New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Reckless spending

In other words, decrease the size of the economy so that it can grow or what the Germans and Brits call "austerity". Never has worked, never will work and it will never come to pass anyway so stop blathering about it.

Typical (wrong) Keynesian response. In case you haven't noticed, $5 trillion in "stimulus" under Obama hasn't ignited the private economy. $5 trillion more is unlikely to move the needle much on anything but our debt level (which has already entered the Reinhart/Rogoff death spiral zone). Getting government down to a size we can afford over the long haul, coupled with pro-growth regulatory and tax reform is NOT what the Euro's are doing at all. They are raising taxes and reducing the "growth rate" of spending. That is EXACTLY what Obama is doing.
 
Well, we see how your "proper" response helped European economies....

Getting government down to a size we can afford over the long haul, coupled with pro-growth regulatory and tax reform is NOT what the Euro's are doing at all. They are raising taxes and reducing the "growth rate" of spending. That is EXACTLY what Obama is doing.
 
Typical (wrong) Keynesian response. In case you haven't noticed, $5 trillion in "stimulus" under Obama hasn't ignited the private economy. $5 trillion more is unlikely to move the needle much on anything but our debt level (which has already entered the Reinhart/Rogoff death spiral zone). Getting government down to a size we can afford over the long haul, coupled with pro-growth regulatory and tax reform is NOT what the Euro's are doing at all. They are raising taxes and reducing the "growth rate" of spending. That is EXACTLY what Obama is doing.

Typical wrong voodoo fantasies.
Funny that the people even with minimal understanding of economics witnessing once again that Keynes was correct.
but people totally brainwashed by Heritage sold out manipulators are still clueless or don't have intellectual honesty and/or brain power to face the reality
 
The top post cited the leftist spin that Obama hasn't "grown government."

No, it didn't. Care to copy and paste what you "quoted"? If changing the subject and misrepresenting the TP is the only way you can respond, you got nuttin' but another wagon load of straw.

You didn't dispute a single word of the TP. That's a sincere response?

The entire premise of the top post is that Obama is NOT a "big gubbermint" liberal, due to the fact that government is growing so slowly under his policies. Well, his big spending initiatives haven't all hit yet, his winding down of the Iraq war (remember - that was supposed to be temporary spending) has masked the increases in permanent programs on his watch and his policies have led us into a "low growth" trap where even without increasing the overall spending levels, spending as a percent of GDP is skyrocketing. I think that does a pretty god job of deconstructing his premise. Now you can feel free to attempt to refute me on my points, but you cannot say they do not exist.

fed+budget.jpg
 
Typical wrong voodoo fantasies.
Funny that the people even with minimal understanding of economics witnessing once again that Keynes was correct.
but people totally brainwashed by Heritage sold out manipulators are still clueless or don't have intellectual honesty and/or brain power to face the reality

No, as I pointed out, the people who are misinterpreting what is going on, because they filter all data through a flawed Keynesain model (that assumes government spending multipliers that do not exist) are pronouncing themselves (again) to be correct, despite the clear evidence that what they advocated was done and it didn't work!!!
 
The entire premise of the top post is that Obama is NOT a "big gubbermint" liberal

No, it wasn't. It was a presentation of facts about a specific indicator of Presidential spending.

You don't get to assign a phony "premise" just because you can't dispute the facts.
 
No, as I pointed out, the people who are misinterpreting what is going on, because they filter all data through a flawed Keynesain model (that assumes government spending multipliers that do not exist) are pronouncing themselves (again) to be correct, despite the clear evidence that what they advocated was done and it didn't work!!!

I don't know what conditions exist on Mars , but here on Earth everybody with integrity can see CLEAR EVIDENCE that Keynes was and is still correct.
 
The entire premise of the top post is that Obama is NOT a "big gubbermint" liberal

No, it wasn't. It was a presentation of facts about a specific indicator of Presidential spending.

You don't get to assign a phony "premise" just because you can't dispute the facts.

And I showed how those "facts" are misleading, particularly by not backing out the war spending.
 
Are you talking about 5 trillion in deficit financing over the last 3 years? Per year, thats about 1.75 trillion a year. What exactly do you think that money is spent on? I bet every single penny is spent. For it to have zero affect it would have to be saved (IOWs, hoarded like rich people do with their stashes). Even a person with extreme ideological views has to admit that taking that money out of the system (GNP or AD decreases by that amount) means the economy will shrink meaning someone will be out of a job meaning people go on the dole and don't pay taxes meaning more government spending....any chance you will ever understand basic economics?
 
Are you talking about 5 trillion in deficit financing over the last 3 years? Per year, thats about 1.75 trillion a year. What exactly do you think that money is spent on? I bet every single penny is spent. For it to have zero affect it would have to be saved (IOWs, hoarded like rich people do with their stashes). Even a person with extreme ideological views has to admit that taking that money out of the system (GNP or AD decreases by that amount) means the economy will shrink meaning someone will be out of a job meaning people go on the dole and don't pay taxes meaning more government spending....any chance you will ever understand basic economics?

It is only supporting growth in the fake (government spending) economy, which is almost completely offset by declines in the real (private) economy (crowding out - look it up) as the ever bigger government reduces the desire to invest in and grow the private sector. We have to reverse that dynamic and start growing the private sector again if we hope to ever grow out of our debt.
 
Translation

Yes, I keep telling you that Obama just continued the failed Bush policies (and unaffordable spending levels) but you keep telling me that somehow he is different.

That was a graph i didn't like because it didn't have a right wing spin. So i'll just call it "debunked" and then we can all call my analysis good. ;-)
 
That was a graph i didn't like because it didn't have a right wing spin. So i'll just call it "debunked" and then we can all call my analysis good. ;-)

If you have to translate what I said into something I didn't say in order to debunk it, I'd say you lose the debate...
 
What is fake about spending 700 billion a year on defense? is there something fake about my buddies new SS check he will be getting next month? Are the paychecks the FBI agents get fake? How about those fake checks sent out to Nasa? You bore me.
 
What is fake about spending 700 billion a year on defense? is there something fake about my buddies new SS check he will be getting next month? Are the paychecks the FBI agents get fake? How about those fake checks sent out to Nasa? You bore me.

It is fake in that it is in no way self sustaining. Once the money is out the door, all we have to show for it is the (increased) debt level. ALL government spending must be paid for by taxes garnered from the PRIVATE sector. The NET private sector (after backing out government and non-profit purchases). That is the ONLY sector of the economy that can support the spending on government and non-profits (INCLUDING THE TAXES GOVERNMENT AND NONPROFIT EMPLOYEES PAY AND ALL THE PURCHASES FROM THE PRIVATE SECTOR). And, as we have seen over the past 40 years as the size of government has skyrocketed, this net private sector has been shrinking!!!
 
Back
Top