as seen on tv
Senator
When I encountered the headline “US catholics want 3rd world pope", I nearly dropped my rosary beads.
Full disclosure – this write is secular, and has never been catholic. But I’m good with living next door to a church, mosque, or synagogue, just so long as the guy in charge isn’t advocating flying a plane into the side of skyscraper, or sending unarmed children to the holy land to recover religious relics.
But the poll by the “Pew Research Center” – asserting that 60% of US catholics want a “diversity” Pope is a real stunner. Sorry, Pew-bies, it doesn’t work that way. The Vatican is not a democracy. No direct election of the Pope by the masses. It’s not even a “republic” where you get to vote for cardinals, who designate the Pope.
And the poll showing the next Pope would be more popular if he was Nigerian, Chinese, or Mexican is a perfect example of why democracy doesn’t fit every situation.
It would seem to me that the LEAST important thing about a Pope is the color of his skin, or his place of birth. More important qualities immediately suggest themselves. For example . . .
· Is he devout, and leads by example? (No cover-ups of pedophile scandals, or military service in Hitler’s army, please)
· Is he able parse the complexities of modern social challenges? (reconciling 2,000 year old biblical text with family planning? The role of women? The role of church vs. state? Tolerance for different faiths, or even sects within Catholicism?)
· Will he have the courage to speak out against injustice and human rights abuses? It’s one thing to issue an encyclical saying abortion is still a sin; quite another to speak up and ask the UN for assistance for catholics who are being driven from the certain regions or killed outright in the latest wave of ethnic cleansing.
My local cable network rushed to broadcast “The Shoes of the Fisherman” as soon as Pope Ratzinger (er, I mean Benedict) resigned earlier this month. You know – the movie where “Zorba the Greek” gets elevated from Soviet gulag prisoner to Pope in 90 minutes running time. This is definitely a better role for Anthony Quinn than some of his later films, such as “Hercules and the Amazon Women”. But still . ..
Even though Anthony Quinn was a gulag inmate before becoming pope, the USA doesn’t get off scot free in this film either. We are accused of causing a massive famine in China due to a trade war. These difficulties are ultimately resolved when Pope Anthony Quinn sells all the vatican’s priceless artifacts to feed the starving Chinese.
This plot may seem simplistic, even laughable. But it (inadvertently) identifies a real danger to elevating an idealist without real world experience to a position of power. Pope Quinn clearly never ran into the aphorism “Give a man a fish, and you feed him for a day – Teach him to fish and he will never be hungry”. But I don’t think the next pope, even if comes from Cambodia, Costa Rica, or the Congo, is in any danger of being empowered to sell all the Vatican’s heirlooms to feed the world's hungry masses for the next 10 weeks. I’m sure the “boots on the ground” reports from priests in starving 3[SUP]rd[/SUP] world countries reaching the vatican contain some sense that oppressive governments, corruption, and confiscatory policies are the main ingredients of a starvation diet – not the lack of arable land or the willingness of farmers to work it.
Hunger, oppression, murder of ethinc and political factions with unpopular political views – these are things that aren’t going to be solved by money. At least they never have been, in the past. Greed begets greed, just as violence begets violence.
Instead of a Pew poll, if the college of cardinals wants to introduce some transparency into their selection process, they might consider a series of televised debates among the aspirants? (tip - don't let Jim Lehrer moderate - he's older and feebler than the Pope who just abdicated)
But please, no “religical action committees” broadcasting attack ads funded with shadowy contributions from the darkest right and left corners of the political spectrum, hoping to use character assassination to narrow down the field. We’ve tried that here, and my take is that you don’t get a better result.
Full disclosure – this writer’s daughter played soccer for the local catholic diocese youth league several years ago. They did not try to convert her, or ridicule her for a secular upbringing, or un-catholic ancestry. It was exactly what you’d want to see from an organization which dedicates itself to offering wholesome activites for young people.




