New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Question for Conservatives

I repeat CNN busted that 4.5 million jobs myth and lie last week. Obama's only created 400,000 new jobs in total since taking office in 2009.

Um CNN did nothing of the sort.. YOUR OWN CITATION of CNN's story misrepresented it.

All CNN did was point out the NET CHANGE in jobs.. which NO ONE DISPUTES.
 
Cicero seems to've become the "master of the talking point" (and not much else).

As to whether or not some 4.6 million jobs have been created during the Obama Era, there's virtually no dispute. Cicero claims CNN "busted this 'myth' ". They did not. All they did, is attempt to answer the completely different question of "total number of jobs then", as compared with "total number of jobs now".

And, that begs the question....where would we be today, had only 400k jobs been created? Well for one thing, we'd be 4.2 million jobs "behinder" than we are now!
 
In Massachusetts and everywhere else on the planet, that means money out can't exceed money in. If it does, there are three fixes. Decrease money going out. Increase money coming in. Or combine the two. Only blindered right wingers assume there's a single option.

Gee Jack. let's get it straight again, why isn't the money available ? Does it have anything to do with the lowest corporate tax rates in the industrialized world or maybe the Bush Tax Cuts, they are linked. Seems the Treasury dept. can provide the statistics that say just that. Now why are we forced to spend money we haven't got ? Because we have to make up the difference. Arithmetic, Jack, 10 - 11 = -1. Now how about another look at both.

TaiPan

Tai Pan
 
Cicero,

I agree with you that businesspeople rarely if ever make decisions based on hate. However, I also know that a blanket statement like "Obama's going to create an environment that is bad for business in general and in which they are scared to invest" is just as much hogwash as the "They hate Obama" angle. In fact, I think that Connie's perspective (which I suspect is based on the "small" business people that she does accounting for) may have more validity than yours.

There is a lot that goes into business decisions. But the most important factors are generally their customers, their suppliers (including their employees who supply labor), their investors (who supply financial resources), and their competitors. The general environment (e.g. the government or the culture) has an effect on general market conditions but is of only secondary importance to most business decisions because government and culture typically affect all the businesses in a market equally.

This whole "socialistic" angle is a bunch of baloney in my opinion. Businesses have no problem investing in China despite the fact that it is much more socialistic than the United States will ever be whether under Democrats or Republicans.


Bottom line - Business' regardless of size make decisions based on profit. Otherwise they wouldn't be in business very long. No business is in business to lose money. So we can move on from the esoteric maunderings of the totally economically ill informed.

TaiPan
 
I am not discussing this with Sarge, I am discussing this with you. I do understand where Sarge is coming from, I don't understand where you are coming from.

This whole thread started because I objected to your pissing on Obama while responding to Sarge's post. Therefore Sarge is still relevant. I don't understand where Sarge is coming from (and I have started and built two - not three - businesses). You blindly cheer Sarge despite the fact that Sarge cannot back up his assertions. If this is a discussion, you have to explain your views to me as well as vice-versa.

Coolidge was a small government republican who did not want to get government involve in any aspect of the private market if at all possible. Coolidge even refused disaster assistance to states in times of trouble. When he did that, a remarkable thing happened. States stepped up and took care of their own problems.

The seeds that Coolidge policies sewed were reaped by the Hoover Administration in 1929 and onward. Silent Cal would have been universally reviled if he had been reelected. He would have failed as badly or worse than Hoover did.

Bush, on the other hand, was a big government republican who expanded social spending, such as the prescription program, and got us involved in 2 wars, and expanded the powers of the police, the FBI, and the CIA. The assertion that Bush is anything like Coolidge is unfounded.

Bush's economic policies were an attempt to return to the economic policies of Hoover. You supported Bush getting the U.S. into two wars (without raising taxes to pay for the wars). Romney is not going to reduce the powers of the police, the FBI, and the CIA. If you think that would happen under Romney and Ryan, you are very naive. Neither of them is a civil libertarian. Bush and Cheney certainly were not. Obama has been a disappointment to me on this score. I would expect Romney and Ryan to be worse.

Hoover was another big government republican in the vain of Bush. Expansion of the power of government, the creation of the FBI, and large spending projects, such as the Hoover Damn, makes Hoover a lot closer to Bush than Coolidge was. The greatest of our problems seem to have always come from large government leaders.

You are entitled to make any assertions that you want. You have not substantively backed them up. That the Hoover Dam was a failure would be news to most people. I suspect that you think that Eisenhower should not have pushed the creation of the interstate highway system either.


I read all those articles. I never said that small business credit (which was discussed in the first two articles) was not a problem. However, both articles said that the causes of the problem was complex and neither placed the blame squarely on the shoulders of the Obama Adminstration. Furthermore, neither of them indicated the Romney or Republicans had better solutions. So, we agree that small business credit is a problem. However, you think that replacing Obama with Romney will solve the problem without providing any basis for me to believe you other than your insistance that Obama is bad and Romney is good. As a business person, I do not buy that line.

The next two regulations is about business people complaining about particular regulations that I assume that you think are frivolous. However, the case that they make is entirely one-sided. I also have a problem because ALL their competitors face the same problems. It is not just Sara Lee that has to meet the sodium requirements. It is the whole industry. No one gets a competitive advantage. I would make an analogy between the ban on advertising for meats over the standard as equivalent to the ban on advertising cigarettes. Cigarettes have been demonstrated tp be very hazardous to your health. Similarly, high-sodium has health consequences. So - in principle - I do not consider the regulations "frivolous." There is a trade-off. Ditto for environmental regulations. So I would say that we differ in two respects. First, I do not think that regulations are - by and large - frivolous. But I do think that there are trade-offs. There are times when the benefits of regulations are not worth their cost. And there are times when old regulations outlive their value and are still enforced. Second, you demonstrated that SOME business people (but not all) complain about regulations. You did not demonstrate a direct effect on job creation. (There are real costs to high-sodium diets and to pollution that you seem to blow off.)

Business leaders would disagree with you, as my links show. The Obama administration is taken a micromanagement style of economic management, and has shown that he favors unions over business, as with his UAW deal with GM and Chrysler. This election cycle, business contributions are going almost exclusively to Romney. This wouldn't happen if Obama was as business friendly as you believe.

You just make unsubstantiated claims about the Obama Administration micromanaging the economy and favoring unions over business. (I am still not sure what you have against unions or collective bargaining.) However, I will grant you that Romney has substantial support from business people. I don't think that this is because business people want what is best for the average American or the middle-class. Doesn't mean I hate business. Based on my experience in business and with business people, I take both their complaints and their promises with a grain of salt. I do the same with unions. I think that Romney believes the business line hook, line, and sinker and has a tin ear for anyone who is not a businessman. You like that. (And you are not a businessman.) I am skeptical (and I am a businessperson.)

BTW, this article from the Huff Post about Jim Sinegal (recently retired CEO of Costco) captures my perspective. I agree with Sinegal for the most part. He believes in building the economy from the middle out and the bottom up rather than from the top down (like you and Romney).

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/09/06/jim-sinegal-costco-dnc_n_1861203.html

If anyone has repeated Bush's failures, it would be Obama. He has continued, and expanded, Bush's social spending, increased deficit spending, and expanded government. He's piled on new regulations and is strangling business. From everything I am seeing, this is what is keeping our economy from rebounding. From what I have seen, Romney and Ryan would do the exact opposite of Bush, and shrink government intervention in the private market, reduce social spending, and use the private market to manage key social programs. I find all of these things appealing. Right now, the Obama plan adds 8 years to the longevity of SS and Medicare, kicking the problem down the road to another administration. In my opinion, that is the cowardly way of going about a solution. I didn't like it with Bush, I really don't like it with Obama. Romney and Ryan want people collecting their SS and Medicare for decades to come, which means things need to be changed.

Well, you are entitled to your preferences. Romney and Ryan are warmed over Bush who will explode the deficit and destroy the social safety net while feeding the military and their big business paymeisters. (BTW, if you think that I am making assertions without substantiating them, I point you to your paragraph above. You did not substantiate anything either. You just stated your beliefs.}

I will end by telling you what I tell most righties on PJ. You are entitled to vote for who you want to vote. You are entitled to your opinion. I have no expectation that anything that I say is going to persuade you to believe differently than you do. And though I vehemently disagree with your political views and think that you are - to some extent - a dupe of a vast right-wing propoganda machine, I do not think that you are a bad guy. Conversely, there is nothing that you could do that would persuade me that Obama has been a failure and does not deserve to be reelected. I think that he does. I also happen to think that Democratic values and principles are better for me, for my family, for the middle-class, and for the United States as a whole. Like it or not, millions of people agree with me (and millions disagree as well.) I used to be an independent and would vote for folks who are now considered RINOs. I will never vote for a party that holds to the policies of the current version of Romney or Paul Ryan. I think that the policies of Paul Ryan would be a boon for the very wealthy but a disaster for the middle class and the United States as a whole. I will do my best to make sure that Romney and Ryan are defeated and I expect to impose their conservative policies if the nation is unfortunate enough (in my opinion) to see them elected. I oppose most of their agenda. Where I agree with their agenda, I might listen.
 
Couple of points.. Hoover Damn was built by FDR not Hoover.

Secondly the interesting thing about the SunTimes articles about small businesses is very intersting for THREE reasons

  1. First off, there is the statement that while the number of loans to small businesses rose dramatically from 2010 to 2011 that this is still less than the number of loans made in 2006.

    Well one has to think about this critically for a while. Realize that you cannot apply for a small business loan UNTIL YOU HAVE THREE YEARS OF REVENUES to show the bank. They won't talk to you before that.

    So that means that in 2006 the lending was largely predicated on the business track record from 2003-2006. A time in which job numbers were flat and a lot of people seem to have started their own businesses... FUNDED BY SUBPRIME MORTGAGES and 2nd Mortgages. Meanwhile the 2010/11 numbers are based on revenues from 2007/8 onwards... the HEIGHT OF THE CRASH. So right there we have a question on how meaningful that comparison between 2006 and 2011 really is

    Secondly - while it is true that Most TOTAL jobs exist in small businesses. IT IS UNTRUE THAT Small business IN GENERAL is the "creator of job growth" REcent studies on small businesses show that 90%+ of them DO NOT CREATE NEW JOBS They are basically steady-state businesses. For example a bakery typically does not add a lot of jobs as its customer base fluctuates. It changes how much bread it bakes but because of the capital costs involved, it does not buy new ovens. And without additional ovens you DO NOT NEED MORE WORKERS.

    The businesses that DO create new jobs are ones that are RAPIDLY GROWING small businesses and those are typically businesses in new fields or offering new and innovative services. http://articles.businessinsider.com...nesses-source-of-job-creation-small-companies

    Thirdly - Much of the so called "small business job creation" is actually job churn from failing small businesses. For example, I know one young couple where the wife drove Pizza Delivery. In the three years she worked for us part-time, she went through THREE Pizza Delivery jobs. Each of the Pizza shops opened - ran, and then went bust or moved to a wealthier town. Now ON PAPER that looks like three small businesses created three Pizza Delivery jobs (plus all the other jobs they created)... but IN REALITY it was just ONE steady state Pizza Delivery Job.

    Yet this sort of critical thinking analysis is not what we see from conservatives.
    .
  2. Now the US News article about "$3.5 Billion in Red Tape Regulations"
    At Tuesday's GOP Senate caucus lunch, the lawmakers said that they will renew their efforts, supported by business groups like the U.S. Chamber of Commerce. In a memo Barasso handed out to the lawmakers, he claimed that the administration in July only has put in $9.5 billion in new regulatory costs by proposing 229 new rules and finalizing 379 rules
    Notice the words I highlighted. These are rules THAT ARE NOT IN EFFECT YET NOR HAVE BEEN IN EFFECT. These are regulations Going Forwards. So Barasso is basically lying by omission here. NOT ONE of the regulations he listed has added ANY COSTS IN THE LAST 4 years.

    Which actually means the businesses have been in essence STUPID to not take profits NOW before such regulations go into effect. But of course that logic is also something that seems to escape our friend here. BTW this also is another case of the Innumeracy of Large numbers that I got from Color in a previous thread on Dominos. that $9.5 is 0.06% of the US GDP. IOW that is 0.06% LESS THAN ONE TENTH OF ONE PERCENT of Revenue costs for the economy. And NO ONE.. I mean NO ONE makes hiring decisions based on 0.06% change in OpEx costs. Particularly when they are sitting on a cash reserve that is about 20% of annual revenue (retained earnigns in cash now are about 1/5 of GDP).
    .
  3. Notice ALSO that two of the articles are about how BANKING CREDIT is hard for small business to come by. Essentially Color is asking for GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION IN BUSINESS to fix a creditworthiness problem... And yet this is the same person whining about Government that is TOO BIG
    .
  4. The Last article is mostly about SARA LEEE and its ability to advertise - arguably less than honestly - about the supposed "healthiness" of some of its products... WTF does this have to do with job creation? Unless of course you are a person who believes that fraudulent advertising is a good thing for the economy. Just because Sara Lee cannot misrepresent some of its products does not mean this hurts job creation. In fact Free Market Theory tells us that if there is a demand for that type of product - SOMEONE ELSE will step into the gap and produce a product THAT CAN BE advertised as healthy without misrepresentation.

    So again, this is a demand by the industry to allow markets to be LESS EFFICIENT!!! and yet it is something we are supposed to acceed to? WHY?
 
Degs,

Thanks for the more detailed analysis of the four articles. I think that our basic points were similar but your detailed exposition added a lot. (I hope that Color will attempt to respond to your more detailed analysis.)

Vis a vis the Hoover Dam, I did wonder about Color's assertion. So I looked up the history of the Hoover Dam. In fact it was authorized in a bill signed by Calvin Coolidge in December, 1928 and was built from 1931 to 1936. Roosevelt dedicated Hoover Dam. So this is actually a classic example of bi-partisan cooperation on an important piece of public infrastructure. The fact that Coolidge signed the bill that authorized Hoover Dam would seem to put a gaping hole in Color's view of Coolidge.

Wikipedia: Hoover Dam


Couple of points.. Hoover Damn was built by FDR not Hoover.

Secondly the interesting thing about the SunTimes articles about small businesses is very intersting for THREE reasons

  1. First off, there is the statement that while the number of loans to small businesses rose dramatically from 2010 to 2011 that this is still less than the number of loans made in 2006.

    Well one has to think about this critically for a while. Realize that you cannot apply for a small business loan UNTIL YOU HAVE THREE YEARS OF REVENUES to show the bank. They won't talk to you before that.

    So that means that in 2006 the lending was largely predicated on the business track record from 2003-2006. A time in which job numbers were flat and a lot of people seem to have started their own businesses... FUNDED BY SUBPRIME MORTGAGES and 2nd Mortgages. Meanwhile the 2010/11 numbers are based on revenues from 2007/8 onwards... the HEIGHT OF THE CRASH. So right there we have a question on how meaningful that comparison between 2006 and 2011 really is

    Secondly - while it is true that Most TOTAL jobs exist in small businesses. IT IS UNTRUE THAT Small business IN GENERAL is the "creator of job growth" REcent studies on small businesses show that 90%+ of them DO NOT CREATE NEW JOBS They are basically steady-state businesses. For example a bakery typically does not add a lot of jobs as its customer base fluctuates. It changes how much bread it bakes but because of the capital costs involved, it does not buy new ovens. And without additional ovens you DO NOT NEED MORE WORKERS.

    The businesses that DO create new jobs are ones that are RAPIDLY GROWING small businesses and those are typically businesses in new fields or offering new and innovative services.

    Thirdly - Much of the so called "small business job creation" is actually job churn from failing small businesses. For example, I know one young couple where the wife drove Pizza Delivery. In the three years she worked for us part-time, she went through THREE Pizza Delivery jobs. Each of the Pizza shops opened - ran, and then went bust or moved to a wealthier town. Now ON PAPER that looks like three small businesses created three Pizza Delivery jobs (plus all the other jobs they created)... but IN REALITY it was just ONE steady state Pizza Delivery Job.

    Yet this sort of critical thinking analysis is not what we see from conservatives.
  2. Now the US News article about "$3.5 Billion in Red Tape Regulations"

    Notice the words I highlighted. These are rules THAT ARE NOT IN EFFECT YET NOR HAVE BEEN IN EFFECT. These are regulations Going Forwards. So Barasso is basically lying by omission here. NOT ONE of the regulations he listed has added ANY COSTS IN THE LAST 4 years.

    Which actually means the businesses have been in essence STUPID to not take profits NOW before such regulations go into effect. But of course that logic is also something that seems to escape our friend here. BTW this also is another case of the Innumeracy of Large numbers that I got from Color in a previous thread on Dominos. that $9.5 is 0.06% of the US GDP. IOW that is 0.06% LESS THAN ONE TENTH OF ONE PERCENT of Revenue costs for the economy. And NO ONE.. I mean NO ONE makes hiring decisions based on 0.06% change in OpEx costs. Particularly when they are sitting on a cash reserve that is about 20% of annual revenue (retained earnigns in cash now are about 1/5 of GDP).
  3. Notice ALSO that two of the articles are about how BANKING CREDIT is hard for small business to come by. Essentially Color is asking for GOVERNMENT INTERVENTION IN BUSINESS to fix a creditworthiness problem... And yet this is the same person whining about Government that is TOO BIG
  4. The Last article is mostly about SARA LEEE and its ability to advertise - arguably less than honestly - about the supposed "healthiness" of some of its products... WTF does this have to do with job creation? Unless of course you are a person who believes that fraudulent advertising is a good thing for the economy. Just because Sara Lee cannot misrepresent some of its products does not mean this hurts job creation. In fact Free Market Theory tells us that if there is a demand for that type of product - SOMEONE ELSE will step into the gap and produce a product THAT CAN BE advertised as healthy without misrepresentation.

    So again, this is a demand by the industry to allow markets to be LESS EFFICIENT!!! and yet it is something we are supposed to acceed to? WHY?
 
Interesting point about Coolidge and Hoover Damn... add to that that Hoover Damn was built not just to provide irrigation control - (benefitting AgriBusiness interests and thus PROMOTING them) but also to provide Electrical Power for INDUSTRY on the coast... Again.. Government funding for Business growth and infrastructure.

Sadly I don't think Colorforms is likely to reply in any sort of civil manner. My experience with him is that when the inconvenient facts and critical reasoning are mixed in with his citations, he starts complaining about how its just untrue and not worth providing any support for his assertions anyway. This is what he did with the story about how Caloric Content regs by the FDA supposedly "cost" Dominos Pizza $5 million to implement.

What of course the story left out was that

  • Dominos Pizza has annual revenues of $1.64 Billion and thus this "cost" would be 0.3% of Revenue
  • No one makes hiring or layoff decisions based on 0.3% of COGS
  • That most of this "cost" was one Dominos had to have ANYWAY - since they print Pizza Boxes for its franchises ANYWAY, and changing the content of what is printed is actually an infintessimal part of that printing cost
  • Even IF ALL of that printing cost came out of Domino's revenenues- that would be about 250 Jobs CREATED in the printing industry that printed the new boxes and WOULD NOT affect staffing at Dominos given the low level of COGS impact

But instead of engaging on a discussion of this, he retreated to Ad Hominem.
 
I am reading a really interesting book right now about this topic, its called "grand pursuit". The guy that has really impressed me so far is Fisher. Marx never ever went into a factory in his life, had no clue what manufacturing was like and didn't care...
 
You need to get a load of Keen...he is the best economist you have never heard of...and Krugman knows it too. I love Paul, he is a fighter but he cannot hold a candle to Keen on the current situation...
 
Without promoting Marx, one thing to understand is that Engels was a died-in-the-wool industrialist who spent plenty of time in factories and Mills.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Engels

I am reading a really interesting book right now about this topic, its called "grand pursuit". The guy that has really impressed me so far is Fisher. Marx never ever went into a factory in his life, had no clue what manufacturing was like and didn't care...
 
Representatives historically have not acted in a direct representational manner. The very point of an APPOINTED Senate - as it was originally concieved. was to insure that the Senate was populated with "Solid, Thinking Leaders".

That some representatives have ignored their responsibility to represent that people that elected them is immaterial. The very point of a democratically elected House and Senate (as we have moved to) is to enhance the force of democracy -- to ensure that the will of the people is enacted and not merely a deal among politicians. You've effectively said representatives should represent something other than their electorate. If that's the case, why have a representation system at all -- who, in fact, are they representing?



Well today - the rabble - who don't understand about liquidity traps and Sovereign vs. personal debt and international monetary economics.. are demanding "balanced budgets" and punishing representatives, who upon learning the facts - decide to do something different.

it comes down to the question of what are representatives supposed to represent:


[*]The BEST INTERESTS of the constituency?
or
[*]The basest knee jerk BELIEFS of the constituency?

Neither -- they're supposed to represent the POLITICAL VIEWS of the constituency. If they fail to do so, they can be voted out.
 
I think those are strong proposals. I would modify that just a bit, though. I'm still a little annoyed by the idea of government swooping in and rescuing dumb people from their own mistakes. If someone leveraged his home to the hilt to finance consumer spending, why should the ordinary taxpayer save him from his mistake? Even aside from the moral hazard issue, there's the fact that this involves lots of people who couldn't even afford homes essentially subsidizing the consumer lifestyles of reckless richer people who could afford homes.

So, I'd look to have two government-financed programs. One would be something like you're talking about (e.g.., 100-year refinances), but only for those who didn't do anything particularly dumb (e.g., those who wound up over their head because of a job loss, illness, or other economic shift they shouldn't necessarily have planned for), while those who acted particularly stupidly would be allowed to lose their homes. But then the second program would be designed to prevent a cascading devaluation of home prices caused by mass foreclosures against those dumb folks. It would make 100-year mortgages available to first-time buyers, but would only be available for those buying existing homes. That would bring in a lot of new buyers, especially the poor and working class people and young people who couldn't afford houses during the run-up in real estate, and they'd mop up the excess housing stock, so we didn't get a glut that further depressed values. If there weren't enough of them to do that, I'd also consider 100-year mortgages for first-time second-home buyers who were otherwise financially sound (if someone is going to swoop in and pick up a vacation home or investment property, I'd rather it be someone who didn't contribute to the housing bubble and meltdown).

Yes, unfortunately in order to save everyone the dumb had to be rescued. I like your ideas of extending long term mortgages with low payments to others for specific reasons and I'm sure there are other workable ideas. When housing rises, so will the rest of our economy. Until that time we will stay mostly stagnant. My personal experience was that I had a mortgage line of credit for 100k along with a business line of credit for 200k, both were snatched back by the bank when the bubble burst. Multiply that times several million and we can see how it affected small business.
 
We get it. The GOTP wants people to die without healthcare-EXCEPT FOR ZYGOTES. You still haven't answered for the huge amount of negativism from the right to stop all things Obama. Why is that?

Could it be that the GOTP is a self-absorbed theocracy trying only to keep all the wealth- no matter who worked for the money, and the rest of America be damned?

It is not the money but the direction. Liberals and Conservatives want to go in opposite directions as they each believe their path is good for the whole. To demonize each other is dishonest and petty, roughly half the country is equally divided with each side not understanding the other.

It is either time for a third direction or two separate U.S. countries. We have plenty of social history and economic experiments to develop something better than we've seen in the world so far. Personally I would like to see two different nations and live and do business in the conservative one.
 
It is not the money but the direction. Liberals and Conservatives want to go in opposite directions as they each believe their path is good for the whole. To demonize each other is dishonest and petty, roughly half the country is equally divided with each side not understanding the other.

Nah its more 60:40... that's what the demographics say. And that's why conservatives for 30 years have tried to reduce the number of voters turning out. Don't believe me? look at the demographics at http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/how_groups_voted/voted_84.html http://www.ropercenter.uconn.edu/elections/how_groups_voted/voted_08.html


Personally I would like to see two different nations and live and do business in the conservative one.
But then how are you going to deal with the Below Average Per Capita GDP production, and the lack fo subsidies from blue States? I'm asking tha seriously:


And what do you do with someplace like Texas where currently the minority has Gerrymandered the districts so the majority cannot win enough seats to control the government. But that will change in 4-5 years simply because of demographics.

Does texas then leave the failing Conservative States of the Union and joing the United States? See the real issue is that liberals DO understand conservatives. We really do. I could predict what you are likley to say in any given post well enough that were I a good enough writer to change writing styles, I could write your posts for you.

I don't think you could do the same with me. See BD, I UNDERSTAND how you actually think. But I don't think the revers is true.


BTW one other problem with your view is that if you do a county by county breakdown of red vs. blue weighted by population... there is no such clean Red/Blue divide. rather its an artificact of "first past the post" voting rules Check out this population by county weighted cartogram That's what the USA looks like in terms of Red/Blue when done at a more granular level. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~mejn/election/2008/ (the second image shows how it looked at the state level) So you can't really do what you want to do without disenfranchising a lot of blue voters. And remember they tend to be the productive types so if you evict them to the coasts... the red inerior just dies.

countycartpurple512.jpgstatemapredbluer512.jpg
 
My belated response to Jen:

1. Focused on the economy instead of the health care thing.

First, as I posted above, he did focus on the economy first and foremost. If you think he should have done so to the total exclusion of health care (notwithstanding the solid argument that focusing on health care was a form of focusing on the economy), I'll defer to Krugman, whose response puts it better than I can:

The whole focus on “focus” is, as I see it, an act of intellectual cowardice — a way to criticize President Obama’s record without explaining what you would have done differently. After all, are people who say that Mr. Obama should have focused on the economy saying that he should have pursued a bigger stimulus package? Are they saying that he should have taken a tougher line with the banks? If not, what are they saying? That he should have walked around with furrowed brow muttering, “I’m focused, I’m focused”?... And pretty much without fail, the “focus” types are also people who opposed or dismiss the notion of stimulus. So what do they mean? As I said, it’s intellectual cowardice.

2. Refrained from adding regulation after regulation regarding things that didn't need regulating at this moment (environmental stuff).

I haven't seen any attempt to show that any Obama-era regulations, environmental or otherwise, have had a meaningful negative impact on GDP growth or job creation, or anything else. Which regulations, in particular, do you think hurt? I've been following his environmental regulations, but, for the most part, he seems to have either withdrawn his own rules or delayed their implementation, just in case they might hurt the economy:

http://abcnews.go.com/blogs/politic...s-environmental-rules-citing-business-burden/
http://www.washingtonpost.com/natio...mental-rules/2012/02/07/gIQAvJzx8Q_story.html

So, I'm curious what regulations, in particular, you think have been in force that have been hurting job creation. If you can cite a new regulation that's actually been in force, we can check the theory, easily enough, by comparing the trend lines for overall job creation vs. the trendlines in the industries expected to be most impacted by the regulation, using BLS numbers.

For example, let's say you cite an environmental regulation that you think would make oil and gas extraction less profitable, hurting job creation in that area. To test that theory, we could compare overall job creation to job creation in the oil and gas extraction industry. If your theory were right, we'd expect to find job creation within that industry trailing overall job creation, right? In reality, the opposite is true. If you compare current jobs numbers to numbers at the end of 2009 (which is a decent baseline, since presumably Obama's policies took a while to take effect on the job market), overall job creation has been 3.08%, versus 26.56% in the oil and gas extraction industries.

That makes sense, of course, when you take a step back and recall that Obama's image (among conservatives) as an environmental zealot is largely unearned. In fact, the one Obama-era decision that, in retrospect, looks like a Bush-style royal screw-up, was when Obama publicly came out in favor of allowing deep-water oil drilling, just days before such drilling resulted in the biggest environmental disaster in US history.

3. Not even fought with Congress about extending Bush tax cuts. They just needed to be extended due to the state of the economy.

That's a funny criticism. It amounts to "sure, Obama did exactly what we thought he should do, but it didn't have the effect we thought it would have because he argued with us about doing it, before caving." So, for conservative economic policies to work, they don't just need to be implemented, they have to be implemented without any fight. Wow.

Look, there's no reason at all to think extending those tax cuts was a good idea, economically. The tax cuts had been an economic disaster in the first place (they were sold as a big job creator, and yet were followed by a long era of badly sub-par job creation, coupled with massive deficit growth). And, given the nature of the current economy, there's no reason at all to think they've helped with the recovery. The wealthy are sitting on tons of money, right now, but not using it to create jobs, because there's insufficient consumer demand to justify that kind of investment. Extending tax cuts that give the vast majority of their benefit to the wealthy just increases the height of the piles of money those rich people are sitting on, with no significant benefit. We'd have done better to emulate FDR, who hiked taxes sharply on the rich and used the money for government jobs creation programs. By this point in FDR's presidency, we'd had tremendous job creation and GDP growth.

4. Not invested in Green companies with our tax money (Solyndra) in order to make a green transition at the worst time.

Wouldn't this, in fact, be the BEST time for a transition? Right now we have severely under-utilized capacity (lots of skilled workers without jobs, lots of infrastructure and resources going idle). In a strong economy, we might figure the best thing is to ride the wave while there was time, whereas in a weak economy, we have a breather during which to get some long-postponed things done that seem less pressing when we're busier. To put it in simple terms, the time to repaint the gridlines in football isn't in the middle of a game, it's when nobody's using the field. And, similarly, the government's cost of capital is at an ALL TIME LOW right now. If we wait and borrow money to invest in a transition to green energy when the economy is stronger, we'll pay a lot more for that money than now, with interest rates for the government near zero. So, why wait and compete for capital, labor, and other resources during a strong economy, when all those things will be in demand elsewhere, when we can get far more bang for our buck, today, and also create extra economic activity at a time when it's particularly needed?

5. He should have urged/ encouraged his ALL Democratic House came up with a good budget that everyone could sign off on that would show us a direction to get our economy back on track.

Can you cite ANY president, in the history of this nation, or any head of state in the history of ANY nation on earth, who has EVER come up with a budget that "everyone could sign off on"? You're saying Obama should have done something that, as far as I'm aware, nobody has ever accomplished in all of political history. Aren't your standards, maybe, a bit high?
 
My belated response to Jen:

Can you cite ANY president, in the history of this nation, or any head of state in the history of ANY nation on earth, who has EVER come up with a budget that "everyone could sign off on"? You're saying Obama should have done something that, as far as I'm aware, nobody has ever accomplished in all of political history. Aren't your standards, maybe, a bit high?



Damn Arkady,

I like this line. It sums up the fact that the only pronounced fact of Republican intentions since 2008
has been the one term Presidency of Barrack Obama, culminating with his defeat in 2011. In 1863 people bet against Lincoln, but the capture of Atlanta, secured his relection, despite the fact that monied Republican interests, were against his reelection. Well can you blame those dependent on cotton and trade generated by Southern Planters (btw many were democrats at that point as well) from wanting access to their most profitable trade items. Goods bought cheap from slave labor and sold at high profit on a deprived European market. When they realized after Atlanta that there was going to be even more opportunity for profit, they changed their tunes. All of a sudden, conquest rather than compromise was the tune of the day. It only goes to prove that Money is loyal only to itself. As you well know I am neither a socialist nor a communist, but I am a realist.

I forget who it was that once said, "the purpose of money is to make more of it." Sound like the Romney platform ?

Tai Pan

Ah yes,
 
Back
Top