New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Religeons

As we have recently seen with the IRS targeting groups that disagree with the party in control, to even pretend to be even-handed would be a joke.


If you watched other than Fox News You would learn that they also targeted Democrats but this is what happens when you allow yourself to be misled
 
Since when are catholic hospitals forced to do abortions? How does removing tax exempt status lead to controlling religion? Quite the opposite. The church is taking advantage of the gov, and it they paid their fair share, they could be free to do and say anything.

I agree with this. If you play with public money you play by public rules.
 
I'd be OK with that. However, I'd also be OK with creating a tax exemption for genuine charitable work. That could include charitable work by churches, but, like non-church entities, they'd need to distinguish between the part of their organization that does charitable work, and the part that doesn't. That way if someone donated money to an organization that the church uses exclusively to, say, bring clean drinking water to poor villages in the Sudan, that would be tax deductible, but if someone donated money to an organization the church uses to install a big AV system for sermons, or to proselytize for new members, or to pay to defend clergy sex abuse cases, that wouldn't be.

I had to think about this for awhile before responding. Churches have only been officially tax exempt for about half of America's existence. You give some very good examples of activities which most reasonable people wouldn't think of as non-profit. The only downside I see to taxing churches is that it opens the door to religion in politics. An organization which is paying taxes has the right to openly and directly participate in our political system. After a couple of generations of people being raised in a country where the participation of churches in politics is seen as normal I don't see how, at least unofficially, we wouldn't have religious tests for potential office holders. Imagine the national political organization the Catholic Church could create, fund, and maintain if allowed to.
 
I had to think about this for awhile before responding. Churches have only been officially tax exempt for about half of America's existence. You give some very good examples of activities which most reasonable people wouldn't think of as non-profit. The only downside I see to taxing churches is that it opens the door to religion in politics. An organization which is paying taxes has the right to openly and directly participate in our political system. After a couple of generations of people being raised in a country where the participation of churches in politics is seen as normal I don't see how, at least unofficially, we wouldn't have religious tests for potential office holders. Imagine the national political organization the Catholic Church could create, fund, and maintain if allowed to.
I can't see a slippery slope leading from churches engaging in politics to a religious test for office (especially since there's a clear Constitutional prohibition on that). Besides, there's nothing that says that paying taxes gives you the right to participate in our political system. Foreign nationals very often pay taxes, but aren't given the vote, and aren't supposed to donate to candidates. Children also pay taxes, but can't vote. Felons, too. Until the recent ridiculous Supreme Court cases, corporations paid taxes and yet couldn't, for many generations, donate to campaigns. Those generations of corporate tax payment didn't lead to a "corporate test" for holding office. I think we'd have the ability to tax churches and then decide, as a completely separate matter, what level of involvement we wanted to permit them in the political process.

My own preference would be to let churches engage openly in the political process. Let them donate to whatever candidates and causes they want, and openly support particular candidates from the pulpit, etc. Be done with the hypocrisy of it. As long as all the donations are completely public, I'm fine with it, as I'm fine with similar behavior from any non-commercial organization (unions, fraternal orders, non-profit social clubs, etc.) I don't see how it would led to a religious test... any more than we already have a de facto religious test (I think in the entire modern history of the nation, only one member of Congress has ever been openly atheist or agnostic).
 
I can't see a slippery slope leading from churches engaging in politics to a religious test for office (especially since there's a clear Constitutional prohibition on that).

There is a prohibition on the government naming an official state religion and then requiring a test to hold office, there is no such prohibition on a Party requiring such a test. Do you really believe a Catholic Party wouldn't have such a test?

Besides, there's nothing that says that paying taxes gives you the right to participate in our political system. Foreign nationals very often pay taxes, but aren't given the vote, and aren't supposed to donate to candidates. Children also pay taxes, but can't vote. Felons, too.

You're just listing exceptions here. If a Catholic Party were to exist I'm sure it wouldn't be run from Rome, it would consist of Americans using American money.

Until the recent ridiculous Supreme Court cases, corporations paid taxes and yet couldn't, for many generations, donate to campaigns. Those generations of corporate tax payment didn't lead to a "corporate test" for holding office.

Agree that the Supreme Court ruling was ridiculous but it's the law we have to work with. You really believe there isn't a 'corporate test' to be backed for office?

I think we'd have the ability to tax churches and then decide, as a completely separate matter, what level of involvement we wanted to permit them in the political process.

You can't tax and then deny entrance. It'll never fly.

My own preference would be to let churches engage openly in the political process.

I think this would be a horrible mistake.

Let them donate to whatever candidates and causes they want, and openly support particular candidates from the pulpit, etc. Be done with the hypocrisy of it.

I'm not talking about donating and lobbying, I'm talking about a full-blown political party with a metric shit-ton of money.

As long as all the donations are completely public, I'm fine with it, as I'm fine with similar behavior from any non-commercial organization (unions, fraternal orders, non-profit social clubs, etc.)

None of those groups can even come close to the membership and money of an American Catholic Party, and there would be overlap.

(I think in the entire modern history of the nation, only one member of Congress has ever been openly atheist or agnostic).

I think this actually illustrates my point and highlights the danger.
 
Do you really believe a Catholic Party wouldn't have such a test?

No. Of course it would. So what?

Agree that the Supreme Court ruling was ridiculous but it's the law we have to work with. You really believe there isn't a 'corporate test' to be backed for office?

There isn't a corporate test in the sense of the "religious test" the founders were talking about. A candidate doesn't legally have to be publicly affiliated with a particular corporation to get elected. There's no law saying that to hold a particular office, someone must be a major shareholder of Microsoft, for example. In fact, politicians, even the biggest corporate whores among them, go out of their way to try to obscure any corporate allegiance.


I think this would be a horrible mistake.

Why?

I'm not talking about donating and lobbying, I'm talking about a full-blown political party with a metric shit-ton of money.

I'd be OK with religious parties. They've got some in Europe and that hasn't interfered with the secularization of the Continent. In fact, it may have accelerated it, by making it more open, rather than the hypocritical system in the US, where the GOP is gradually becoming the evangelical Protestant party, but doesn't have the guts to just come out an label itself accurately.
 
No. Of course it would. So what?

You were the one talking about the prohibition on a religious test. I pointed out that only the government was bound by that, and you just agreed with me. So what? I don't really want a Congress full of people who had to pass a religious test from any source.



There isn't a corporate test in the sense of the "religious test" the founders were talking about. A candidate doesn't legally have to be publicly affiliated with a particular corporation to get elected. There's no law saying that to hold a particular office, someone must be a major shareholder of Microsoft, for example. In fact, politicians, even the biggest corporate whores among them, go out of their way to try to obscure any corporate allegiance.

Of course there is a corporate test. Corporations give a large amount of money to candidates every election cycle and while you may not believe this, I think there has to be a quid pro quo at work here.




I've been talking about why, in fact everything I've posted has had to do with why it's a bad idea.



I'd be OK with religious parties. They've got some in Europe and that hasn't interfered with the secularization of the Continent. In fact, it may have accelerated it, by making it more open, rather than the hypocritical system in the US, where the GOP is gradually becoming the evangelical Protestant party, but doesn't have the guts to just come out an label itself accurately.

Europe's token religious parties don't concern me. I'm concerned about what may happen in America and comparing current American religious involvement in politics to full-blown religious parties seems a bit disingenuous to me.
 
I discovered what I believe in....me! I control my behavior and morality
It is good if you have that kind of control, and the only thing you need is you. I can't find one thing wrong, with what you choose to believe.
 
There are also horrible things that happen outside of coincidence so do we blame god or let him off the hook with ..."he has a reason"
In my opinion God caused all things too happen, so if a horrible thing happens, and you want, blame God.
 
In my opinion God caused all things too happen, so if a horrible thing happens, and you want, blame God.


Why would I blame god? I don't believe in the supernatural. I also don't credit him......actually , when I make speeches I wear the same earrings...my good luck earrings. That's kind of believing. I guess superstition is the same thing..in my opinion.
 
It is so easy to find what you think is the real deal, only to find out it is mostly about money, power, and control. I make it a point to not discuss individual churches, and if you are happy with your church stick with it.

I don't believe in coincidence. But that's just me. This sort of thing has happened more than once. I will tell you one of them that happened a number of years ago. My husband's workplace was downsizing and he hadn't been there very long so he knew he was going to lose his job. His boss told him that we could relocate to Alaska and his job would be saved. The relocation would be pretty swift .... no time to sell our house. So we figured it couldn't happen. We pray and trust about everything. So we did that in this case too.

We told some friends about the possibility of moving to Alaska and they said they wanted to buy our house, but it would require that they sell theirs and that would take time. Just a few days later, a man at our friend's work [who was relocating here from Japan] said that he needed a house for him and his family, and described our friends house exactly. So the Japanese guy moved into our friend's house [and made the payments until closing], our friend paid the payments on our house while his was being bought. Then he bought ours. We moved to Alaska and bought a house.........and all the closing dates were exactly right so all of that could happen.

That is far more than coincidence, my friend.
The idea is not to pray and tell God what you want then expect it to be handed out. The idea is to put your life into God's hands and accept each challenge with relish and ask God to work his miracles in whatever way he sees fit. And believe me, God has way more cool stuff in mind for you than you can imagine, so it will work out a lot better than you could expect.

I have many examples in my life and I know it's true.
Jen
It is hard to believe that many co-incidents without some guidance from somewhere, and do believe God has touched your life. The truth is we never know all there is to know.
 
It is hard to believe that many co-incidents without some guidance from somewhere, and do believe God has touched your life. The truth is we never know all there is to know.


I know people who have had some terrible co incidents happen to them with the guidance from somewhere .... does that mean God touched their lives
 
I know people who have had some terrible co incidents happen to them with the guidance from somewhere .... does that mean God touched their lives
NO. it only means that I believe that if it's your day you can win, lose, or draw. More than that you will have to find out from God.
 
That's because you'll never hear a sermon in a Catholic Church. A homily is about as close as you'll come to hearing one. Most Protestant Churches, and certainly the Southern Baptist variety, don't operate under the kind of strict hierarchy that outlines the rigid structure of a Catholic Mass, and Priests are not preachers.

I too have been shocked in recent decades by the amount of blatant secular politics that has infested the more conservative strains of Protestant preaching. Still, to pretend that there are no politics nor social club atmosphere present in a Catholic Church is patently ridiculous. It simply expresses itself in a slightly different manner, due to the different environment.
Yeah, there are those that start their day, and finish their day with accounts from a certain TV news organization, and they swear that everything on that broadcast is gospel. It is almost Gospel that hates, and lies, and will cheat in any way to win, and they still think they are holy. And that what they want is to destroy any politician that opposes them. And that's here in America. Lord have mercy.
 
I know people who have had some terrible co incidents happen to them with the guidance from somewhere .... does that mean God touched their lives
Yes! But would you want the devil with that kind of power.
 
Yes! But would you want the devil with that kind of power.


According to the Bible, God created Satan.

Did you ever wonder why He doesn't simply destroy him, as He destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah?

God went so far as to kill every human except for Noah's family in the great flood, simply for being disobedient -- yet Lucifer gets a pass?

What's up with that?
 
According to the Bible, God created Satan.

Did you ever wonder why He doesn't simply destroy him, as He destroyed Sodom and Gomorrah?

God went so far as to kill every human except for Noah's family in the great flood, simply for being disobedient -- yet Lucifer gets a pass?

What's up with that?
Good question, for which I have no answer. But I must tell you that I find the story of the great flood a little hard to swallow.
 
Back
Top