Arkady
President
I don't expect intelligent discussion of this from conservatives, so I'm directing it specifically at liberals. What went wrong with the Obamacare website? Has anyone followed it closely enough to have a feel for it?
I mean, it's not like the concept itself is unworkable: we have plenty of other working exchanges at the state level, including an extremely large one in California. Those state exchanges are mostly working with no more glitches than you'd expect for any complicated IS system. Nor was this the product of some sort of overly ambitious schedule -- the delay between passage of the law and opening of the website was considerably longer than a similar period when Massachusetts did pretty much the exact same thing at the state level (and Massachusetts didn't have a prior roll-out to learn from). So this isn't a failure driven by the extreme difficulty of the task. It seems like it must, then, have something to do with mis-management.
Although I think most of the criticisms of Obama, in relation to Affordable Care, are ideologically driven partisan horseshit, the fact remains that the website rollout was a very conspicuous belly flop, and I'd like to have a better idea of why. Was the wrong contractor used? If so, why was it selected? Were there ill-considered mid-stream adjustments? Active resistance by the private insurers (and, if so, why wasn't this highlighted early enough to scare them into line)? Was there insufficient oversight of the processes?
I have my own suspicions, just based on my personal experience with large IS-system roll-outs in the private sector, and what I've heard generally about management style within the Obama adminstration. I suspect that Obama laid out a vision then failed to get the dirt under his fingernails that would be needed to make sure that vision became a reality on time, and on-budget. But, I have no specific evidence to back that up, in the context of this particular screw-up, so I'm curious to hear from those who have studied it more closely.
I mean, it's not like the concept itself is unworkable: we have plenty of other working exchanges at the state level, including an extremely large one in California. Those state exchanges are mostly working with no more glitches than you'd expect for any complicated IS system. Nor was this the product of some sort of overly ambitious schedule -- the delay between passage of the law and opening of the website was considerably longer than a similar period when Massachusetts did pretty much the exact same thing at the state level (and Massachusetts didn't have a prior roll-out to learn from). So this isn't a failure driven by the extreme difficulty of the task. It seems like it must, then, have something to do with mis-management.
Although I think most of the criticisms of Obama, in relation to Affordable Care, are ideologically driven partisan horseshit, the fact remains that the website rollout was a very conspicuous belly flop, and I'd like to have a better idea of why. Was the wrong contractor used? If so, why was it selected? Were there ill-considered mid-stream adjustments? Active resistance by the private insurers (and, if so, why wasn't this highlighted early enough to scare them into line)? Was there insufficient oversight of the processes?
I have my own suspicions, just based on my personal experience with large IS-system roll-outs in the private sector, and what I've heard generally about management style within the Obama adminstration. I suspect that Obama laid out a vision then failed to get the dirt under his fingernails that would be needed to make sure that vision became a reality on time, and on-budget. But, I have no specific evidence to back that up, in the context of this particular screw-up, so I'm curious to hear from those who have studied it more closely.