New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Scalia

This reminds me of a discussion I had with a fellow lawyer friend the other day. We were talking about how dispiriting the last few years must have been for law professors. Most of them got into that line because they had a genuinely idealistic view of the role of the courts in the history of the Republic. Although that idealism was always necessarily tempered by the bits of cynicism that are unavoidable for someone who has studied how the sausages get made a bit too closely, they still were able to say with conviction, to their students, that it wasn't just a matter of the makeup of a bench at the moment imposing its political will on the nation. These days, how can a law professor say, with any kind of a straight face, what your professor said to you in the mid 80s? The court is so clearly results-driven, and what is and isn't constitutional comes down to whether Justice Kennedy's sense of shame happens to be functioning on that particular day.
 
"standard left-wing anti-Semitism, anti-Americanism and pro-Islamist bias exists there just as it does at MSNBC, NBC, CNN and other state-run propaganda outlets.'

Holy cow. Nice try PJCon FNG.
 
Thomas could, quite literally, be retarded, and we wouldn't know the difference. Seriously, if you took someone with severe brain damage, to the point of being incapable of processing speech, and you sat him quietly on the bench, then had him "vote" with whatever Scalia decided, with a team of federalist society law clerks penning the opinions to which they signed his name, the results would be indiscernible from Clarence Thomas. That's how much of a contribution he has to court proceedings.
 
I used to. I worked for the Navy, and his garbage was always on in the break room at lunch. That was back in the 90s, but if the clips that I hear are any indication, he hasn't improved since then.
 
When I was in law school in the mid 80's,I made a comment in Constitutional Law class one day to the effect that "What is and what isn't constitutional depends on who the SCOTUS Justices are at that point in time." The professor assured the class that wasn't so and proceeded to tell us in a very academic and idealistic way why it wasn't so.

You were right.

Early in my college career I took a US history course, and on the first night, pretty much in the first minutes, the 'teacher' wrote Church of England on the blackboard then turned around to ask, "Can anyone tell me the meaning of these words?"

I looked around, and no answers seemed forthcoming from my classmates, so I raised my hand.

"You," he said, pointing at me.

"It means that the church and state were one."

"No, no, no... it meant it was England's church," emphasizing England by underlining it with chalk.

During the first recess, I went to the Administration Building and dropped the class.
 
This reminds me of a discussion I had with a fellow lawyer friend the other day. We were talking about how dispiriting the last few years must have been for law professors. Most of them got into that line because they had a genuinely idealistic view of the role of the courts in the history of the Republic. Although that idealism was always necessarily tempered by the bits of cynicism that are unavoidable for someone who has studied how the sausages get made a bit too closely, they still were able to say with conviction, to their students, that it wasn't just a matter of the makeup of a bench at the moment imposing its political will on the nation. These days, how can a law professor say, with any kind of a straight face, what your professor said to you in the mid 80s? The court is so clearly results-driven, and what is and isn't constitutional comes down to whether Justice Kennedy's sense of shame happens to be functioning on that particular day.

I never went to law school, but I'm cynical as hell when it comes to the law. I'm genuinely surprised it took you so long, but you shouldn't feel bad. You mentioned your own idealism before, and one should hold on to that like grim death. I sure wish I had some left.
 
Scalia is an unwise justice, to him, rulings are like making envelopes, he will opine in his lectures that courts are now influenced by foreign law, whereas he holds constitutional law in sancrosant, Really? a few points.

Scalia has been known to point to "common law" or "old English law" in his arguments, as he has stated the right to "privacy" did not have the same meaning during the days of the founder's as it does today.

That's very interesting as I seem to recall that the stamp tax being the tax that broke the backs of the Bostonians when lobsterman came in to protect the tax collectors, which led to the Boston Massacre, it would appear that the founder's stood by and watch unmoved by the activities in Boston Common where people were indeed protecting their right to "privacy", they didn't need the British Crown to tell them if they paid their stamp tax, their babies were recognized as "born", their marriages were recognized as "legal" and their dead were recognized as "dead".

Me thinks Scalia has made some short sighted arguments in his career and basically became a "mechanic" instead of a Legal scholar.

now, there's an interesting argument that remained under the pot lid during the days of Mrs. O'Connor, and that was Sandra's insistence that the court would have to broaden it's ability to argument cases where international law set the precedent, indeed to this day, the only justice on the court who is an expert, Stephen Breyer, writes 99% of the arguments in cases where international law interlopes against constitutional law, Scalia and Thomas could never do that, and the amateur mechanics, Roberts and Alito, are YEARS away from the kind of intellectual temperance that would allow for that.

I think that Scalia has been a grandstander from the first day, and some of his arguments are rather interesting and of course, debatable.

But when you hear that a justice is lecturing at a school of law, but his lecture cannot be captured by the press, nor can it be published, you must give pause and think of the consequences of that action.

This is censorship in the worst form, and no matter what you might think of the press, it is indeed well recognized by the founding fathers, as the "Fourth Estate"

After all, how would Paul Revere, part time newspaperman, ever get the fence sitters in ole Virginy to converge on the side of independence if he hadn't taken the killing of five people in Boston and called it "The Boston Massacre"???

Regards
Pace
 
Yeah. It would have been 7-2. Alito and Roberts are scumbags, and Kennedy is nearly as bad, but they all have a sense of shame the prevents them from playing their Republican operative role in the most extreme situations. They need at least a shred of legalistic cover. Scalia and Thomas, on the other hand, vote the same way Limbaugh would.
 
Back
Top