New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Regarding Julius Caesar...a "Play"...

Craig

Senator
Supporting Member
There has been some recent outrage over a contemporary take on a 418 year old play about Rome. The play, which media outlets seem loathe to name, is Julius Caesar.

For your consideration:

For decades, conservatives have darkly warned that failing to teach the Western canon of literature to students — that deeming books and plays by dead white guys irrelevant to today’s concerns — would lead to disastrous consequences.

Last weekend, they proved their own point...

...right-wing media outlets’ swift move to offense and outrage over the production — presumably because they think outrage will play well to their audience — does call into question how well they grasp, and support, the history of Shakespeare and his place in the Western canon.

It also makes you wonder whether they’re familiar with Julius Caesar...

...The Public’s stagings of Shakespeare follow the tradition of most professional productions of the Bard’s work, which honor the magnitude of Shakespeare’s accomplishments by using staging clues to draw connections between his plays and contemporary movements in politics and culture.

In 2016, for instance, the Public produced Troilus and Cressida (set in ancient Greece), as well as The Taming of the Shrew — the latter with an entirely female cast. And so one of the major topics of discussion in cultural circles that summer was whether, and how, the misogyny and subjugation of women that are seemingly advanced by The Taming of the Shrew could be staged in 2017.

Shakespeare’s ability to speak to every time period is considered one of the marks of his mastery as a playwright. As early as 1623, 17 years after Shakespeare’s death, the poet Ben Jonson declared, in his preface to the First Folio (an early collection of 36 of Shakespeare’s major comedies, tragedies, and histories) that the playwright was “not of an age but for all time!”

Jonson was exactly right. Shakespeare’s plays about real-life political figures were never meant to be strict live-action reenactments of historical records for educational purposes. The Bard wrote plays about the history of his own country, England, but he also wrote about major figures from Roman history, in addition to using old poems, myths, and stories as the basis for his work.

Even in his own era, his audiences recognized that a play about a Roman general or a Danish king wasn’t an education in the past, something that had relevance to them only because it happened. Shakespeare was able to capture essential truths about human nature, treachery, loyalty, love, politics, societies, justice, and both the noble and corrupting uses of power in his plays. He wrote about populism and elitism. His plays tell stories about tribalism, and treachery, and honor. For him — as with classic theater in virtually every time and place — plays weren’t just entertainment, but a place to confront people with challenging notions about their own world...

...there are several warnings in Julius Caesar. One is a warning to would-be authoritarian leaders who may be surrounded by people clinging to patriotic ideals and willing to act on them. One is a warning to populists, with the play showing how public opinion is easily swayed and manipulated by charismatic figures.
(In a canny move, Shakespeare includes the sad story of Cinna, a poet who is in no way related to the plot against Caesar but who is mistaken for a conspirator with the same name. The crowd realizes the error, but kills him anyway.)

And there’s a warning to those who, like the conspirators, believe themselves to be acting in service of country over their own interests as individuals. Violence begets violence.
Scholars have long argued that the play casts their motivations in a less-than-flattering light, with Shakespeare suggesting that just because you think you’re acting patriotically doesn’t mean you don’t have your own private reasons for doing it, and your own drive to gain power. By the end of the play, Antony concludes that Brutus — Caesar’s friend who betrays him — is the “noblest Roman of them all,” and the only one who truly acted in service of the republic. And coming from the mouth of Antony, who has a vested interest in his own power, even that is in question...

Complete essay @

https://www.vox.com/culture/2017/6/...kespeare-in-park-trump-public-theater-outrage
 
nobody is surprised that a winger sees nothing wrong with depicting trumps assassination as "entertainment".

the only surprise would have been if you'd posted something along the lines of "It would have been wrong if they did this to Obama, too"
 
You do see the difference, right Craig?

The Obama version was no explicitly made to be Obama. The Trump version IS.

That's the difference.
 
I'd like to see Brer Rabbit run into Tar-baby in a play. The part of Tar-baby symbolically played as Barack Hussein Obama.

85433363-congressman-called.jpg
 
I'd like to see Brer Rabbit run into Tar-baby in a play. The part of Tar-baby symbolically played as Barack Hussein Obama.

85433363-congressman-called.jpg

that would have lib screaming a different tune and hopefully seeing their ObamaCare Doctors

19029683_10209019746233313_6987403564901840701_n.jpg
because I care
 
My god man is there anything you won't whine about? And it's rather silly that the left, who got Huckleberry Finn banned from public schools because it uses the word N*****r.

And you are trying to compare that to commercial interests choosing to not sponsor a play?

Laughable.
 
You do see the difference, right Craig?

The Obama version was no explicitly made to be Obama. The Trump version IS.

That's the difference.

Implicit...versus explicit. Not a very convincing argument...especially in light of the viewpoints (and the many warnings the play expresses) expressed in the essay. Sure...it was just a lanky black guy...when a lanky black guy was President. Gee...that's so very different. :rolleyes:
 
nobody is surprised that a winger sees nothing wrong with depicting trumps assassination as "entertainment".

the only surprise would have been if you'd posted something along the lines of "It would have been wrong if they did this to Obama, too"

I'd be surprised if you commented on the article regarding Julius Caesar.

Oh well.
 
My god man is there anything you won't whine about? And it's rather silly that the left, who got Huckleberry Finn banned from public schools because it uses the word N*****r.

And you are trying to compare that to commercial interests choosing to not sponsor a play?

Laughable.

It was mostly the right that wanted to ban that book, for being anti-racist. The language was the pretext they used.
 
Implicit...versus explicit. Not a very convincing argument...especially in light of the viewpoints (and the many warnings the play expresses) expressed in the essay. Sure...it was just a lanky black guy...when a lanky black guy was President. Gee...that's so very different. :rolleyes:

It's THE argument. I could say I'm going to beat to death a whiny, stupid, burned out old leftist who used to drive a cab and spends his mornings smoking pot and whining about anything to the right of Stalin.

It means nothing.

I could say I'm going to beat Craig to death and it would mean something entirely different.

Get it, Einstein?
 
Implicit...versus explicit. Not a very convincing argument...especially in light of the viewpoints (and the many warnings the play expresses) expressed in the essay. Sure...it was just a lanky black guy...when a lanky black guy was President. Gee...that's so very different. :rolleyes:

You are correct...The left has a problem with a black guy being a Emperor (ceasar).
 
upload_2017-6-13_14-13-40.png

Lefty has a problem with this...No wonder, they are the party of slavery and segregation.
 
Back
Top