New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Revoking security clearances

Boltlady

Governor
Until Brennan got his clearance revoked it had never occurred to me that people would even keep their clearance after they were no longer employed by the gov't. It seems pretty foolish to me given that so many go to work for lobbyists shortly after leaving.

Could this be one way that Trump is letting the public know what goes on in the swamp? It may not have been his main reason in that Brennan certainly has given enough reasons to lose his but it has been useful in getting the word out to the public.
 
https://townhall.com/columnists/kur...ts-time-to-stamp-out-elite-privilege-n2511233
From the link;
"Help, I’m being oppressed! My freedom of speech was been utterly stripped from me because when I retired from the Army those fascist monsters took away my TOP SECRET security clearance. See, a security clearance is a special privilege I should be entitled to exploit for as long as I want to because… well, shut up peasant, that’s why. I learned this in my Con Law class, right after we studied the Constitution’s text enumerating the rights to abortion, wedding cake baking servitude, and to be called by the bizarre pronoun of your – I mean “xir” – choice.

Oh wait, all of that – except the giving up my clearance part – is utter nonsense.

But John Brennan, that hack, and his elite pals are supposed to get the special privilege of keeping it. Why? As a professional courtesy. See, security clearances are things you pass out as favors or rewards, I guess, at least among the elite. Courtesy among them, nothing for you, though. You aren’t special. You’re just some guy serving his country and not turning it into a profit center on the outside. Like a sucker.

I got my clearance for the same reason you readers who got one got yours –because I needed it to do my job in the service of our country. And when I stopped needing it because I was no longer doing a job in the service of my country, I didn’t get to keep it to inflate my value as a pundit or “consultant.” Mine went away. As did yours, I’ll wager. The chances are pretty infinitesimal that you are one of the special somebodies who get handed power and privilege not to serve our country but as a perk for being part of the in-crowd.

CARTOONS | ROBERT ARIAIL

VIEW CARTOON
Being a colonel was just a job for me, and doing what you did was just a job for you. But for a lot of these retired generals and senior bureaucrat timeservers, it’s a lifestyle. I always saw my eagle as leased; they think they hold the pink slip on their positions. Oh, and do they ever have contempt for Normals like you.

Security clearances get pulled routinely when the holder no longer needs access because the fewer people with access, the safer the info is – pretty basic stuff. But hey, we’ll take the chance on classified info spilling if it means elite jerks can get to bask in the warm light of being In The Know. It’s not like any of our betters ever got caught up in classified info shenanigans. Not Felonia Milhous von Pantsuit. Not that Towering Doofus James Comey. Not David Petreaus. And not his mistress.

Oh, wait – all of them totally did. But, of course, these elite malefactors are all in jail, because you or I would be if we did what they did. Aren’t they?

Oh, right. They aren’t. They’re special. More professional courtesy. More special rules for special people.

Now, we’re also told that these special somebodies need to keep their clearances in case someone actually in the government who is actually doing a government job (instead of raking in bucks as a “consultant” or pundit) wants to ask their sage advice. How would that go with John Brennan?

“Hey John, it’s Don. Yeah, no hard feelings. Anyway, I needed to pick your brain about some stuff that you have a unique perspective on. So, how do I lie to Congress and get away with it? How about leaking to the liberal media – any pro tips? Oh, and how do I get 30 of our sources in China caught and shot? Yeah, I know you weren’t in charge of the CIA then, but you can tell me how you repaired the damage when you were Director. Oh. You didn’t. Awkward.”

If we had a real media and not the world’s most pompous Democrat transcription service, the CIA’s blown Chinese spy ring disaster would be front page news but hey, Omarosa! In any case, the only consulting anyone should do with the members of this class of unmitigated failures whose incompetence brought us 9/11, Iraq, Libya, ISIS, and a future where we would all be wise to learn Mandarin, is to ask their opinion and then do the opposite – Costanza style.

Let’s look at our elite’s track record of success. Don’t worry – it won’t take long. We’re still chasing bandits in Afghanistan after nearly 17 years, the Navy can’t stop running into other people’s boats, and our best and brightest in the FBI are texting each other like teens while they try to undo the election. They can’t be bothered with things like, I don’t know, following up on warnings about psychotic freaks who get online and announce their plan to shoot up schools. Oh, and remember the 2008 economic collapse? I’m thinking you weren’t the one making bad bets with billions of dollars that brought it all tumbling down. By the way, guess how many people the feds tossed in the pokey for the 2008 meltdown that cost you and me a trillion bucks? One. Uno. A single dude.

If you lifted $50 of Coors Light from a 7-Eleven fridge, where would you be?

Our elite is a failure that is fixated on its own privilege and avoiding accountability. As my upcoming book Militant Normals: How Regular Americans Are Rebelling Against the Elite to Reclaim Our Democracywonders, is it too much to ask that our elite actually be elite? Is it too much to ask that we have one standard of accountability?

The liberals are right about something – privilege is destroying our country. But it’s not privilege based on what hellhole your great-great-great grandfather escaped from or the kind of biological plumbing you were born with. It is privilege based on your membership in a selfish, feckless, unaccomplished caste of schmucks that fancies itself our betters yet rejects, with the help of a complicit liberal press, any kind of accountability for the mess it’s made of everything.

You know why you got Trump? Because Donald Trump, with all his quirks, is exponentially more competent, capable, and trustworthy when it comes to running this country for the benefit of Normal Americans than the sorry collection of Ivy League-credentialed dimwits, progressive poohbahs, and Fredocon enablers that masquerades as America’s elite.

Pull their security clearances? Yeah, but that’s just a start. Strip them of all of the privileges they haven’t earned, then ship the whole useless bunch of them off to a desert island and see if they can survive eating their own smugness."
 
Until Brennan got his clearance revoked it had never occurred to me that people would even keep their clearance after they were no longer employed by the gov't. It seems pretty foolish to me given that so many go to work for lobbyists shortly after leaving.

Could this be one way that Trump is letting the public know what goes on in the swamp? It may not have been his main reason in that Brennan certainly has given enough reasons to lose his but it has been useful in getting the word out to the public.

He will only be eliminating clearances for those who have criticized him. It is retaliation, pure and simple. Trying to make it into some really great accomplishment for Trump is just some silly bullshit. He is witness tampering by threatening people he sees as a threat to him.
 
https://townhall.com/columnists/kur...ts-time-to-stamp-out-elite-privilege-n2511233
From the link;
"Help, I’m being oppressed! My freedom of speech was been utterly stripped from me because when I retired from the Army those fascist monsters took away my TOP SECRET security clearance. See, a security clearance is a special privilege I should be entitled to exploit for as long as I want to because… well, shut up peasant, that’s why. I learned this in my Con Law class, right after we studied the Constitution’s text enumerating the rights to abortion, wedding cake baking servitude, and to be called by the bizarre pronoun of your – I mean “xir” – choice.

Oh wait, all of that – except the giving up my clearance part – is utter nonsense.

But John Brennan, that hack, and his elite pals are supposed to get the special privilege of keeping it. Why? As a professional courtesy. See, security clearances are things you pass out as favors or rewards, I guess, at least among the elite. Courtesy among them, nothing for you, though. You aren’t special. You’re just some guy serving his country and not turning it into a profit center on the outside. Like a sucker.

I got my clearance for the same reason you readers who got one got yours –because I needed it to do my job in the service of our country. And when I stopped needing it because I was no longer doing a job in the service of my country, I didn’t get to keep it to inflate my value as a pundit or “consultant.” Mine went away. As did yours, I’ll wager. The chances are pretty infinitesimal that you are one of the special somebodies who get handed power and privilege not to serve our country but as a perk for being part of the in-crowd.

CARTOONS | ROBERT ARIAIL

VIEW CARTOON
Being a colonel was just a job for me, and doing what you did was just a job for you. But for a lot of these retired generals and senior bureaucrat timeservers, it’s a lifestyle. I always saw my eagle as leased; they think they hold the pink slip on their positions. Oh, and do they ever have contempt for Normals like you.

Security clearances get pulled routinely when the holder no longer needs access because the fewer people with access, the safer the info is – pretty basic stuff. But hey, we’ll take the chance on classified info spilling if it means elite jerks can get to bask in the warm light of being In The Know. It’s not like any of our betters ever got caught up in classified info shenanigans. Not Felonia Milhous von Pantsuit. Not that Towering Doofus James Comey. Not David Petreaus. And not his mistress.

Oh, wait – all of them totally did. But, of course, these elite malefactors are all in jail, because you or I would be if we did what they did. Aren’t they?

Oh, right. They aren’t. They’re special. More professional courtesy. More special rules for special people.

Now, we’re also told that these special somebodies need to keep their clearances in case someone actually in the government who is actually doing a government job (instead of raking in bucks as a “consultant” or pundit) wants to ask their sage advice. How would that go with John Brennan?

“Hey John, it’s Don. Yeah, no hard feelings. Anyway, I needed to pick your brain about some stuff that you have a unique perspective on. So, how do I lie to Congress and get away with it? How about leaking to the liberal media – any pro tips? Oh, and how do I get 30 of our sources in China caught and shot? Yeah, I know you weren’t in charge of the CIA then, but you can tell me how you repaired the damage when you were Director. Oh. You didn’t. Awkward.”

If we had a real media and not the world’s most pompous Democrat transcription service, the CIA’s blown Chinese spy ring disaster would be front page news but hey, Omarosa! In any case, the only consulting anyone should do with the members of this class of unmitigated failures whose incompetence brought us 9/11, Iraq, Libya, ISIS, and a future where we would all be wise to learn Mandarin, is to ask their opinion and then do the opposite – Costanza style.

Let’s look at our elite’s track record of success. Don’t worry – it won’t take long. We’re still chasing bandits in Afghanistan after nearly 17 years, the Navy can’t stop running into other people’s boats, and our best and brightest in the FBI are texting each other like teens while they try to undo the election. They can’t be bothered with things like, I don’t know, following up on warnings about psychotic freaks who get online and announce their plan to shoot up schools. Oh, and remember the 2008 economic collapse? I’m thinking you weren’t the one making bad bets with billions of dollars that brought it all tumbling down. By the way, guess how many people the feds tossed in the pokey for the 2008 meltdown that cost you and me a trillion bucks? One. Uno. A single dude.

If you lifted $50 of Coors Light from a 7-Eleven fridge, where would you be?

Our elite is a failure that is fixated on its own privilege and avoiding accountability. As my upcoming book Militant Normals: How Regular Americans Are Rebelling Against the Elite to Reclaim Our Democracywonders, is it too much to ask that our elite actually be elite? Is it too much to ask that we have one standard of accountability?

The liberals are right about something – privilege is destroying our country. But it’s not privilege based on what hellhole your great-great-great grandfather escaped from or the kind of biological plumbing you were born with. It is privilege based on your membership in a selfish, feckless, unaccomplished caste of schmucks that fancies itself our betters yet rejects, with the help of a complicit liberal press, any kind of accountability for the mess it’s made of everything.

You know why you got Trump? Because Donald Trump, with all his quirks, is exponentially more competent, capable, and trustworthy when it comes to running this country for the benefit of Normal Americans than the sorry collection of Ivy League-credentialed dimwits, progressive poohbahs, and Fredocon enablers that masquerades as America’s elite.

Pull their security clearances? Yeah, but that’s just a start. Strip them of all of the privileges they haven’t earned, then ship the whole useless bunch of them off to a desert island and see if they can survive eating their own smugness."

Great find.:)
 
He will only be eliminating clearances for those who have criticized him. It is retaliation, pure and simple. Trying to make it into some really great accomplishment for Trump is just some silly bullshit. He is witness tampering by threatening people he sees as a threat to him.

Now that this particular horse has left the barn it could well be that some public pressure will come to bear that will lead to some common sense being used in eliminating this "privilege".
 
Until Brennan got his clearance revoked it had never occurred to me that people would even keep their clearance after they were no longer employed by the gov't. It seems pretty foolish to me given that so many go to work for lobbyists shortly after leaving.

Could this be one way that Trump is letting the public know what goes on in the swamp? It may not have been his main reason in that Brennan certainly has given enough reasons to lose his but it has been useful in getting the word out to the public.
1. Several of the people who Trump threatens to revoke their security clearance.....no longer have security clearances anyway, so what is Trump up to?

2. What this "list of enemies" have in common is they are all privy to information to testify as a witness to Trump's suspected misdeeds.

3. That makes Trump's actions/threat suspect. I call it Trump witness tampering. Trump trying to discredit these people. It's quite shameful truly.
 
Now that this particular horse has left the barn it could well be that some public pressure will come to bear that will lead to some common sense being used in eliminating this "privilege".
That's a separate issue entirely. How long or whether someone should retain their security clearance after leaving the job can be a discussion by congress.
What I have learned is that some of these top level people are called upon to consult, share their wealth of experience and knowledge when current spooks are concerned about some new development. Plus those who have security clearances are NOT able to just go and get more classified intel. It doesn't work that way.
 
That's a separate issue entirely. How long or whether someone should retain their security clearance after leaving the job can be a discussion by congress.
What I have learned is that some of these top level people are called upon to consult, share their wealth of experience and knowledge when current spooks are concerned about some new development. Plus those who have security clearances are NOT able to just go and get more classified intel. It doesn't work that way.

The nature of the word "experience" is that it is something based on that which has already happened. They could surely share that knowledge without being privy to the latest stuff.
 
The nature of the word "experience" is that it is something based on that which has already happened. They could surely share that knowledge without being privy to the latest stuff.
The only material these consultants are privy to is what's relevant to the current problem.
 
Now that this particular horse has left the barn it could well be that some public pressure will come to bear that will lead to some common sense being used in eliminating this "privilege".

I've heard several people interviewed on how their clearances were used productively to help with ongoing situations where they had knowledge of the players and past events. That included testimony before congress and time with current office holders.

I have yet to hear anyone call it a "privilege" that has helped them make a buck. It seems it is more like them making a contribution to the nation's best interests.
 
The nature of the word "experience" is that it is something based on that which has already happened. They could surely share that knowledge without being privy to the latest stuff.

and you know this from your wealth of experience in the intelligence business?

One former CIA director had to testify before a senate committee. To do so he went to CIA HQ and reviewed his own reports from the incident that the Senate wanted to discuss. Without his clearance he'd have been guessing at some parts of what they wanted to know.

Any damage done?
 
I've heard several people interviewed on how their clearances were used productively to help with ongoing situations where they had knowledge of the players and past events. That included testimony before congress and time with current office holders.

I have yet to hear anyone call it a "privilege" that has helped them make a buck. It seems it is more like them making a contribution to the nation's best interests.
Trump and his Trumpies want these experts to shut up if they disagree with Trump and NOT go on cable TV and talk about what's going on.
Putin would just poison them.
 
I couldn't say and I don't care anyway.... but it sure is fun watching that other guy lose his shit completely, lol. :D:p
How much of a [Unwelcome language removed] douchebag do you have to be to try and kick another commentator off a show that ain't even your's?:rolleyes:

If some douchebag goes on the air, calls you a liar and accuses you of misusing a security clearance to make money...would you lose your temper?
 
He will only be eliminating clearances for those who have criticized him. It is retaliation, pure and simple. Trying to make it into some really great accomplishment for Trump is just some silly bullshit. He is witness tampering by threatening people he sees as a threat to him.
1. Several of the people who Trump threatens to revoke their security clearance.....no longer have security clearances anyway, so what is Trump up to?

2. What this "list of enemies" have in common is they are all privy to information to testify as a witness to Trump's suspected misdeeds.

3. That makes Trump's actions/threat suspect. I call it Trump witness tampering. Trump trying to discredit these people. It's quite shameful truly.
So what did you hypocritical asshats have to say in 2013 when Obobo revoked the security clearances of thousands of people? Where was the outrage then?

Anything? Of course not!

You leftists are sooooo transparently pathetic. PATHETIC!

https://www.politico.com/story/2013/11/government-security-clearance-list-100195

"The Obama administration has ordered a government-wide reassessment of how almost 5 million Americans have been granted classified information security clearances and whether each person currently approved to see sensitive national security secrets truly has a need for such access."

“I write to express my concern about threats to national security resulting from the increasing number of people with eligibility for access to classified national security information, particularly Top Secret (TS) and Top Secret/Secure Compartmented Information (TS/SCI),” Clapper wrote in a three-page memo, dated Oct. 31 and cited at a Senate hearing Wednesday."

"Clapper asked agencies to perform a top-to-bottom scrub of the teeming rolls of people authorized to access classified information and to remove anyone deemed not to have a so-called need to know."
 
So what did you hypocritical asshats have to say in 2013 when Obobo revoked the security clearances of thousands of people? Where was the outrage then?

Anything? Of course not!

You leftists are sooooo transparently pathetic. PATHETIC!

https://www.politico.com/story/2013/11/government-security-clearance-list-100195

"The Obama administration has ordered a government-wide reassessment of how almost 5 million Americans have been granted classified information security clearances and whether each person currently approved to see sensitive national security secrets truly has a need for such access."

“I write to express my concern about threats to national security resulting from the increasing number of people with eligibility for access to classified national security information, particularly Top Secret (TS) and Top Secret/Secure Compartmented Information (TS/SCI),” Clapper wrote in a three-page memo, dated Oct. 31 and cited at a Senate hearing Wednesday."

"Clapper asked agencies to perform a top-to-bottom scrub of the teeming rolls of people authorized to access classified information and to remove anyone deemed not to have a so-called need to know."

Hey Twer-Pee-doh...the article you linked to does not state that thousands of people had their clearances revoked. It does say that after a major security leak, the president ordered a review. It was not based on politics. Obama was not revoking clearances because someone criticized him or his policies. It was based on national security and the costs of maintaining those clearances. Thanks for pointing out the differences between Obama and Trump.

ETC5425-LIGHTBLUE-LT-DESIGN.jpg
 
So what did you hypocritical asshats have to say in 2013 when Obobo revoked the security clearances of thousands of people? Where was the outrage then?

Anything? Of course not!

You leftists are sooooo transparently pathetic. PATHETIC!

https://www.politico.com/story/2013/11/government-security-clearance-list-100195

"The Obama administration has ordered a government-wide reassessment of how almost 5 million Americans have been granted classified information security clearances and whether each person currently approved to see sensitive national security secrets truly has a need for such access."

“I write to express my concern about threats to national security resulting from the increasing number of people with eligibility for access to classified national security information, particularly Top Secret (TS) and Top Secret/Secure Compartmented Information (TS/SCI),” Clapper wrote in a three-page memo, dated Oct. 31 and cited at a Senate hearing Wednesday."

"Clapper asked agencies to perform a top-to-bottom scrub of the teeming rolls of people authorized to access classified information and to remove anyone deemed not to have a so-called need to know."
If Trump were doing what Obama did.....that would be good. He isn't.
What Trump is doing is threatening former intel/spooks who've spoken out against him, some of whom don't even have security clearances to revoke.
 
Back
Top