New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Remembering the 1980 election

imreallyperplexed

Council Member
It seems that over the last week or so, we are hearing Republicans renew the comparison of the 1980 election to the 2012 election with Barack Obama playing the role of Jimmy Carter and Mitt Romney playing the role of Ronald Reagan. To assess that comparison, it is worth looking back at the 1980 election. Here is the link to the Wikipedia article:

The 1980 Presidential election:

On reading the article, I was struck by the major disparities between the two elections.

Though I am sure that righties will insist that there are lots of similarities, the differences between Barack Obama and Jimmy Carter are striking.

Carter had approval ratings in the low 30s and several prominent Democrats endorsed Reagan. Obama has maintained approval ratings in the high 40s (despite a weak economy) and will get several endorsements from "RINOs."

Carter suffered through a bitter primary campaign and would probably have lost to Jerry Brown if Brown had entered the race earlier. Ted Kennedy did a body blow to Carter. Obama has a united party and will run a united convention. He will be nominated and endorsed by Bill Clinton.

Carter was dour and preachy and tended to scold the American people. Obama is "hopeful/optomistic" but realistic. Carter had hostages in Iran. Obama authorized the mission that got OBL.

The contrasts between Ronald Reagan and Mitt Romney are striking as well.

Mitt Romney claims to be a "serious conservative" and Ronald Reagan was the "real thing"

Romney's support among the Republican faithful is shallow. (Support for Romney is driven by hate for Obama and liberals.) Reagan's support among the Republican faithful was ardent.

Mitt Romney has an uncomfortable relationship with the Reagan revolution. Ronald Reagan embodied the Reagan revolution.

I also noticed two particular paragraphs from the article that are worth highlighting:

Through the 1970s, the United States underwent a wrenching period of low economic growth, high inflation and interest rates, and intermittent energy crises. Added to this was a perceived sense of malaise that in both foreign and domestic affairs the nation was headed downward. By the beginning of the election season, the prolonged Iran hostage crisis had sharpened public perceptions of a national crisis.

Jimmy Carter was blamed for the Iran hostage crisis, in which the followers of the Ayatollah Khomeni burned American flags and chanted anti-American slogans, parading the captured American hostages in public, and burning effigies of Carter. Carter's critics saw him as an inept leader who had failed to solve the worsening economic problems at home. His supporters defended the president as a decent, well-intentioned man being unfairly attacked for problems that had been building for years.


It is quite clear that the Republicans are attempting to use their money, their advertising, and their Citizens United fueled massive propoganda machine to sell the narrative that America in 2012 is the same as America in 1980. However, I don't think that people are going to buy this. I was alive at the time. I voted for John Anderson. I was disturbed by that state of the nation in 1980. I was in sympathy with Carter's policies but I thought that he was ineffective. I didn't believe in Reagan or his policies. Anderson was the best option. This year is not 1980. The people that voted for the first time in 1980 are now 50 or older. Most people under 50 have distant or no memory of 1980 (or even of the Gingrich Revolution of 1994). They remember the Bush era. And try as it might the Repbulican Party can't run away from Bush, Bush's policies, and Bush's record. There is still a wealth of anger at Bush and it sticks on Romney. Furthermore, today, malaise is not the right word. Malaise signifies being adrift and rudderless. The public today is more angry and frustrated. What the public needs to do is choose a direction. It is a choice election. It is not a referendum on Obama's ineptness (except of course for the people who are hardwired ABO.)

Here is the second paragraph of note:

In his closing remarks, Reagan asked the viewers a simple yet devastating question that would resonate with voters in 1980 and beyond: "Are you better off now than you were four years ago? Is it easier for you to go and buy things in the stores than it was four years ago? Is there more or less unemployment in the country than there was four years ago? Is America as respected throughout the world as it was? Do you feel that our security is as safe, that we're as strong as we were four years ago? And if you answer all of those questions 'yes', why then, I think your choice is very obvious as to whom you will vote for. If you don't agree, if you don't think that this course that we've been on for the last four years is what you would like to see us follow for the next four, then I could suggest another choice that you have." According to President Carter's Press Secretary Jody Powell's memoirs, internal tracking polls showed the President's tiny lead turning into a major Reagan landslide over the final weekend.

The important point to remember here was that the 1980 debates were a mess. There were all sorts of fights about the debates. And if you read the whole article, it is pretty clear that Carter would have been better off not debating. There was only one debate and it was held one week before the election and - from polling evidence - turned a close race into a rout.

The important difference is timing. The Democrats already know the question in 2012. Jimmy Carter was caught off guard. Romney is asking that question now and not a week before the election. Where he falls down is that people have been watching him and sizing him up for almost two years now and people just don't like him very much. I don't think that the Democrats will have an awful convention. Rather, I think that it is likely to be positive and upbeat. And I just don't think that the debates will pack the punch in 2012 that they did in 1980 (though I am sure that they will be widely viewed). And even in 1980, Carter - for all his ineptness and unpopularity - still had a narrow lead over Reagan just before the fateful debate. It just doesn't seem to me that Romney will be able to open a lead. The best that he can hope for is a nailbiter, The downside - Obama getting a comfortable victory - is more likely in my mind.

Of course, there is a lot of the race that is yet to be run. And none of us really knows how things are going to play out. We shall see. But 2012 is not likely to be either 1980 (which the ABO folks want) or 1984 (with Obama in the role of Reagan which the Democrats would love to see). It is probably going to be something in between. It will be 2012.
 
Back
Top