New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Republican Brains

Arkady

President
There's an article on Salon.com today about a study testing brain differences based on party affiliation:

http://www.salon.com/2013/02/22/are_republican_brains_different_partner/

That particular study deals with the greater reliance of Republican brains on the amygdala (a section of the brain that processes fear). It could help to explain things like the Republican affinity for militarization and guns. If you have a heightened sense of fear about the world around you, aggression can be a natural response. I think most people who spend a lot of time with dogs are familiar with that -- generally it's not the big, mature alpha that is a threat to bite you unexpectedly. Rather, it's a dog that is fearful, because of its social or physical status, and which perceives a need for pre-emptive biting in cases where there's not even a real threat. That heightened fear might also explain the greater Republican discomfort with change and the unfamiliar. For example, I think it's no accident that bigotry against homosexuals is often classified as "homophobia" -- there is a phobic response at work there.

Aside from this fear response, something I personally see different about Republican brains is a strong preference for simplicity. I can sympathize here, because the moment a theory starts sounding too byzantine or a machine has too many working parts, I start pushing for ways to simplify it. In chess, I play a masterful endgame, but am awful in the middle of games, because I'm over-eager to start the piece swapping, to simplify my strategic considerations. This preference for simplicity can make a person a good mathematician or engineer, by cutting through mushy-headedness to the core considerations, and I think it's a strength of the male brain, in general. But in other settings it can be a real weakness. Sometimes there really are a lot of inter-relating parts that can't be ignored, and trying to shove the system down into some simplistic theory isn't going to work.

I see that from Republicans on economics all the time. The libertarian strain of Republican economics raises that preference for simplicity into a kind of holy dogma. Lower taxes are ALWAYS better. Smaller government is ALWAYS better. Less regulation is ALWAYS better. Republicans talking economics remind me of myself in the middle of a complicated chess game -- so frustrated by my inability to hold all the working parts of a complicated system in my mind simultaneously, that I just want to swipe my hand across the board and fling the pieces away. They don't like thinking in terms of long-term optimization of some multi-dimensional function, and so they keep retreating into absolutist principles.

Granted, there are some "rules of thumb" that are helpful for coping with the complexity of a system that's just too big for any human mind to hold it, just as there are in chess. In the mid-game of chess, when it's impossible to think about all the potential moves three or even just two moves down the road, one is forced to work more in terms of general strategic principles. Generally, for example, you want to try to control the middle of the board, and to move certain pieces to certain areas where they have the most options. But if you turn those rules of thumb into holy dogma, you'll lose against decent players, because there are huge numbers of exceptions. You need to be able to accept some amount of ambiguity and probabilistic thinking to cope well. In the same sense, it might be OK to embrace a rule of thumb that says less regulation of industry is generally better, but you need to understand the exceptions are frequent and so if you want good results you're going to need to be willing to move off that rule of thumb frequently.

Economics is the place I see Republicans most often pulling too hard towards simplicity, but it shows up in other places, too. For example, in foreign policy Republicans seem to have taken a single lesson ("Neville Chamberlain made a mistake when he tried to placate Hitler") and turned it into an all-purpose algorithm for dealing with any foreign policy question ("all foreign policy challenges must be met with total inflexibility, backed by eagerness to use overwhelming military force.")
 
America is bursting to the gills with people who have taken ONE college course in economics, and think they know everything they need to know about economics, or even everything there IS to know about economics.

Such people are dangerous. We even have a platitude for it: A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

I personally DETEST people who try to over-simplify economics. I was just explaining to my Intro to Economics class this morning just how complex the debate over minimum wage laws really is, when you dig into pro and con arguments by Ph.D. economists....
 
Does it mention the gullibility of the Democrat brain? I think you got suckered by another joke article. No names, institutions, dates or documents are cited and you still bought it? Plus, it came from Alternet, the batshit craziest liberal toilet on the internet...
 
America is bursting to the gills with people who have taken ONE college course in economics, and think they know everything they need to know about economics, or even everything there IS to know about economics.

Such people are dangerous. We even have a platitude for it: A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

I personally DETEST people who try to over-simplify economics. I was just explaining to my Intro to Economics class this morning just how complex the debate over minimum wage laws really is, when you dig into pro and con arguments by Ph.D. economists....

Minimum wage is a great example. It isn't hard to picture how a rising minimum wage COULD result in rising unemployment. In a simple system, if there are people who are employed at the absolute maximum pay that employing them makes economic sense, then raising the minimum wage above that level will result in them losing their jobs. But the point is that this isn't a simple system. It's a system with all sorts of moving parts. For example, raising the minimum wage causes upward pressure on other wages, which can raise consumer incomes generally, which can raise demand for consumer products, which can raise the amount of pay that can be profitably shelled out for low-end workers making those product. Raising minimum wage also increases the spread between the rewards of having a job and the alternative of being on the dole, which will potentially raise productivity (as people have more incentive to work hard to keep their jobs), and as productivity rises so does the amount you can profitably pay the worker. That's just the tip of the iceberg when it comes to the interactions between the minimum wage and unemployment.

That's why you're better off looking at real-world results from "natural experiments" situations where minimum wages rose in some areas and not in others that can act as decent control groups, to see what actually happens. Trying to model the whole thing from basic principles is just not going to work, because there are too many factors interacting in too many unknown ways, but checking what ACTUALLY happened in hundreds of natural experiments will teach you things. And what studies of that show is that, at least within reasonable levels, the minimum wage can be quite a bit higher than it is today without meaningfully depressing employment.

But, Republicans just fixate on that very first step, where they see how an increased minimum wage COULD increase unemployment, in an ultra-simplified model, and they just don't want to be nudged off of that.... and that kind of obstinacy is why their economic predictions are routinely crappy. They're basically saying "here's what my absurdly simplified model would predict, notwithstanding what all the more complicated models and the actual real-world history suggest, and therefore that's what I think will happen."
 
Does it mention the gullibility of the Democrat brain? I think you got suckered by another joke article. No names, institutions, dates or documents are cited and you still bought it? Plus, it came from Alternet, the batshit craziest liberal toilet on the internet...

I have to agree with you for once Jake. Though interesting, I chased the hyperlinks around and can't find any details about who actually performed the study.
 
Does it mention the gullibility of the Democrat brain? I think you got suckered by another joke article. No names, institutions, dates or documents are cited and you still bought it? Plus, it came from Alternet, the batshit craziest liberal toilet on the internet...

Presumably you'll be more comfortable here:

http://www.foxnews.com/health/2013/02/20/are-wired-to-be-republican/

Here's the article:

http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0052970
 
Thanks Ark. I'm not sure why the Alternet story wouldn't have made mention of this!

The study, from the University of Exeter and the University of California, San Diego, evaluated the brain activity of 82 subjects engaged in gambling games.
 
Thanks Ark. I'm not sure why the Alternet story wouldn't have made mention of this!

The study, from the University of Exeter and the University of California, San Diego, evaluated the brain activity of 82 subjects engaged in gambling games.

It was sloppy not to cite to it, but since it was on Salon.com, I was fairly confident that it was a fundamentally accurate summary of a peer-reviewed study, just because Salon is pretty reputable.
 
Republican brains...because nobody thinks they do not havce abrain...now on the other hand nobody thinks democrats have a brain...thus the Democrat logic of think going from 10.8 trillion to 16.4 trillion is debt reduction.

America is bursting to the gills with people who have taken ONE college course in economics, and think they know everything they need to know about economics, or even everything there IS to know about economics.

That does explain democrat logic once again...They havent done a budget in 4 years plus ...and anyone who has done even one course in economics would know that with out a busget you will not succeed....If you fail to plan you plan to fail.
 
It was sloppy not to cite to it, but since it was on Salon.com, I was fairly confident that it was a fundamentally accurate summary of a peer-reviewed study, just because Salon is pretty reputable.

making my point again...salon reputable...rather laughable. Democrats dont have brains..they are the dumbing down of society...the go with the lowest common denominator.
 
Republican brains...because nobody thinks they do not havce abrain...now on the other hand nobody thinks democrats have a brain...thus the Democrat logic of think going from 10.8 trillion to 16.4 trillion is debt reduction.

That does explain democrat logic once again...They havent done a budget in 4 years plus ...and anyone who has done even one course in economics would know that with out a busget you will not succeed....If you fail to plan you plan to fail.

Here, folks, in all its 'glory', is the typical Republican brain.
 
So are you(reputable), Arkady. I thoroughly enjoy reading your thoughts and arguments on a wide variety of topics, always fact-based. So much so that I began quoting you to 2 of my teenage sons, 18 and 15 years old, respectively. Now you have some teen fans as well!

The article does make a lot of sense. I have always suspected that Republicans brains are wired differently. A little AC/DC ;)

It was sloppy not to cite to it, but since it was on Salon.com, I was fairly confident that it was a fundamentally accurate summary of a peer-reviewed study, just because Salon is pretty reputable.
 
Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah blah blah bla

BTW- Salon is an award winning and reputable magazine. If only you could read. (sigh)

making my point again...salon reputable...rather laughable. Democrats dont have brains..they are the dumbing down of society...the go with the lowest common denominator.
 
I know, right??! OMG, the other pet peeve of mine is people who take ONE class in Psychology and think they are Psychologists. In a lot of cases, a little info is a dangerous thing.

Too many times I think Republicans will deny more knowledge to avoid being called "elitist" instead of worrying if they have enough information to make a measured decision. When they get stuck on a wrong point, they tend to go to the ends of the Earth to prove they are right. When in fact, they have always been wrong. Then it makes their decision-making ability that much more contentious.

Like President Obama getting re-elelcted. They were so wrong about Rmoney that now they still want to ruin Obama's second term, even at the risk of destroying the GOP brand. Typical.

America is bursting to the gills with people who have taken ONE college course in economics, and think they know everything they need to know about economics, or even everything there IS to know about economics.

Such people are dangerous. We even have a platitude for it: A little knowledge is a dangerous thing.

I personally DETEST people who try to over-simplify economics. I was just explaining to my Intro to Economics class this morning just how complex the debate over minimum wage laws really is, when you dig into pro and con arguments by Ph.D. economists....
 
From the original study

One of the functions of the anterior cingulate cortex is to monitor uncertainty [16,17] and conflicts [18]. Thus, it is conceivable that individuals with a larger ACC have a higher capacity to tolerate uncertainty and conflicts, allowing them to accept more liberal views. Such speculations provide a basis for theorizing about the psychological constructs (and their neural substrates) underlying political attitudes. However, it should be noted that every brain region, including those identified here, invariably participates in multiple psychological processes. It is therefore not possible to unambiguously infer from involvement of a particular brain area that a particular psychological process must be involved.

http://www.cell.com/current-biology/abstract/S0960-9822(11)00289-2#ResultsandDiscussion

More chaff from left wing talking points.
 
The Budget of the United States Government often begins as the President's proposal to the U.S. Congress which recommends funding levels for the next fiscal year, beginning October 1. However, Congress is the body required by law to pass a budget annually and to submit the budget passed by both houses to the President for signature. Congressional decisions are governed by rules and legislation regarding the federal budget process. Budget committees set spending limits for the House and Senate committees and for Appropriations subcommittees, which then approve individual appropriations bills to allocate funding to various federal programs.

If Congress fails to pass an annual budget (as has been the case since 2009), a series of Appropriations bills must be passed as "stop gap" measures. After Congress approves an appropriations bill, it is sent to the President, who may sign it into law, or may veto it (as he would a budget when passed by the Congress). A vetoed bill is sent back to Congress, which can pass it into law with a two-thirds majority in each chamber. Congress may also combine all or some appropriations bills into an omnibus reconciliation bill. In addition, the president may request and the Congress may pass supplemental appropriations bills or emergency supplemental appropriations bills.
****************************************************
If only you could understand what you try to read. (sigh)
IO

Republican brains...because nobody thinks they do not havce abrain...now on the other hand nobody thinks democrats have a brain...thus the Democrat logic of think going from 10.8 trillion to 16.4 trillion is debt reduction.



That does explain democrat logic once again...They havent done a budget in 4 years plus ...and anyone who has done even one course in economics would know that with out a busget you will not succeed....If you fail to plan you plan to fail.
 
I did.

http://www.cell.com/current-biology/abstract/S0960-9822(11)00289-2#ResultsandDiscussion

But there is a disclaimer in there that basically renders the study moot.

One of the functions of the anterior cingulate cortex is to monitor uncertainty [16,17] and conflicts [18]. Thus, it is conceivable that individuals with a larger ACC have a higher capacity to tolerate uncertainty and conflicts, allowing them to accept more liberal views. Such speculations provide a basis for theorizing about the psychological constructs (and their neural substrates) underlying political attitudes. However, it should be noted that every brain region, including those identified here, invariably participates in multiple psychological processes. It is therefore not possible to unambiguously infer from involvement of a particular brain area that a particular psychological process must be involved.
 
Back
Top