Arkady
President
Salon.com has an unusually stupid piece today, talking about the supposed rise of right-wing blockbuster movies:
http://www.salon.com/2012/08/28/right_wing_blockbusters_rule/
There certainly are and always have been right-wing blockbusters coming out of Hollywood. The first true blockbuster, "Birth of a Nation," was an incredibly racist piece of right-wing crap glorifying the KKK. The biggest hit of all-time, "Gone With the Wind," is marinated in similar racism and Confederate nostalgia. And at least since the 1980s, most of the big-budget movies have pushed conservative-friendly themes. Hollywood blockbusters tend to include positive portrayals of the military, vigilantes, and money-making efforts, while shilling for traditional monogamous heterosexual relationships and Judeo-christian faith, and taking swats at minorities and non-military government workers. Take "Ghostbusters" as an example -- academia is the home of frauds, entrepreneurs are the heroes, and the human villain is an EPA bureaucrat. Or take the "Transformers" series -- where US military personnel nobly work in secret to protect all of mankind, while occasionally being undermined by pointy-headed civilian politicians. Or how about the Batman franchise? A benevolent super-rich guy places himself above the law to fight crime. But, that's not the kind of conservative blockbuster Salon is talking about. Salon is, instead, imagining the existence of blockbuster conservative documentary films.
For the term "blockbuster" to have any meaning, you can't be sticking it to just any old film. It's supposed to indicate exceptional ticket sales. If we set the threshold at a $250 million adjusted gross (adjusted for ticket prices), there's NEVER been a blockbuster documentary film of any sort, even though there have been over 200 blockbuster films of other sorts. If you lower the bar to $100 million, such that there are usually around thirty blockbusters per year, then there's been exactly one blockbuster documentary, ever-- Michael Moore's "Fahrenheit 9/11." If you want to lower that threshold far enough to include even a single Republican political documentary in the list, you'd need to bring it all the way down to around $9 million, such that there are around 150 "blockbusters" every year.
Debasing the term "blockbuster" that much makes a joke of it. With a $9 million threshold, there have already been 85 "blockbusters" just this year, including such obscurities as "Salmon Fishing in Yemen," and a 3D retrofit for one of the Star Wars movies. But, even if you were OK with such a useless "blockbuster" filter, it would be impossible to make Salon's point about right-wing blockbusters ruling. If you drop the threshold to $9 million, then among the "blockbuster" documentaries, you have only one right-wing blockbuster, preceded in the list by four Michael Moore movies, Al Gore's "Inconvenient Truth," and Bill Maher's "Religulous," along with biopics by notable non-conservatives Madonna and Katy Perry, and a bunch of nature documentaries, some of which have environmentalist themes, including the global-warming-themed documentary "Earth." Documentary film is a small corner of Hollywood's kingdom, but it's indisputably one that's ruled by liberal-themed movies, unlike the big-budget fiction universe, where right-wing values are the order of the day.
http://www.salon.com/2012/08/28/right_wing_blockbusters_rule/
There certainly are and always have been right-wing blockbusters coming out of Hollywood. The first true blockbuster, "Birth of a Nation," was an incredibly racist piece of right-wing crap glorifying the KKK. The biggest hit of all-time, "Gone With the Wind," is marinated in similar racism and Confederate nostalgia. And at least since the 1980s, most of the big-budget movies have pushed conservative-friendly themes. Hollywood blockbusters tend to include positive portrayals of the military, vigilantes, and money-making efforts, while shilling for traditional monogamous heterosexual relationships and Judeo-christian faith, and taking swats at minorities and non-military government workers. Take "Ghostbusters" as an example -- academia is the home of frauds, entrepreneurs are the heroes, and the human villain is an EPA bureaucrat. Or take the "Transformers" series -- where US military personnel nobly work in secret to protect all of mankind, while occasionally being undermined by pointy-headed civilian politicians. Or how about the Batman franchise? A benevolent super-rich guy places himself above the law to fight crime. But, that's not the kind of conservative blockbuster Salon is talking about. Salon is, instead, imagining the existence of blockbuster conservative documentary films.
For the term "blockbuster" to have any meaning, you can't be sticking it to just any old film. It's supposed to indicate exceptional ticket sales. If we set the threshold at a $250 million adjusted gross (adjusted for ticket prices), there's NEVER been a blockbuster documentary film of any sort, even though there have been over 200 blockbuster films of other sorts. If you lower the bar to $100 million, such that there are usually around thirty blockbusters per year, then there's been exactly one blockbuster documentary, ever-- Michael Moore's "Fahrenheit 9/11." If you want to lower that threshold far enough to include even a single Republican political documentary in the list, you'd need to bring it all the way down to around $9 million, such that there are around 150 "blockbusters" every year.
Debasing the term "blockbuster" that much makes a joke of it. With a $9 million threshold, there have already been 85 "blockbusters" just this year, including such obscurities as "Salmon Fishing in Yemen," and a 3D retrofit for one of the Star Wars movies. But, even if you were OK with such a useless "blockbuster" filter, it would be impossible to make Salon's point about right-wing blockbusters ruling. If you drop the threshold to $9 million, then among the "blockbuster" documentaries, you have only one right-wing blockbuster, preceded in the list by four Michael Moore movies, Al Gore's "Inconvenient Truth," and Bill Maher's "Religulous," along with biopics by notable non-conservatives Madonna and Katy Perry, and a bunch of nature documentaries, some of which have environmentalist themes, including the global-warming-themed documentary "Earth." Documentary film is a small corner of Hollywood's kingdom, but it's indisputably one that's ruled by liberal-themed movies, unlike the big-budget fiction universe, where right-wing values are the order of the day.