New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

RIP James Brady

President Reagan was also shot in that attack (as well as a secret service agent and a cop), perpetrated by a deranged young leftist named John Hinckley, Jr.
What makes you think he was a leftist? I haven't read much about Hinckley, but what I know of him is that he was a Southern gun nut from an oil company family, who got hung up on an actress, plotted to kill Carter, to get her attention, and then after Reagan was elected plotted against him, instead, before the failed assassination attempt. He doesn't sound terribly political. Just nuts.
 
Last edited:
He didn't GIVE it... it was TAKEN by Hinckley.

Brady seemed like a good man, and I'm taking nothing away from him... but it seems silly (and phony) to suddenly elevate him to hero status and pretend to be heartbroken about his passing, don't you think?

Nah... I guess you don't. Think.
I don't know Babs. Remember when lefty was heartbroken over Turdy Kennedy's death?
 
I don't know Babs. Remember when lefty was heartbroken over Turdy Kennedy's death?

We all know that, if Brady didn't happen to champion one of the Left's favorite meme, gun control, they would've been all over him just for being Reagan's press secretary and a Republican.

In fact, they probably were before he got shot....
 
What makes you think he was a leftist. I haven't read much about Hinckley

I stopped there, after your customary admission of talking out of your ass. You should read a bit more (or watch a tv program or something, if you can't handle the reading), then it will make more sense...
 
And you know this... how, exactly? How many lives? Oh yeah, that's right... "countless".

Can you prove that assertion?
As you know, the murder rate in this country plummeted after the Brady Bill was finally made law, in 1993. It was at a rate of 9.5 and today is at 4.7. The vast majority of this decline was, doubtless, due to other factors (Roe v. Wade, the deleading of gas, the aging of the population, better emergency medicine). However, it's likely that gun control was one factor in the mix.

Quantifying the impact of gun control is difficult, but it can be estimated simply by determining the decline in firearms homicides relative to other homicides. If gun control weren't a factor, we'd expect firearm homicides to decline at the same overall rate as overall homicide declines. So, if firearms homicides declined faster than overall homicides, the difference between the two would be a good candidate for the impact of gun control.

Since we'd expect the impact of gun control to phase in relatively quickly, let's compare 1993 to 2003, with the idea that within the first decade the impact would be phased in. So, in 1993, there were 18,253 firearm homicides. In 2003, there were 11,920. For total murders, the numbers were 24,526 for 1993 and 16,528 for 2003. So, if firearms homicides declined at a pace with total homicides, they would have declined 48.4%, in that time. Instead, they declined 53.1%. The difference is an "extra" 4.74% decline, over and above what would have happened without gun control.

So, for 2003, we can estimate that without the "extra" decline in firearms homicide rates, there would have been 12,513 of them, for a net life savings of 593 lives. That's for a single year. Just for simple math, assuming roughly equal savings every year, over the last 20 years that would be 11,860 lives saved. In other words, it was approximately the same number of lives that would be saved by stopping FOUR 9/11-magnitude terrorist attacks!

And that's just for the prevented murders. It doesn't count the prevented serious woundings of the sort Reagan suffered. Doubtless if gun control saved that many lives, it would have spared many more people from severely diminished quality of life caused by bullets. And then there are the suicides. A similar method could be used to determine the difference between the change in the rate of suicides, generally, and the change in the rate of firearms suicides, and if firearms suicides fell faster, as did firearms homicides, it would be plausible that the passage of the Brady Bill played a part in the difference, by keeping guns out of the hands of some self-destructive people. And then there are the accidental death rates, too -- if firearms accidental death rates fell faster than overall accidental death rates, the Brady Bill is one plausible factor in the difference.

In the end, I was stuck saying "countless" because it's impossible to get a definitive estimate of how many lives Brady's campaign saved. However, a decent estimate would put the figure into the many thousands, already. If some person's years of effort stopped a terrorist attack that would have killed four times as many people as 9/11, you'd have no problem calling him a hero. Well, Brady was a hero in the same sense and with roughly the same magnitude of lives saved, so far.
 
I stopped there, after your customary admission of talking out of your ass. You should read a bit more (or watch a tv program or something, if you can't handle the reading), then it will make more sense...
Can you link me to something about his politics? If he was a leftist, why did he plot to kill Carter?
 
"Countless" is always a great number for leftists to deal with. Also "a lot", "tons" and "a whole bunch".
In this case, it's impossible to say for sure, how many, but I'd estimate it's something on an order of magnitude of 10,000 lives, so far.
 
No thanks. I just ate scrambled eggs with fresh Jersey tomatoes, spinach, and cheddar. I'm stuffed!

Hope that helped! I never met anyone who didn't think the dead should be respected. Then again, nothing surprises me from a Republican these days. ;)
 
As you know, the murder rate in this country plummeted after the Brady Bill was finally made law, in 1993. It was at a rate of 9.5 and today is at 4.7. The vast majority of this decline was, doubtless, due to other factors (Roe v. Wade, the deleading of gas, the aging of the population, better emergency medicine). However, it's likely that gun control was one factor in the mix.

Quantifying the impact of gun control is difficult, but it can be estimated simply by determining the decline in firearms homicides relative to other homicides. If gun control weren't a factor, we'd expect firearm homicides to decline at the same overall rate as overall homicide declines. So, if firearms homicides declined faster than overall homicides, the difference between the two would be a good candidate for the impact of gun control.

Since we'd expect the impact of gun control to phase in relatively quickly, let's compare 1993 to 2003, with the idea that within the first decade the impact would be phased in. So, in 1993, there were 18,253 firearm homicides. In 2003, there were 11,920. For total murders, the numbers were 24,526 for 1993 and 16,528 for 2003. So, if firearms homicides declined at a pace with total homicides, they would have declined 48.4%, in that time. Instead, they declined 53.1%. The difference is an "extra" 4.74% decline, over and above what would have happened without gun control.

So, for 2003, we can estimate that without the "extra" decline in firearms homicide rates, there would have been 12,513 of them, for a net life savings of 593 lives. That's for a single year. Just for simple math, assuming roughly equal savings every year, over the last 20 years that would be 11,860 lives saved. In other words, it was approximately the same number of lives that would be saved by stopping FOUR 9/11-magnitude terrorist attacks!

And that's just for the prevented murders. It doesn't count the prevented serious woundings of the sort Reagan suffered. Doubtless if gun control saved that many lives, it would have spared many more people from severely diminished quality of life caused by bullets. And then there are the suicides. A similar method could be used to determine the difference between the change in the rate of suicides, generally, and the change in the rate of firearms suicides, and if firearms suicides fell faster, as did firearms homicides, it would be plausible that the passage of the Brady Bill played a part in the difference, by keeping guns out of the hands of some self-destructive people. And then there are the accidental death rates, too -- if firearms accidental death rates fell faster than overall accidental death rates, the Brady Bill is one plausible factor in the difference.

In the end, I was stuck saying "countless" because it's impossible to get a definitive estimate of how many lives Brady's campaign saved. However, a decent estimate would put the figure into the many thousands, already. If some person's years of effort stopped a terrorist attack that would have killed four times as many people as 9/11, you'd have no problem calling him a hero. Well, Brady was a hero in the same sense and with roughly the same magnitude of lives saved, so far.

Now and again in the context of the gun control issue, someone will bring up traffic deaths and pose a rhetorical question about why we don't "outlaw" cars.

That pathetic rejoinder is silly on its face, since no one is proposing to "outlaw" guns. BUT....I read a terrific piece the other day that puts the issue of traffic deaths into a useful context. As we all should know full well, the rate of "traffic deaths per mile driven" has been a downward vector almost since the invention of the automobile! Shoot, if the rate today was the same as it was 50 years ago, we'd be talking high six figures, every year.

Anyway....we didn't address the traffic death issueby outlawing cars. We did it by way of constantly revising and updating our regimes of both traffic control and the safety of cars themselves. We COULD do the same as regards guns.

We adopted stop signs way back then, even as we knew they wouldn't prevent all accidents.
 
Hope that helped! I never met anyone who didn't think the dead should be respected. Then again, nothing surprises me from a Republican these days. ;)

Brady's death has been somewhat uncomfortable for today's movement "conservatives". It bothers them somewhat, that Brady, a putative conservative, advocated for additional gun control. It bothers them WAY more though, that Reagan was "all in" with him on the issue.
 
Brady's death has been somewhat uncomfortable for today's movement "conservatives". It bothers them somewhat, that Brady, a putative conservative, advocated for additional gun control. It bothers them WAY more though, that Reagan was "all in" with him on the issue.

They appear out of sorts today no? You may have hit the nail on the head! :)
 
As you know, the murder rate in this country plummeted after the Brady Bill was finally made law, in 1993. It was at a rate of 9.5 and today is at 4.7. The vast majority of this decline was, doubtless, due to other factors (Roe v. Wade, the deleading of gas, the aging of the population, better emergency medicine). However, it's likely that gun control was one factor in the mix.

Quantifying the impact of gun control is difficult, but it can be estimated simply by determining the decline in firearms homicides relative to other homicides. If gun control weren't a factor, we'd expect firearm homicides to decline at the same overall rate as overall homicide declines. So, if firearms homicides declined faster than overall homicides, the difference between the two would be a good candidate for the impact of gun control.

Since we'd expect the impact of gun control to phase in relatively quickly, let's compare 1993 to 2003, with the idea that within the first decade the impact would be phased in. So, in 1993, there were 18,253 firearm homicides. In 2003, there were 11,920. For total murders, the numbers were 24,526 for 1993 and 16,528 for 2003. So, if firearms homicides declined at a pace with total homicides, they would have declined 48.4%, in that time. Instead, they declined 53.1%. The difference is an "extra" 4.74% decline, over and above what would have happened without gun control.

So, for 2003, we can estimate that without the "extra" decline in firearms homicide rates, there would have been 12,513 of them, for a net life savings of 593 lives. That's for a single year. Just for simple math, assuming roughly equal savings every year, over the last 20 years that would be 11,860 lives saved. In other words, it was approximately the same number of lives that would be saved by stopping FOUR 9/11-magnitude terrorist attacks!

And that's just for the prevented murders. It doesn't count the prevented serious woundings of the sort Reagan suffered. Doubtless if gun control saved that many lives, it would have spared many more people from severely diminished quality of life caused by bullets. And then there are the suicides. A similar method could be used to determine the difference between the change in the rate of suicides, generally, and the change in the rate of firearms suicides, and if firearms suicides fell faster, as did firearms homicides, it would be plausible that the passage of the Brady Bill played a part in the difference, by keeping guns out of the hands of some self-destructive people. And then there are the accidental death rates, too -- if firearms accidental death rates fell faster than overall accidental death rates, the Brady Bill is one plausible factor in the difference.

In the end, I was stuck saying "countless" because it's impossible to get a definitive estimate of how many lives Brady's campaign saved. However, a decent estimate would put the figure into the many thousands, already. If some person's years of effort stopped a terrorist attack that would have killed four times as many people as 9/11, you'd have no problem calling him a hero. Well, Brady was a hero in the same sense and with roughly the same magnitude of lives saved, so far.

As you know, the murder rate in this country plummeted after the Brady Bill was finally made law, in 1993. It was at a rate of 9.5 and today is at 4.7. The vast majority of this decline was, doubtless, due to other factors (Roe v. Wade, the deleading of gas, the aging of the population, better emergency medicine). However, it's likely that gun control was one factor in the mix.

Honestly, I stopped reading right there. The MURDER rate plummeted after the Brady Bill. It was 9.5 and today is 4.7. The majority of this decline was due to Roe vs. Wade, deleading of gas, aging of the population, better emergency medicine.

What??? Huh????
 
Honestly, I stopped reading right there. The MURDER rate plummeted after the Brady Bill. It was 9.5 and today is 4.7. The majority of this decline was due to Roe vs. Wade, deleading of gas, aging of the population, better emergency medicine.

What??? Huh????

Arkady has listed four different things that objective researchers of this sort of thing, link to the declining murder rate. If one or another doesn't make sense to you at first blush, you might oughta spend some time with the google.

BUT...what seems to be flying straight over your head, is the HUGE intellectual-honesty bone he's tossed you here. A more partisan advocate for gun control, certainly wouldn't come right out and qualify that somethings in addition to gun control, have been responsible for this declining rate.
 
Arkady has listed four different things that objective researchers of this sort of thing, link to the declining murder rate. If one or another doesn't make sense to you at first blush, you might oughta spend some time with the google.

BUT...what seems to be flying straight over your head, is the HUGE intellectual-honesty bone he's tossed you here. A more partisan advocate for gun control, certainly wouldn't come right out and qualify that somethings in addition to gun control, have been responsible for this declining rate.

It didn't fly over my head. I wanted him to explain how in the world he can toss MURDER into the same basket as lead poisoning, roe vs wade, and old age.... and then aver that the declining murder rate was due to gun control.
 
Honestly, I stopped reading right there. The MURDER rate plummeted after the Brady Bill. It was 9.5 and today is 4.7. The majority of this decline was due to Roe vs. Wade, deleading of gas, aging of the population, better emergency medicine.

What??? Huh????
Which part of that did you have trouble understanding? I'm happy rephrasing more simply.
 
Back
Top