connieb
Senator
bogus article.
http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10
Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.
When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.
In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "
Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook
It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.
And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.
I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.
At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.
http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10
Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.
When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.
In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "
Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook
It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.
And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.
I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.
At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.