New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Reading Comprehension

Dumber than a post. A lot of them.
Those that are either flunk out, quit or, if they have wealthy parents, become perpetual college students working on their PhD in basket weaving or navel contemplation.

FWIW, I'm completely against Bernie Sanders' plan to make all college education "free" by raising taxes. It's idiotic ideas like his which have already jacked up the cost of college that many folks can't afford to go.
 
When readers have responded to my posts in a way that shows they didn't follow the argument, I've simply urged them to reread. This hasn't worked. People don't like to admit they have poor reading comprehension skills, and so it takes a lot of pride-swallowing to go back and reread a piece and then admit your hot take was based on a misunderstanding of the person's argument. But I'm not sure what the alternative is.

I try to write simply, and one of the reasons I'm so long-winded is that I will come at the same point from three or four directions, to try to make sure people get it. I'll also couch my points in layers of caveats to preempt the most obvious likely misreadings. My posts include a lot of superfluous "I'm not saying" sentences, that are only there because I know some careless or unskilled readers would otherwise assume that's exactly what I'm saying. The more I try to "idiot-proof" what I write, that way, the longer it gets, and the more I risk something being misread simply because people resort to skimming.

I bring this up here because I think poor reading comprehension isn't just a problem on this forum -- I think it's a problem with the American political system generally. Over 50% of students at four-year colleges lack the literacy skills needed to perform complex literacy tasks like understanding the arguments of a newspaper editorial:

http://www.nbcnews.com/id/10928755/...ollege-literacy-levels-sobering/#.VknaT3arTcu

Only about 13% of American adults can handle prose at a "proficient" level:

https://nces.ed.gov/naal/kf_demographics.asp

This helps to explain why people on forums like this react to postings in a way that shows they've identified what general side of the culture war someone is on, but not the details of his argument. And that is why they're left vaguely venting their emotions against the person, or blindly shooting off-topic talking points at him, rather than trying to rebut the substance. I think it also helps to explain the success of politicians who specialize in generically invoking an us-versus-them emotional response. And it explains why conservative and liberal movements just talk right past each other. I'm not sure how we fix the educational system without fixing our politics, but it may be impossible to fix our politics without first fixing our educational system. We'll just keep talking past each other, with over 50% of the participants in the national dialogue not even comprehending the arguments.

so to sum up . . .

you're a genius, and anyone who thinks your not has poor reading comprehension.

no wonder you have no friends
 
I can't win either way. Long posts play poorly with the lazy while short posts play poorly with the stupid. So, in each case, I need to decide which group of posters to leave behind.
If you're really smart you can get across what you need to say in brevity.
 
When readers have responded to my posts in a way that shows they didn't follow the argument, I've simply urged them to reread. This hasn't worked. People don't like to admit they have poor reading comprehension skills, and so it takes a lot of pride-swallowing to go back and reread a piece and then admit your hot take was based on a misunderstanding of the person's argument. But I'm not sure what the alternative is.

I try to write simply, and one of the reasons I'm so long-winded is that I will come at the same point from three or four directions, to try to make sure people get it. I'll also couch my points in layers of caveats to preempt the most obvious likely misreadings. My posts include a lot of superfluous "I'm not saying" sentences, that are only there because I know some careless or unskilled readers would otherwise assume that's exactly what I'm saying. The more I try to "idiot-proof" what I write, that way, the longer it gets, and the more I risk something being misread simply because people resort to skimming.

I bring this up here because I think poor reading comprehension isn't just a problem on this forum -- I think it's a problem with the American political system generally. Over 50% of students at four-year colleges lack the literacy skills needed to perform complex literacy tasks like understanding the arguments of a newspaper editorial:

http://www.nbcnews.com/id/10928755/...ollege-literacy-levels-sobering/#.VknaT3arTcu

Only about 13% of American adults can handle prose at a "proficient" level:

https://nces.ed.gov/naal/kf_demographics.asp

This helps to explain why people on forums like this react to postings in a way that shows they've identified what general side of the culture war someone is on, but not the details of his argument. And that is why they're left vaguely venting their emotions against the person, or blindly shooting off-topic talking points at him, rather than trying to rebut the substance. I think it also helps to explain the success of politicians who specialize in generically invoking an us-versus-them emotional response. And it explains why conservative and liberal movements just talk right past each other. I'm not sure how we fix the educational system without fixing our politics, but it may be impossible to fix our politics without first fixing our educational system. We'll just keep talking past each other, with over 50% of the participants in the national dialogue not even comprehending the arguments.

Does it EVER occur to you that people might simply DISAGREE with your point of view, no matter HOW you "couch your points"?

Good grief...
 
So, in each case, I need to decide which group of posters to leave behind.

I'll volunteer...any f'kn black sicko that get's a rise out of the Memphis City Council voting to dig up the bones of a white confederate general that have been in the ground for 125 years is not someone I' m inclined to look to for intelligent input anyway.
 
Does it EVER occur to you that people might simply DISAGREE with your point of view, no matter HOW you "couch your points"?

Good grief...
Sometimes people do. I'm referring here, instead, to instances where a person's post makes it clear he or she isn't trying to counter a specific point I made, but rather that he or she has misunderstood what I wrote.
 
Why is this in Politics and Current Events?
Appears General Discussions would be proper place, of course as all can see this diatribe is allowed to remain...........
It's in "politics" because I'm offering a theory as to what is wrong with our nation's politics. If you were better at reading, you'd probably have spotted that.
 
There are 807,361 words in the Bible. Must have been written by an idiot, right?

Funny.

High word counts clearly indicate a poor mind...:cool:


206,052 – Moby Dick – Herman Melville
208,773 – Midnight’s Children – Salman Rushdie
211,591 – Crime and Punishment – Fyodor Dostoyevsky
216,020 – The Amazing Adventures of Kavelier and Clay – Chabon, Michael
225,395 – East of Eden – John Steinbeck
236,061 – A Prayer for Owen Meany – John Irving
257,154 – Order of the Phoenix – JK Rowling
260,742 – Cloudsplitter – Banks, Russell
311,596 – The Fountainhead – Ayn Rand
316,059 – Middlemarch – George Eliot
349,736 – Anna Karenina – Leo Tolstoy
364,153 – The Brothers Karamazov – Fyodor Dostoyevsky
365,712 – Lonesome Dove – McMurtry, Larry
418,053 – Gone with the Wind – Margaret Mitchell
455,125 – The Lord of the Rings – J. R. R. Tolkien
561,996 – Atlas Shrugged – Ayn Rand
587,287 – War and Peace – Leo Tolstoy
591,554 – A Suitable Boy – Vikram Seth

http://commonplacebook.com/culture/literature/books/word-count-for-famous-novels/
 
I just admitted that sometimes people simply disagree with my point. So, either I'm not narcissistic or you're wrong about the result of narcissism.
Or you're wrong and I'm correct. After all, why post a "Look at Me!" thread in the political discussion thread. Why post, in effect, either you agree with me or you can't read?
 
Funny.

High word counts clearly indicate a poor mind...:cool:


206,052 – Moby Dick – Herman Melville
208,773 – Midnight’s Children – Salman Rushdie
211,591 – Crime and Punishment – Fyodor Dostoyevsky
216,020 – The Amazing Adventures of Kavelier and Clay – Chabon, Michael
225,395 – East of Eden – John Steinbeck
236,061 – A Prayer for Owen Meany – John Irving
257,154 – Order of the Phoenix – JK Rowling
260,742 – Cloudsplitter – Banks, Russell
311,596 – The Fountainhead – Ayn Rand
316,059 – Middlemarch – George Eliot
349,736 – Anna Karenina – Leo Tolstoy
364,153 – The Brothers Karamazov – Fyodor Dostoyevsky
365,712 – Lonesome Dove – McMurtry, Larry
418,053 – Gone with the Wind – Margaret Mitchell
455,125 – The Lord of the Rings – J. R. R. Tolkien
561,996 – Atlas Shrugged – Ayn Rand
587,287 – War and Peace – Leo Tolstoy
591,554 – A Suitable Boy – Vikram Seth

http://commonplacebook.com/culture/literature/books/word-count-for-famous-novels/
Yep. Not just fiction, either. Plato's Republic, about politics, has over 88,000 words. Aquinas's Summa Theologica has over 143,000. Gibbon's Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire is around 3,700 PAGES. Ben Franklin spends 144 pages on his Autobiography and only makes it to the late 1750s, thus completely missing his time in France, the Continental Congress, the Revolutionary War, the Constitutional Convention, etc.

Even smart people need lots of words to make detailed or nuanced arguments in a convincing way.
 
Or you're wrong and I'm correct. After all, why post a "Look at Me!" thread in the political discussion thread. Why post, in effect, either you agree with me or you can't read?
That's not what I posted. But, I'm glad you brought that up. It's a really strong example of the phenomenon I mentioned. I anticipated the poor reading skills of people like you and made my reason for putting this in a political forum express, rather than relying on everyone being bright enough to figure out the reason from implicit evidence:

I bring this up here because I think poor reading comprehension isn't just a problem on this forum -- I think it's a problem with the American political system generally.
​
Yet, even when I explain exactly why I posted here, in express terms, I'm left with weak readers asking why I did it. With nigh-illiterate readers, what can a person do? I try hard to idiot-proof my posts, but idiocy will find a way.
 
Yep. Not just fiction, either. Plato's Republic, about politics, has over 88,000 words. Aquinas's Summa Theologica has over 143,000. Gibbon's Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire is around 3,700 PAGES. Ben Franklin spends 144 pages on his Autobiography and only makes it to the late 1750s, thus completely missing his time in France, the Continental Congress, the Revolutionary War, the Constitutional Convention, etc.

Even smart people need lots of words to make detailed or nuanced arguments in a convincing way.

While you might think you're equal Plato, Gibbon's or Franklin, I think most people here will agree you are not. Just saying. ;)
 
That's not what I posted. But, I'm glad you brought that up. It's a really strong example of the phenomenon I mentioned. I anticipated the poor reading skills of people like you...<BULLSHIT SNIPPED>
If you were as smart as you think you are, you'd understand that what you take to be "poor reading skills" is simply people being annoyed by the bullshit spilling from a narcissistic stuffed shirt and moving on to something more entertaining.

If you were as smart as you think you are, you'd realize that people come to these forums primarily for entertainment, not long-winded lectures from a blowhard.

If you were as smart as you think you are, you'd realize that the art of persuasion is much more effective than telling people they are stupid, ignorant, less than you, etc.
 
While you might think you're equal Plato, Gibbon's or Franklin, I think most people here will agree you are not. Just saying. ;)
I wouldn't claim to be. Those examples are simply a proof of concept: the concept being that even very smart people sometimes require a lot of words to convey an idea.
 
Back
Top