New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Reality Check

I'm not either dude. I was providing an explanation, not a justification. I've long thought and argued that his apparent timidity and pisspoor negotiating skills in the past may well have more to do with his agreement in significant part with the "austerity" agenda, and that the timidity and incompetence on the negotiating front merely serve to provide cover for that, kinda the way Bush used incompetence to cover his criminality.

The TPer and all the other rightwingers intent with this kinda garbage however, is to use it as an indictment of the failures of liberalism/Keynes, when it is anything but. It is also of course, one of the reasons why their charges of socialist/Marxist/Commie against BHO are so stupid and/or dishonest.
Agreed entirely.

Sadly, the foremost Kynesian of our times, Paul Krugman, foresaw how this would go down. When the initial stimulus plan was proposed, he pointed out that it was MUCH too small, relative to what the models said was necessary and relative to what produced the strong rebound in the mid-1930s. And he pointed out that if the result was a weak rebound, the Republicans would use it as "proof" that Keynesianism had failed.
 
The economy is improving. Real GDP per capita is up. That's a simple, demonstrable fact. There's more money to go around than there was, even, at the height of the Clinton boom. It's just that ALL of that improvement has been captured by the very rich, and they've taken up enough extra that median incomes are falling and poverty is up. The problem isn't a lack of economic improvement. It's income distribution. The economy can double in size, but if the very rich take all that new wealth and then some, most people will get poorer. The math isn't hard to understand. Nor is the solution. We know how to lower income inequality. We had much lower income inequality in the Golden Age of American economics, when upper class taxes were much higher and government benefits for the working class were expanding.

One reason there is more money to go around is that the feds are printing it up like crazy. It's a bubble that will be very ugly when the feds quit the printing and it busts.
 
You want to talk about wealth redistribution when the topic was jobs....why am I not surprised?

The topic was broader than jobs, but let's talk about jobs.

Under Obama we have had 50 months in a row of private job growth, replacing the horrid monthly job loss conditions GWB left behind.

Remarkable, no?
 
Bush policies were not the best, but, where doing ok until 2006.............economy went to hell then.why?
are you kidding? You think all those mortgages went bad the same year they were written?

This started in 2003. The American Dreams Act was the first step. That was where the FHA started guaranteeing no-down mortgages. Then the Bush administration decided that allowing banks to go from 15::1 leverage to 40::1 leverage...Borrow $40 for every $1 in deposits. Once they made that decision....if their investments (where they put that borrowed money) dropped in value just 3% the bank was insolvent. Sounding familiar?

No, Bush's policies were not doing OK until 2006. More and more companies were taking out insurance policies (called default debt swaps) on those crappy investments. The number one source was AIG. Who was auditing AIG to make sure they had money to pay claims on those insurance policies? The Bush administration was....what could go wrong there? That is why AIG need $80 billion to keep all those banks from going down the crapper.

Sadly, this isn't the first time I've had to give you this history lesson....Get the movie "Inside Job". There is a lot of blame to go around....but you should attempt to inform yourself.
 
It's odd how some people still beat the drum that the economy is improving. Where are they getting that idea?

50 months in a row of economic growth, replacing the horrid GWB depression, will do that to those who like reality.

;-)
 
Six trillion of new baby-bottom pink debt is not a major expansion of government spending?

Don't you remember that the skimpy amount of 750 billion in stimulus back in 2009 was advertised by the criminals in charge as the advent of the Summer of Recovery 2009?

Or did that just slip your mind?
No. Of course not. What on earth would make you think rising debt has to be a sign of expanding government spending? Do you not know how debt works? Debt is the accumulated impact of deficits. Deficits are caused by a mismatch between revenues an spending. They can be caused by revenues growing too slowly or spending growing too quickly, or both. In the present case, spending grew at an EXTREMELY low pace. For the last five years, we had the slowest pace of spending growth since the end of WWII -- a pace that's a fraction of the norm. The rise in debt is despite that austerity. It's because revenues grew even more poorly, partly because of the second Bush recession, and partly because of very low tax rates (effective taxes hit a fifty-year low, as a share of GDP, in the Obama years).

The stimulus we got in 2009 was a small success: it turned an epic economic collapse (the worst since 1929) into an anemic recovery. But, as predicted by the Keynesians, it was far too small and poorly structured (giving a huge chunk of its "benefit" in the form of tax cuts, which did nothing to stimulate the economy, since the economic shortfall wasn't caused by a lack of capital, it was caused by a lack of demand).
 
So how much of other people money do you think you need?

I don't care how you put it, a 16 yr old working at a fast food restaurant should NOT be earning $15/hr. But libs think they deserve the best....forget about that thing of earning your way and working your way UP to that wealth!

I don't need any of it.

And if you like the massive wealth gap the way it is, or if you want it even wider, no poor or middle class people should get a bigger share of the pie.

What's your preference?
 
are you kidding? You think all those mortgages went bad the same year they were written?

This started in 2003. The American Dreams Act was the first step. That was where the FHA started guaranteeing no-down mortgages. Then the Bush administration decided that allowing banks to go from 15::1 leverage to 40::1 leverage...Borrow $40 for every $1 in deposits. Once they made that decision....if their investments (where they put that borrowed money) dropped in value just 3% the bank was insolvent. Sounding familiar?

No, Bush's policies were not doing OK until 2006. More and more companies were taking out insurance policies (called default debt swaps) on those crappy investments. The number one source was AIG. Who was auditing AIG to make sure they had money to pay claims on those insurance policies? The Bush administration was....what could go wrong there? That is why AIG need $80 billion to keep all those banks from going down the crapper.

Sadly, this isn't the first time I've had to give you this history lesson....Get the movie "Inside Job". There is a lot of blame to go around....but you should attempt to inform yourself.

Who was it that signed a Bill where NO DOWN PAYMENT NEEDED........it wasn't Bush..........what you posted is due to the Clinton-making banks loan to dead-beats......ya may fool some kids, but, no kids here in PJ..........
 
750,000 jobs a month would be 9,000,000 a year! Times that by 8 = a loss of 72,000,000 jobs! Wow.......wonder how that could be true when he had a GAIN of at least 1 million jobs by the end of his 8 yrs?

And there's this (where libs are trying to say how much Bush added to the deficit)...they need to stop adding what was already there from Clinton's terms....funny how you all try to say Clinton left a "surplus"....

Also, the total public debt stood at $5.7 trillion on Jan. 20, 2001, the date of Bush's inauguration. And when he left, the total debt was $10.6 trillion. That's a huge increase, to be sure. But to suggest Bush's policies were to blame for the entire $14.3 trillion debt ignores what happened before and after Bush's presidency.

This is some pretty good information here....but i doubt you'll take the time to read it...
http://www.factcheck.org/2011/08/reid-wrong-on-bushs-economic-record/

How many jobs were lost in December of 2008? (750,000). Nobody said that the job losses were 750,000 per month for Bush's entire administration.

You don't seem to understand the difference between the deficit and the debt. Take a class. You also don't seem to understand the federal budget, which runs from September to September. So to accurately account for Bush's spending you'd have to start on September 30, 2001 and go to September 30, 2009. From January 20, 2001 to September 30, 2001 was Clinton's budget.

Nobody said Bush was responsible for any more than the difference between the debt on Sept 30, 2001 to September 30, 2009....$5.9 trillion (12.31.2001) to $12.3 trillion (12.31.2009).

http://www.skymachines.com/US-National-Debt-Per-Capita-Percent-of-GDP-and-by-Presidental-Term.htm
 
No. Of course not. What on earth would make you think rising debt has to be a sign of expanding government spending?

Ohhh...so if our household debt goes up it's not because we spent too much.

Got it...thanks.
 
One reason there is more money to go around is that the feds are printing it up like crazy. It's a bubble that will be very ugly when the feds quit the printing and it busts.
No. Printing money can't increase real GDP per capita. The word "real" in that phrase means "inflation adjusted."

If real GDP per capita coul be raised that way, everyone would just print all the money they could all the time and we'd all be rich, with no need to ever stop the bubble. The reason that won't work is that if the money supply is increased too quickly, you get too many dollars chasing too few goods, which means rising inflation. Some inflation is good, especially during certain types of recessions. But lots of inflation is bad. But that's not relevant in this discussion. Money supply growth has not only not been enough to trigger high inflation, it hasn't even triggered NORMAL inflation levels. We've had some of the lowest inflation levels of the modern era, during the last several years.

Nor is the market predicting that'll change any time soon. Long-term interest rates remain low and the spread between inflation-protected treasuries and their non-inflation-protected equivalents remains small. Those things mean the smart money is betting on low inflation rates for the foreseeable future.

Right now, the 10-year Treasury pays 2.79 and the 10-year TIPS pays 0.66, meaning the market is betting inflation will average 2.13% over the next 10 years. That's a rate that's far below the average rate of inflation. And that's actually trended down in recent months. And the predicted average inflation rate over the next 20 years is only slightly higher: 2.30%

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?id=DFII10

The smart money could, of course, be wrong. But, if so, we're not talking about mis-valuing some obscure low-volume investment or novel type of security. We're talking treasuries here -- one of the best-understood, simplest, and highly-traded securities on the planet. So it's not something we'd expect to be subject to major miscalculations by the market. And the market is telling us that the Fed isn't printing too much money, becaus the market is saying we're going to have very little inflation for at least 20 years.
 
Who was it that signed a Bill where NO DOWN PAYMENT NEEDED........it wasn't Bush..........what you posted is due to the Clinton-making banks loan to dead-beats......ya may fool some kids, but, no kids here in PJ..........

The American Dream Act....passed by the repubs and signed by Bush. Took effect in 2003...2004 the FBI wrote a report that mortgage fraud had gone through the roof and was in danger of destabilizing the economy. As of 2003 the FHA guaranteed loans with a 3% down, but the bill provided a loan for the 3%...and it didn't count against household debt in calculating max mortgage payment. That was the start of federal guarantees for no down loans.....

The CRA did not change downpayment requirements. Why lie? Oh, I forgot who I was talking to.

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/108/s811
 
Last edited:
Ohhh...so if our household debt goes up it's not because we spent too much.

Got it...thanks.
Are you being deliberatelyobtuse? If our household debt goes up, it's because our spending was too much for our income, or because or income was too little for our spending. You could frame it either way.

Imagine that for many years, your household spending rose by an average of 5% per year. Then, over the course of five years, that increase dropped to just 1% per year -- not even enough to keep up with inflation. Yet your household debt went up, because your income dropped severely, due to a decision to work a lot fewer hours. Now, you can blame that on "too much spending." Or you can blame it on "too little working," as you see fit. But it's clear enough what the operative change was that triggered the debt increase.

That's analogous to our national situations. For the last five years, spending growth has been far below normal, and below what would be needed to keep up with inflation and population growth. Yet debt has risen, because income fell. You can see that as a spending problem, if you'd like, but spending growth actually moved pretty dramatically in a direction that would favor decreasing deficits, already. The difference-maker was the drop in revenues. And that is due to an anemic economy and ultra-low tax rates.

Since what the economy is suffering from is inadequate demand, spending more would actually help. We'd get the ball rolling, causing debt to drop rapidly as a share of GDP, the way it did during other boom times, making the debt less and less signficant to us over time. Or we can go the the other way and try to cut the spending deeper and deeper, causing a 1937-style recession, and hope eventually the economy corrects itself (which, over the very long term, it will). We know what works, but we can go with what we know doesn't work, instead, and wait this thing out. If we do, we'll have squandered a decade or two in the process.
 
The American Dream Act....passed by the repubs and signed by Bush. Took effect in 2003...2004 the FBI wrote a report that mortgage fraud had gone through the roof and was in danger of destabilizing the economy. As of 2003 the FHA guaranteed loans with a 3% down, but the bill provided a loan for the 3%...and it didn't count against household debt in calculating max mortgage payment. That was the start of federal guarantees for no down loans.....

The CRA did not change downpayment requirements. Why lie? Oh, I forgot who I was talking to.

lmfao.........no.....I was posting of the CRA that Slick signed.........where Banks were made to offer loan to those that didn't/couldn't qualify for home-loans........many made off with second mortgages of $60,000+ and destroyed the homes they bought due to Slicks CRA............I'm aware you want to act stupidly...it's what liberal converts do best..............☻
 
Are you being deliberatelyobtuse? If our household debt goes up, it's because our spending was too much for our income, or because or income was too little for our spending. You could frame it either way.

Imagine that for many years, your household spending rose by an average of 5% per year. Then, over the course of five years, that increase dropped to just 1% per year -- not even enough to keep up with inflation. Yet your household debt went up, because your income dropped severely, due to a decision to work a lot fewer hours. Now, you can blame that on "too much spending." Or you can blame it on "too little working," as you see fit. But it's clear enough what the operative change was that triggered the debt increase.

That's analogous to our national situations. For the last five years, spending growth has been far below normal, and below what would be needed to keep up with inflation and population growth. Yet debt has risen, because income fell. You can see that as a spending problem, if you'd like, but spending growth actually moved pretty dramatically in a direction that would favor decreasing deficits, already. The difference-maker was the drop in revenues. And that is due to an anemic economy and ultra-low tax rates.

Since what the economy is suffering from is inadequate demand, spending more would actually help. We'd get the ball rolling, causing debt to drop rapidly as a share of GDP, the way it did during other boom times, making the debt less and less signficant to us over time. Or we can go the the other way and try to cut the spending deeper and deeper, causing a 1937-style recession, and hope eventually the economy corrects itself (which, over the very long term, it will). We know what works, but we can go with what we know doesn't work, instead, and wait this thing out. If we do, we'll have squandered a decade or two in the process.

$85 BILLION monthly spent on the market-QE-------made whom RICH.......the middle-class factory worker, the HUD project dweller.........OR.......Wall Street Mongals________or YOU.that post of it's riches and soon retirement and travels.........HOPE first trip is to hike in Syria.........or Afghanistan......hell, try Iraq.............big boy!
 
lmfao.........no.....I was posting of the CRA that Slick signed.........where Banks were made to offer loan to those that didn't/couldn't qualify for home-loans........many made off with second mortgages of $60,000+ and destroyed the homes they bought due to Slicks CRA............I'm aware you want to act stupidly...it's what liberal converts do best..............☻

https://www.govtrack.us/congress/bills/108/s811

The CRA was about red-lining. It was a practice of drawing a line around some areas of a city and refusing to grant loans to anyone wanting to buy property there. There is nothing in the bill (which originated in the 1970s) about downpayments and nothing about relaxing credit standards.

I've given you a link to the bill. Feel free to read it so you don't come off as completely uninformed.
 
$85 BILLION monthly spent on the market-QE-------made whom RICH.......the middle-class factory worker, the HUD project dweller.........OR.......Wall Street Mongals________or YOU.that post of it's riches and soon retirement and travels.........HOPE from trip is to hike in Syria.........or Afghanistan......hell, try Iraq.............big boy!

Who ever had stocks....pension funds, mutual funds....ME....

I didn't know that there were many Mongals on Wall Street....I thought most of them stayed in Mongalia.....;)
 
No. Of course not. What on earth would make you think rising debt has to be a sign of expanding government spending? Do you not know how debt works? Debt is the accumulated impact of deficits. Deficits are caused by a mismatch between revenues an spending. They can be caused by revenues growing too slowly or spending growing too quickly, or both. In the present case, spending grew at an EXTREMELY low pace. For the last five years, we had the slowest pace of spending growth since the end of WWII -- a pace that's a fraction of the norm. The rise in debt is despite that austerity. It's because revenues grew even more poorly, partly because of the second Bush recession, and partly because of very low tax rates (effective taxes hit a fifty-year low, as a share of GDP, in the Obama years).

The stimulus we got in 2009 was a small success: it turned an epic economic collapse (the worst since 1929) into an anemic recovery. But, as predicted by the Keynesians, it was far too small and poorly structured (giving a huge chunk of its "benefit" in the form of tax cuts, which did nothing to stimulate the economy, since the economic shortfall wasn't caused by a lack of capital, it was caused by a lack of demand).

The tax cuts should have been primarily to those making less than $75k....not those making more than $750k....We needed a bump in consumer spending. Trickle up....Instead we rewarded those who didn't need it and wouldn't spend it.
 
$85 BILLION monthly spent on the market-QE-------made whom RICH.......the middle-class factory worker, the HUD project dweller.........OR.......Wall Street Mongals________or YOU.that post of it's riches and soon retirement and travels.........HOPE first trip is to hike in Syria.........or Afghanistan......hell, try Iraq.............big boy!
I.... don't..... know.... what in hell... you.... trying.... to say... big boy!
 
Back
Top