New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Rolling Stone - retracting UVA Rape Case...

connieb

Senator
bogus article.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10

Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.

When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.


In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "

Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook



It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.

And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.

I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.

At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.
 
bogus article.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10

Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.

When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.


In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "

Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook



It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.

And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.

I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.

At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.

It's really too bad, because rape and sexual assault is a problem on college campuses. But, Rolling Stone had to go after a mostly white, relatively conservative university, and they were willing to completely and utterly trash their journalistic integrity (what's left of it) to do so.
 
bogus article.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10

Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.

When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.


In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "

Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook



It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.

And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.

I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.

At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.
I think reporters inevitably have an agenda, though some may work really hard to hide it. They're human beings, and like the rest of us, they have a worldview, and they're going to want to find facts that support that worldview. The difference between a good reporter and a bad one isn't whether they have an agenda, but rather how good their standards are about vetting material, especially when the material is something they want to believe. That's where Rolling Stone screwed up.

Funny you should bring up Global Warming, since this is a perfect example of low journalistic standards..... right-wing outlets routinely report the story in howlingly misleading ways, because they want desperately to believe that global warming isn't happening, or that human beings aren't responsible for it. The big difference, of course, is that Rolling Stone eventually realized its error and retracted its botched reporting, whereas outlets like Fox News will never retract their denialism. The difference is between an outlet that falls short of its journalistic standards (Rolling Stone) and an outlet that never had journalistic standards to begin with (Fox News). When you have no standards, you can't fall short of them, no matter how bad the reporting.
 
bogus article.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10

Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.

When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.


In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "

Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook



It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.

And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.

I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.

At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.
Glad I didn't read the original article.
 
I think reporters inevitably have an agenda, though some may work really hard to hide it. They're human beings, and like the rest of us, they have a worldview, and they're going to want to find facts that support that worldview. The difference between a good reporter and a bad one isn't whether they have an agenda, but rather how good their standards are about vetting material, especially when the material is something they want to believe. That's where Rolling Stone screwed up.

Funny you should bring up Global Warming, since this is a perfect example of low journalistic standards..... right-wing outlets routinely report the story in howlingly misleading ways, because they want desperately to believe that global warming isn't happening, or that human beings aren't responsible for it. The big difference, of course, is that Rolling Stone eventually realized its error and retracted its botched reporting, whereas outlets like Fox News will never retract their denialism. The difference is between an outlet that falls short of its journalistic standards (Rolling Stone) and an outlet that never had journalistic standards to begin with (Fox News). When you have no standards, you can't fall short of them, no matter how bad the reporting.

Aaaand, the liberal media gets another pass from a loyal subject...
 
I think reporters inevitably have an agenda, though some may work really hard to hide it. They're human beings, and like the rest of us, they have a worldview, and they're going to want to find facts that support that worldview. The difference between a good reporter and a bad one isn't whether they have an agenda, but rather how good their standards are about vetting material, especially when the material is something they want to believe. That's where Rolling Stone screwed up.

Funny you should bring up Global Warming, since this is a perfect example of low journalistic standards..... right-wing outlets routinely report the story in howlingly misleading ways, because they want desperately to believe that global warming isn't happening, or that human beings aren't responsible for it. The big difference, of course, is that Rolling Stone eventually realized its error and retracted its botched reporting, whereas outlets like Fox News will never retract their denialism. The difference is between an outlet that falls short of its journalistic standards (Rolling Stone) and an outlet that never had journalistic standards to begin with (Fox News). When you have no standards, you can't fall short of them, no matter how bad the reporting.

Bringing up global warming wasn't about the journalism around it. It was to talk about the group think and reliance of the integrity and the research of others, to use as the basis for your own opinion.

In this case they relied on the experience, data, and integrity of each other. And, successively they did not challenge and question things because they thought that someone else would take are of it, or they were trustworthy, or that their skills were superior or they had more clout.

So, yes, the question is ( and having worked in academia I have seen this for myself) how much of the "consensus" is essentially one person relying on the work of another and instead of independently verifying it, saying.. Oh well, you know.. if John did it, he is likely right. - so I believe it. Or saying.. well, John is more powerful than me, so I won't question him.. he must be right.

I am simply saying that ANYTIME we are confronted with a topic, in which the people involved are part of a closed system, working with and relying on each other - that the work is suspect, because as we see here, there is an strong pressure, to not rock the boat, to not be the one to question and to rely on others you know to have done the work that you think they should have done.

connie
 
bogus article.

http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405?page=10

Well, after reading this entire report - this is what I would say... it boils down to this Reporting with an Agenda. In the end, neither Rolling Stone's editing team, nor the reporter, were willing to give up their agenda of finding some sort explosive case of date rape, to perpetuate their beliefs in the date/rape, sex assault culture on college campuses. Despite Jackie having numerous holes in her story - they SOOOOO wanted to believe in it, believe in the message that they overlooked basic quality journalism.

When our journalists - are no longer reporting but reporting with an agenda, it is nothing short of propaganda.


In fact the report specifically says "The problem of confirmation bias – the tendency of people to be trapped by pre-existing assumptions and to select facts that support their own views while overlooking contradictory ones – is a well-established finding of social science. It seems to have been a factor here. "

Read more: http://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/a-rape-on-campus-what-went-wrong-20150405#ixzz3WZ3ydukF
Follow us: @rollingstone on Twitter | RollingStone on Facebook



It did make me think how many other times, do we allow this sort of "confirmation bias" to go unchecked. I think that pretty much every policy argument we have in this country boils down to this. No matter the side of the aisle, and no matter the issue, each side has their on bias. Who they believe when they say it.

And, it is also an interesting critique about how in the culture - they simply ended up relying on each other to perpetuate the story. And, again this could apply in any industry or policy disagreement. The fact checker relied on the editor, and the editor was relying on the fact checker, and the fact checker relied on the writer, who though that the Editor would catch anything wrong. And, so instead of independently verifying any of the data or unresolved issues themselves - they merely said... well if so and so thinks its right, then it looks right to me.

I mean can you imagine these conversations going on with the Global Warming Alarmists or at the FDA for instance? Well, if this data wasn't right, so and so would have caught it. And, so and so says, well, if this data was wrong, then first so and so would have never even given it to me. And, honestly it happens in my profession too. We are supposed to review and test work before it goes out the door and we really have to caution ourselves to not rely on the fact that you know the person who did the work originally was a highly skilled professional. You are in place to be their other set of eyes - and it is your job to pick apart their work, not place faith in the because you otherwise trust their work.

At any rate, it is a good reminder for all of us to consider - that just because something is reported by what appears to to be a reputable outlet - that it doesn't mean THEY did their own due diligence. And, that ultimately if they are corrupted by adherence to a particularly theory or narrative, their reporting should be that much more suspect.

The difference between the Rolling Stone and media outlets like Fox News....

When Rolling Stone puts out a story that turns out to be false, they do so unintentionally, and they then retract it and apologize.

When outlets like Fox News put out lies, it's because they did so intentionally, will never retract it, and they will tell more tomorrow.

;-)
 
It's really too bad, because rape and sexual assault is a problem on college campuses. But, Rolling Stone had to go after a mostly white, relatively conservative university, and they were willing to completely and utterly trash their journalistic integrity (what's left of it) to do so.

It is. And, worse, it highlighted what advocates like to downplay is that amount of made up accusations out there.

I was sexually assaulted and I did not report it. Not out of fear from my own reputation. This was not someone I would have crossed paths with or ran in the same circles with. But, because, It would have come down to he-said, she said. And, other than sympathy or empathy for me, there wasn't anything about my story more believable than what would have been his. That isn't justice in my mind.

And, I do have a real problem using what affected these people. this inability or unwillingness to really confront a victim, against the accused. To me it seems we pendulum has swung to far. Now in sexual assault cases, I do believe we take a more guilty until proven innocent. And, really how can you prove that a person said yes, or not or was not as impaired as they now claim to be? Obviously in a violent attack where there is substantial other evidence, etc. That is a different story. But, in these date rape incidents where the sex is going to be consensual until it is "not" how do you ever prove your innocence when the official position seems to take the side of the accused.

Maybe I knew too many girls like Jackie who cried wolf essentially and maybe because of my own experience, but I am more skeptical when I see and read these kinds of accounts than many others I talk to. And, I think that is a real problem for true justice.

connie
 
The difference between the Rolling Stone and media outlets like Fox News....

When Rolling Stone puts out a story that turns out to be false, they do so unintentionally, and they then retract it and apologize.

When outlets like Fox News put out lies, it's because they did so intentionally, will never retract it, and they will tell more tomorrow.

;-)
Such as?
 
You're right....it's just that I don't remember any major lawsuits against Fox News for lying. Rolling Stone, however, is in for a big one.

Fox went you one better...they defended against a suit by insisting that they have the right to lie.

;-)
 
Fox went you one better...they defended against a suit by insisting that they have the right to lie.

;-)
Rolling Stone has admitted their screw up...For the idiots at Fox stuff like this pretty much a daily occurrence...They just claim they are not a "news" station but entertainment and continue their lies and distortions
 
You're right....it's just that I don't remember any major lawsuits against Fox News for lying. Rolling Stone, however, is in for a big one.

Still, its not worth it. He will just make up some crap and in the end it will come down to he is whining about what Hannity said, or O'Reilly said, which won't actually matter as a "lie" anyway because they are commentators, not actually news anchors, and Bugs will get away with being a pain in everyone's tukus. Its best just not to engage him.
 
Fox went you one better...they defended against a suit by insisting that they have the right to lie.

;-)

That's been the one you ALL go to when asked that question....that was proven a lie over and over. Can't any of you come up with another? Nobody ever does.
 
Rolling Stone has done nothing to the Author of the false article or the Editor(s) that reviewed and approved it for publication.

Therefore, a sort of apology but our guys are still gonna be here is not much of a mea culpa other than some lame words...
 
That's been the one you ALL go to when asked that question....that was proven a lie over and over. Can't any of you come up with another? Nobody ever does.

A you know, I could bury you in a mountain of Fox News lies, and you would swear that each and every one was true. But, just for kicks, here's a sampling....

http://www.politifact.com/punditfact/tv/fox/

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/02/26/jon-stewart-50-fox-news-lies-in-6-seconds_n_6758614.html

https://www.facebook.com/FoxNewsLiesOfTheDay

http://www.forwardprogressives.com/fact-checking-site-finds-fox-news-tells-truth-18-percent-time/

http://aattp.org/category/fox-news-lies-2/
 

Got any commentary on what Rolling Stone did wrong, rape on campus, the danger of group think, or standards and policies they could implement to not make this mistake in the future?

If so - post it.

You want to bitch about Fox - start your own damn thread.
 
Back
Top