New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Romney vs. Bush

Arkady

President
Let me preface by saying I haven't seen the debate yet. However, I did see the transcript, and thought one particular question was a very important one, so I wanted to dissect it and the response in detail.
Q: Governor Romney, I am an undecided voter because I'm disappointed with the lack of progress I've seen in the last four years. However, I do attribute much of America's economic and international problems to the failings and missteps of the Bush administration. Since both you and President Bush are Republicans, I fear a return to the policies of those years should you win this election. What is the biggest difference between you and George W. Bush, and how do you differentiate yourself from George W. Bush?

I think that's an absolutely key issue. My perception has been that Romney is essentially running as a third term for Bush, with almost no key differences on policy. Unlike when you compare Clinton and Carter or Carter and Johnson, or any other two modern Democrats, it's hard to identify any large differences between George W. Bush's presidency and what has been proposed by Romney (or McCain in 2008, for that matter). That's quite extraordinary when you think about the fact that the Bush presidency is widely considered an unmitigated disaster of historical proportions for Americans. You'd think subsequent Republicans would be falling all over themselves to explain how they're a different kind of Republican, so it's interesting that Romney only makes that case when directly asked.

Unfortunately, Romney frittered away much of his time (perhaps by design) going back and answering an earlier question, about contraception, before addressing the question at hand. That left him little opportunity to explain how he'd be different. When he did get on topic, though, he had several points:

(1) He wants to get all our energy in North America. Romney doesn't frame this as a criticism of Bush, mind you. He just says the technology wasn't there to do it in the Bush years. So, this isn't really a matter of him saying "I'm different from the guy who led you to an epic national catastrophe." It's more like, "here's some stuff I think I can do that would have been technologically impossible in the Bush years." As such, it's not responsive to the question he was asked. But, regardless, let's recall that Bush was an oil man, who made a good chunk of his money in the Texas oil fields, and that his VP was a former Halliburton CEO. It's not like they were hostile to the idea of fully exploiting North America's fossil fuel possibilities.

(2) Romney promises to "crack down on China." That would, indeed, be a big difference from Bush (and Clinton, and the elder Bush, and Reagan, and every president going back to Richard Nixon). For about forty years our consistent policy, under both parties' leadership, has been constructive engagement with China, with fairly limited strong-arming. The idea was the peace could be best assured, China could be most assuredly brought along, and the economy could be best served, through robust trade. If Romney reverses that, it will indeed be a gigantic change (not necessarily for the better). But, does anyone here HONESTLY think he means it? This is a guy who got very rich outsourcing jobs, in highly-leveraged deals. Is he the man who is likely to step in and pursue protectionist policies towards arguably our most important trade partner and financier? It strikes me as extremely unlikely. The Mitt Romneys of the business world love our kid-gloves approach to China.

(3) He'll dramatically expand trade in Latin America, through new trade agreements. This seems to be at odds with his new-found protectionist rhetoric with regard to China. But, regardless, this is just an instance of Romney shoving a talking point into a question where it doesn't fit. This is absolutely not a difference with Bush. Bush also worked to try to expand trade with Latin America. I know this well, because I'm both a free-trade proponent and someone who despises Bush deeply, so that when I was forced to side with Bush against my fellow liberals, it was an uncomfortable experience that stuck in my mind. If Romney wants to turn this into a "how I'm different from Bush" argument, it needs to be more than just aspirational, since both men had exactly matching aspirations on this front. Rather, he needs to argue why it is he'll succeed more than Bush did. It's possible to make that argument. For example, "Bush squandered America's international goodwill and poisoned our diplomatic relations with his unpopular and illegal conquest of Iraq, which made it much harder to get favorable trade terms during negotiations, and harder for other governments to sell these trade deals with the US to their own people." Or: "Bush used up his domestic political capital on things like upper-class tax cuts, so he was unable to get Congress to ratify more trade agreements. I'll put my emphasis on trade rather than taxes." Or something like that. But Romney said nothing of the sort. He just cited an area where he and Bush are on exactly the same page, as an answer to a question about how they differ.

(4) He's going to get us a balanced budget. Again, Bush had exactly the same aspiration. Back in 2000, he was promising us the big tax cut he was pushing through would not create a deficit. Always after that, he spoke of the aspiration of getting back to a balanced budget (supposedly by his low-tax, low regulation approach growing the economy, while his "tough love" towards those needing government support significantly reduced spending). It never worked, especially with Bush pushing massively increased military spending. So, this is another item where, in terms of goals, Romney and Bush are indistinguishable. Romney is instead merely asserting that he'll succeed where Bush failed. But he never bothers to explain how. Bush's deficits can be attributed to three major changes from the Clinton years: (a) economic growth was worse, (b) taxes were lower, and (c) defense spending was higher. Romney plans to lower taxes and raise defense spending, so he's emulating Bush's two policies most responsible for the deficit problem. That leaves only the prayer that economic growth will, for some reason, be stronger than it was in the Bush years. But since Romney is proposing all the same policies (other than the supposed crackdown on China, which most economists would predict would lower GDP growth), why should we expect it to be different this time?

(5) He'll champion small businesses. This is yet another example of matching policies that Romney is, inexplicably, offering up as an example of somewhere he differs with Bush. You could fill whole books with small-business-promoting comments from Bush:

http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/smallbusiness/a/sbagenda.htm

He regularly called small businesses the lifeblood of our economy, and he sold just about every economic policy in terms of its supposed positive impact on small businesses, to the point that you'd have thought he had an outright hostility towards any big business. He even portrayed himself as a former small businessman. So, Romney is again citing something where he and Bush are entirely on the same page. The only way to make this responsive to the question of how he's differ from Bush is to get specific about some key policy change, relative to what Bush did. For example, if Romney proposed that small businesses should be able to pay a lower minimum wage than bigger businesses, to give them an edge, that would be a specific proposal Bush never made. But he did nothing of the sort.

If I'd needed any more convincing that Romney is the wrong choice for president, that would do it. Even when effectively backed into a corner where he was forced to explain how his policies would differ from those of a president whose tenure is broadly considered one of the worst in our history, he could come up with only one actual difference -- his supposed plan to "crack down on China." And even if you believe that he's being honest on that one (I sure don't), it's not like Bush didn't also talk about cracking down on China:

http://www.mobilitytechzone.com/news/2007/04/11/2473821.htm

If that's the best Romney can come up with, I think it's fair to conclude he really is planning a third Bush term. Based on that, if you think things went well for this country, overall, between 2001 and 2008, by all means vote for Romney. He'll re-implement the policies that took us from where we were in January 2001 to where we were in January of 2009. If, on the other hand, you think that was a bad run, then don't vote for a guy who hasn't a clue what went wrong and how to avoid repeating those mistakes.
 
If I'd needed any more convincing that Romney is the wrong choice for president, that would do it.
lol., yea. you were entertaining that option.

Romney nailed this. his answer was money. I loved it. it was crisp. he sold it. you're analysis is bullshit... you completely discount what Romney said. in two minutes he gave 5 solid differences, communicated effectively.

to me this was the turning point in the debate since his punk ass opponent is still running against bush.
 
(5) He'll champion small businesses. You could fill whole books with small-business-promoting comments from Bush:

http://usgovinfo.about.com/od/smallbusiness/a/sbagenda.htm

He regularly called small businesses the lifeblood of our economy, and he sold just about every economic policy in terms of its supposed positive impact on small businesses, to the point that you'd have thought he had an outright hostility to any big business.

at a time when 'jobs' (that 3 letter word) is the top or #2 issue in America (now that we solved that health care takeover) what did you expect him to talk about? big bird?

Small businesses are a continuing source of dynamism for the American economy. They produced three-fourths of the economy's new jobs between 1990 and 1995, an even larger contribution to employment growth than they made in the 1980s. They also represent an entry point into the economy for new groups. Women, for instance, participate heavily in small businesses. The number of female-owned businesses climbed by 89 percent, to an estimated 8.1 million, between 1987 and 1997, and women-owned sole proprietorships were expected to reach 35 percent of all such ventures by the year 2000. Small firms also tend to hire a greater number of older workers and people who prefer to work part-time.
http://economics.about.com/od/smallbigbusiness/a/us_business.htm

it's a bit dated but my point is that regarding jobs and job creation, small business is key

and your dismissal of the distinction's Romney drew is to say, in this instance, that Bush talked about small business alot too....

well hell they're practically siamese twins
 
If I'd needed any more convincing that Romney is the wrong choice for president, that would do it.

lol., yea. you were entertaining that option.

Romney nailed this. his answer was money. I loved it. it was crisp. he sold it. you're analysis is bullshit... you completely discount what Romney said. in two minutes he gave 5 solid differences, communicated effectively.

to me this was the turning point in the debate since his punk ass opponent is still running against bush.

I read it. I haven't spotted a difference from Bush. Please, can you explain? Since Bush was also in favor of fully exploiting North American fossil fuels, increasing trade with Latin America, balancing the budget, and championing small businesses, and since he also at least talked about cracking down on China, what difference is there? Is there some specific Bush-era policy Romney is planning to alter? If so, what is it? Is he going to deny China most-favored nation status? Is he going to open up our southern border to let goods flow more quickly to Latin America? Is he going to block importation of foreign oil? Is he going to default on our debt to balance the budget? Seriously, I don't understand where he has proposed a single change from what Bush did. Please explain.
 
For the record, the woman who asked the question was interviewed post the debate. She allowed that she was dissatisfied with Mitt's reponse and would be voting for Obama.
 
at a time when 'jobs' (that 3 letter word) is the top or #2 issue in America (now that we solved that health care takeover) what did you expect him to talk about? big bird?

Small businesses are a continuing source of dynamism for the American economy. They produced three-fourths of the economy's new jobs between 1990 and 1995, an even larger contribution to employment growth than they made in the 1980s. They also represent an entry point into the economy for new groups. Women, for instance, participate heavily in small businesses. The number of female-owned businesses climbed by 89 percent, to an estimated 8.1 million, between 1987 and 1997, and women-owned sole proprietorships were expected to reach 35 percent of all such ventures by the year 2000. Small firms also tend to hire a greater number of older workers and people who prefer to work part-time.
http://economics.about.com/od/smallbigbusiness/a/us_business.htm

it's a bit dated but my point is that regarding jobs and job creation, small business is key

and your dismissal of the distinction's Romney drew is to say, in this instance, that Bush talked about small business alot too....

well hell they're practically siamese twins

I'm all ears. If you're aware of a specific difference between what Bush championed, with regard to small businesses, and what Romney's championing, just name it. I can think of literally dozens of ways a person could try to give small businesses a leg up on their big business competitors, but I haven't heard Romney suggest any of them -- at least none where Bush isn't on the record supporting the exact same thing. So, what exactly is the difference, if you'd be so kind as to educate me?
 
In fairness to Romney,I thought that was not a good question for a townhall debate. It was win-win for Pres. Obama. As you pointed out,Willard's really not that different from GWB and the best he could do was try to muddle it up a little. Pres. Obama got to pile on Romney afterwards and then explain how his policies and WJC's are alike and how good the economy was in those years. It was a tough question for Willard but not at all for BHO.
 
For the record, the woman who asked the question was interviewed post the debate. She allowed that she was dissatisfied with Mitt's reponse and would be voting for Obama.

How could she not be dissatisfied? She asked him to differentiate his position from Bush's, and he utterly failed to do so. He may as well have come right out and said, "I can't think of a single specific policy of mine that differs from Bush's policy positions in any meaningful way."

I've said before that I was upset enough at Obama, mostly over civil liberties issues, that I could have considered voting for a Republican, if the right kind of Republican ran -- a William Cohen type. But Bush's presidency was the most across-the-board awful presidency in our lifetimes, by a margin, and so step one for a Republican trying to win me over would be making a very clear case for how he was a new kind of Republican, who'd identified what Bush did wrong and would be charting a different course. Romney didn't even do that when backed into a corner. Hell, even Obama made a better case for Romney being different from Bush than Romney did (although Obama argued Romney sat even farther to the right than Bush).
 
In fairness to Romney,I thought that was not a good question for a townhall debate. It was win-win for Pres. Obama. As you pointed out,Willard's really not that different from GWB and the best he could do was try to muddle it up a little. Pres. Obama got to pile on Romney afterwards and then explain how his policies and WJC's are alike and how good the economy was in those years. It was a tough question for Willard but not at all for BHO.

It could have been a win for Romney if he'd positioned himself during the campaign to have a good answer. There were a lot of non-Democrats, myself included, who were looking for any reason at all to vote against Obama, given what a mess he's been on civil liberties issues and some foreign policy matters. A Republican who could make a compelling case for how he'd fix the Obama mistakes without repeating the vastly worse mistakes of Bush could have won votes from people like me. It was only a win-win for Obama because Romney has essentially taken the Bush administration policy sheet and adopted it verbatim, and Bush was a horrible, horrible president, such that the best he could do was try to muddle the answer, as you say.

But that doesn't make it a bad question for a townhall debate. It makes it a very, very good question. The good questions are the ones that help to illuminate the choice the American people face, and that question did. It underscored the fact that one of the two candidates wants to give us a rerun of 2001-2009.

The key to doing a good townhall debate isn't necessarily to include only questions where both candidates have an equal opportunity to shine. What good is that, if it just leaves a sense of he-said, she said? Instead, it should include questions that heighten the electorate's understanding of their options. If that includes questions that are impossible for one candidate to handle well --questions that let the other candidate pile on-- so be it.
 
If that's the best Romney can come up with, I think it's fair to conclude he really is planning a third Bush term. Based on that, if you think things went well for this country, overall, between 2001 and 2008, by all means vote for Romney. He'll re-implement the policies that took us from where we were in January 2001 to where we were in January of 2009. If, on the other hand, you think that was a bad run, then don't vote for a guy who hasn't a clue what went wrong and how to avoid repeating those mistakes.

Mitt does a lot of hand waving. He reminds me of a character from Dilbert.
 
In fairness to Romney,I thought that was not a good question for a townhall debate. It was win-win for Pres. Obama. As you pointed out,Willard's really not that different from GWB and the best he could do was try to muddle it up a little. Pres. Obama got to pile on Romney afterwards and then explain how his policies and WJC's are alike and how good the economy was in those years. It was a tough question for Willard but not at all for BHO.

Although....This seems like a question that Mitt SHOULD have been prepared for - not just in the context of this debate, but in terms of his campaign in general. Had he and his campaign considered it aforehand, I don't think it would've been all that hard to come up with 2 minutes of lofty, overarching, blah-blah-blah comprised of lots of words but nothing of real substance.
 
Although....This seems like a question that Mitt SHOULD have been prepared for - not just in the context of this debate, but in terms of his campaign in general. Had he and his campaign considered it aforehand, I don't think it would've been all that hard to come up with 2 minutes of lofty, overarching, blah-blah-blah comprised of lots of words but nothing of real substance.

Stepping away from the "theater criticism" for a second, the real problem wasn't that he failed to prepare for this question in the days leading up to the debate. Rather, it's that he failed to even ask himself this question during the last four plus years, since it became clear to even most center-right people that Bush's policies led to unmitigated disaster for this nation. A genuinely patriotic person, interested in leading this nation, couldn't have avoided thinking long and hard about what had gone wrong to lead to such terrible suffering among his fellow Americans. Such a person would necessarily have had to ask himself what he would have done differently, and how he could avoid repeating those mistakes if ever put in the same position. And that would have informed his campaign platform, and left him with some clear and compelling answers in the debate, without even having to be coached. But Romney never asked himself anything of the sort, because he never gave a crap about the suffering caused by Bush's horrible policies. He only cared about becoming president, and step one in that process was to embrace all of Bush's policies without exception, in order to recreate the conservative coalition that had let Bush win the nomination. He got the nomination, but was left with a collection of policy positions exactly matching those that nearly destroyed this nation.
 
You make a good point. I just remember thinking when that question was asked that it was No Way Out for Romney and a slam dunk for Pres. Obama. Seemed unfair at the time. :)
 
You make a good point. I just remember thinking when that question was asked that it was No Way Out for Romney and a slam dunk for Pres. Obama. Seemed unfair at the time. :)

It seems incredibly unfair, if you think of a debate as being primarily about establishing who is the better debater. If that's what it is, then questions should be asked that give both sides and equal chance to shine, so that the best debater emerges as the winner, similar to a high school debate competition. But that would be a huge waste of the nation's time. The real goal of the debate should be to negate, as far as possible, the question of who is a more skillful debater, and instead make a winner of whoever has policies and personal attributes more appealing to the people he's going to be leading. The more "unfair" the questions are, in the sense of not allowing even the best debater to look good, because of underlying unfairnesses in the facts, the better.
 
Stepping away from the "theater criticism" for a second, the real problem wasn't that he failed to prepare for this question in the days leading up to the debate. Rather, it's that he failed to even ask himself this question during the last four plus years, since it became clear to even most center-right people that Bush's policies led to unmitigated disaster for this nation.


In fairness to Romney, he had no choice but to toe the Party line if he wanted to have any chance of gaining the nomination. With McCain's previous loss, the Republican Party had no clear leader. Most of the dominant characters from the Bush administration (Tom Delay, etc.) had either gotten out of politics or been convicted of some sort of crime. In the power vacuum, Rush Limbaugh and Grover Norquist effectively assumed the mantle of leadership for the Party. Romney's only option to run as a "different kind" of Republican would have been to run as an Independent. Had he openly opposed the status quo GOP doctrine that was practiced by the Bush administration, he would have received no support whatsoever from the Party.

That said, he had his opportunity to shake his Etch-A-Sketch early on. Once he had the nomination nailed down, conventional wisdom dictated that he would tack to the center and adopt a more moderate policy stance. He didn't. Instead, he doubled down on extremism by choosing Paul Ryan as his running mate. I suppose Mitt never trusted the loyalty of his base enough to risk appearing even somewhat "moderate"? Now, he's stuck with his "severe conservatism" and it is, as you said, almost identical to the economic and foreign policy positions of the Bush administration with a slightly more rightward lean on the classic conservative social wedge issues.
 
I read it. I haven't spotted a difference from Bush. Please, can you explain? Since Bush was also in favor of fully exploiting North American fossil fuels, increasing trade with Latin America, balancing the budget, and championing small businesses, and since he also at least talked about cracking down on China, what difference is there?

so Mitt will fail because Bush did?

hell, all Mitt needed to say then to satisfy you, was "I'm not Bush"

or blame him...that a credible lefty buck pass....

see below for an example I left you
 
I'm all ears. If you're aware of a specific difference between what Bush championed, with regard to small businesses, and what Romney's championing, just name it. I can think of literally dozens of ways a person could try to give small businesses a leg up on their big business competitors, but I haven't heard Romney suggest any of them -- at least none where Bush isn't on the record supporting the exact same thing. So, what exactly is the difference, if you'd be so kind as to educate me?

first off, what Bush wanted/didn't is irrelevant. he's not running for anything. Romney is calling for tax cuts, repealing obamacare and reducing the regulatory burden on small business.... It needs to be more complicated than that?
 
Back
Top