New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Samuelson gets it, as to a "way out"

fairsheet

Senator
http://www.thenewstribune.com/2013/10/10/2830374/a-way-out-and-its-better-than.html

He suggests the GOP must settle for a promise from Obama, to talk. Of course, Samuelson IS an insistent "entitlement scold". There's no doubt about that. But in agreeing to "talk", Obama isn't conceding anything practical to Samuelson and his.

Samuelson doesn't come right out and say it, but I imagine that he recognizes that a mere commitment "to talk", is historically huge. Democrats past, have virtually always had to say that Social Security is off the table, untouchable, and non-negotiable.

And to qualify even as I shouldn't have to, I'm not advocating for any specific changes to, nor concessions on, Social Security.
 
http://www.thenewstribune.com/2013/10/10/2830374/a-way-out-and-its-better-than.html

He suggests the GOP must settle for a promise from Obama, to talk. Of course, Samuelson IS an insistent "entitlement scold". There's no doubt about that. But in agreeing to "talk", Obama isn't conceding anything practical to Samuelson and his.

Samuelson doesn't come right out and say it, but I imagine that he recognizes that a mere commitment "to talk", is historically huge. Democrats past, have virtually always had to say that Social Security is off the table, untouchable, and non-negotiable.

And to qualify even as I shouldn't have to, I'm not advocating for any specific changes to, nor concessions on, Social Security.
I think we need to raise the age of eligibility. That's about it. It's just facing economic/demographic reality...
 
Repubs are over a barrel. A promise to "talk" about entitlements is their "face-saving" "victory" as the "defund or shutdown" strategy has blown up in their faces.

Given the short memories of the Tea Partyers, they can declare "victory" now with "We're going to reform entitlements, we dragged a concession from the Dems to talk about it".....and in a few weeks, the TPers won't even remember the fight over Obamacare was lost.
 
http://www.thenewstribune.com/2013/10/10/2830374/a-way-out-and-its-better-than.html

He suggests the GOP must settle for a promise from Obama, to talk. Of course, Samuelson IS an insistent "entitlement scold". There's no doubt about that. But in agreeing to "talk", Obama isn't conceding anything practical to Samuelson and his.

Samuelson doesn't come right out and say it, but I imagine that he recognizes that a mere commitment "to talk", is historically huge. Democrats past, have virtually always had to say that Social Security is off the table, untouchable, and non-negotiable.

And to qualify even as I shouldn't have to, I'm not advocating for any specific changes to, nor concessions on, Social Security.
Talk is cheap. Specially from O'bungle.
 
http://www.thenewstribune.com/2013/10/10/2830374/a-way-out-and-its-better-than.html

He suggests the GOP must settle for a promise from Obama, to talk. Of course, Samuelson IS an insistent "entitlement scold". There's no doubt about that. But in agreeing to "talk", Obama isn't conceding anything practical to Samuelson and his.

Samuelson doesn't come right out and say it, but I imagine that he recognizes that a mere commitment "to talk", is historically huge. Democrats past, have virtually always had to say that Social Security is off the table, untouchable, and non-negotiable.

And to qualify even as I shouldn't have to, I'm not advocating for any specific changes to, nor concessions on, Social Security.

The "grand bargain" that Obama and the Dems agreed to, and Boehner walked away from, included some cuts to SS. It has never been put "off the table."
 
I think we need to raise the age of eligibility. That's about it. It's just facing economic/demographic reality...

The solution to Social Security's fiscal issues, is nominal. In this thread, I'm not advocating for anything specific. We could raise the age, the tax, the cap, or some combination. Whatever we do, it won't need to be nearly so dramatic or onerous as some seem convinced.

That begs the question of why it hasn't already been addressed. IMHO, the answer's simple. Social Security has offered up a wedgie security blanket for BOTH parties, for far too long. Therefore, they'd much rather talk about it than do anything about it.
 
The solution to Social Security's fiscal issues, is nominal. In this thread, I'm not advocating for anything specific. We could raise the age, the tax, the cap, or some combination. Whatever we do, it won't need to be nearly so dramatic or onerous as some seem convinced.

That begs the question of why it hasn't already been addressed. IMHO, the answer's simple. Social Security has offered up a wedgie security blanket for BOTH parties, for far too long. Therefore, they'd much rather talk about it than do anything about it.


Social Security would only become a long-term problem for the US government if all of us old baby-boomers suddenly discovered the Fountain of Youth. Temporary deficits in the system will be overcome in short order once we've shuffled off this mortal coil.
 
Fairsheet this fits well into our last conversation (wink wink)

Yup. I like the fact that Samuelson skirts the issue of the partisan/political gamesmanship as much as he can, while still forwarding his case. I'm always a little put off when presumptive "real" economists wonder themselves too far off into the political weeds.

In this case, he posits the fact the guvmint needs to be open and the debt ceiling raised, as "givens". I doubt there's any other objective economist out there, who sees it any differently.
 
The solution to Social Security's fiscal issues, is nominal. In this thread, I'm not advocating for anything specific. We could raise the age, the tax, the cap, or some combination. Whatever we do, it won't need to be nearly so dramatic or onerous as some seem convinced.

That begs the question of why it hasn't already been addressed. IMHO, the answer's simple. Social Security has offered up a wedgie security blanket for BOTH parties, for far too long. Therefore, they'd much rather talk about it than do anything about it.
Agreed. The two parties have no problem pilfering from it to conceal ugly economic truths...but they're generally comfortable using it as volleyball year in and out.

Regarding the "debt ceiling", I find the constant revisiting of this issue maddening. Our pols are weaklings - altogether unable to find ways to contain (let alone reduce) spending...then they bicker when it comes time to fund what they committed.

The debt ceiling has been raised 78 times since 1960 (don't ask how many times it's been lowered - we all know how government works). 78 times since 1960 - let that sink in. On average, that's just under 1.5 times per year every year (1.472 if you care to pick nits).

As far as a "suckiness metric", that's a decent barometer of our politicians' ability and willingness to make a plan, budget for it, and work within that budgeted plan.

These guys are idiots - but what's worse is that they're idiots consistently...year-over-year...for decades. You know what that says about the electorate (i.e. us), right?

:-(
 
Social Security would only become a long-term problem for the US government if all of us old baby-boomers suddenly discovered the Fountain of Youth. Temporary deficits in the system will be overcome in short order once we've shuffled off this mortal coil.

Back in the 80's, under Reagan, we confronted the baby boomer issue head on. The "solution" was to essentially double the tax rate such that the baby boomers paid the freight for the prior generation AND for themselves. Prior to that, we only paid for the prior generation.

In so doing, we worked from some pretty indisputable actuarial tables showing how many people would be retiring and when. The baby boomers represent a "birth bubble", a "retirement bubble", AND a dead bubble.

The Social Security math applying to the baby boomer's retirement and death bubbles, is different prior to those bubbles AND post those bubbles. But somehow...we've "truthinessed" that all aside, and now seem to be working under the assumption that the baby boomer's bubbles continue on into eternity.
 
The solution to Social Security's fiscal issues, is nominal. In this thread, I'm not advocating for anything specific. We could raise the age, the tax, the cap, or some combination. Whatever we do, it won't need to be nearly so dramatic or onerous as some seem convinced.

If you really had a GOP that would compromise (perhaps more likely given their utterly suicidal move these past 3 weeks)....you could get a deal on Social Security.

Dems give up raising the age, Repubs give up raising the cap. Bang....program solvent for decades to come, even with the Baby Boomer retirees coming on-line.
 
Agreed. The two parties have no problem pilfering from it to conceal ugly economic truths...but they're generally comfortable using it as volleyball year in and out.

Regarding the "debt ceiling", I find the constant revisiting of this issue maddening. Our pols are weaklings - altogether unable to find ways to contain (let alone reduce) spending...then they bicker when it comes time to fund what they committed.

The debt ceiling has been raised 78 times since 1960 (don't ask how many times it's been lowered - we all know how government works). 78 times since 1960 - let that sink in. On average, that's just under 1.5 times per year every year (1.472 if you care to pick nits).

As far as a "suckiness metric", that's a decent barometer of our politicians' ability and willingness to make a plan, budget for it, and work within that budgeted plan.

These guys are idiots - but what's worse is that they're idiots consistently...year-over-year...for decades. You know what that says about the electorate (i.e. us), right?

:-(


As I understand it, the debt ceiling thing was conceived of back around WWI. The Republicans wanted an opportunity to bitch about Wilson's war spending. They made the case that prior to that, the debt simply rose with spending, with no one paying any attention to it. BUT...the understanding then and clear up to a few years ago, the raising the debt ceiling was just only that, an opportunity to bitch about the debt going up. They new damn well that once the spending had been authorized, if borrowing was necessary to cover it, the borrowing was a foregone conclusion per the Constitution.
 
As I understand it, the debt ceiling thing was conceived of back around WWI. The Republicans wanted an opportunity to bitch about Wilson's war spending. They made the case that prior to that, the debt simply rose with spending, with no one paying any attention to it. BUT...the understanding then and clear up to a few years ago, the raising the debt ceiling was just only that, an opportunity to bitch about the debt going up. They new damn well that once the spending had been authorized, if borrowing was necessary to cover it, the borrowing was a foregone conclusion per the Constitution.
Yes, but the advent of the "liquid borrowing ceiling" is pure insanity. You're correct that it emanated from WW1 spending concerns. Now, the $16.7 trillion is just not tenable. Who could work within such limitations? Not us. Not now, not ever. It's the reverse-limbo. How high can ya go?

At any rate, my point was that our intemperate congressional weaklings cannot plan and sustain a budget at the point of attack. They're just too squishy - every year for decades.
 
If you really had a GOP that would compromise (perhaps more likely given their utterly suicidal move these past 3 weeks)....you could get a deal on Social Security.

Dems give up raising the age, Repubs give up raising the cap. Bang....program solvent for decades to come, even with the Baby Boomer retirees coming on-line.


On a tangent - from a fiscal economic perspective, raising the eligibility age is a BAD idea. Rather than forcing older people to occupy a space in the labor market longer, we need to open up opportunities on the other end of the spectrum for people entering the workforce.

Of course, some will note that the Euros have trended towards raising their retirement ages. And, that's true. But...what they've done is to raise them nearer to what ours are NOW. Human life is progressive and finite. Raising the retirement age from say....65 to 70, is NOT "equal" to raising it from 60 to 65.
 
On a tangent - from a fiscal economic perspective, raising the eligibility age is a BAD idea. Rather than forcing older people to occupy a space in the labor market longer, we need to open up opportunities on the other end of the spectrum for people entering the workforce.

Of course, some will note that the Euros have trended towards raising their retirement ages. And, that's true. But...what they've done is to raise them nearer to what ours are NOW. Human life is progressive and finite. Raising the retirement age from say....65 to 70, is NOT "equal" to raising it from 60 to 65.
That, of course, depends upon whether or not your population is aging or undergoing a youth movement. It likewise depends on whether one sees economic opportunity as a zero-sum game.
 
Yes, but the advent of the "liquid borrowing ceiling" is pure insanity. You're correct that it emanated from WW1 spending concerns. Now, the $16.7 trillion is just not tenable. Who could work within such limitations? Not us. Not now, not ever. It's the reverse-limbo. How high can ya go?

At any rate, my point was that our intemperate congressional weaklings cannot plan and sustain a budget at the point of attack. They're just too squishy - every year for decades.


The advent of a liquid borrowing ceiling, came at our founding. You need to take that one up with our founders. The idea that Congress must "authorize" an increase in debt, only works when Congress always authorizes said increase. Some think that Bill's hummer represented a "constitutional crisis". Wait and see the ensuing constitutional crisis if Congress refuses to cover the debt that IT engendered!
 
That, of course, depends upon whether or not your population is aging or undergoing a youth movement. It likewise depends on whether one sees economic opportunity as a zero-sum game.


IMHO, the term "zero sum" is way overused. We can acknowledge that something is finite, without the sum being zero. We can accept the idea that there's a limit to how fast a man can run, while still accepting that man will run faster than he does now.
 
IMHO, the term "zero sum" is way overused. We can acknowledge that something is finite, without the sum being zero. We can accept the idea that there's a limit to how fast a man can run, while still accepting that man will run faster than he does now.
Ok, let's put it this way. I don't see a 1:1 correlation regarding employment opportunities for each geezer who stays in the workforce versus each whippersnapper. It may not be infinite, but jobs often beget jobs.
 
Back
Top