New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Religeons

For those of you who don't know, NS is in more than one thread trying to show that I'm not really religious because I don't fit in with his preconceived notions of who I should be and what I should believe, so there's going to be a lot of this juvenile bullcrap from him after every post I make in this Religion forum. Sorry about that guys but I believe in evolution and the heliocentric solar system so some people think I'm not really Christian.

In fact, I'm just going to go ahead and do what has to be done here. I'm tired of you playing 'gotcha' games. It's too bad because I don't have much of an issue with what you say in the other forums on the board but your childishness in this one is something I'm just not willing to waste my time dealing with anymore so congratulations, you are now the one and only occupant of the iggy bin, and it's permanent.


If you desire to address me, then address me. I may leave the site from time to time, but I usually come back.

You've assumed many things about me that I have not written, and now you appear to be calling upon the townspeople of this little burg to assist you in taking retribution against me for the misperceived sleights of which I am accused.

I don't care what you call yourself. I don't really care very much about these little evolution arguments either. These tired, old themes have been beaten to death in religious fora, so there is hardly anything novel left to be said.

I'm surprised that you'd be surprised by the social club nature of community churches. I'm also surprised that you would assert that this political aspect of churchgoing doesn't apply to the Catholic Church. That's certainly not reflective of my own experience.
 
Last edited:
The Catholic church seems to be a little more about crowd control than social club, but at present, they are weak on the crowd control aspect since most people are only nominally catholic. The social club thing comes from the feeling of community where one says "I am Catholic" and is immediately linked with the millions of people who are also Catholic. There is nothing wrong or even bad about that group identification. But it has absolutely nothing to do with a personal relationship with God. Any relationship with God has to be one-on-one and unique to be real.

If you move into a new town in the South, and you desire to successfully do business there, then you'd damned well better be in Church on Sunday. That's another aspect of the "social club" atmosphere that I'm familiar with.
 
The Catholic church seems to be a little more about crowd control than social club, but at present, they are weak on the crowd control aspect since most people are only nominally catholic.

Speaking specifically about Catholicism, it takes more heat than others. It's been around a lot longer and has had more power and influence than others. It's had more time and opportunity to do things which people can point to and say 'aha!, you're really bad', but as far as people being nominally Catholic I would say that that point applies to any organization, and in order to make the statement that anyone in any organization is nominally a member of that organization assumes a knowledge of the organization that the members themselves do not have. I don't know of any large body of people where all of the members march in lockstep.

Any relationship with God has to be one-on-one and unique to be real.

I completely agree with you about this. My point earlier was that because you acknowledge a Creator and obviously believe that He is working in the world you were able to see what happened to you, whatever that was, for what it was. People who don't want to believe that these things happen are very difficult to talk to about these types of things and are not as likely to want to believe that they happen even if they do happen to them. That's all I was saying.
 
There are also horrible things that happen outside of coincidence so do we blame god or let him off the hook with ..."he has a reason"
What do you mean "we"? Do you believe the Divine is at work in the world and do you give credit for the "good" things? If you do then we can discuss the "bad" but if you don't then your question seems awful one-sided.
 
Speaking specifically about Catholicism, it takes more heat than others. It's been around a lot longer and has had more power and influence than others. It's had more time and opportunity to do things which people can point to and say 'aha!, you're really bad', but as far as people being nominally Catholic I would say that that point applies to any organization, and in order to make the statement that anyone in any organization is nominally a member of that organization assumes a knowledge of the organization that the members themselves do not have. I don't know of any large body of people where all of the members march in lockstep.



I completely agree with you about this. My point earlier was that because you acknowledge a Creator and obviously believe that He is working in the world you were able to see what happened to you, whatever that was, for what it was. People who don't want to believe that these things happen are very difficult to talk to about these types of things and are not as likely to want to believe that they happen even if they do happen to them. That's all I was saying.

I think the Catholic church is great because it doesn't require people to march in lockstep. That is a positive feature, but of course it can also be a negative in some instances. All religions have their place and they are important to people who need them. A group of people working together is a good thing.

And I agree that non-believers are what they are. Everyone has choice.
 
What do you mean "we"? Do you believe the Divine is at work in the world and do you give credit for the "good" things? If you do then we can discuss the "bad" but if you don't then your question seems awful one-sided.

Are you speaking to me here? Not sure but I will give you my opinion. The earth, planets, universe (everything) are set up on physical rules of science. We know what many of those rules are and our mathematicians and scientists have proven them to be true. 2+2 = 4 is a pretty solid statement as far as we know. So every action has a reaction. Everything we do has a consequence be it minute or great. Throwing a stone into water produces ripples.

God does not change science (usually) though he can since he created it. Bad consequences follow bad actions. Sometimes bad consequences follow good actions. But it's all math and science and those rules are set in stone. Also, Evil exists and that is something that opposes God every chance it gets.

Through belief and trust in God, we can roll with the bad easier and we'll get help through it too. Belief in God does not eliminate the laws of nature or Evil. And there's bad stuff in there no matter how much we believe God is Good.

That's how I see it and how it's played out in my life anyway.
 
If you move into a new town in the South, and you desire to successfully do business there, then you'd damned well better be in Church on Sunday. That's another aspect of the "social club" atmosphere that I'm familiar with.

Hahaha... well. The South is what it is. And yep. What you say here is no doubt true. That's not God though. It's the people.
 
Sorry. I hope it was okay for me to answer.

I'm glad you did because you made a point that I was going to make to Renee later. Some people are fixated on "good" things or "bad" things but that's not really how we should look at it. In your house example, everything worked out for you and yours but someone else may have been hurt by it, we'll never know but it's a mistake to assume that an event is absolutely good for everyone. The same goes for assuming something is absolutely bad, we have no idea what might have happened if the event in question hadn't happened first.
 
I'm glad you did because you made a point that I was going to make to Renee later. Some people are fixated on "good" things or "bad" things but that's not really how we should look at it. In your house example, everything worked out for you and yours but someone else may have been hurt by it, we'll never know but it's a mistake to assume that an event is absolutely good for everyone. The same goes for assuming something is absolutely bad, we have no idea what might have happened if the event in question hadn't happened first.

I agree. I don't know who my house thing would have been bad for, but it's certainly possible. Good and Bad are facts of life. How we deal with it is up to us.

Oh, and sometimes we're the windshield and sometimes we're the bug. :p
 
I agree. I don't know who my house thing would have been bad for, but it's certainly possible. Good and Bad are facts of life. How we deal with it is up to us.

Oh, and sometimes we're the windshield and sometimes we're the bug. :p

Suppose that you didn't sell your house right away and had to stay a bit longer than planned and then ended up selling to someone other than you did. And, let's suppose that the person who ended up moving into your house later was a paramedic. This is a lot of 'what if' I know but now let's say that 10 years from now a student gets in a car accident outside of the house you used to live in and needs immediate treatment to survive. Let's also suppose that the student would grow up to cure cancer. The paramedic is home and is able to stabilize the student. The person who really did end up buying your house even if home at the time wouldn't have been able to save the student's life... now we still have cancer and a lot of other people will die who wouldn't have died if things hadn't of gone so well for you and yours regarding the houses.

Consider what happened with the tsunami in Japan and the Fukushima reactor. Horrible tragedy, right? Let's say that the tsunami didn't happen and as a result some needed improvements in Japan's nuclear facilities weren't made or weren't fast tracked because the same urgency just wasn't there. Maybe as a result you have a far more devastating nuclear disaster in a more heavily populated area at a later date.

Or maybe better things happen in both cases, the point is we don't know so we can't really make the statement that something is "good" or "bad" as far as most people on this planet or those who will be on the planet are concerned. This is why I don't really like the "why don't you blame God for bad things" argument.
 
Suppose that you didn't sell your house right away and had to stay a bit longer than planned and then ended up selling to someone other than you did. And, let's suppose that the person who ended up moving into your house later was a paramedic. This is a lot of 'what if' I know but now let's say that 10 years from now a student gets in a car accident outside of the house you used to live in and needs immediate treatment to survive. Let's also suppose that the student would grow up to cure cancer. The paramedic is home and is able to stabilize the student. The person who really did end up buying your house even if home at the time wouldn't have been able to save the student's life... now we still have cancer and a lot of other people will die who wouldn't have died if things hadn't of gone so well for you and yours regarding the houses.

Consider what happened with the tsunami in Japan and the Fukushima reactor. Horrible tragedy, right? Let's say that the tsunami didn't happen and as a result some needed improvements in Japan's nuclear facilities weren't made or weren't fast tracked because the same urgency just wasn't there. Maybe as a result you have a far more devastating nuclear disaster in a more heavily populated area at a later date.

Or maybe better things happen in both cases, the point is we don't know so we can't really make the statement that something is "good" or "bad" as far as most people on this planet or those who will be on the planet are concerned. This is why I don't really like the "why don't you blame God for bad things" argument.

I have never blamed God for the bad.
But I do thank God for getting me through it. And if my getting through it includes me dying, that's okay too. It is what it is. Easier to roll with pain than it is to fight it.
 
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to imply that you had done that. I was dealing more with the comment you made about not knowing what could have been bad about the house deal.
 
I'm sorry, I didn't mean to imply that you had done that. I was dealing more with the comment you made about not knowing what could have been bad about the house deal.

No problem. Had it gone in some other way it could have been difficult. The way it did go I can't see that it was bad for anyone specifically because of the house sale. But it's possible. Ripples in the water don't know who deserves what.........they just happen. But I think that having God in our lives can make us solid enough to take the ripples when they come and I do think that sometimes God provides little miracles way in advance to come our way just at the right time in the future. We have to remember that our Creator is not bound to our time line. Time to us is only relevant on this earth. So God knows past and future as if it is all present........
 
What do you mean "we"? Do you believe the Divine is at work in the world and do you give credit for the "good" things? If you do then we can discuss the "bad" but if you don't then your question seems awful one-sided.


I give neither credit nor blame. I don't believe in the supernatural, sometimes I wish I did.
 
Why do you sometimes wish you did?


I used to believe and took comfort from believing that someone would solve my problems and do good for the world. I cannot suspend logic anymore and therefore don't get this comfort that many here get.
 
Let's examine this.

Were you really taught that someone would solve all of your problems for you?

What logic are you suspending?

If this is what you really think of religious people then why are you even bothering to post in the Religion forum?
 
Back
Top