New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Regarding my avatar

Piffle. If there's a profit to be made, the tobacco companies, which already have the infrastructure in place, will jump in to make the profit. There's no "assuming" the costs ourselves at all. If the tobacco companies don't want to jump on the bandwagon (and really, why wouldn't they?) there WILL be entrepreneurs who will be right there ready to profit from the market. How long did it take after prohibition for various liquor manufacturers to leap into the market? (See Jack Daniels)

I've never suggested that there isn't a profit to be made and that some wouldn't be all over the opportunity. You should maybe reread my ramble. In fact, I've assumed all along, that "legal" companies would take advantage of the opportunity. The point I'm making is that the price point at which they could make a profit, wouldn't be sufficient to dissuade the black market.
 
I'm not actually sure what all you said there. I think you were trying to say that somehow I was arguing that the black market for marijuana would disappear because the illegal market for marijuana wasn't there? Or that I said that if marijuana was legalized that somehow I thought that black markets would disappear? I'm truely not sure what you were saying.

I think that black markets will always exist, as a means for people to obtain that which they cannot obtain legally. You seemed to be saying that if we took marijuana off the black market, that the "void" left behind would be filled by something more nefarious. My response is: nonsense. The people in the market for something more nefarious than pot already have people who fill that market. If we take pot off the black market, nothing will rush in to fill the void: all those voids are already filled.

I think you may be misapprehending the concept. (I think) You're thinking that I'm saying some sort of direct replacement for marijuana will rush in to fill the void. Sort of like...if we were to suddenly legalize potato chips, a black market in pretzels would develop. But..that's not what I'm suggesting. It's more like....if we legalized potato chips, a black market in knock-off purses might develop.

Although...your apparent certitude that legalizing marijuana wouldn't engender new markets in some other mind-altering substance, is probably naive. But...your apparent certitude that the "element" currently trafficking in marijuana would just up and retire from the black market bidness model, definitely IS naive.

And once again......why is it SO important for us to "legalize" something that for all intents and purposes and consumed as we might hope that it'd be consumed, already IS legal?
 
Hah!....I'm not surprised that you aren't buying my argument. Although it's generally well understood and accepted withIN the criminal justice milieu, it's not so much so, OUTside of it.

While we're at it...I'll toss another one at you, that I don't imagine you'll buy into either. A whole lot of people are convinced that if we were to legalize and tax marijuana, we could rake in big bucks whilst putting the black marketeers out of bidness. Alas...the actual pushers-of-pencils around such things, disagree.

There are costs involved in sourcing, packaging, marketing, taxing, and regulating marijuana. All of those costs total up a "break even" price point. Unfortunately, that price point would end up being too high, to put the black marketeers out of bidness. SO...what we'd end up with is the "state" in the marijuana bidness AND...the black marketeers continuing to do THEIR thing. The only way of countering that, would be for the taxpayers to actually SUBSIDIZE marijuana such that the "state" could lower its price sufficiently to drive out the black marketeers.

Yeah & there's none of that cost i.e. packaing asprin etc....
 
Fairsheet.. I don't know all that much about marijuana, I have never tried it. Is there such a thing as a pill or capsule type product derived from this weed? Interesting medicinal benefits for some types of illnesses have been reported and touted as making a beneficial impact in some patients' lives.

Something I have wondered about through the years is off topic actually. When reading about the Indians in history books and as portrayed in the movies.. smoking a peace pipe with their adversaries -- usually resulted in an agreement being reached on important issues.. Do you think they were smoking marijuana?
 
Yeah & there's none of that cost i.e. packaing asprin etc....

Of course, you're actually suggesting that these costs DO apply in the case of the aspirin marketing transaction. I'm not sure why you think that would be anything other than an affirmation of my gist. Remember though....in terms of markets, every potential product must be considered in isolation. Aspirin in the U.S., is remarkably cheap AND safe. It offers up virtually no black market potential. BUT....there are other places around the world, where the market for black market aspirin can be quite lucrative.
 
Fairsheet.. I don't know all that much about marijuana, I have never tried it. Is there such a thing as a pill or capsule type product derived from this weed? Interesting medicinal benefits for some types of illnesses have been reported and touted as making a beneficial impact in some patients' lives.

Something I have wondered about through the years is off topic actually. When reading about the Indians in history books and as portrayed in the movies.. smoking a peace pipe with their adversaries -- usually resulted in an agreement being reached on important issues.. Do you think they were smoking marijuana?

Addy, I don't actually KNOW the origins of marijuana - well, except that when I've gotten it, the origin was a guy name of Bob!

But...I'm guessing - and this is just a guess - that it was not indigenous to the New World (but, I could be wrong). What I DO know though, is....that like horses, tobacco definitely came from the Old World. And when you "saw" those Indians smoking pipes?...they were smoking tobacco. I'm guessing that as Indians didn't ride horses prior to "whitey's" arrival, they may not have smoked, either.
 
Thanks for your comments, Fairsheet.
Indians used all types of herbs in their lives for healing, nothing was wasted. All of us could learn something from them pertaining to waste!
Years ago kids used to smoke rabbit tobacco was common to see it growing wild. To this day not sure what rabbit tobacco really was.
 
Thanks for your comments, Fairsheet.
Indians used all types of herbs in their lives for healing, nothing was wasted. All of us could learn something from them pertaining to waste!
Years ago kids used to smoke rabbit tobacco was common to see it growing wild. To this day not sure what rabbit tobacco really was.

We used to hide in our friends' pony barn, and smoke straw. Silly kids....playing with matches...in a barn full of straw....
 
lol, smoking straw..too funny, Fairsheet and it was dangerous, agree with you! : )
 
Tobacco is a New World plant.

Addy, I don't actually KNOW the origins of marijuana - well, except that when I've gotten it, the origin was a guy name of Bob!

But...I'm guessing - and this is just a guess - that it was not indigenous to the New World (but, I could be wrong). What I DO know though, is....that like horses, tobacco definitely came from the Old World. And when you "saw" those Indians smoking pipes?...they were smoking tobacco. I'm guessing that as Indians didn't ride horses prior to "whitey's" arrival, they may not have smoked, either.

Tobacco is indigenous to the Americas. The oldest evidence of its cultivation and use is found in South America, I believe. It's use by Native Americans long predates the arrival of Europeans and it was traditionally smoked.

Cannabis, on the other hand, is an Old World plant. It may have originated in Central Asia. In any case it was first widely cultivated in China; it's use spread from there to India, the Middle East, and then to Europe and the New World. That's the commonly-accepted hypothesis anyway.

Cheers.
 
The Indians put it in their peace pipes; why else would they have sold Manhattan to the Pilgrims for $24?
 
Well, you're argument is certainly novel.

I think you may be misapprehending the concept. (I think) You're thinking that I'm saying some sort of direct replacement for marijuana will rush in to fill the void. Sort of like...if we were to suddenly legalize potato chips, a black market in pretzels would develop. But..that's not what I'm suggesting. It's more like....if we legalized potato chips, a black market in knock-off purses might develop.

Although...your apparent certitude that legalizing marijuana wouldn't engender new markets in some other mind-altering substance, is probably naive. But...your apparent certitude that the "element" currently trafficking in marijuana would just up and retire from the black market bidness model, definitely IS naive.

And once again......why is it SO important for us to "legalize" something that for all intents and purposes and consumed as we might hope that it'd be consumed, already IS legal?

I don't believe I've ever heard anyone suggest that marijuana should remain illegal because, after all, the black marketeers have to have something to peddle and marijuana is fairly benign.

I have to say, though, that your argument strikes me as being both rather weak and fairly pernicious.

To begin, and correct me if I've misunderstood, you seem to assume that there's a certain "black market demand" that's more or less fixed and thus if one thing doesn't fill it, then another thing will. If that is your assumption, well, it seems wrong.

Now, it does make sense that racketeers will always be with us and of course racketeers will always be looking for a lucrative black market niche to fill. Sure. But surely the market has to exist in order to be exploited. There a huge market for marijuana because a lot of people enjoy using it regularly. But your average marijuana user isn't necessarily likely to switch to some other illegal habit simply because pot is legalized.

"Well, I was going to spark a bowl this evening, but ever since they legalized it, I just don't get the same thrill. What to do...? What to do...? Oh, I know! I'll find myself a nice, underage prostitute instead! Oh yeah, that's so illegal. Man, this is going to be great!"

I don't see it.

I agree with you that legalizing pot isn't all that likely to provide the state with an enormous financial windfall. But I do think it's likely to have a net positive effect on the state's coffers. I guess we'll see about that.

I also agree that legalizing and regulating pot isn't likely to do away with the black market all together. We still have a black market in alcohol, after all. But that market and it's negative effects on society is miniscule compared to what it was during Prohibition. Right? Why would it be any different for marijuana?

Finally, I disagree that there's little point in legalizing marijuana because it's already legal for all intents and purposes. First, the degree to which it is "effectively" legal varies a lot depending on where one lives. Second, it's not just the reckless and the foolish who fall afoul of the prohibition, it's the unlucky as well. And it's not just a matter of getting in trouble with the law. Workers lose or fail to land a job simply because a drug test shows that they've used an illegal drug. Adult college students are suspended, lose scholarships, and collect permanent blemishes on their records. And so on...

Fact is, if one believes the drug is relatively harmless, then people who've done nothing harmful are being unfairly hurt by this prohibition. If one wishes to argue that this cost is worth it, then one is obliged to lay out a concrete balance sheet, in my opinion. Vague speculation about possible harms won't do.

Cheers.
 
I don't believe I've ever heard anyone suggest that marijuana should remain illegal because, after all, the black marketeers have to have something to peddle and marijuana is fairly benign.

I have to say, though, that your argument strikes me as being both rather weak and fairly pernicious.

To begin, and correct me if I've misunderstood, you seem to assume that there's a certain "black market demand" that's more or less fixed and thus if one thing doesn't fill it, then another thing will. If that is your assumption, well, it seems wrong.

Now, it does make sense that racketeers will always be with us and of course racketeers will always be looking for a lucrative black market niche to fill. Sure. But surely the market has to exist in order to be exploited. There a huge market for marijuana because a lot of people enjoy using it regularly. But your average marijuana user isn't necessarily likely to switch to some other illegal habit simply because pot is legalized.

"Well, I was going to spark a bowl this evening, but ever since they legalized it, I just don't get the same thrill. What to do...? What to do...? Oh, I know! I'll find myself a nice, underage prostitute instead! Oh yeah, that's so illegal. Man, this is going to be great!"

I don't see it.

I agree with you that legalizing pot isn't all that likely to provide the state with an enormous financial windfall. But I do think it's likely to have a net positive effect on the state's coffers. I guess we'll see about that.

I also agree that legalizing and regulating pot isn't likely to do away with the black market all together. We still have a black market in alcohol, after all. But that market and it's negative effects on society is miniscule compared to what it was during Prohibition. Right? Why would it be any different for marijuana?

Finally, I disagree that there's little point in legalizing marijuana because it's already legal for all intents and purposes. First, the degree to which it is "effectively" legal varies a lot depending on where one lives. Second, it's not just the reckless and the foolish who fall afoul of the prohibition, it's the unlucky as well. And it's not just a matter of getting in trouble with the law. Workers lose or fail to land a job simply because a drug test shows that they've used an illegal drug. Adult college students are suspended, lose scholarships, and collect permanent blemishes on their records. And so on...

Fact is, if one believes the drug is relatively harmless, then people who've done nothing harmful are being unfairly hurt by this prohibition. If one wishes to argue that this cost is worth it, then one is obliged to lay out a concrete balance sheet, in my opinion. Vague speculation about possible harms won't do.

Cheers.

Thanks Havelock, you said that way better than I. I would add to the costs of keeping marajuana illegel those costs associated with busting, charging, trying, and incarcerating marajuana users and dealers. A quick google showed those costs to be quite steep, and they are borne by the state. I'd add links but didn't want to take the trouble to winnow the wheat from the chaff (wasn't sure for example that a site called legalizemjnow.org would be considered legit).
 
I don't believe I've ever heard anyone suggest that marijuana should remain illegal because, after all, the black marketeers have to have something to peddle and marijuana is fairly benign.

I have to say, though, that your argument strikes me as being both rather weak and fairly pernicious.

To begin, and correct me if I've misunderstood, you seem to assume that there's a certain "black market demand" that's more or less fixed and thus if one thing doesn't fill it, then another thing will. If that is your assumption, well, it seems wrong.

Now, it does make sense that racketeers will always be with us and of course racketeers will always be looking for a lucrative black market niche to fill. Sure. But surely the market has to exist in order to be exploited. There a huge market for marijuana because a lot of people enjoy using it regularly. But your average marijuana user isn't necessarily likely to switch to some other illegal habit simply because pot is legalized.

"Well, I was going to spark a bowl this evening, but ever since they legalized it, I just don't get the same thrill. What to do...? What to do...? Oh, I know! I'll find myself a nice, underage prostitute instead! Oh yeah, that's so illegal. Man, this is going to be great!"

I don't see it.

I agree with you that legalizing pot isn't all that likely to provide the state with an enormous financial windfall. But I do think it's likely to have a net positive effect on the state's coffers. I guess we'll see about that.

I also agree that legalizing and regulating pot isn't likely to do away with the black market all together. We still have a black market in alcohol, after all. But that market and it's negative effects on society is miniscule compared to what it was during Prohibition. Right? Why would it be any different for marijuana?

Finally, I disagree that there's little point in legalizing marijuana because it's already legal for all intents and purposes. First, the degree to which it is "effectively" legal varies a lot depending on where one lives. Second, it's not just the reckless and the foolish who fall afoul of the prohibition, it's the unlucky as well. And it's not just a matter of getting in trouble with the law. Workers lose or fail to land a job simply because a drug test shows that they've used an illegal drug. Adult college students are suspended, lose scholarships, and collect permanent blemishes on their records. And so on...

Fact is, if one believes the drug is relatively harmless, then people who've done nothing harmful are being unfairly hurt by this prohibition. If one wishes to argue that this cost is worth it, then one is obliged to lay out a concrete balance sheet, in my opinion. Vague speculation about possible harms won't do.

Cheers.

My "weak and pernicious argument", nonetheless drives the politic around the legalization of marijuana. The "adults" know full well that it would be silly to fully-acquiesce to the certitudes of the pot heads, so what they've done is "shift" the legalities towards decriminalization - in the guise of things like "medical marijuana", without actually obligating society to the costs of full legalization.

And frankly....as an occasional indulger myself, I've got no problem whatsoever, with the approach the politic has taken. BUT...as I've never stooped to full-on "potheadism" myself, I continue to get a big-assed kick out of the pot-headed righteousness around the whole thing!
 
Tobacco is indigenous to the Americas. The oldest evidence of its cultivation and use is found in South America, I believe. It's use by Native Americans long predates the arrival of Europeans and it was traditionally smoked.

Cannabis, on the other hand, is an Old World plant. It may have originated in Central Asia. In any case it was first widely cultivated in China; it's use spread from there to India, the Middle East, and then to Europe and the New World. That's the commonly-accepted hypothesis anyway.

Cheers.
Hah!....This the PERFECT example of a numbskull who should've done his research! (Thanks)
 
This is one of the sadder of the hemphead's arguments. For all intents and purposes, "industrial hemp" already IS legal. If people really wanted more hemp-derived products, they'd be buying them now. The hemphead's suggestion that "if only" industrial hemp were legal, there'd be some huge hemp bubble, is a red herring.

Industrial hemp, before 1913, was a primary cash crop in Missouri where I grew up. Today, the remainders of that crop (a no-till crop which was very good for the soil, by the way), are regularly burned where they line ditches and fence rows because their presence on the property is illegal -- the law makes no distinction between wild growing cannabis and that grown for the purposes of dealing drugs. There is almost no commercial hemp grown in this country today, and where it is grown, the fields are fenced and licensing to produce the crop is expensive. To attribute its downfall to mere consumer apathy is to ignore a century of American history in regard to the crop.
 
Industrial hemp, before 1913, was a primary cash crop in Missouri where I grew up. Today, the remainders of that crop (a no-till crop which was very good for the soil, by the way), are regularly burned where they line ditches and fence rows because their presence on the property is illegal -- the law makes no distinction between wild growing cannabis and that grown for the purposes of dealing drugs. There is almost no commercial hemp grown in this country today, and where it is grown, the fields are fenced and licensing to produce the crop is expensive. To attribute its downfall to mere consumer apathy is to ignore a century of American history in regard to the crop.

People don't really wanna wear hemp hats, serve their guests "hemp tartar", nor hang off a cliff from a rope made of hemp. The ONLY thread the wouldbe shillers of hemp have to cling to, is the fact of its being marginally illegal. Their entire meme would be blown to smithereens, if all legalities around hemp were wiped off the books.
 
Eh?

My "weak and pernicious argument", nonetheless drives the politic around the legalization of marijuana.

Really? How so?

If you're saying that a lot of folks who object to legalization do so on the basis of nebulous claims about possible social costs, then I agree. I'm not sure that tactic is anything one should hang one's hat on, however.

fairsheet said:
The "adults" know full well that it would be silly to fully-acquiesce to the certitudes of the pot heads, so what they've done is "shift" the legalities towards decriminalization - in the guise of things like "medical marijuana", without actually obligating society to the costs of full legalization.

Okay, I'll agree that a lot of folks who argue in favor of legalization puff up their case with a lot of speculative talk about the benefits of hemp, the wonder crop. I also agree that some of what drives the “medical marijuana” movement is little more than a desire to get high legally. And that front is unfortunate to the extent that it tarnishes the legalization movement with the stain of cynical opportunism and disingenuousness.

Personally, I don't see anything wrong with wanting to get high, or in getting high, as long as it's done responsibly. The fact that the desire as well as the practice still carries a whiff of disreputableness is mostly an unfortunate remnant of our puritanical, moralistic streak, don't you think? Fact is, a lot of animals enjoy getting a buzz. What's the harm in it, as long as it's not pursued to excess?

fairsheet said:
And frankly....as an occasional indulger myself, I've got no problem whatsoever, with the approach the politic has taken. BUT...as I've never stooped to full-on "potheadism" myself, I continue to get a big-assed kick out of the pot-headed righteousness around the whole thing!

Well, I don't know what you mean by “full-on 'potheadism'” and thus I don't know why it's good to be proud of not having stooped to it. That aside, I don't see how the self-righteousness or the misdirection offered by folks on both sides of the legalization debate materially affects the heart of the argument. And frankly, I don't see a defense of your basic assumptions or a rebuttal of my critique of those assumptions in your reply. Neither do I see an answer to my point about the fundamental perniciousness of outlawing objectively harmless actions.

So then, are we basically in agreement?

Cheers.
 
Back
Top