I'd be OK with that. However, I'd also be OK with creating a tax exemption for genuine charitable work. That could include charitable work by churches, but, like non-church entities, they'd need to distinguish between the part of their organization that does charitable work, and the part that doesn't. That way if someone donated money to an organization that the church uses exclusively to, say, bring clean drinking water to poor villages in the Sudan, that would be tax deductible, but if someone donated money to an organization the church uses to install a big AV system for sermons, or to proselytize for new members, or to pay to defend clergy sex abuse cases, that wouldn't be.