New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Regarding my avatar

Really? How so?

If you're saying that a lot of folks who object to legalization do so on the basis of nebulous claims about possible social costs, then I agree. I'm not sure that tactic is anything one should hang one's hat on, however.



Okay, I'll agree that a lot of folks who argue in favor of legalization puff up their case with a lot of speculative talk about the benefits of hemp, the wonder crop. I also agree that some of what drives the “medical marijuana” movement is little more than a desire to get high legally. And that front is unfortunate to the extent that it tarnishes the legalization movement with the stain of cynical opportunism and disingenuousness.

Personally, I don't see anything wrong with wanting to get high, or in getting high, as long as it's done responsibly. The fact that the desire as well as the practice still carries a whiff of disreputableness is mostly an unfortunate remnant of our puritanical, moralistic streak, don't you think? Fact is, a lot of animals enjoy getting a buzz. What's the harm in it, as long as it's not pursued to excess?



Well, I don't know what you mean by “full-on 'potheadism'” and thus I don't know why it's good to be proud of not having stooped to it. That aside, I don't see how the self-righteousness or the misdirection offered by folks on both sides of the legalization debate materially affects the heart of the argument. And frankly, I don't see a defense of your basic assumptions or a rebuttal of my critique of those assumptions in your reply. Neither do I see an answer to my point about the fundamental perniciousness of outlawing objectively harmless actions.

So then, are we basically in agreement?

Cheers.

Pot is fun. From my perspective, it's always been fun. I get sort of a kick out of the folks who take it so seriously - kind of like the folks who live their lives around the "fetus". Nevertheless....I'll indulge as I see fit, and I'll pontificate around the objective realities, and I'll certainly not engage in any "intense" tet a tets around something as ridiculous and presumptively "fun", as pot.

I'll suggest that for those for whom pot is their "be all and end all", they find someone else to butt heads with.
 
Dude, I don't mind pontification.

Pot is fun. From my perspective, it's always been fun. I get sort of a kick out of the folks who take it so seriously - kind of like the folks who live their lives around the "fetus". Nevertheless....I'll indulge as I see fit, and I'll pontificate around the objective realities, and I'll certainly not engage in any "intense" tet a tets around something as ridiculous and presumptively "fun", as pot.

I'll suggest that for those for whom pot is their "be all and end all", they find someone else to butt heads with.

In fact, some might say it's my trade. I was just hoping to learn more about the putative connections between your sermon and objective realities, but if you don't want to explain or defend your own argument then that's certainly your prerogative. No biggie...

Fact is, the specific arguments don't really matter all that much at this point. As far as legalization is concerned, it looks to me as if the writing is on the wall. Whether it's five years, or ten, or twenty, federal prohibition will be rescinded and that'll inevitably lead to at least de facto decriminalization among the states. I do think it's a shame that some folks will be hurt needlessly in the interim as others temporize and pontificate, but what're ya gonna do?

Really though, after all is said and done I'm much more interested in the legal/ethical philosophy being advanced here than I am in the legalization of pot as such. And the basic philosophy I hear you advancing is:

  1. The ostensible justifications for a law may matter less than the practical effects of that law; i.e. if a law helps to maintain good social order then we needn't worry too much about the ethical foundations of that law.
  2. Related to the above, we needn't worry if an “acceptable” number of folks run afoul of a law that's routinely broken and largely unenforceable as long as one can argue that the law serves a net social good and is generally used to target “bad guys.”
  3. Regardless of whether or not a law's ethical foundations have been shown to be suspect, the onus ought to be on those who want to change a law to show that negative social consequences won't ensue from any proposed change.

If the spirit so moves you, please feel free to correct me if I've misunderstood.

Cheers.
 
In fact, some might say it's my trade. I was just hoping to learn more about the putative connections between your sermon and objective realities, but if you don't want to explain or defend your own argument then that's certainly your prerogative. No biggie...

Fact is, the specific arguments don't really matter all that much at this point. As far as legalization is concerned, it looks to me as if the writing is on the wall. Whether it's five years, or ten, or twenty, federal prohibition will be rescinded and that'll inevitably lead to at least de facto decriminalization among the states. I do think it's a shame that some folks will be hurt needlessly in the interim as others temporize and pontificate, but what're ya gonna do?

Really though, after all is said and done I'm much more interested in the legal/ethical philosophy being advanced here than I am in the legalization of pot as such. And the basic philosophy I hear you advancing is:

  1. The ostensible justifications for a law may matter less than the practical effects of that law; i.e. if a law helps to maintain good social order then we needn't worry too much about the ethical foundations of that law.
  2. Related to the above, we needn't worry if an “acceptable” number of folks run afoul of a law that's routinely broken and largely unenforceable as long as one can argue that the law serves a net social good and is generally used to target “bad guys.”
  3. Regardless of whether or not a law's ethical foundations have been shown to be suspect, the onus ought to be on those who want to change a law to show that negative social consequences won't ensue from any proposed change.

If the spirit so moves you, please feel free to correct me if I've misunderstood.

Cheers.

Now that is a good argument, I would like to see fairsheet respomd to that.
 
People don't really wanna wear hemp hats, serve their guests "hemp tartar", nor hang off a cliff from a rope made of hemp. The ONLY thread the wouldbe shillers of hemp have to cling to, is the fact of its being marginally illegal. Their entire meme would be blown to smithereens, if all legalities around hemp were wiped off the books.

I'm not among those who think hemp is a miracle crop. Having said that, it's still a viable crop. Hemp rope is useful rope, even now, but that isn't the best application today. Where I envision hemp being a huge cash crop is in the paper industry, where it is cheaper than wood and makes better paper, and entails a lot less environmental concerns that that caused by tree farming. Obviously, it has other commercial applications, including the fact that hemp oil is as valid an oil as that coming from rape seeds for similar purposes.

I've never been a regular marijuana user. I've tried it, and I DID inhale, and it simply wasn't the drug of choice for me (I'm a beer drinker). Legalization? I'm all for it. Forcing it onto a black market as it is today is a waste of resources at several levels.
 
People don't really wanna wear hemp hats, serve their guests "hemp tartar", nor hang off a cliff from a rope made of hemp. The ONLY thread the wouldbe shillers of hemp have to cling to, is the fact of its being marginally illegal. Their entire meme would be blown to smithereens, if all legalities around hemp were wiped off the books.

Actually, people DO want to wear hemp, as well as use it in fabrics for a wide variety of other purposes, such as upholstery. I, personally, was looking for a supplier for hemp just a couple months ago as a cheaper alternative to a) cotton (which recently went through the roof price-wise and is only now just beginning to come down a little bit) - hemp is cheaper and stronger; b) linen - hemp is much cheaper and just as strong; c) rayon and bamboo - hemp is much cheaper and way better in fabric as well as for the environment; d) jute - hemp has a similar look but is cheaper and feels better. (I am a textile designer, working for a fabric manufacturer.)

As a natural fibre, hemp would make an excellent substitute for most of the other natural fibres available for weaving and knitting and yields more fibre less expensively on the same amount of land than most of the other fibre crops.

FYI, hemp also does not grow under the same conditions as marijuana, so it can easily be distinguished from marijuana just from looking at it growing.

As of right now, the only place I could find to buy hemp yarn/fibre for the purpose of use in fabric manufacturing is China, India and Chile. If the price of cotton doesn't come down soon and stay down, you will see a spike in interest in hemp as an alternative, as all of the other natural fibres tend to be more expensive and less durable than cotton. Hemp is the only one that is actually cheaper and more durable than cotton and could compete effectively in the marketplace as a viable substitute for cotton.
 
The parts need to be cheap, especially the body panels which will rust while you watch. When I was in college my roommate had the 124 -- he said FIAT stood for "Fix It Again, Tony."

Now THAT is funny.. thanks Tony. : )
 
Now THAT is funny.. thanks Tony. : )

He would always deliver the statement with thumb and forefinger together, in a deeply fake Italian accent, "Fix It Again, Tony" -- and then he'd run off to buy a new rear fender, a tube of Bondo, etc.
 
Hey, growing dope for fun and profit beats working to some.
 
ya think? You should know they did...
and without that culture, white man would never have been able to make (and then break) the treaties that enabled our "civilizing" of the continent.
 
Back
Top