New Posts
  • Hi there guest! Welcome to PoliticalJack.com. Register for free to join our community?

Secession Plan

Arkady

President
It's unlikely any state or region will secede from the union in our lifetimes, but it's not unthinkable. The most likely candidate to leave would be Texas, since it has a strong independent streak, and is big enough and sufficiently well supplied with raw resources to make a credible go of it alone. Picture a Scotland-style referendum in Texas with enough people voting they want out that it goes to the US Congress and passes, ushering Texas out with a reverse of the procedure that let them in. There are rough precedents for this, already, in the US giving up the Philippines, for example. And there are modern precedents, in other countries, for peaceful, lawful divisions (e.g., Czech Republic and Slovakia).

This would be bad news, long term, for Texans. They'd be transformed into a religiously conservative nation with an economy driven by oil. There are quite a few of those in the world, and they don't tend to be nice places to live. But it might be a good thing for the rest of the country. Without Texas, politics in this country would tilt left (which is to say, more to the center, by the standards of most advanced nations). Take Texas out of the mix, and not only would 2008 and 2012 have been landslides for the Democrats, they may also have won in 2004, and the election of 2000 would have been placed safely beyond the clutches of the Supreme Court's election-nullifying cabal of conservatives.

If Texas were to leave, I think it would set off a string of exits. The new --more liberal-- United States would be a worse fit for the states of the Deep South, increasing the pressure for them to leave. So, you could end up with a dissolution of the country.

Just brain-storming, this would be a sensible division, into five countries that are big enough and economically viable enough to make a go of it, each with a particular political flavor:

Oceana, population 57 million (California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Hawaii, New Mexico, American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands)
The Range, population 61 million (Arizona, Texas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Colorado, Kansas, Wyoming, Utah, Idaho, Montana, North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Alaska)
CSA, population 78 million (Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee).
Lakeville, population 60 million (Minnesota, Missouri, Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana)
Yankeeville, population 72 million (Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, DC, and Virginia).

None of those would be land-locked, and each would have a diversity of economic products, so I think they'd all be economically viable. They'd also have roughly similarly sized economies. In terms of sizes, they'd have populations that are fairly typical among most leading countries (a bit smaller than Japan, but bigger than Canada or Australia).

Although basic economic theory suggests the average person in these new countries would be materially worse off (losing the efficiencies of a big trade block and currency zone, etc.), I think probably most would feel more at home than before.
 
Texas 365,000 new Jobs...if Red states leave then lefty will have to eat it's own again. As much as lefty likes to claim superiority over the fellow man and people of color...they cannot survive with out Red States.
 
Oceana, population 57 million (California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Hawaii, New Mexico, American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands)
The Range, population 61 million (Arizona, Texas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Colorado, Kansas, Wyoming, Utah, Idaho, Montana, North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Alaska)
CSA, population 78 million (Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee).
Lakeville, population 60 million (Minnesota, Missouri, Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana)
Yankeeville, population 72 million (Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, DC, and Virginia).

I see an additional opportunity in re: some fine tuning. While such a breakup is underway, allow counties on borders to go either way. Those western NY state counties could easily align with Lakeville. The NoVa counties that are currently purple/blue in the capital region move to Yankeeville.

The Atlantic Islands seem more associated with the east coast. Travel to PR is through NY or Miami. And Miami is a different animal from the rest of Florida. Alaska has shown we don't require contiguous borders; maybe the east coast of FL goes to Yankeeville as well...
 
I see an additional opportunity in re: some fine tuning. While such a breakup is underway, allow counties on borders to go either way. Those western NY state counties could easily align with Lakeville. The NoVa counties that are currently purple/blue in the capital region move to Yankeeville.

The Atlantic Islands seem more associated with the east coast. Travel to PR is through NY or Miami. And Miami is a different animal from the rest of Florida. Alaska has shown we don't require contiguous borders; maybe the east coast of FL goes to Yankeeville as well...
Yeah, I thought about breaking states up that way. Buffalo definitely fits in better with Lakeville, and Southern Virginia with the CSA, etc. My only concern is that if you break them up too much, you could wind up with economic monocultures -- for example, Yankeeville could be nothing but the Eastern Megalopolis, with few natural resources, and on the flip side you could wind up with vast rural areas that are dirt-poor and lack world-class cities, or even decent ports, and have no high culture, no high-tech industry, etc.

I agree about PR and the Virgin Islands. I just was trying to beef up Oceana so that it had a population closer to the others. Despite the distance, those seem like a better fit with it than trying to fit in Alaska, Idaho, Utah, or some other nearby conservative area in with California.

I also struggled with Florida, because much of it would fit in better with New York than Dixie, culturally and economically, but it would be an island, cut off from the rest of that political block. Maybe that's not an issue, but in theory the CSA could block land transport from there to the rest of Yankeeville, which would be hard on the economy, even with easy water and air access. Alaska, as you said, has a similar problem, but that one is unavoidable, unless you give it to Canada or annex parts of Canada.
 
Last edited:
Texas 365,000 new Jobs...if Red states leave then lefty will have to eat it's own again. As much as lefty likes to claim superiority over the fellow man and people of color...they cannot survive with out Red States.
I suspect if a division happened more or less along the lines I laid out, it would be much better for the Northeast and West than for those Red State blocks. Overall, the red states are net tax dollar leeches, and that would dry up. If you do the math, you'll also see that those liberal blocks are considerably richer than the others, and tend to have fewer socioeconomic problems (less poverty, less obesity, lower infant mortality, higher life expectancies, higher average education levels, etc.)

Chances are if things got broken up the way I laid out, the richer areas of the "confederate" states would be free to indulge their objection to centralized government, allowing a few states to do fairly well (like Texas), while the poor ones become a whole lot poorer and more troubled.
 
It's unlikely any state or region will secede from the union in our lifetimes, but it's not unthinkable. The most likely candidate to leave would be Texas, since it has a strong independent streak, and is big enough and sufficiently well supplied with raw resources to make a credible go of it alone. Picture a Scotland-style referendum in Texas with enough people voting they want out that it goes to the US Congress and passes, ushering Texas out with a reverse of the procedure that let them in. There are rough precedents for this, already, in the US giving up the Philippines, for example. And there are modern precedents, in other countries, for peaceful, lawful divisions (e.g., Czech Republic and Slovakia).

This would be bad news, long term, for Texans. They'd be transformed into a religiously conservative nation with an economy driven by oil. There are quite a few of those in the world, and they don't tend to be nice places to live. But it might be a good thing for the rest of the country. Without Texas, politics in this country would tilt left (which is to say, more to the center, by the standards of most advanced nations). Take Texas out of the mix, and not only would 2008 and 2012 have been landslides for the Democrats, they may also have won in 2004, and the election of 2000 would have been placed safely beyond the clutches of the Supreme Court's election-nullifying cabal of conservatives.

If Texas were to leave, I think it would set off a string of exits. The new --more liberal-- United States would be a worse fit for the states of the Deep South, increasing the pressure for them to leave. So, you could end up with a dissolution of the country.

Just brain-storming, this would be a sensible division, into five countries that are big enough and economically viable enough to make a go of it, each with a particular political flavor:

Oceana, population 57 million (California, Oregon, Washington, Nevada, Hawaii, New Mexico, American Samoa, Guam, Northern Mariana Islands, Puerto Rico, US Virgin Islands)
The Range, population 61 million (Arizona, Texas, Arkansas, Oklahoma, Colorado, Kansas, Wyoming, Utah, Idaho, Montana, North and South Dakota, Nebraska, Alaska)
CSA, population 78 million (Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Georgia, Florida, South Carolina, North Carolina, West Virginia, Kentucky, Tennessee).
Lakeville, population 60 million (Minnesota, Missouri, Wisconsin, Michigan, Ohio, Illinois, Iowa, Indiana)
Yankeeville, population 72 million (Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware, Pennsylvania, DC, and Virginia).

None of those would be land-locked, and each would have a diversity of economic products, so I think they'd all be economically viable. They'd also have roughly similarly sized economies. In terms of sizes, they'd have populations that are fairly typical among most leading countries (a bit smaller than Japan, but bigger than Canada or Australia).

Although basic economic theory suggests the average person in these new countries would be materially worse off (losing the efficiencies of a big trade block and currency zone, etc.), I think probably most would feel more at home than before.

In just imagine land
I am not so sure Texas would want to align itself with that many states . It would make more sense for Tx, La and OK. to form a smaller alliance maybe call it Thirdcostia. I really like Cajun food
 
Last edited:
In just imagine land
I am not so sure Texas would want to align itself with the that many states . It would make more sense for Tx, La and OK. to form a smaller alliance maybe call it Thirdcostia. I really like Cajun food
You could be right. Texas could really be screwing over the others, though, if it cut them off. Places like Wyoming and Montana just don't make much economic sense if not part of a wider economic corridor, with access to good sea ports and large, cosmopolitan cities. With Texas in the mix, you have a credible nation. Without it (and LA) putting the rest of "The Range" into its own nation would be a disaster, i think.
 
Back
Top