New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Religeons

Let's examine this.

Were you really taught that someone would solve all of your problems for you?

What logic are you suspending?

If this is what you really think of religious people then why are you even bothering to post in the Religion forum?


I should have said HELP solve my problems. I used to pray for help all the time. The logic I am suspending is belief in the supernatural...that angels appear and talk to us etc. the stories in the bible etc. I did say religious people get comfort and I think that is a good thing, why should I not post in a religion forum!? You sound like that Fox News reporter .....are only religious people allowed to post here? Is religion a no hands on topic?
 
I didn't say that I had heard a sermon in a Catholic church, read it again, I said I'd never heard politics discussed there. Nice try though, gotta give you credit for beating that dead horse across multiple threads. Oh Noes! I left out a word which wasn't necessary due to the context of the statement...I must not know what I'm talking about! Oh woe is me, you caught me! Good Job!

I can't speak to the amount of politics in Protestant church services but I have noticed an increase in the amount of people recently willing to state that they think certain things should be done in the secular world due to their religious beliefs.

As for what happens in Catholic churches, yep, obviously my opinion doesn't matter and should be automatically discounted as patently ridiculous since my experience doesn't at all jibe with what you so obviously want to be seen as true. The only time I've ever noticed anything political at all take place at a church I was a member of was last year when flyers had been placed on our windshields. They had to do with a perceived attack by the federal government on Catholic health care providers, and the parish wasn't responsible for that, that came from higher up.

Yeah, I'd been going to Mass for at least 50 years, before I heard even the slightest thing that could be construed as "political". It was a one-time mention mention of the name Vice President Cheney, in the context of a much broader discussion around a Hobbesian world view. It was so fleeting that imagine most paid it no nevermind. But suffice to say...I was a little taken aback!

Then a few years later, some young junior Priest who'd been there for maybe three months, launched into a riff about how Planned Parenthood is the equivalent of "genocide" (as to African-Americans). Ya coulda heard a pin drop. As I'm not into Parish "politics", I don't know what happened to him, but I never saw him again.

Oh....one more from way back...20+ years ago, the city nearest us passed an ordinance giving gay people some pretty basic human rights - housing, employment, and that sort of thing, So..we came out from Mass one day, to find flyers on all our windshields prevailing upon us to vote "Yes" on a measure to repeal that ordinance. Next week at Mass, Fr. George gave the most animated homily I'd ever seen from him, excoriating those who'd left the fliers.
 

I don't believe in coincidence. But that's just me. This sort of thing has happened more than once. I will tell you one of them that happened a number of years ago. My husband's workplace was downsizing and he hadn't been there very long so he knew he was going to lose his job. His boss told him that we could relocate to Alaska and his job would be saved. The relocation would be pretty swift .... no time to sell our house. So we figured it couldn't happen. We pray and trust about everything. So we did that in this case too.

We told some friends about the possibility of moving to Alaska and they said they wanted to buy our house, but it would require that they sell theirs and that would take time. Just a few days later, a man at our friend's work [who was relocating here from Japan] said that he needed a house for him and his family, and described our friends house exactly. So the Japanese guy moved into our friend's house [and made the payments until closing], our friend paid the payments on our house while his was being bought. Then he bought ours. We moved to Alaska and bought a house.........and all the closing dates were exactly right so all of that could happen.

That is far more than coincidence, my friend.
The idea is not to pray and tell God what you want then expect it to be handed out. The idea is to put your life into God's hands and accept each challenge with relish and ask God to work his miracles in whatever way he sees fit. And believe me, God has way more cool stuff in mind for you than you can imagine, so it will work out a lot better than you could expect.

I have many examples in my life and I know it's true.
Jen
Wow, Jen, you said a mouth full. Co-incidences do happen, but still sometimes you just know the difference. How can He be everywhere in this world.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It is so easy to find what you think is the real deal, only to find out it is mostly about money, power, and control. I make it a point to not discuss individual churches, and if you are happy with your church stick with it.
And don't you think churches are about money, power and control. I am not Christian for almost unlimited reasons, and I would like to talk about those reasons. But I know you are all tired of my rhetoric.
 
And don't you think churches are about money, power and control. I am not Christian for almost unlimited reasons, and I would like to talk about those reasons. But I know you are all tired of my rhetoric.

Of course they are, you can't look at the history of any church, at least a Christian church, and not see it mixed up in influence peddling and making money.
 
I should have said HELP solve my problems. I used to pray for help all the time. The logic I am suspending is belief in the supernatural...that angels appear and talk to us etc. the stories in the bible etc. I did say religious people get comfort and I think that is a good thing, why should I not post in a religion forum!? You sound like that Fox News reporter .....are only religious people allowed to post here? Is religion a no hands on topic?

I don't think you shouldn't be allowed to post in this forum, I just asked you three questions.

I do agree that 'help' changes the meaning significantly. I don't understand why logic would need to be suspended in order to be religious or have faith but I do see how those who aren't can also be using logic. I was merely curious why you were posting in the religion forum given your statements, that's all.
 
I'm curious as to why a person would employ an arrogant and aggressive posting style, if they are not prepared to countenance an aggressive response.
 
How many religions do you think there are. It must number in the thousands. I have heard of many of them. Some are real, some not so much. Do you know of any that seem to have God at their back. The Catholic Church seems to have the money, but they have been around since Christianity started. Do you know of any that believe in God and not the son. Tell me what you think of your Church.
There are probably more religions than languages, in the world, of which the majority are either dead languages/religions, or ones particular to some small isolated group of tribes. In each case, you have the semantic issue of where you draw the line and call something its own religion or language, as opposed to a sect of a larger religion, or a dialect of a larger language.

As for which religion has God at its back, I guess I'd have to say atheism, if you call it a religion -- it's been growing at a remarkable pace all over the world, and appears to be the dominant religious trend in the most advanced nations.
 
Most churches have become political and should not be tax exempt
I believe that churches are political by definition, in all cases. The extent to which they engage in the electoral process varies greatly from church to church, but they all promote various policies, at least at the individual level, on subjects like sex, economics, an society, and that's political. None should be tax exempt.
 
There are probably more religions than languages, in the world, of which the majority are either dead languages/religions, or ones particular to some small isolated group of tribes. In each case, you have the semantic issue of where you draw the line and call something its own religion or language, as opposed to a sect of a larger religion, or a dialect of a larger language.

As for which religion has God at its back, I guess I'd have to say atheism, if you call it a religion -- it's been growing at a remarkable pace all over the world, and appears to be the dominant religious trend in the most advanced nations.

The definition for religion is clear. You must acknowledge a Creator and believe that the Creator exercises control over our world. So...uh...Atheists can kiss my ass.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jen
I believe that churches are political by definition, in all cases. The extent to which they engage in the electoral process varies greatly from church to church, but they all promote various policies, at least at the individual level, on subjects like sex, economics, an society, and that's political. None should be tax exempt.

I believe that too, Arkady......that churches are political by definition and by nature. Some engage in the electoral process others don't do it outright. And that's okay.
But Constitutionally, we have decreed that the State cannot run its own church with people required to join it and the tax exempt part is to insure that that doesn't happen. If churches are taxed, then the state has some control over them AND the church might be able to demand that the state does certain things that the state shouldn't do.

Tax free status is important because it removes the idea that one can force the other to do something. This is why I believe the government has overstepped its bounds when it requires that Catholic hospitals perform abortions and/ or provide abortion coverage in its own insurance.

So removing tax exempt status from churches.............seems to me to be a ploy by government to control our religion and it is unconstitutional and wrong.
 
I don't think you shouldn't be allowed to post in this forum, I just asked you three questions.

I do agree that 'help' changes the meaning significantly. I don't understand why logic would need to be suspended in order to be religious or have faith but I do see how those who aren't can also be using logic. I was merely curious why you were posting in the religion forum given your statements, that's all.
Thank you, I knew that it would come up, and was prepared to 'splain myself.
 
I believe that too, Arkady......that churches are political by definition and by nature. Some engage in the electoral process others don't do it outright. And that's okay.
But Constitutionally, we have decreed that the State cannot run its own church with people required to join it and the tax exempt part is to insure that that doesn't happen. If churches are taxed, then the state has some control over them AND the church might be able to demand that the state does certain things that the state shouldn't do.

Tax free status is important because it removes the idea that one can force the other to do something. This is why I believe the government has overstepped its bounds when it requires that Catholic hospitals perform abortions and/ or provide abortion coverage in its own insurance.

So removing tax exempt status from churches.............seems to me to be a ploy by government to control our religion and it is unconstitutional and wrong.
I'd simply have the government be completely even-handed as to religious and non-religious nature of institutions. That doesn't restrict any rights.

For example, let's say my organization objects to paying black people as much for work as it pays equally qualified white people, on the basis of the idea that whites are genetically superior, and therefore a policy that results in more money flowing to them is ultimately in the best interest of society. I have a right to believe that, no matter how absurd; and I have a right under the first amendment to say it. However, that doesn't mean I have a right to actually pay black people less for the same work. I'm subject to labor laws that make that illegal. Why should that be any different if I claim my belief isn't rooted in a PERSONAL conviction, but rather rooted in some ancient myth my superstitious distant ancestors adhered to?

The rule should be the same either way: no special treatment for someone who claims his non-compliance is due to religion, as opposed to philosophy, aesthetics, politics, whim or anything else. In the same way, if some organization doesn't want to cover birth control, or abortion, or some other medical service that we, the society, through the democratic process, have decided should be covered, then it is simply wrong for the government to say "wait, is your objection religious, or based on absolutely anything else, because only if it is religious does that give you a special dispensation." That kind of double-standard gives extra rights to the religious and thus promotes religion, which is something government shouldn't be doing. And, in the same way, they shouldn't be giving preferential tax treatments to churches that they wouldn't give to other non-religious organizations that function the same way.
 
I believe that churches are political by definition, in all cases. The extent to which they engage in the electoral process varies greatly from church to church, but they all promote various policies, at least at the individual level, on subjects like sex, economics, an society, and that's political. None should be tax exempt.

I certainly agree that by definition, churches are political. Any church that says it isn't is stupid or lying. But..it doesn't necessarily follow that they're NO different from an areligious political organization. For if that were the case, our founders wouldn't have gone so far out of there way to carve out a specific exception for them. And, it's certainly not the case that churches were apolitical at the time of our founding and now they're not.

Still.....we need to be able to draw a distinct line between religious and areligious. That's very difficult to do. And, I think the burden should fall on the churches, to maintain the original spirit of our founders, or risk losing that exemption altogether.
 
I'd simply have the government be completely even-handed as to religious and non-religious nature of institutions. That doesn't restrict any rights.

.

As we have recently seen with the IRS targeting groups that disagree with the party in control, to even pretend to be even-handed would be a joke.
 
I believe that churches are political by definition, in all cases. The extent to which they engage in the electoral process varies greatly from church to church, but they all promote various policies, at least at the individual level, on subjects like sex, economics, an society, and that's political. None should be tax exempt.

By your definition, no organization of any kind should be tax exempt. Is that what you believe?
 
By your definition, no organization of any kind should be tax exempt. Is that what you believe?

I'd be OK with that. However, I'd also be OK with creating a tax exemption for genuine charitable work. That could include charitable work by churches, but, like non-church entities, they'd need to distinguish between the part of their organization that does charitable work, and the part that doesn't. That way if someone donated money to an organization that the church uses exclusively to, say, bring clean drinking water to poor villages in the Sudan, that would be tax deductible, but if someone donated money to an organization the church uses to install a big AV system for sermons, or to proselytize for new members, or to pay to defend clergy sex abuse cases, that wouldn't be.
 
I'd be OK with that. However, I'd also be OK with creating a tax exemption for genuine charitable work. That could include charitable work by churches, but, like non-church entities, they'd need to distinguish between the part of their organization that does charitable work, and the part that doesn't. That way if someone donated money to an organization that the church uses exclusively to, say, bring clean drinking water to poor villages in the Sudan, that would be tax deductible, but if someone donated money to an organization the church uses to install a big AV system for sermons, or to proselytize for new members, or to pay to defend clergy sex abuse cases, that wouldn't be.

On a bit a tangent.....I remain certain that this explains why "IRSGate" is fizzling, despite Fox's best efforts. The next logical step of course, would be to subpoena the aggrieved organizations and have them answer a few questions - not only as to the presumptive harm they suffered, but as ot what it is they actually DO, that would justify giving them a tax exemption!
 
I believe that too, Arkady......that churches are political by definition and by nature. Some engage in the electoral process others don't do it outright. And that's okay.
But Constitutionally, we have decreed that the State cannot run its own church with people required to join it and the tax exempt part is to insure that that doesn't happen. If churches are taxed, then the state has some control over them AND the church might be able to demand that the state does certain things that the state shouldn't do.

Tax free status is important because it removes the idea that one can force the other to do something. This is why I believe the government has overstepped its bounds when it requires that Catholic hospitals perform abortions and/ or provide abortion coverage in its own insurance.

So removing tax exempt status from churches.............seems to me to be a ploy by government to control our religion and it is unconstitutional and wrong.


Since when are catholic hospitals forced to do abortions? How does removing tax exempt status lead to controlling religion? Quite the opposite. The church is taking advantage of the gov, and it they paid their fair share, they could be free to do and say anything.
 
Back
Top