback" loop that is SLOWER or LONGER than the outcome loop (ie you need to be able to figure out if you bought crap BEFORE a lot of profit can be made)
  • The existance of substitute products and vendors in the marketplace
  • A full reflection of Cost Of Goods Sold into the products (ie no exernalization of the costs)

And violate any one of these and your market ceases to be efficient.

In healthcare There is

  • no information symmetry. MDs know more than you do. Insurance Companies know more than you do
  • No Risk symmetry. Chose the wrong insurance company and you are screwed, dead even. Sell insurnace to the wrong patient, and your liability is rather limited
  • fairly high Barriers to entry - you need a large pool of capital to create enough of a base of the insurance pool so that the first big claim does not bankrupt you
  • Fairly high barriers to entry - you need to do a lot of studying before you can provide healthcare services
  • Profit Loop is shorter than feedback loop - IE you pay into the insurance plan for a long time before you use it, so they make a profit long before you know the outcome
  • Profit loop is shorter than feedback loop - You will be paying your medical bill long before you are fully recovered. So you don't even know if you WILL fully recover
  • Limited substitute products - When you are in the ambulance you are not choosing between which hospital to go to
  • COGS is not accurately reflected - this is part of the information assymmetry. The prices being set by providers and insurers externalize as much of the costs as possible by amortizing underperforming costs/customers onto profitable ones


Given this complete failure of market dynamics... the idea that a "free market" will always deliver better results is bullsh!t. Absent regulation, I could throw together a series of cheap ERs that don't really do much but have an "ambulance" every 10 miles of highway or so. The be the First Responder and bring the patient to my ER. That the quality of care sucks doesn't matter to the person bleeding profusely in the car wreck. I pocket the profit and they suffer for the rest of their lives.

yeah Market competition realy works in such a circumstance.

So of Course Sgt setsup an alternative chain of clinics and now we race to the scene and how does a patient bleeding on the side of the road know which of the 5 competitive responders to go with?

Its just STUPID.
 
1. He did start with the economic crisis and turned to health care after that. See the various bios out there on his first term

2. There is never a good time to let polluters have a free hand: "our children are watching us" Dixie Chicks line.

3. The tax cuts had years to take affect and the wealthy among us didn't step up to the plate. He still chose to compromise with them at one point but learned that their idea of compromise is to do it their way.

4. Who started funding that company?

5. You know full well that the House leadership would not budge on any revenue increases, so there was NO BASIS FOR COMPROMISE.


From my perspective this is what Obama should have done as soon as he was inaugurated:

1. Focused on the economy instead of the health care thing.

2. Refrained from adding regulation after regulation regarding things that didn't need regulating at this moment (environmental stuff).

3. Not even fought with Congress about extending Bush tax cuts. They just needed to be extended due to the state of the economy.

4. Not invested in Green companies with our tax money (Solyndra) in order to make a green transition at the worst time.

and

5. He should have urged/ encouraged his ALL Democratic House came up with a good budget that everyone could sign off on that would show us a direction to get our economy back on track.
 
Right on,Tai! We need young blood in both the White House and the parties.Those,whose minds are not set in stone.I am all for a new generation taking over .Jennifer for Senate,now!:eek:)

We'll have Paul Ryan in January, he's young.
 
You made many good point, but I'd like to repeat this line: "If one assumes that expending money to fix a big hole one caused in one's roof is in fact, ruining the roof or hurting the house worse than the hole in the roof did, then perhaps that which appears as an absurdity to me, makes sense to someone else."

I must say that this has been an excellent thread.
 
Man are you a breath of fresh air ! I spent 7 years as senior analyst of corp marketing for a fortune 500 before I moved on to Director of Regulatory Affairs responsible for compliance and government relations worldwide. You are right on target and right on factually. INC. Latin for Illegitmi non carborundum


You know the problem is that most of the people who write the nonsense you see here have never had to negotiate with the commerce department of China, Japan, Korea, Uganda, India, Indonesia, Chile, Belgium, Italy, Morocco, or South Africa. They have no clue how the game is played.

Tai Pan.
 
We'll have Paul Ryan in January, he's young.

If God really protects this country, NOT !

I despise people like Paul Ryan who live a life based on "Do what I say, not what I do."

People who do not respect your rights, and the rights of others, cannot be trusted with power.

TaiPan
 
If God really protects this country, NOT !
I despise people like Paul Ryan who live a life based on "Do what I say, not what I do."
People who do not respect your rights, and the rights of others, cannot be trusted with power.
TaiPan

Who has robbed you of your rights?
 
Back
Top