New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Scoring Colleges

Arkady

President
Here's an interesting website that lets you find out the kind of information you might want to know before investing hundreds of thousands of dollars on an undergraduate education:

https://collegescorecard.ed.gov/

My own alma mater has a rival in the same region and the same tier, so I couldn't resist looking them both up, and was pleased to find out mine costs considerably less, on average, has a higher graduation rate, and the graduates earn $6,400 more after attending than do the rival's. If that kind of data becomes widely known by people deciding on colleges, it's bound to have an impact on decisions.

One particular stat I thought was really useful was the "percentage earning above high school grad" stats. Although merely earning a good salary isn't the whole reason for going to college, if you're going to invest a lot of money, you're likely to want to see that you're going to get a financial return on that investment, in terms of earnings. At some colleges, you can spend an arm and a leg and yet hardly increase your chances of out-earning what you'd have made right out of high school.

I also found it interesting that the numbers don't necessarily track what you'd expect them to be based on selectivity. For example, Brown University is in the Ivy League, but average salary after attending was "just" $59,700, and "only" 76% of students earned more than high school grads. Compare that to Georgetown, which isn't Ivy, where average salary is $83,300 and 89% earn more than high school graduates. Brown is generally considered the more selective school (and has the higher SATs to prove it), yet Georgetown grads are getting a much better deal in purely financial terms. This presumably has a lot to do with the kinds of majors people have in each, as well as which job markets they gravitate towards.

Such numbers are particularly hard on high-priced private schools that have long had a reputation as places that the not-so-bright kids of rich families can be sent, when they can't get into good schools but money is no object for buying a degree that at least sounds good. Sarah Lawrence, for example, is the most expensive college in America, and yet only has a 72% graduation rate, the salary after attending is just $39,700, and barely over half the students earn more than they would with just a high school diploma.
 
Such numbers are particularly hard on high-priced private schools that have long had a reputation as places that the not-so-bright kids of rich families can be sent, when they can't get into good schools but money is no object for buying a degree that at least sounds good. Sarah Lawrence, for example, is the most expensive college in America, and yet only has a 72% graduation rate, the salary after attending is just $39,700, and barely over half the students earn more than they would with just a high school diploma.

Yes, I'm sure that's the problem at Sarah Lawrence; not the fact that they are putting easily-duped students in massive amounts of debt in order to earn degrees in useless liberal arts and "___ Studies" fields that have no future paid employment potential...
 
This sub-link was interesting: 23 four-year schools with low costs that lead to high incomes

Many students can save a ton of cash just by living at home and going to community college to earn an AA or AS degree before transferring to a four-year University in state. This is given that they don't have a scholarship that equally offsets the high costs.

This editorial demonstrates how the "good intentions" of Democrats have paved a way to "collegiate Hell" and how both Hillary and Bernie's college plans will worsen the situation:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opini...-sanders-omalley-editorials-debates/31977025/
The United States prides itself on being innovative and creative. Yet it is struggling to train its next generation of achievers. Despite rapidly rising sums that the federal government has devoted to loans and grants, American college students and recent graduates are wallowing in debt. At last count, they owed $1.2 trillion.

Not surprisingly, the leading Democratic presidential candidates — Hillary Clinton,Bernie Sanders and Martin O'Malley — have come up with plans they say will make colleges more affordable and provide debt relief for millennials. Though well-intentioned, their plans threaten to drive up costs rather than rein them in. They would all throw more federal money at colleges while offering little but hope that these institutions would hold expenses down.

If history is any guide, colleges and universities will channel much of the additional money into areas that don't directly benefit students. They might also hike tuition, telling students not to worry because taxpayers will pick up much of the additional burden. A Federal Reserve Bank of New York report found that colleges increased tuition 40 cents for every dollar received in Pell Grants, and 65 cents for every dollar in subsidized loans.

Clinton's plan is the least ambitious and the most practical. Yet it still amounts to taxpayers spending a lot more money without concrete efforts to make colleges control costs. Its centerpiece is a 10-year, $175 billion program of matching grants to states that would require states to reverse recent budget cuts. It would also allow students and graduates to refinance their debts at lower interest rates, expand programs that let people repay their loans as a percentage of their incomes, and enhance existing education tax credits.

She would pay for all this with higher taxes on wealthy Americans. While the affluent can and should pay more, this is a well that lawmakers can go to only so often. New revenue that goes to tuition assistance is money that can't be used to shore up Social Security or Medicare, expand the nation's infrastructure, or reduce the budget deficit.

Plans offered by Sanders and O'Malley would go even further, setting a goal of debt-free education for all students at all public universities.

A better idea would be to take a magnifying glass to exactly why college costs have skyrocketed at three times the overall inflation rate since 1980. As with health care, the answer involves what happens when bills are paid with other people's money.

Too many universities have become bloated and inefficient, using their revenue in ways that don’t benefit the students’ education: Million dollar salaries awarded to top-paid college presidents. Professors who barely teach. Sparkling recreation centers, such as the one at Louisiana State University complete with a lazy river. Bloated bureaucracies with endless vice presidents. Money-losing sports programs.

It doesn’t take a Ph.D. to figure out where money could be saved, but persuading colleges to part with these extras won’t be easy. This is where the federal government and states can harness the leverage that accompanies their dollars to demand accountability, perhaps by awarding grants only to institutions that hold the line on tuition and fees.

Contrary to what many schools would tell you, such cost cutting isn't impossible. Purdue University in Indiana has frozen its tuition for two straight years and will continue to do so for at least two more. To be sure, some of this has been done with the budgetary gimmick of taking more out-of-state students, who pay much higher rates. Even so, Purdue's focus on cost containment should be followed by other schools.

Only by attacking rising tuition at its root cause will the problem of college affordability be addressed. The Democratic candidates need a little more educating on this.
 
notably absent - trending concerns such as . . .

  • campus crime rates
  • does the university suspend the rule of law when accusations of rape are made, and expel students with the sort of due process a court would rely on?
  • what are the faculty attitudes/publishings on topics such as 9/11; free markets; Israel; radical islam; freedom of speech?
  • how many courses are taught by the actual tenure professor, rather than his gradate assistant who speaks with an indecipherable foreign accent
 
notably absent - trending concerns such as . . .

  • campus crime rates
  • does the university suspend the rule of law when accusations of rape are made, and expel students with the sort of due process a court would rely on?
  • what are the faculty attitudes/publishings on topics such as 9/11; free markets; Israel; radical islam; freedom of speech?
  • how many courses are taught by the actual tenure professor, rather than his gradate assistant who speaks with an indecipherable foreign accent


It's a government website. You can only expect so much, and had better be wary of even that.

Those who have complete faith in the government, however, will love it in advance.
 
notably absent - trending concerns such as . . .

  • campus crime rates
  • does the university suspend the rule of law when accusations of rape are made, and expel students with the sort of due process a court would rely on?
  • what are the faculty attitudes/publishings on topics such as 9/11; free markets; Israel; radical islam; freedom of speech?
  • how many courses are taught by the actual tenure professor, rather than his gradate assistant who speaks with an indecipherable foreign accent

On that, the University of California is now banning "intolerance". Let the oxymoronic nature of that sink in for a moment, and realize just how abysmal public universities have become...

http://www.mrctv.org/blog/universit...e-acts-and-expressions-tolerance#.ow0f08:i7ys
 
It's a government website. You can only expect so much, and had better be wary of even that.

Those who have complete faith in the government, however, will love it in advance.

still, its a good start.

depending on the parent, concerns will vary. if the parents live in Hollywood or NYC, they probably would like a website that assures them the college has no religious services or buildings. If the parents live south of the mason Dixon line, they might be looking for the opposite.

I met someone a few years ago whose parents screened his college choices based on the school's attitude toward evolution. he ended up attending a bible-type college, but got a degree in accounting and got a job right away.

evidently Christian accountants are assumed to be more ethical and less likely to cook the books?
 
On that, the University of California is now banning "intolerance". Let the oxymoronic nature of that sink in for a moment, and realize just how abysmal public universities have become...

http://www.mrctv.org/blog/university-california-seeks-create-right-be-free-acts-and-expressions-tolerance#.ow0f08:i7ys

yeah - I had that same thought when I saw it on yahoo or drudge a day ago. ironic.

that could possibly mean the entire football team will have to be expelled. plus all the "students of color" who are involved in things like #BLM; who voted against gay marriages during the last referendum; muslims who have anti-jew social media profiles . . .

but I fully understand the intent. it's intended as an anti-Christian weapon, and the star chamber inquiry will involve questions on abortion, evolution, and gay sex.

making a more diverse campus by excluding those who disagree with the regents and legislature. probably not what the founding fathers had in mind.

many of the first colleges in America were founded by religious figures, or got land/money grants from churches. they were happy to accept students of all faiths, or none at all, because they understood that some might change their mind after a year or two at religious affiliated school.

California's attitude appears to be that they don't believe its possible to persuade the faithful to abandon their beliefs, and they don't care to risk having any other students encounter faith based discussion.
 
This sub-link was interesting: 23 four-year schools with low costs that lead to high incomes

Many students can save a ton of cash just by living at home and going to community college to earn an AA or AS degree before transferring to a four-year University in state. This is given that they don't have a scholarship that equally offsets the high costs.

This editorial demonstrates how the "good intentions" of Democrats have paved a way to "collegiate Hell" and how both Hillary and Bernie's college plans will worsen the situation:

http://www.usatoday.com/story/opini...-sanders-omalley-editorials-debates/31977025/
The United States prides itself on being innovative and creative. Yet it is struggling to train its next generation of achievers. Despite rapidly rising sums that the federal government has devoted to loans and grants, American college students and recent graduates are wallowing in debt. At last count, they owed $1.2 trillion.

Not surprisingly, the leading Democratic presidential candidates — Hillary Clinton,Bernie Sanders and Martin O'Malley — have come up with plans they say will make colleges more affordable and provide debt relief for millennials. Though well-intentioned, their plans threaten to drive up costs rather than rein them in. They would all throw more federal money at colleges while offering little but hope that these institutions would hold expenses down.

If history is any guide, colleges and universities will channel much of the additional money into areas that don't directly benefit students. They might also hike tuition, telling students not to worry because taxpayers will pick up much of the additional burden. A Federal Reserve Bank of New York report found that colleges increased tuition 40 cents for every dollar received in Pell Grants, and 65 cents for every dollar in subsidized loans.

Clinton's plan is the least ambitious and the most practical. Yet it still amounts to taxpayers spending a lot more money without concrete efforts to make colleges control costs. Its centerpiece is a 10-year, $175 billion program of matching grants to states that would require states to reverse recent budget cuts. It would also allow students and graduates to refinance their debts at lower interest rates, expand programs that let people repay their loans as a percentage of their incomes, and enhance existing education tax credits.

She would pay for all this with higher taxes on wealthy Americans. While the affluent can and should pay more, this is a well that lawmakers can go to only so often. New revenue that goes to tuition assistance is money that can't be used to shore up Social Security or Medicare, expand the nation's infrastructure, or reduce the budget deficit.

Plans offered by Sanders and O'Malley would go even further, setting a goal of debt-free education for all students at all public universities.

A better idea would be to take a magnifying glass to exactly why college costs have skyrocketed at three times the overall inflation rate since 1980. As with health care, the answer involves what happens when bills are paid with other people's money.

Too many universities have become bloated and inefficient, using their revenue in ways that don’t benefit the students’ education: Million dollar salaries awarded to top-paid college presidents. Professors who barely teach. Sparkling recreation centers, such as the one at Louisiana State University complete with a lazy river. Bloated bureaucracies with endless vice presidents. Money-losing sports programs.

It doesn’t take a Ph.D. to figure out where money could be saved, but persuading colleges to part with these extras won’t be easy. This is where the federal government and states can harness the leverage that accompanies their dollars to demand accountability, perhaps by awarding grants only to institutions that hold the line on tuition and fees.

Contrary to what many schools would tell you, such cost cutting isn't impossible. Purdue University in Indiana has frozen its tuition for two straight years and will continue to do so for at least two more. To be sure, some of this has been done with the budgetary gimmick of taking more out-of-state students, who pay much higher rates. Even so, Purdue's focus on cost containment should be followed by other schools.

Only by attacking rising tuition at its root cause will the problem of college affordability be addressed. The Democratic candidates need a little more educating on this.


Well just comparing my father's college "experience" with mine, with my friends children's current experience and the difference is obvious... these days its all about the "experience". When my dad went to school at Penn State living in the dorms was what I would have called "roughing" it. There were three to four guys in a 10x10 space. There was one or two communal bathrooms per floor. The dining hall was your typical cafeteria fare, etc. My own experience was about half way between his and what is the current experience. Now its like an extended vacation. They have all sorts of dining options, entertainment options, etc. None of those things impact the actual quality of the education.
 
Well just comparing my father's college "experience" with mine, with my friends children's current experience and the difference is obvious... these days its all about the "experience". When my dad went to school at Penn State living in the dorms was what I would have called "roughing" it. There were three to four guys in a 10x10 space. There was one or two communal bathrooms per floor. The dining hall was your typical cafeteria fare, etc. My own experience was about half way between his and what is the current experience. Now its like an extended vacation. They have all sorts of dining options, entertainment options, etc. None of those things impact the actual quality of the education.
Agreed, but they'd certainly contribute to the higher cost.
 
Agreed, but they'd certainly contribute to the higher cost.

And that's how we wind up with folks like Arkady, who wasted his daddy's money going to a high-priced law school, only to spend all of his time talking politics on a web forum with people he considers to be intellectually inferior.
 
Agreed, but they'd certainly contribute to the higher cost.

Oh certainly. I personally would rather have the "war stories" of eating greasy take-out pizza and bad chinese at 2 am.. because there is no suitable food options, or choosing that over the cafeteria food because it sucks, and deal with communal bathrooms, than pay 10 or 20k more a year just to have fancier living conditions. But, you barely have the choice anymore.

connie
 
Oh certainly. I personally would rather have the "war stories" of eating greasy take-out pizza and bad chinese at 2 am.. because there is no suitable food options, or choosing that over the cafeteria food because it sucks, and deal with communal bathrooms, than pay 10 or 20k more a year just to have fancier living conditions. But, you barely have the choice anymore.
connie

They can get the "college experience" as a junior and senior rather than racking up a bill for all four years at a an average cost of over $20,000/year. They can save the $10K+ room and board costs by living at home the first two years.

This, IMO, is good for a few reasons; it allows them to go to college and see if it's for them at a minimal price. At 18-20, many are still immature and new a little more time to transition from dependency to responsible independence. An alcohol or drug incident, over-the-top college prank or some other on-time event that goes over the legal line can cause more problems than two years and $40K of debt as a Freshman and Sophomore is worth.

http://www.collegedata.com/cs/content/content_payarticle_tmpl.jhtml?articleId=10064
In its most recent survey of college pricing, the College Board reports that a "moderate" college budget for an in-state public college for the 2014–2015 academic year averaged $23,410. A moderate budget at a private college averaged $46,272......

Colleges often report a combined tuition and fees figure. According to the College Board, the average cost of tuition and fees for the 2014–2015 school year was $31,231 at private colleges, $9,139 for state residents at public colleges, and $22,958 for out-of-state residents attending public universities.

Housing and Meals
The cost of "room and board" depends on the campus housing and food plans you choose. The College Board reports that the average cost of room and board in 2014–2015 ranged from $9,804 at four-year public schools to $11,188 at private schools. Colleges also provide room and board estimates for living off campus based on typical student costs.
 
They can get the "college experience" as a junior and senior rather than racking up a bill for all four years at a an average cost of over $20,000/year. They can save the $10K+ room and board costs by living at home the first two years.

This, IMO, is good for a few reasons; it allows them to go to college and see if it's for them at a minimal price. At 18-20, many are still immature and new a little more time to transition from dependency to responsible independence. An alcohol or drug incident, over-the-top college prank or some other on-time event that goes over the legal line can cause more problems than two years and $40K of debt as a Freshman and Sophomore is worth.

http://www.collegedata.com/cs/content/content_payarticle_tmpl.jhtml?articleId=10064
In its most recent survey of college pricing, the College Board reports that a "moderate" college budget for an in-state public college for the 2014–2015 academic year averaged $23,410. A moderate budget at a private college averaged $46,272......

Colleges often report a combined tuition and fees figure. According to the College Board, the average cost of tuition and fees for the 2014–2015 school year was $31,231 at private colleges, $9,139 for state residents at public colleges, and $22,958 for out-of-state residents attending public universities.

Housing and Meals
The cost of "room and board" depends on the campus housing and food plans you choose. The College Board reports that the average cost of room and board in 2014–2015 ranged from $9,804 at four-year public schools to $11,188 at private schools. Colleges also provide room and board estimates for living off campus based on typical student costs.


It was actually way cheaper to live off campus when I went to college. I think it must still be. But, they really discourage that - so kids get the "college" experience.

My aunt and uncle actually bought a condo near where their kids went to school and they lived in it while in college and had other roommates who paid the rent which covered the mortgage and utilties. Honestly, for some upper middle class families - who maybe are still forced to take out loans for their kid to go to college, that may not be a bad path. In the end you have an asset you can keep renting or sell.

connie
 
It was actually way cheaper to live off campus when I went to college. I think it must still be. But, they really discourage that - so kids get the "college" experience.

My aunt and uncle actually bought a condo near where their kids went to school and they lived in it while in college and had other roommates who paid the rent which covered the mortgage and utilties. Honestly, for some upper middle class families - who maybe are still forced to take out loans for their kid to go to college, that may not be a bad path. In the end you have an asset you can keep renting or sell.

connie
Agreed it's cheaper to live off campus. That's what I did my senior year after living my junior year on campus.

As for recommendations, there's a financial consideration there which makes the University biased in their recommendations. There's also a legal one where they "recommend" to cover their asses in case someone's little princess or prince get into trouble off campus.

The condo investment is a consideration my wife and I are looking as a replacement for our current "second chance" homes. We've had the police over a few times due to "drama" among the residents and one police officer, knowing my wife and I are good, honest people, recommended selling those two homes and doing the college rental thing. We're looking at it, not very actively. There are other factors for us to consider.
 
This presumably has a lot to do with the kinds of majors people have in each, as well as which job markets they gravitate towards.
Yeah, those from Georgetown gravitate towards government jobs that these days are paying hand over fist. The richest counties in the country surround DC.
 
Agreed it's cheaper to live off campus. That's what I did my senior year after living my junior year on campus.

As for recommendations, there's a financial consideration there which makes the University biased in their recommendations. There's also a legal one where they "recommend" to cover their asses in case someone's little princess or prince get into trouble off campus.

The condo investment is a consideration my wife and I are looking as a replacement for our current "second chance" homes. We've had the police over a few times due to "drama" among the residents and one police officer, knowing my wife and I are good, honest people, recommended selling those two homes and doing the college rental thing. We're looking at it, not very actively. There are other factors for us to consider.

Right now their youngest is still in it though he no longer is in college and is paying rent as well with a friend. But, it was certainly less drama with their own kids involved. I can see how it would be drama there too though if your own kids weren't part of it and you didn't have that tab and then the control on the selection of roommates. On the other hand, since we three worked and paid our rent ourselves, we didn't have too terrible much time for all the uusal hijinks that kids get into so our rental was drama free.

connie
 
Right now their youngest is still in it though he no longer is in college and is paying rent as well with a friend. But, it was certainly less drama with their own kids involved. I can see how it would be drama there too though if your own kids weren't part of it and you didn't have that tab and then the control on the selection of roommates. On the other hand, since we three worked and paid our rent ourselves, we didn't have too terrible much time for all the uusal hijinks that kids get into so our rental was drama free.

connie
The drama with our residents isn't because they're college students, but because they are either fresh out of county, have mental disabilities or are just "troubled" (aka idiots) as in lacking intellect.
 
The drama with our residents isn't because they're college students, but because they are either fresh out of county, have mental disabilities or are just "troubled" (aka idiots) as in lacking intellect.

I didn't think it was. Just pointing out that sometimes the college students come with their own brand of drama. too much partying, etc.

We have renters and a few rental properties, too. The drama I think comes with the territory. There is always some strife or calamity happening.
 
I didn't think it was. Just pointing out that sometimes the college students come with their own brand of drama. too much partying, etc.

We have renters and a few rental properties, too. The drama I think comes with the territory. There is always some strife or calamity happening.
Oh, baby. All humans come with a bit of "drama", some more than others! I'm stating the obvious since you are certainly aware of the point. :)

As noted in the previous example, the police officer advised moving our business to a better side of town, specifically one of the college areas. My guess is, despite the drama of young people in general, college students are smarter and more goal oriented. They're less likely to be engaged in many types of criminal behavior beyond youthful disobedience to authority and exploration of altered states of consciousness.
 
Back
Top