New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Samuelson gets it, as to a "way out"

The advent of a liquid borrowing ceiling, came at our founding. You need to take that one up with our founders. The idea that Congress must "authorize" an increase in debt, only works when Congress always authorizes said increase. Some think that Bill's hummer represented a "constitutional crisis". Wait and see the ensuing constitutional crisis if Congress refuses to cover the debt that IT engendered!
Not that liquid. Our modern clowns don't feel hamstrung at all by the ceiling under which they operate - so much so that raising the ceiling has become part of the conventional mechanics ~1.5 times per year. Just commit away with no regard to budget...we can always reinvent borrowing limits down the road. Discipline and accountability at policy-prescription time is passé.
 
On a tangent - from a fiscal economic perspective, raising the eligibility age is a BAD idea. Rather than forcing older people to occupy a space in the labor market longer, we need to open up opportunities on the other end of the spectrum for people entering the workforce.

I think part of the idea is....the seniors already have jobs, so they won't be launching into any "open spots" that a younger person would need or "keep a spot occupied" for that much longer than normal.

Plus you're going to have to give the Right "something" and a "age extension" over a very long period may satisfy them or atleast allow them to claim "victory" to their voters.
 
Not that liquid. Our modern clowns don't feel hamstrung at all by the ceiling under which they operate - so much so that raising the ceiling has become part of the conventional mechanics ~1.5 times per year. Just commit away with no regard to budget...we can always reinvent borrowing limits down the road. Discipline and accountability at policy-prescription time is passé.


Yes but....I'm not sure you're quite understanding that the "ceiling" is utterly artificial. The only reason anyone thinks it has any force of law, is because it's never been tested.

This reminds me of (almost) everyone's certitude that Congress passed a law back in the 60's, allowing them to access the Social Security fund, with the assumption that prior to that, they could not.

I hate to hurt the feelings of almost everyone, but they're flat out wrong. Congress has had access to the Social Security fund since its inception. NOTHING changed in that regard, in the 60's. What changed was remarkably pissant AND some would say, monumental.

Prior to that 60's change, presidents, the guvmint, or whomever, referred to Social Security's debt/surplus seperately from the general fund's debt/surplus - two different figures. The law in question - actually more of a "resolution" - allowed them to combine the two together when referring to them. Notice I say "refer to", rather than "report". That's because right up until today, the Social Security balance seperate from the general fund balance, are just a computer click away.

Of course we know damn well why they passed this "resolution", It was so they could "talk" about a lower debt number. But, ANYone or any politician who chooses to, is perfectly free to draw the distinction between the two fund balances.

The same is true in the context of Congressional appropriations. The debt accrues at the point of spending/taxation. If a politician wants to make a big stink about the debt deriving from some specific Congressional spending or revenue issue?....he's free to do so. But, we people are being played for saps by this silliness that "requires" Congress to make a particular stink.
 
Yes but....I'm not sure you're quite understanding that the "ceiling" is utterly artificial. The only reason anyone thinks it has any force of law, is because it's never been tested.

This reminds me of (almost) everyone's certitude that Congress passed a law back in the 60's, allowing them to access the Social Security fund, with the assumption that prior to that, they could not.

I hate to hurt the feelings of almost everyone, but they're flat out wrong. Congress has had access to the Social Security fund since its inception. NOTHING changed in that regard, in the 60's. What changed was remarkably pissant AND some would say, monumental.

Prior to that 60's change, presidents, the guvmint, or whomever, referred to Social Security's debt/surplus seperately from the general fund's debt/surplus - two different figures. The law in question - actually more of a "resolution" - allowed them to combine the two together when referring to them. Notice I say "refer to", rather than "report". That's because right up until today, the Social Security balance seperate from the general fund balance, are just a computer click away.

Of course we know damn well why they passed this "resolution", It was so they could "talk" about a lower debt number. But, ANYone or any politician who chooses to, is perfectly free to draw the distinction between the two fund balances.

The same is true in the context of Congressional appropriations. The debt accrues at the point of spending/taxation. If a politician wants to make a big stink about the debt deriving from some specific Congressional spending or revenue issue?....he's free to do so. But, we people are being played for saps by this silliness that "requires" Congress to make a particular stink.
I suppose my point is not the novelty of this, Fairsheet. It's the brazenness of our representatives and how regularly they bust the bank. They simply don't consider any notion of operating within an existing budget at the time that they consider and enact policy. They are so cavalier about their procedural "reset button" that it has become a matter of convention - a matter of practice. It is a rule of thumb. This is now the congressional BKM.
I'm not sure why anyone even clamors for budgeting any longer.

The list of things that don't matter:
Budgets
Debt
Deficits

Where to go from here? Folks get hung up on a minority party invoking procedural technicality as lagging braking mechanism independent of passed law. It's equally problematic when one party has an untouchable operational majority. Why have a ceiling if it's not a ceiling? Forgo the budgets because they are not constraining in any way. Eliminate the procedural approvals of increasing debt ceilings, as neither are they. Just go with the blank check.
 
I suppose my point is not the novelty of this, Fairsheet. It's the brazenness of our representatives and how regularly they bust the bank. They simply don't consider any notion of operating within an existing budget at the time that they consider and enact policy. They are so cavalier about their procedural "reset button" that it has become a matter of convention - a matter of practice. It is a rule of thumb. This is now the congressional BKM.
I'm not sure why anyone even clamors for budgeting any longer.

The list of things that don't matter:
Budgets
Debt
Deficits

Where to go from here? Folks get hung up on a minority party invoking procedural technicality as lagging braking mechanism independent of passed law. It's equally problematic when one party has an untouchable operational majority. Why have a ceiling if it's not a ceiling? Forgo the budgets because they are not constraining in any way. Eliminate the procedural approvals of increasing debt ceilings, as neither are they. Just go with the blank check.


"Why have a ceiling if it's not a ceiling?" Good question....but I think I've already answered it. We have a "ceiling" as a matter of political artiface. But, the idea of Congress voting on whether or not to pay the debt THEY created, is silly. They can't NOT pay that debt. So, why do we let them play us for fools by pretending that they can?

If we have an issue with debt (which for the most part, I do not), the time to confront it is when the money is appropriated and the revenue streams are legislated. Focusing on the gross debt number -that has to be paid no matter what - plays us for simpletons.
 
"Why have a ceiling if it's not a ceiling?" Good question....but I think I've already answered it. We have a "ceiling" as a matter of political artiface. But, the idea of Congress voting on whether or not to pay the debt THEY created, is silly. They can't NOT pay that debt. So, why do we let them play us for fools by pretending that they can?

If we have an issue with debt (which for the most part, I do not), the time to confront it is when the money is appropriated and the revenue streams are legislated. Focusing on the gross debt number -that has to be paid no matter what - plays us for simpletons.
Yes - fiscal accountability at the point of sale/point of attack. These guys are unaccountable.
 
Yes - fiscal accountability at the point of sale/point of attack. These guys are unaccountable.

Here's a hypothetical:

1. Let's say I propose to borrow $1 billion for some sort of childhood education program and I can make a good case that it will benefit our economy to the tune of $10 billion.

-Do ya go for it?
-Do you insist that it must be paid for out of some specifically indentified or legistlated revenue stream?
-If so to the second, why?.....if I've already demostrated that it will more than repay itself?
-Do you insist that it be "offset" by negating spending on something else, perhaps somethingthat only promises a 5x return?
-IF my case for a 10x return is a good one and it pretty much buys you over, how do (or can you?) you ensure that it does generate that 10x return?
-What if it only returns 8x, but it messes you up elsewhere, because you were counting on that $2 billion to offset something else?
 
Back
Top