New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

rare con honesty

I see that Andrew Sullivan was asked to list what he got wrong about Iraq for the five year anniversary of the invasion, and since I was as big a war booster as anyone, I thought I would list what I got wrong:
Everything.
And I don’t say that to provide people with an easy way to beat up on me, but I do sort of have to face facts. I was wrong about everything.
I was wrong about the Doctrine of Pre-emptive warfare.
I was wrong about Iraq possessing WMD.
I was wrong about Scott Ritter and the inspections.
I was wrong about the UN involvement in weapons inspections.
I was wrong about the containment sanctions.
I was wrong about the broader impact of the war on the Middle East.
I was wrong about this making us more safe.
I was wrong about the number of troops needed to stabilize Iraq.
I was wrong when I stated this administration had a clear plan for the aftermath.
I was wrong about securing the ammunition dumps.
I was wrong about the ease of bringing democracy to the Middle East.
I was wrong about dissolving the Iraqi army.
I was wrong about the looting being unimportant.
I was wrong that Bush/Cheney were competent.
I was wrong that we would be greeted as liberators.
I was wrong to make fun of the anti-war protestors.
I was wrong not to trust the dirty smelly hippies.
I mean, I could go down the list and continue on, but you get the point. I was wrong about EVERY. GOD. DAMNED. THING. It is amazing I could tie my shoes in 2001-2004. If you took all the wrongness I generated, put it together and compacted it and processed it, there would be enough concentrated stupid to fuel three hundred years of Weekly Standard journals. I am not sure how I snapped out of it, but I think Abu Ghraib and the negative impact of the insurgency did sober me up a bit.
War should always be an absolute last resort, not just another option. I will never make the same mistakes again
John Cole, ex-con, new human
 
I see that Andrew Sullivan was asked to list what he got wrong about Iraq for the five year anniversary of the invasion, and since I was as big a war booster as anyone, I thought I would list what I got wrong:
Everything.
And I don’t say that to provide people with an easy way to beat up on me, but I do sort of have to face facts. I was wrong about everything.
I was wrong about the Doctrine of Pre-emptive warfare.
I was wrong about Iraq possessing WMD.
I was wrong about Scott Ritter and the inspections.
I was wrong about the UN involvement in weapons inspections.
I was wrong about the containment sanctions.
I was wrong about the broader impact of the war on the Middle East.
I was wrong about this making us more safe.
I was wrong about the number of troops needed to stabilize Iraq.
I was wrong when I stated this administration had a clear plan for the aftermath.
I was wrong about securing the ammunition dumps.
I was wrong about the ease of bringing democracy to the Middle East.
I was wrong about dissolving the Iraqi army.
I was wrong about the looting being unimportant.
I was wrong that Bush/Cheney were competent.
I was wrong that we would be greeted as liberators.
I was wrong to make fun of the anti-war protestors.
I was wrong not to trust the dirty smelly hippies.
I mean, I could go down the list and continue on, but you get the point. I was wrong about EVERY. GOD. DAMNED. THING. It is amazing I could tie my shoes in 2001-2004. If you took all the wrongness I generated, put it together and compacted it and processed it, there would be enough concentrated stupid to fuel three hundred years of Weekly Standard journals. I am not sure how I snapped out of it, but I think Abu Ghraib and the negative impact of the insurgency did sober me up a bit.
War should always be an absolute last resort, not just another option. I will never make the same mistakes again
John Cole, ex-con, new human

A brilliant and humble confession. It's just sad more former hawks haven't been as merciless with themselves in identifying the nature and extent of their errors. Only by facing how horribly they screwed up can they make sure that they won't ever make the same mistakes again.
 
I'm sorry, but there's really no excuse for so many, being so wrong. The most common self-apologia we hear, was that people feel that they "were lied to". But c'mon, these people saw the exact same case being made, as I did. That cas was absolutely pathetic, on all counts. The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Post 9/11, the American people felt a desperate need to blow someone - something - to smithereens.
 
I'm sorry, but there's really no excuse for so many, being so wrong. The most common self-apologia we hear, was that people feel that they "were lied to". But c'mon, these people saw the exact same case being made, as I did. That cas was absolutely pathetic, on all counts. The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Post 9/11, the American people felt a desperate need to blow someone - something - to smithereens.
Yes, fair, i remember and you do to, even from the old fray, we were always against that war(and if you remember I was against Serbia bombing as well, alwasy thought and still think that Kosovo their 1000 year old original territory were serbs lived, only populated about 100 years ago by Albanians)
But I am willing to cut a slack to those who sincerely regret the mistake about Iraq war
 
A brilliant and humble confession. It's just sad more former hawks haven't been as merciless with themselves in identifying the nature and extent of their errors. Only by facing how horribly they screwed up can they make sure that they won't ever make the same mistakes again.

and if only that was not related to the war only, they can use some confession about their total wrongness on economy as well
 
I'm sorry, but there's really no excuse for so many, being so wrong. The most common self-apologia we hear, was that people feel that they "were lied to". But c'mon, these people saw the exact same case being made, as I did. That cas was absolutely pathetic, on all counts. The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Post 9/11, the American people felt a desperate need to blow someone - something - to smithereens.

I suspect you read newspaper articles in their entirety and/or sought out information on the internet. People who only read newspaper headlines or got their news from TV--particularly Fox News viewers, who were notoriously misinformed about Iraq's alleged WMD and ties to 9/11--may well have later learned that they were lied to. Of course it's their own fault for accepting sound bites uncritically ... the tragedy is that apparently so few of them learned their lesson.
 
Hah!...a number of things from back then, pop into my head. But, I think my favorite was when Sec. of State Powell showed the U.N. a crayon picture of a "mobile weapons lab", that looked like it was drawn by my 6-year old grandson.

C'mon...we all know that the Li'l Georgieans were desperate to go to war, and we all know how desperate they were to make their case for their war. In situations like that, one brings his BEST case to the table. And...if your "best case" is a kid's drawing?.....your case obviously ain't worth shit.
 
Denial is NOT a river in Africa, but possibly a serious affliction and not just for substance abusers.

We're all vulnerable to it, but that vulnerability does not wipe the truth out of existence.

In short, where two positions contradict one another, where does the truth lie? Is one position not the truth or "wrong", totally or partially? If one position is "wrong" or not the truth, does that automatically the contradictory position "right", "correct" or the truth?

There is the current position of some that resistance to the Iraq War, then and now, was because of hate for GWB and had nothing to do with any validity or merit to the reasons for resistance to it. Some of the same seem to believe their resistance to nearly anything Mr. Obama proposes or does as no different than how they saw resistance to the Bush administration.

Rarely do we see discussion of where the thread of truth might lie regardless of contradictory or opposing positions. There is my side, there is someone else's side and there is the "truth". The question we might all ask is how much of our own positions align with the "truth" and why, how much of our own positions do not have strong evidence to back them up as "truth" or what is more likely to be determined to be the "truth".

What the "truth" is or how it might be defined is a whole other discussion and debate, but we might view the truth of that which proves to be valid, especially in the longer term. Whether there is any such thing as "absolute truth" and who or what becomes the ultimate judge of that.

Having heard Colin Powell's "evidence" about WMD in Iraq, I wasn't convinced then that is was something that rose to the level of a need for a military invasion and an expenditure of 2 trillion dollars and more Amercian lives lost than were lost on 9-11-01.

I heard Dr. David Kay speak about his being totally convinced there were WMD's in Iraq at the time we invaded. It was interesting to hear him speak and admit how wrong he was after heading up the first ISG and resigning from that.
 
yep, I just read that over there dude

that was awful big of him, and something all those in the so-called "liberal" media need to do as well.
 
The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Someone mentioned yesterday that if Blair hadn't signed on, neither would the American people or Congress have done so. I think that's a very valid point. The so-called coalition was a knee slapping joke without him. I hope little Georgie enjoyed the British blow job.
 
The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Someone mentioned yesterday that if Blair hadn't signed on, neither would the American people or Congress have done so. I think that's a very valid point. The so-called coalition was a knee slapping joke without him. I hope little Georgie enjoyed the British blow job.

In the 1991 Gulf War, there was a lot more participation by a wider spectrum of not just industrialized nations, but Arab nations as well. Many or most of them did not sign up this time because most of them did not see the evidence that justified the use of military force. That was also evident in the UN Security Council's lack of support for a resolution drafted and introduced by Spain, Britain and the U.S. that would have authorized the use of force in Iraq. I think Blair's support of U.S. unilateralist lead came from a pledge on 9-11-01 by Blair to back the U.S. in bringing the culprits of 9-11 to justice. Kinda like the pledge nations made to Jews around the world to prevent a repeat of the Pograms, discrimination and ultimately a Holocaust and all the dynamics that led up to them. Unfortunately, some people have seen that as an opportunity to do bad things and not be held accountable for them. Whether Blair was in cahoots with GWB or simply standing by his pledge from 9-11, history will reveal more as time goes on. It may be a bit of both. Making such a pledge on 9-11-01 put Blair in the position of being vulnerable to being pressured by Bush to join in to support the invasion of Iraq. Whether that was the case, I don't know.

A fair number of other nations in the "coalition" contributed relatively small numbers of troops, some of them almost in proportion to their size, but there appeared to be a rag tag bunch that may have received generous "packages" of aid or some sort of financial assistance in exchange for their "signing on".

It's little wonder that in subsequent years, there was a real effort to demonize the UN as pariahs for not bowing to the "Great and Powerful".

Anyone remember "Freedom Fries"? Interesting, considering not just the Statue of Liberty and all the immigrants to this nation it has greeted, but Gilbert du Motier, Marquis de Lafayette, his role and the role of French support during the American Revolutionary War.
 
these people saw the exact same case being made, as I did. That cas was absolutely pathetic, on all counts. The main reason people fell for that con job, was because they desperately WANTED to fall for it.

Post 9/11, the American people felt a desperate need to blow someone - something - to smithereens.

I agree, Fair.
 
Of course it's their own fault for accepting sound bites uncritically ... the tragedy is that apparently so few of them learned their lesson.

Too true, ETR. You can see the same thing playing out in the last two elections, the dialog on political boards and all around us.
 
Kinda like the pledge nations made to Jews around the world to prevent a repeat of the Pograms, discrimination and ultimately a Holocaust and all the dynamics that led up to them. Unfortunately, some people have seen that as an opportunity to do bad things and not be held accountable for them.

Those whose progenitors were once victims have become the perpetrators.
 
Cheney/Bush/Fox "NEWS"/Major Media had successully convinced the gullibles in America to invade. Britain GUBMENT signing on was just a bit more ammo and really more to PREVENT embarrassment if they didn't sign on. For afterall the so called coalition was an embarrassing assembly if you didn't have Britain.

Republicans really have blood on their hands with the IRAQ / NO WMD / Trillions spents, hundreds of thousands dead and wounded fiasco all based on crafted LIES from their brain trust lead by Dick Cheney. They orchestrated the propaganda and need to be charged with War Crimes.

Blatant. Clear case of war criminals directing the US military into a tragic and horrific crime.
 
Crickets from the right. Go figure. Where are our resident gay bashers? I figured at least they would have something to say about Sullivan never being a real con.
 
Denial is NOT a river in Africa, but possibly a serious affliction and not just for substance abusers.

We're all vulnerable to it, but that vulnerability does not wipe the truth out of existence.

In short, where two positions contradict one another, where does the truth lie? Is one position not the truth or "wrong", totally or partially? If one position is "wrong" or not the truth, does that automatically the contradictory position "right", "correct" or the truth?

There is the current position of some that resistance to the Iraq War, then and now, was because of hate for GWB and had nothing to do with any validity or merit to the reasons for resistance to it. Some of the same seem to believe their resistance to nearly anything Mr. Obama proposes or does as no different than how they saw resistance to the Bush administration.

Rarely do we see discussion of where the thread of truth might lie regardless of contradictory or opposing positions. There is my side, there is someone else's side and there is the "truth". The question we might all ask is how much of our own positions align with the "truth" and why, how much of our own positions do not have strong evidence to back them up as "truth" or what is more likely to be determined to be the "truth".

What the "truth" is or how it might be defined is a whole other discussion and debate, but we might view the truth of that which proves to be valid, especially in the longer term. Whether there is any such thing as "absolute truth" and who or what becomes the ultimate judge of that.

Having heard Colin Powell's "evidence" about WMD in Iraq, I wasn't convinced then that is was something that rose to the level of a need for a military invasion and an expenditure of 2 trillion dollars and more Amercian lives lost than were lost on 9-11-01.

I heard Dr. David Kay speak about his being totally convinced there were WMD's in Iraq at the time we invaded. It was interesting to hear him speak and admit how wrong he was after heading up the first ISG and resigning from that.

Knot, you remind me of a fascinating piece I read prior to the commencement of Li'l George's Debacle. I wish I could remember its author...but, I can't.

Anyway, this writer went step-by-step through Saddam's "career" as Iraq's dictator, from the beginning to the then-current. He didn't just document Saddam's actions, he posited Saddam's reasoning behind those acts. In some cases, his reasoning could be described as "shrewd". In others, it was foolish. Nevertheless, he did whatever he did, for a reason in each case.

But, we were being told that Saddam was an insane mad man. It was a fool's mission to try figuring him out or predicting what he might do next. He might do absolutely anything at any minute, and there was absolutely nothing he wouldn't do!

To me then..trying to put myself in Saddam's head, it never made sense that Saddam would actually have stockpiles of WMD. In terms of the "game" he was playing with Li'l George at the time, NOT having them in the end, made way more sense than having them. Now some might ask why - if this is the case - Saddam continued to play a bit of a cat 'n' mouse game with the inspectors. He did it partly because it makes sense for a rogue nation to at least hint that it has chemical/biological weapons in order to forestall attack. Even more so though, he did it to bait Li'l George.

I don't think Saddam seriously believed that Li'l George would be SO stupid, as to invade Iraq. Saddam saw this "game" playing out differently. In the end, Saddam lost the game - as did we all. And in the end, Saddam's biggest mistake was in assuming that the American President AND the American people, were smarter than they were.
 
Yes, fair, i remember and you do to, even from the old fray, we were always against that war(and if you remember I was against Serbia bombing as well, alwasy thought and still think that Kosovo their 1000 year old original territory were serbs lived, only populated about 100 years ago by Albanians)
But I am willing to cut a slack to those who sincerely regret the mistake about Iraq war

Yuri...Yes I DO remember that we never came to a meeting of the minds, around Kosova. But, our disagreement went more to the righteousness of the "cause", than how the effort was conducted. Lookit it this way..What if we were to hypothesize that driving the Serbs out of Kosova WAS a righteous cause. Wouldn't agree that Clinton went about it the "right' way? He state the "cause" and the "goal", and he accomplished them in a then-historically efficient manner.

And, as I suggest elsewhere in this forum - in retrospect - I recognize that that's pretty much what "Old George" did in terms of "The Gulf War".

Li'l George's Iraq Debacle was completely different. In that one, they initially lied as to the cause, and then "evolved" the cause over the next several years, to whatever suited them at the time. They NEVER innunciated a specific goal. And, they sure as HELL didn't wrap the whole thing up in the <90 days that Dick/George/Rummy lied that they would.
 
Except for Bill Kristol, Charles Krauthammer, and....Dino :)....

NOBODY wants to be a Neo-con anymore. That's pretty good news, huh?
 
Yuri...Yes I DO remember that we never came to a meeting of the minds, around Kosova. But, our disagreement went more to the righteousness of the "cause", than how the effort was conducted..

That's true, we were not discussing the way to go about it, but should this thing be ever done to begin with.
As far as the way the operation was conducted, sure beats the failed invasion of Iraq and multitude deaths and lost treasure
 
Back
Top